Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

for believing that people

135 replies

3andnomore · 10/02/2007 22:58

shouldn't be doing something (nothing in particular right now) because on just shouldn't , rather because one fears punishment?

OP posts:
3LoveHeartsAndNoMore · 10/02/2007 23:23

isn't it better though to be your own worst judge ?
I mean, for example,sportsmen tend to be succesful because they can motivate themselfs, etc....

TheArmadillo · 10/02/2007 23:19

surely by teaching children not to do something because of empathy/morals/ethics is teaching them to punish themselves (by feeling guilty or bad).

aviatrix · 10/02/2007 23:15

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

TheArmadillo · 10/02/2007 23:15

punishment by society is something others inflict on you but (am I not sure I can explain it very well) when you don't do something because it is 'wrong' surely it is because you still fear feeling bad/guilty which is a punishment you would inflict on yourself.

Being pedantic, I know. I do agree with you but I can't help thinking these things.

aviatrix · 10/02/2007 23:15

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

HeartOnMyGreensleeve · 10/02/2007 23:10

It is one of the most compelling arguments against modern standardised "positive parenting" methods. The child learns how to behave according to a set of criteria guided by a system of good and bad consequences (bribery and blackmail) rather than learning about empathy/morality/ethics/the "real" reasons for some behaviours being more desirable socially than others. It could be argued also that this standardisation of parenting into asimple system of training - like training an animal by using positive and negative reinforcers - suits modern parents better, because a) we generally have less time and more commitments outside the family, b) extended family/community infrastructures are much looser than they used to be and parents can become isolated in their parenting, and c) in a culture where children may have several "primary" carers and more and more of children's upbringing is contracted out to dispassionate professionals, it is easier to have a uniform system in which all the rules and reinforcers are the same.

3LoveHeartsAndNoMore · 10/02/2007 23:08

Oh, not disagreeing at the punishment bit...just finding it sad that people need it as motivation, iykwim

TheArmadillo · 10/02/2007 23:02

people 'shouldn't' not do something just because they fear punishment, rather than because they know it is wrong.

HOwever people don't always do what they should or shouldn't. Also society sets the moral code and not every individual is going to agree with every single part of it so punishment is there to make sure they conform.

WelshBoris · 10/02/2007 23:00

If they are decent people with morals, then they wouldn't do "something" because they are good. Not because they are afraid of the repercussions.

I agree with you.

3andnomore · 10/02/2007 22:59

one just shouldn't

OP posts: