Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect tax avoidance to be treated in the same way as benefit fraud

66 replies

speedymama · 12/02/2007 11:45

Does the govt put as much emphasis on clamping down rich folk who avoid paying taxes as they do on targetting benefit fraudsters?

I ask this because of the current advertising campaign against benefit cheats. I personally think it is just as wrong and in some ways more immoral, for those you can pay more tax but don't to get away with it because they can afford to get round all the loopholes.

Just want to add that benefit fraud is wrong too and should be dealt with accordingly. It just appears to me that society treats benefit cheats with more disdain than those who deliberately seek ways of avoiding to pay tax even though they can afford to pay it, e.g. residents of Monte Carlo who enjoy the trappings of being British.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
bran · 12/02/2007 19:41

Twoisenoughmum, I think that Bono (and other muscians/artists) doesn't pay very much tax because in Ireland artists don't pay tax on income from their art, so his royalties are not subject to tax but any other income/investment is taxable. It's been like that for as long as I can remember, and on the whole I think it's a good idea as the vast majority of artists struggle to make a living, so their tax contribution would be low anyway but the loss to the cultural heritage of the country if they left the country would be greater than the loss of tax. Although, obviously any sort of art vs. money calculation is very subjective. I did read in the papers a few years ago that the Irish govt is thinking of changing this so that the very high earners do pay more tax. If it does change it'll be interesting to see whether Bono still lives in Ireland or suddenly develops a need to leave in a tax haven.

twoisenoughmum · 12/02/2007 16:39

Nothing to hide re. DH's tax. He earned £33,000 profits self employed April 04 to February 05. In February 05 he ceased self employment and took a PAYE job. In order to calculate his tax due now the revenue added together both his self employed earnings and A WHOLE YEAR of PAYE earnings, making it look like he'd earned close to £120,000 in one year, and taxed him on that. When in fact he'd earned £120,000 over 22 months. £85,000 of that was PAYE on which he paid tax through the normal system like everyone else.

speedymama · 12/02/2007 16:27

JimJams, I do think it is crazy that people who are eligible for tax credits are in the same tax bracket as the rich . That is an example of our inequitable tax system which is skewed to favour the rich.

Twoisenougth, yikes! There has to be more to that tax bill than we are party to though.

OP posts:
Jimjams2 · 12/02/2007 16:07

Those are overseas investors though speedy- not UK based ones. Sounds from reading on here that they're taxed differently.

Jimjams2 · 12/02/2007 16:04

Bloody hell twois- that's crazy.

twoisenoughmum · 12/02/2007 16:00

Speedy - UK tax system is full of anomalies. My DH has recently been presented with a tax bill for £15,000 ... on self-employed earnings of just over £33,000. The explanation for this is long and complicated but grrrr grrrr grrrr at the likes of Branson, Green et al getting away with it. And didn't I hear somewhere that Bono with his holier than thou reputation the worst culprit of all?

Jimjams2 · 12/02/2007 15:57

I do one very wealthy person (i mean welathy wealthy- he's not British but main residence is in the uk) and he said that people are leaving the UK because of tax and taking their businesses with them (he was in Barbados I think and said it was crawling with Brits who said they were leaving because of tax laws). From the point of view of someone on a normal salary it might seem churlish, but if they're going they're going and I don't think that's particularly good.

I do resent dh paying 40% tax- but because he really doesn't seem to be a high earner - we still get tax credits for example. 40% seems too much given that 3 times his salary would buy a 2 bedroom terraced house with no parking and no garden (and we're nowhere near the south east). And we've never been able to access the services ds1 needs (until he went special school) so have ended up having to pay for stuff that should be state provided.

speedymama · 12/02/2007 15:56

I don't buy it that the tax burden in the UK is unfavourable compared to many other comparable nations. Why are we attracting so much investment from overseas companies, individuals etc?

Did anyone see that Money Programme called "What makes Britain rich?". Britain is rich because of the growing economy that is buoyed by the fact that our favourable tax laws attracts foreign money (private and corporate). Why do you think the likes of Phillip Green operate out of Britain rather than France or Germany?

Those here who don't want to pay their income tax are just plain greedy and selfish.

OP posts:
Dinosaur · 12/02/2007 15:39

We don't seem to have any trouble attracting dodgy Russian oligarchs

Cloudhopper · 12/02/2007 15:37

True, ladymuck. As I said, they have really clamped down on the tax advantages of being self employed and have squeezed a lot of the flexibility out of having a business, for UK residents.

I am sure that people with the choice to do so will move abroad, taking their wealth with them. Whether the people moving away are being driven out or tempted elsewhere is a moot point though.

Dinosaur · 12/02/2007 15:34

Thanks!

Ladymuck · 12/02/2007 15:33

I can enquire!

Ladymuck · 12/02/2007 15:32

Cloudhopper - there are still plenty of people leaving the country because of the tax rates alas. It is only a haven if you are not from the UK and don't earn much in the UK.

Dinosaur · 12/02/2007 15:30

If I CAT you, Ladymuck, would you be prepared to tell me which solicitors/accountants your parents have used to do their tax planning?

Ladymuck · 12/02/2007 15:29

Well assuming that he is Irish born (so his domicile of origin is Irish), and he has had property available to him there most of his life, my understanding is that there are precedents for him to be able to claim Irish domicile (despite the deemed UK domicile). It does still need appropriate planning and paperwork, but can be done. It reduces the tax issue but doesn't eliminate it as Ireland has Capital Acquisition Tax at 20%.

For someone moving to Spain or France the position is more difficult as they typically won't have domicle of origin in those countries, and they pretty much have to sever all ties with the UK. But Ireland tends to be treated differently though I'm afriad I can't name case precedent.

My parents are in a similar position and have arranged their affairs under 2 wills, one covering Irish property, and the other UK property (complete with the rather familiar nil band discretionary loan trust).

Dinosaur · 12/02/2007 15:28

No, both my parents are Irish. Funnily enough, they both have grave plots there, as have I!

Cloudhopper · 12/02/2007 15:27

The tax burden in this country is heavily weighted such that lower earners pay a higher percent of their incomes in tax. This takes into account the direct taxation as VAT, duty on fuel, cigarettes and alcohol etc.

The richest pay the smallest % of all - I think Richard Branson paid 9%, and he is just an example. Far from people leaving this country because of the tax burden, London is now considered something of a tax haven for people who have massive earnings abroad.

Part of the problem is the difficulty of taxing the rich, who will just move money around and pay advisors to help them make the 'best' of the law.

However, the government have realised that their best way of increasing the tax take is to target middle earners and the self employed. Self employment used to be a great way of avoiding tax, but it has really changed in the last 5 years.

dassie · 12/02/2007 15:24

Neithers my Mum but she's been here 30 years. My parents have found it very difficult!

Is he married to a British citizen?

Of course there is the old buying a grave trick. not sure if this still works very well because HMRC have cottoned on to it but if your Dad bought a grave plot for himself in Ireland and said he would be living out his days there, it might work!

Dinosaur · 12/02/2007 15:15

dassie, he's not a british citizen

Dinosaur · 12/02/2007 15:15

I thought it sounded too good to be true!

Ladymuck - are we missing something obvious here?

dassie · 12/02/2007 15:14

Domicile is very hard to change.

There was the case of the retiree who went off to Spain and claimed he was non-domiciled in the UK. HMRC got hold of a letter he'd sent to a friend saying that he was really homesick and used this to argue his domicile!

If he is living in the UK, is a British citizen, and has been here for the past 17/20 years it would be really hard to change.

As for tax avoidance - it is much harder to avoid tax as an employee than it is for a self employed person.

Hallgerda · 12/02/2007 14:48

When I was looking for nanny shares I was very shocked at the prevalence of not paying tax properly for the nanny. I dare say there are plenty of other illegal scams used by the better off which don't attract the same opprobium or enforcement effort as benefit fraud.

Dinosaur · 12/02/2007 14:35

Ladymuck, I think he's had some very bad advice then. He's been told that if you have spent 17 of the last 20 years in the UK, then you are domiciled in the UK for IHT purposes and there is nowt you can do about it!

Can you point me to a source for saying that changing your domicile is as simple as filling out a form? If he were domiciled in Ireland even though still living in England, I think he'd be delighted!

Ladymuck · 12/02/2007 14:17

I think that it is more of a risk under the Tories rather than Labour though. And I suspect that given the number of trusts alreadfy set up (and the number of wills already written with the intent of setting them up) their will still be a bit of work in the area for some time.

Have to say that my will would be much easier to understand if it wasn't written primarily to avoid IHT.

Jimjams2 · 12/02/2007 14:09

oh that's why dh is concerned about them scrapping IHT (he does lots of (c)) I thought they never would because it must bring in lots of revenue, but if its only 6% I can see why he thinks its a possibility (I do switch off as soon as tax is mentioned).

Swipe left for the next trending thread