Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I wrong to offer an ultimatum? His family or us?

37 replies

IsItMeOrrrrr · 30/10/2016 19:34

My OH comes from a textbook enmeshed family and he absololoutly agrees. They have been awful to me but I don't take it personally as they hate all outsiders. All partners of their children are hated or under their thumb and still hated, all extended family members are conniving, and they literally have no friends.

They are seriously textbook. Someone is always sick. They on the verge of bankruptcy with a household income of around 150k but they guilt us for going on holiday. Gambling, alcohol, medication and drug addiction ALL exist in their house but it is denied and they spend their whole time judging and talking about others!

Anyway, I was NEVER going to be the daughter in-law for them and after years of insults towards me and accusations of me brainwashing their dear son, I decided I would basically stop seeing them except on occasion where it was for the kids. Mine or my OH's nephews.

My daughters birthday party has just passed and they 'couldn't' come. To put it into perspective, their dad has been to our house (less than an hour away) 3 times in 10 years! Once when my daughter was 3 months and my OH and I had a pretty big fall out. I looked outside and the dad had arrived to collect 'his' son and move him back 'home'. He did not check on me or his Granddaughter. Once when my OH and his Brother had a big fall out and I called the dad to come and calm the situation. That ended up in me being blamed for the whole thing and a whole host of accusations against me for using his son, brainwashing his son, trapping his son bla bla bla - I was 21 at the time. And one other time for his son's 30th!

Apparently the reason they couldn't come 'this' time was because the party was on the same day as their 29 year old sons birthday! He spends hardly any time at home and his birthday would have consisted of getting over a hangover, a happy birthday song and cake, potentially a takeaway and him off out again! Its also important to note that my daughters party was in the afternoon and finished at 3pm!

So my OH puts this out there and is told that he has to make more of an effort for his family. 98% of the time he has seen them in the last 10 years it has been his effort. He has dropped fortnightly visits to every 8 or so weeks. He says its a two way thing, and that's the extent of his 'dealing' with the situation.

They also have other grandchildren who visit them almost daily, and as a result, they make a lot of plans that my mine are never invited to be part of. Day trips, holidays etc.

The day after the party was a family event and his dad asks my OH to come over. I don't put any restrictions on them seeing my children but this time I said no!

I'm concerned about the lesson that gives them i.e. Run to people without question that don't make the effort for you, and this time as it was literally the day after my daughters birthday it felt like for once I couldn't let it slide.

My OH said he would still take them which resulted in a near tussle to stop him going through the door with my children.

I'm aware that my problem is him not them. He will eventually say sorry for his behaviour and get re-angry at them. To me he's pathetic and his weakness with his dad in particular makes me genuinely loose love for him. He has no backbone and he typical to an enmeshed family member he is riddled with guilt and fear. After this many years I just can't remain sympathetic with the fact he has been conditioned. He doesn't stand up for me but more importantly he doesn't stand up for our children. And, he's modelling something very wrong in the process.

I have been advised to finally give him an ultimatum. Them or us. And that doesn't mean not see them, but rather stand up to their bullshit and bullying. I have also been advised to stop the children from going to them until they make some effort to come to us and/or include them in their wider family activities.

My reluctance is the fact I know that they wont. This will all become about me (I'm strong enough to take it) and me trying to take him away from his family again. Their actions suggest that they don't give a shit about my children but rather 'their' son but still it feels wrong to stop my children's contact especially as my OH has cousins who they love. His brothers and sisters WILL ALL take the parents side.

One other part of me is also worried about the accusation of 'trying to take him away from his family'. Although I know it's not true, part of their conditioning has also rubbed off on me and has me doubting myself.

I would really appreciate some additional perspective's.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
user1475796520 · 18/11/2022 08:32

to Januarcelebration

i can reply to whatever thread i want to reply to. what does it matter really? the fact that you're here replying to my comment within seconds of it being posted says more about you lol

user1475796520 · 18/11/2022 08:30

even more astounded that you replied so quickly

Januarcelebration · 18/11/2022 08:27

user1475796520 · 18/11/2022 08:26

i am absolutely astounded by the amount of people on here telling this woman to allow their children to see people who hate her. do you think that grandparents who hate the mother of their grandchild /children and is severely enmeshed with their adult child can truly be good for said grandchildren? yes he is their father but these children are not tools for daddy to use to appease his mommy and daddy that he never learned to have boundaries with. there's a saying " if you don't stand for something you will fall for anything"
if these inlaws are against their marriage they are against the children's wellbeing. if hubby had a spine and was doing what he had to then im sure op would be confident that he would be able to protect the children if the granny and grandad or whatever member of his family began talking negatively about mommy which these types of enmeshed people tend to do. its all about control and getting what they want. an ultimatum can be the best thing especially if you've dealt with an enmeshed cult like family for too long and would rather no longer be made their scapegoat or villain. im absolutely flabbergasted by the people here who think its appropriate for op partner to put their children in harms way by allowing people who hate and disrespect their mother to have whatever access they want. that's not a marriage. that's a situation where the enmeshed family cult is controlling their marriage and decisions and op partner needs longterm counselling to see that this set up is dysfunctional and will destroy his marriage and damage their children. what's the point in being married to someone who can't prioritise you and your children's wellbeing? it should not have to come to op and her partner having to tussle to stop him taking the kids to his parents. if they were respectful and civil to op i don't see how op would object. but i would be damned if people hate me, smear me and are trying to destroy my marriage then have access to our young innocent impressionable children. i see alot of spineless people in these comments. if ops h is going to continue to cause chaos in his nuclear family because he can't say no to his mommy and daddy then im sure op would be better off without him. at least she doesn't have to worry about him allowing his family to bully and disrespect her. when you marry someone they become a part of you. you become one and you forsake all others. even your mommy and daddy. you do not go against your spouse for anyone. that's disloyal. obviously in cases of domestic v that's different but some of you do not seem to understand how severely toxic, dysfunctional enmeshed family cults can affect a person. and how hellbent they get to push someone out they consider to be in their way. i would never allow people around my children who disrespect me and are against my marriage and are actively trying to destroy it and if the person i married were ok to allow their family to bully and abuse me then i would most definitely give them an ultimatum and be ready to follow through. that's what ultimatums are.

I am astounded you decided to revive a thread from 2016 tbh.

user1475796520 · 18/11/2022 08:26

i am absolutely astounded by the amount of people on here telling this woman to allow their children to see people who hate her. do you think that grandparents who hate the mother of their grandchild /children and is severely enmeshed with their adult child can truly be good for said grandchildren? yes he is their father but these children are not tools for daddy to use to appease his mommy and daddy that he never learned to have boundaries with. there's a saying " if you don't stand for something you will fall for anything"
if these inlaws are against their marriage they are against the children's wellbeing. if hubby had a spine and was doing what he had to then im sure op would be confident that he would be able to protect the children if the granny and grandad or whatever member of his family began talking negatively about mommy which these types of enmeshed people tend to do. its all about control and getting what they want. an ultimatum can be the best thing especially if you've dealt with an enmeshed cult like family for too long and would rather no longer be made their scapegoat or villain. im absolutely flabbergasted by the people here who think its appropriate for op partner to put their children in harms way by allowing people who hate and disrespect their mother to have whatever access they want. that's not a marriage. that's a situation where the enmeshed family cult is controlling their marriage and decisions and op partner needs longterm counselling to see that this set up is dysfunctional and will destroy his marriage and damage their children. what's the point in being married to someone who can't prioritise you and your children's wellbeing? it should not have to come to op and her partner having to tussle to stop him taking the kids to his parents. if they were respectful and civil to op i don't see how op would object. but i would be damned if people hate me, smear me and are trying to destroy my marriage then have access to our young innocent impressionable children. i see alot of spineless people in these comments. if ops h is going to continue to cause chaos in his nuclear family because he can't say no to his mommy and daddy then im sure op would be better off without him. at least she doesn't have to worry about him allowing his family to bully and disrespect her. when you marry someone they become a part of you. you become one and you forsake all others. even your mommy and daddy. you do not go against your spouse for anyone. that's disloyal. obviously in cases of domestic v that's different but some of you do not seem to understand how severely toxic, dysfunctional enmeshed family cults can affect a person. and how hellbent they get to push someone out they consider to be in their way. i would never allow people around my children who disrespect me and are against my marriage and are actively trying to destroy it and if the person i married were ok to allow their family to bully and abuse me then i would most definitely give them an ultimatum and be ready to follow through. that's what ultimatums are.

Bruce02 · 31/10/2016 18:58

My pil have never seen our kids on their exact birthday. Ds didn't see them until 2 months after his last birthday. When we went to them. It wouldn't occur to me to ban them from seeing the kids. And it doesn't bother the kids at all, because they see it doesn't bother us.

You keep saying they do stuff that makes your kids feel less. But aside from not coming on their birthday you won't say anything else.

I really don't think you should be creating like this when dh is trying to take them out. You say the kids want to see them. So what's the issue?

PigletWasPoohsFriend · 31/10/2016 18:45

I can't see you moving forward as partners and a couple unless something changes, this stalemate is not doing either of you any good

Certainly not doing the DC any good.

Tusseling over them is not acceptable.

0dfod · 31/10/2016 18:42

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

shovetheholly · 31/10/2016 15:21

Of course you're sick of it. Anyone would be! It's exhausting for you.

The problem is, though, that an ultimatum is likely to make him extremely stressed, because he just doesn't have the skills or the emotional support to be able to cope with having to face down either you or his family. And he will probably become angry and resentful at being put in such an uncomfortable position. Better to work on his assertiveness and self-esteem in counselling and then let him draw the boundaries. This doesn't mean that you do nothing - counselling may be quite a scary prospect for him and you may need to gently prod him there - it's just a different strategy.

I also think that when he is stronger and things more settled, you will need time yourself to deal with all the crap that this has put on you.

IsItMeOrrrrr · 31/10/2016 14:32

Thanks Odfod - I actually asked it to be moved here for traffic but I think I'll ask for it to be moved back.

Morris again quote "There is SOOOO much more of a back story with their treatment of me and my children". Naturally, I'm not going to state all of it here, and in and amongst a lot of other things I've said, it's odd that you seem to obsess over that one detail without considering the wider context.

The funny thing is I'm not really even a birthday person, they are!

OP posts:
TheNaze73 · 31/10/2016 14:31

Just be prepared, with any ultimatum, to get the answer you don't want.

I always think they are doomed

0dfod · 31/10/2016 13:08

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

MorrisZapp · 31/10/2016 13:06

I'm still not clear what the shit is that they give your kids. Is it just their failure to come to your house?

These threads always confuse me. As a child, I wouldn't have thought to question why adults were or weren't at my house or why. Do they really get upset because their GPS don't come on their exact birthday? Don't they do extended family stuff? My parents are away pissing away my inheritance half the time, they regularly miss birthdays. DS doesn't notice.

IsItMeOrrrrr · 31/10/2016 13:04

Jelly that is honestly how I feel and it's as a result of years of being the bad guy and his inability do anything about that, even though he agrees. I could bear it when it was just me, but not the kids. I have given him years to stand up for them but he is literally too scared.

I know that I'm not being the best partner (anymore) but I'm tired. I'm sick of being on their bad side for doing absolutely nothing. I'm sick of my children being treated like spare parts. I'm sick of my OH being a bad guy for having his own kids and moving out of his family home 10 years ago! Most importantly I'm sick of his inability to stop this crap affecting us, even with me not having anything to do with them.

Wizzy & Shov, your advice seems sensible and fair. I've always thought of us needing relationship counseling but you're right, he needs space to work on his conditioning alone.

I will encourage that and give it all a bit more time.

OP posts:
IsItMeOrrrrr · 31/10/2016 12:51

WannaBe Just to quote, I said "which resulted in a near tussle to stop him".....

Resulted in violence is slightly over the top!

I have never slagged off his family in front of them.

Where did you get any of this?

OP posts:
WannaBe · 31/10/2016 11:12

We're talking about a child's birthday party here and you resorted to violence over it? There are no excuses for using your children as objects of tug of war at the front door. Seriously.

At the end of the day they are his family and while they may be awful it is not up to you to decide what kind of relationship he chooses to have with them. It is also not up to you to decide that his children cannot have a relationship with them. And where exactly do the children get the idea from that you always go to them and not the other way around? Assuming they are small children it's more than likely that they have got that idea from you and nowhere else.

Stop slagging his family off in front of your children. Stop subjecting your children to being witnesses to domestic violence on your part, Go no contact with his family by all means but only you can choose to do that.

Additionally, if you actually split up He would likely get 50% access at which times he can take his children where he wants including to see his family, so how exactly do you think that giving him an ultimatum is protecting them?

You sound as bad as his family.

JellyBelli · 31/10/2016 10:54

You and your kids should go NC as much as possible with them. If your DH chooses to stay enmeshed with them thats his problem, not yours.
He is choosing them over his own kids. I'd say that to him, give it a go for say 6 months then review the situation.

At the same time you should be making plans to protect yourself and leave, as a contingency plan. I think that is what the eventual outcome will be. Flowers

shovetheholly · 31/10/2016 10:40

I don't know about an ultimatum. I don't think it's a great idea, because I actually think your DH has been conditioned by his upbringing to avoid conflict with these people - and putting him right in the middle of one without giving him any assistance in shoring up his boundaries might be incredibly stressful and awful for him. The way to deal with a weak boundary in physical reality is not to batter it with a forceful assault. It needs to be supported and made stronger first.

I would suggest counselling instead. My DH came from an enmeshed family where he really was afraid to set any boundaries at all with his parents. He had about 12 sessions of counselling and it was transformative. It helped him to grow so much - he became far more confident in himself, and was able to start to set limits and boundaries on unreasonable behaviour.

This led to some tantrums and angst at the start, which were not at all easy to deal with. However, over the course of years, we have all moved to a much more settled, calm and respectful place. We try to meet them half way on things where we can - and if something isn't possible, we either say no or find a compromise that is more suitable.

It also enabled DH to deal more firmly with conflict at work, which led to rapid promotion. So the counselling has paid for itself hundreds of times over.

wizzywig · 31/10/2016 10:20

OP are you me? My story is identical minus the physical violence. They prefer drama and emotional abuse. What ultimately happened was that my husband went to counselling to see how he could continue (or not) to be married to me seeing as i was such a cow (he was heavily influenced by his family). Anyway, the counsellor made him realise that it was his family that were emotionally abusive and were bullies. A year on he is still to go nc and is a wreck as his world has blown apart. Our marriage has never been better

IsItMeOrrrrr · 31/10/2016 10:20

Sorry posted too soon!

Thanks for the replies. I wasn't sure about an ultimatum which is why I posted and I do feel that it is somewhat too much. An ultimatum wouldn't be asking him to stop seeing them, but rather him stand up to their behaviour when it concerns me or the children. Similarly, my children going there will no longer be an automatic, but rather when they make the effort to come to them and include them in their wider family activities. But as posters have said, knowing that the GP's won't make an effort would be me stopping myDC's relationship with them.

There is SOOOO much more of a back story with their treatment of me and my children. I have been able to detach quite easily and I'm really not interested in their constant bitching, stories and drama so the distance for me is really a win win.

My issue is the kids and the message they get about themselves in that they feel less worthy compared to other family members. Honestly, the excitement they have when they think they are coming and the disappointment is heartbreaking when they don't. One of my OH's nephews came down and they were overjoyed to see him in comparison to all of their other cousins. It's like they almost couldn't believe that he had come to them. They see this cousin a lot as my OH takes them there but it's always them doing the running. It's the idolisation of them I worry about, especially in comparison to all of the other family members that DO make an effort for them. Maybe I'm thing too much and children aren't that receptive......

I understand comments about being more supportive of my OH. Ten years of this crap has lost any sympathy I did have. I really used to make effort with them, even after all the accusations and stories about me. The hardest thing for me to contend with is that things would be said in front of my OH and he wouldn't stand up for me or correct their false allegations. Till this day, rather than engage in conversations about how their treatment of the DC's is unfair, he will argue with me. All the while he has never said a word to them. I can't be in his corner if he'd rather be in theirs. I used to feel sorry for him and still supported him through all of the hurt and the guilt he was made to feel. Now I see him witness their crap towards the children and not do or say anything, I feel like I have to stand up. But maybe I'm over thinking this all.

OP posts:
PurpleDaisies · 31/10/2016 10:11

If you don't want to see them, that's absolutely your choice but you're playing a dangerous game by forcing your husband to choose. If he picks then you absolutely have to know you'd leave or your ultimatum is pointless.

The fight at the door in front of the children should never happen again. Family birthdays are always tricky and if I was invited to two on the same day I'd go with whichever invitation came first. I don't think that particular incident was as dreadful as you're making it out to be.

GinIsIn · 31/10/2016 10:03

You keep referring to them as "my children". They are not - they are both of your children. If you don't want to see his family that's fine, but you can't demand that he doesn't or not allow the children to.

GiddyOnZackHunt · 31/10/2016 09:58

If he refused to pick I actually think I could end it.
You need to be sure you could. 100% sure and ready if you're contemplating an ultimatum. If he won't pick or picks them, you have to be able to end it. Not use it as a tool to get your own way.

IsItMeOrrrrr · 31/10/2016 09:55

Thanks for the replies. I wasn't sure about an ultimatum which is why I posted and I do feel that it is somewhat too much.

There is SOOOO much more of a back story with their treatment of me and my children. I have been able to detach quite easily and I'm really not inter about their constant stories and drama so the distance is really a win win.

My issue is the kids.

OP posts:
DeathStare · 31/10/2016 09:37

part of me is also worried about the accusation of 'trying to take him away from his family'. Although I know it's not true

But if you told him to choose between them and you that would be true.

Personally I think you were in the wrong.

Clearly they are unreasonable and you have (quite reasonably) decided to limit your ow contact with them. However you state yourself that contact for the children was something you agreed to. You can't unilaterally change that - your DH has as much of a right to decide whether the children see his family as you do. You turning it into a near tussle by the door is completely unacceptable.

FWIW, while I agree that they sound like unpleasant unreasonable people, I think you completely over-reacting to this specific incident. They didn't come to your DC's birthday because they had a prior commitment. That's perfectly reasonable. That commitment was their own child's birthday. Again perfectly reasonable.

I understand that this comes in the context of many other incidents but you picked the wrong argument in my opinion.

takesnoprisoners · 31/10/2016 09:05

Eeks. OP, you don't seem very pleasant either. Both of you need to grow up and learn to live your lives.

Swipe left for the next trending thread