Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect tax avoidance to be treated in the same way as benefit fraud

66 replies

speedymama · 12/02/2007 11:45

Does the govt put as much emphasis on clamping down rich folk who avoid paying taxes as they do on targetting benefit fraudsters?

I ask this because of the current advertising campaign against benefit cheats. I personally think it is just as wrong and in some ways more immoral, for those you can pay more tax but don't to get away with it because they can afford to get round all the loopholes.

Just want to add that benefit fraud is wrong too and should be dealt with accordingly. It just appears to me that society treats benefit cheats with more disdain than those who deliberately seek ways of avoiding to pay tax even though they can afford to pay it, e.g. residents of Monte Carlo who enjoy the trappings of being British.

OP posts:
Ladymuck · 12/02/2007 14:00

Dino - no reason for him to pay UK IHT on it at all. You just fill out a form to change your domicile and that takes all non-UK property outside of UK IHT. Of course there are still the Irish tax issues, and domicle only affects IHT unless he goes non-resident.

Re the number of estates in scope for IHT - yes it is only about 6%. Many fall out a) because they're below the £285,000 (think of the number of penniless pensioners in the country or those paying care home bills); b) the estate is going primarily to the surviving spouse so exempt from IHT, or c) because they have planned appropriately and used up all of their allowances over the years. You only pay IHT through bad or no will planning (so an early unexpected death) or if you are just over the limit (and therefore a lot of the schemes don't make sense for you).

Dinosaur · 12/02/2007 12:41

wannabe, there aren't, really, unless he gives it to me outright now and then survives 7 years, but there are lots of reasons why that wouldn't work for us

Dinosaur · 12/02/2007 12:40

I agree with speedymama. Tax credits are for working families who don't earn as much. I absolutely do not begrudge paying tax at 40%.

I might have issues with some of the ways the Govt. chooses to spend my taxes, but that's a different qu.

wannaBeWhateverIWannaBe · 12/02/2007 12:39

but there are ways of avoiding that too dino.

speedymama · 12/02/2007 12:38

Wannabe, I know what you mean about tax credits because DH and I are entitled to none but tbh, it does not bother me. I see it as a safety net for those who actually need it. We don't need it because we cut our cloth accordingly. I suppose you could say those on lower incomes should do the same too but with the cost of living the way it is, I certainly do not begrudge those claiming tax credits .

OP posts:
Dinosaur · 12/02/2007 12:36

He would have to pay tax on the capital gain as it's not (from a UK tax point of view anyway) his principal private residence.

wannaBeWhateverIWannaBe · 12/02/2007 12:34

but dinosaur he will have worked hard and paid taxes all his life. if he sold that house he wouldn't be required to pay that level of tax on it, so why should that level of taxation be required purely because he has died?

Dinosaur · 12/02/2007 12:33

I think that it is outrageous that the likes of Philip Green can reap the benefits of living in a civilised country, and in his case get a knighthood to boot, and not pay more tax. Sorry, but it really sticks in my craw.

Dinosaur · 12/02/2007 12:32

Bugsy2, my dad has worked hard all his life, but the fact that his house in Ireland is worth a lot of money now is actually nothing to do with his hard work and everything to do with booming property prices in the Republic.

I suspect this is the case with many estates that now fall within the IHT bracket.

wannaBeWhateverIWannaBe · 12/02/2007 12:31

SM I think it?s punitive because in so many instances while you are expected to pay the higher tax you are entitled to less. Why should you not be entitled to tax credit for instance just because you earn a higher salary? Yes you earn more money and the argument may be that you do not need that money, but as 40% tax payers you are actually contributing a greater amount of tax to the state, and yet because you are a higher tax payer you do not have the same entitlements as the lower rate payers.

speedymama · 12/02/2007 12:31

So in the meantime, everybody else continues to pay their IHT and NI and the Monaco residence come and go as they please and still benefit from everthing that Britain has to offer courtesey of the tax payer!

OP posts:
Bugsy2 · 12/02/2007 12:30

Dino, why is it wrong to moan? Surely your parents worked hard & payed tax & NI all their lives. Why should your family be taxed again because they managed to put enough aside to leave some to you?

Bugsy2 · 12/02/2007 12:28

I suppose it depends how far in the upper tax bracket you are. If you are losing pretty much half your income after tax & NI that has to be a discinsentive. Well, it must be, as they are all buggering off to Monaco. So instead of seeing some of their tax, we are seeing none of it.
I don't honestly know what is right or wrong here, but I do know that it seems to be a slightly "cut of your nose to spite your face tax policy", if all the very wealthy bugger off, rather than give half their earnt income to Gordon.

wannaBeWhateverIWannaBe · 12/02/2007 12:27

But sm if you clamped down on the likes of Phillip green, he would simply leave the country, and go and live somewhere where he didn?t have to pay tax. No maybe he didn?t pay as much tax as he should have, but out of that amount he would have paid some, and ?some? of 1.2 billion is definitely worth more to the government than none. Also it?s worth noting that while he may not have paid income tax on all that money, he will have paid some capital gains tax, and that is still a tax.

speedymama · 12/02/2007 12:26

I personally think a lot of rich people who begrude paying taxes are just greedy and selfish.

OP posts:
Twinkie1 · 12/02/2007 12:25

I have 2 friends who have husbands who are black cab drivers - one was moaning last year about their 3 grand tax bill - I told them to shut up as they had an accountant who swindled their husbands tax bills and they also claimed working families tax credits when they earned too much to do so but got away with it because so much of their work is cash in hand or can be hidden - DH's 14 grand tax bill for one month really put it in perspective for them - this was for his bonus month and not a regular thing - but then he oays over 2k a months so it pretty much pissed me off.

Alright it's not a lot and they aren;t very rich but it sticks in my throat a little that thay can do this and get away with it and moan about being broke too!!

Dinosaur · 12/02/2007 12:25

Jimjams, would you mind asking your DH if it is really correct that only 6% of estates end up being subject to IHT? I would be very interested to know the truth about this. Sounds far too low to me.

If I inherit my parents' house in Ireland (which I hope I do, as the DSs love it) I will be absolutely crippled paying the IHT, but it seems wrong to moan when I would be getting a lovely house (albeit with a rather dodgy septic tank ).

speedymama · 12/02/2007 12:25

I don't see how an upper tax band of 40% is punitive (DH & I are both in the upper tax bracket btw).

OP posts:
Dinosaur · 12/02/2007 12:23

I wish I had the answers, speedymama! I don't get the impression that the UK tax regime is particularly punitive.

speedymama · 12/02/2007 12:22

Well Dinosaur, what can you say to that? I wonder if anyone has compared how much more income the govt would receive if it clamped down on tax avoider and how much it saves on clamping down on benefit cheats?

OP posts:
Bugsy2 · 12/02/2007 12:21

It is getting increasingly difficult to avoid tax nowadays. I work with very wealthy people, most of whom are self made & have worked very hard to earn their money & they are now starting to leave the UK because they find the taxation here so punitive.
I'm not sure what the morality of this is. But I know that Monaco & other tax havens are increasingly going to benefit from their expenditure rather than the UK - which is a very great shame.

wannaBeWhateverIWannaBe · 12/02/2007 12:18

But does he really pay very little income tax? Or does he pay proportionally less iyswim?

I actually disagree with the 40% tax band altogether. The ?rich? as people put it do pay as much tax as the ?poor? ? why should you have to pay more just because you earn over 35 k a year?

Dinosaur · 12/02/2007 12:15

on Philip Green

wannaBeWhateverIWannaBe · 12/02/2007 12:14

inheritance tax is immoral IMO, from the state's point of view. Why should people have to pay tax on money that has effectively already been earned? of course IT was originally implemented to catch the upper classes, but the levels have never moved in accordance with inflation/property prices, so most of us would now be caught by inheritance tax.

speedymama · 12/02/2007 12:14

What I find immoral is that the likes of Philip Green pays very little income tax because he can afford to exploit loopholes in the law.

OP posts: