Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

in wondering why it seems to be wrong on her to say...........

23 replies

2shoescoveredinhearts · 11/02/2007 22:40

you don't like a child?
saw it on another thread and wondered why people seem to get angry or annoyed if someone says the don't like a child

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BetterDays07 · 09/11/2022 19:28

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ -PBP

LittleBoSheep · 13/02/2007 13:40

I think its possible not to like certain children but its unacceptable as an adult to treat them differently because of that.

Also you have to remember that however unpleasant they are not the finished product so reserve your judgement of them until they are 20 or so...they may turn into really nice adults!!

I would say I am not a person who "likes" children (apart from my own!) but I know some who are lovely!

Troutpout · 13/02/2007 13:35

Nah..they're just kids...sometimes they behave like little scrotes but...they are still learning.
Can't say i don't like a kid
Not so forgiving of adults though...i hate plenty of them

Brangelina · 13/02/2007 13:34

And I don't understand why you're seen to have "issues" if you don't like someone. It is possible to dislike someone for absolutely no tangible reason. We're not all saints FGS!

kimivalentin · 13/02/2007 13:30

no one can like everyone all of the time.
I know a few childern i really dislike, and im sure they dislike me just as much.
I also know some adults i would not give time of day to tbh

Brangelina · 13/02/2007 13:26

There are def children I don't like, just the way that there are adults I don't like. Apart from the bad first impression thing, most of my genuine dislikes (of which there are v. few) are down to a gut feeling. Add to that the fact that I'm not really a children person anyway, but that usually means that I feel indifferent to other people's kids rather than actively dislike them. I'd never let on to someone that I dislike their little angel either, as it's not really their fault.

I know I'm not fond of my SIL's 4 yo DD (SIL as in sister of my DP, not partner of my brother) as she has become a right little madam and is manipulative in a sly and nasty way. When she was smaller she was quite sweet and it's a shame she's developed this personality as I just cannot warm to her. I do wonder if it's MIL's influence as she's with her rather a lot...

SofiaAmes · 13/02/2007 05:59

Children have personalities just like adults and there are definitely children whose personalities I prefer just as I do with adults. In fact there are children who I don't like, just like there are adults that I don't like. BUT, I am just as civil and polite to the children I don't like as I am to the adults I don't like. AND I try not to spend time around the children I don't like just like I avoid the adults I don't like.
There are certainly children that I have met that I would attribute characteristics like arrogant or cruel or nasty OR generous or cheerful or helpul to. Of course they have generally picked these qualities up from their parents and that means that one can't blame them for having these qualities, but I don't see why I can't acknowledge the existance of the qualities and react accordingly (eg I don't invite children who I think are cruel and nasty for playdates with my children).

OrmIrian · 12/02/2007 13:12

I wouldn't say that I didn't like an adult either. I've met too many people that made a bad impression on me at first, only to get to know them better and find they were really OK. A child is even more likely to change his personality and behaviour over time. Saying you don't like a child is like looking at a half-finished painting and saying you don't like it.

Having said all that I think you're perfectly entitled to say what you like about anyone. But possibly not aloud.

hana · 12/02/2007 10:02

of course there's nothing wrong with not liking paticular children. I can think of a few I don't really like that much. But I don't voice to to anyone. They are all school age

filthymindedvixen · 12/02/2007 09:55

a play assistant at ds2's preschool made it quite clear she didn't like him. And one day when I pulled her up over a comment she made to me about him, she said ''oh, it's so hard for me, because you're so nice but...''

I have never felt more upset during my 9 years of parenting as at that point to realise a 'professional' could not separate the child from the behaviour (he was going through a difficult patch behaviourally)

I sometimes feel I do not like a child but no-one would ever EVER know.
In fact when I worked at preschool, a child i thought I didn't like, turned out to be one of my 'favourites' within a couple of months. (again, no-one would have known she was a 'favourite' either )

wannaBeWhateverIWannaBe · 12/02/2007 09:49

I disagree that a 4 yo is a baby. A 4 yo does have its own personality, and while I do agree to a large extent that at that age they are still a product of their environment, I think that it is possible to have developed trates that are unpleasant and dislikeable.

There is a little girl who goes to my ds? preschool who I would say I don?t particularly like. In the past her and my ds have played together nicely, but as time has gone on she has developed into a not altogether nice little girl. If she and her best friend are together they actively pick on other children, pushing/being nasty/goading the children into reaction eg shoving things in their face etc. If this little girl is left out of any play she becomes extremely emotional, sobbing/screaming/throwing herself to the floor because she has been left out. And if she doesn?t get her own way she reacts in much the same way. IMO an unpleasant child.

I actually posted a topic on here recently asking at what age it was ok to not like a child, and the general answer that came back was 4.

StrawberrySnowflakes · 12/02/2007 08:23

a boy about 4-5 yesterday was in a paddy with his friend at soft play, my dd mistakenly got in firing line and he punched her right off eequipment she was on!..I DONT LIKE HIM!..and i told him off too!

sugarmagnolia · 12/02/2007 08:21

I don't think there's anything wrong with saying you don't like someone else's 4 year old. I think it's unfair to judge that child because, after all, they are only 4. Obviously a lot of their behaviour has to do with how they are brought up and everyone's 4 year old can have bad days, show off, act up etc. But even if you sympathise with or understand why the child acts that way it may not make it any easier to actually want to be around them.

smoggie · 11/02/2007 23:02

I think calling a 4yo arrogant is very strange and says more about the person making the comment and their relationship with the parents tbh(why is the little boy referred to as SILs ds and not brother's ds?).
I know of a few 4yo's who exhibit many traits that I don't like, but I have also seen the same child hugging my ds1 and playing beautifully. Any parent of a 4yo knows that if you catch them on a bad day then they can seem like the most unruly, disobedient, back-chatty child on the planet. An hour later in a 1-1 situation they are huging you and telling you they love you.
However, I can't honestly get too wound up by somebody else saying they don't like a 4 yo child. Yes it demonstrates a lack of understanding about children of this age and lack of tolerance, but I don't think it's a henous (?sp) crime to say it.

2shoescoveredinhearts · 11/02/2007 22:54

i do know what You mean. I met a small child and he was a bundle aof nauthyness and rather unlikeable. then I saw him with his mum and realise he was atten seeking rather than being naughty.
I asked the question out of genuine curiosity. as when you dc's are older it is hard to remeber what it was like when they were diddy.

OP posts:
northerner · 11/02/2007 22:51

Well yes, I have I suppose come accros kids who do/say things I don't like, but to say you do not like the chld is harsh and means you like nothing about them?

Surely very child has something likeable about them?

Adults are totally different of course!

VeniVidiVickiQV · 11/02/2007 22:50

Because, a child is, to a great extent, a product of its environment and its upbringing. At such a young age, to lay the burden of its behaviour and character at his/her own feet is, well lacking empathy, easy, and intolerant.

Also, because as a parent, we none of us like to think someone doesnt like our child, because they are precious, and ours, and a product of us, and in need of protection, and innocent.

2shoescoveredinhearts · 11/02/2007 22:48

ok forget that thread and can I sk agin in general. as I myself have found myself not likeing small children

OP posts:
northerner · 11/02/2007 22:47

Well this is a parenting forum, and that post in particular referred to a 4 year old child. He is merely a baby.

Skribble · 11/02/2007 22:46

I wouldn't say I don't like a child, I would say I don't like they way they are behaving. Too big a label to stick on a 4yr old. Of course not all children are appealing. Thats why I don't work in nurseries anymore, hate the little buggers .

In this situation she says she likes her SIL but not the child, she brought the child up that way!

2shoescoveredinhearts · 11/02/2007 22:46

but can a child not pick up on it's parents traits.........so if they are arrogant the child can pick that up iynwim

OP posts:
wannaBeWhateverIWannaBe · 11/02/2007 22:44

I don't think it's wrong to not like a child.

but I think it's wrong when you compare that child to an adult - ie the child on other thread was described as "arogant". sorry but I fail to see how one could apply that term to a 4 year old.

alipiggie · 11/02/2007 22:42

Aah wondered if someone would pick up on that.
Surely you can say that - we say it about adults enough don't we. Is it because it's viewed as "cruel" to say it about a child.