Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

for believing that people

135 replies

3andnomore · 10/02/2007 22:58

shouldn't be doing something (nothing in particular right now) because on just shouldn't , rather because one fears punishment?

OP posts:
moondog · 11/02/2007 17:14

Basically,yes.
That's the theory anyway.

Zog · 11/02/2007 17:14

Can you explain further MD? Maybe with an example?

colditz · 11/02/2007 17:13

How would you fade? By giving a smaller piece of chocolate, or a shorter swing upside down?

moondog · 11/02/2007 17:10

May I just add that if using behavioural techniques properly,reinforcers (such as chocolate or swinging upside down)can be used but the golden rule is that they must be faded.
(Am doing MSc in Applied Behaviour Analysis)

colditz · 11/02/2007 17:07

Hmmm.

So, simplistically, is it better to say, upon dealing with misbehavior, "I am taking away a pasta because you kicked your brother" or "You have really hurt your brother and that was naughty and mean. Poor (brother's name)!"

Jimjams2 · 11/02/2007 17:04

I put this on the other thread, but at bedtime last night I blew ds1 a kiss and he blew one back for the first time ever. The fact that getting that kiss took 4 years of table work, reinforcment wiith choc buttons, as well as more social reinforcement by hanging upside down etc didn't, and the fact that it came at 7 didn't make it any less special than ds2 or ds3's that came aged 12 months with no teaching using tangible rewards being necessary.

I also know that if I didn't have a good understaning of reinforcement ds1 would have a whole host of challenging behaviours by now (he began to collect them when he spent 4 terms in mainstream with people who didn't properly understand reinforcement- and that wasn't my view- I didn't see what was going on- that was the view of an autism specialist). I don't apply behavioural methods so carefully to ds2 and ds3, I don't chart their behaviours for example- I don't have to. They're far easier- they're positively reinforced by pleasing me for starters.

Jimjams2 · 11/02/2007 16:58

but your son wants to please you- he knows that treating other people nicely pleases you- that's can still be reinforcement. Yes, you can tune into empathy if its there, but it takes quite a few years to develop (and many aduylts appear to be completely lacking ime), so you need to do something in the meantime. Once the wish to please you is there then of course it makes sense to use that reinforcement. I prefer ds1 to have swinging upside down as reinforcement than slivers of choc buttons because I prefr to work with social reinforcement when possible.

Behaviourism isn't all about providing tangible rewards on completion of some predetermined task- it's much more subtle than that- eg the smiling example I gave earlier.

Another example (stolen from the don't shoot the doog book)is kids squabbling in the car- one way they give to get rid of it is to play games- eye spy etc-because its incompatible with squabbling.

HeartOnMyGreensleeve · 11/02/2007 15:55

Yes, the pasta jar/star chart are just common examples of reinforcers - of course there are as many others as there are families using them, I think that's immaterial really. If your ds1 likes you shouting "No", that's a positive reinforcer. Another child might prefer a chocolate button or a sticker.

It does sound, from your post, as though your ds1's particular condition makes behavioural techniques appropriate for him. I would suggest that the empathy issue lies at the heart of what characterises autism, so the priority is to modify behaviour, rather than developing an understanding of why certain behaviours are unacceptable. I am making the point that IMO in NT children the capacity for fellow-feeling/theory of mind/empathy renders pure behaviour-modification techniques, using reward/punishment reinforcers neither necessary or appropriate, and such methods cannot and do not produce properly socialised adults.

Jimjams2 · 11/02/2007 15:45

I have to go out now- but will return to this later- just a quick something to clear up. The main way I use behavioural techniques with ds1 to tackle challenging behaviours is to ensure that I am not unwittingly reinforcing when he does something difficult. When he pinches me he rather likes me to shout "no" and he'll do it again to get another one, he likes it even more if I (or anyone else) screams, I've been trying therefore to block his hands whilst looking bored/actiing bored- to make the whole activity uninteresting. I missed that blocking his hands was likely to be quite enjoyable for him (grabbing wrists).

Explaining to him that he's hurt someone else isn't really an option.

Without the proper application of behaviourism he would have learned nothing. If you lok at my thread on SN on imitation- such a basic skill- most children are pretty much born with it- I don't remember a time when ds2 and ds3 couldn;t imitate. It's taken us about 4 years to teach it- and he truly understands it. With that in place speech becomes a possibility (by no means a certainty- but without imitation I think its impossible to speak). If that's been achieved via the use of chocolate buttons and being swung around and held upside down (favoured method of reinforcement at the moment) then so be it. He wouldn't have got it any other way.

I'll come back to this later- but to be honest when you talk about behaviourism you describe something that I don't even recognise. I think we're talking about different things. There's no pasta jar in this house and there hasn'[t been a star chart since ds2 was toilet trained 2 years ago.

Empathy though requires theory of mind.And whilst ds1 certainly has some understandsing of others thoughts and feelings he's a long way from being able to process an explanation about pinching hurting others.

HeartOnMyGreensleeve · 11/02/2007 15:27

I would also add (without wishing to upset/offend) that the capacity for empathy might be different in an autistic person, so different methods of conditioning social behaviour might be appropriate with an autistic child. This is only a personal opinion drawn from my own experience of severe autism, which is much less extensive than yours Jimjams - I'd be interested to know what you think - are behaviorist techniques perhaps more effective with an autistic child because of the particular psychosocial impairments autism involves?

I am sincerely not meaning to offend, just to explore.

HeartOnMyGreensleeve · 11/02/2007 12:40

I think the argument about moral/ethical understanding and empathy just being a conditioning system for self-punishment is terrible, in fact I'm quite shocked by it.

Empathy isn't a tool for blackmailing oneself, it's a vital part of the maturation of the human character - the awareness of other people as distinct from oneself and the recognition that others' experiences are as real as one's own. If my 4yo kicks his brother in the shin, I explain to him how it makes his brother feel and ask him to imagine how he would feel if someone did it to him. So he knows why his brother is crying and mummy is upset. That's not about making him feel bad, it's about him learning that his behaviour towards others matters in a real way, rather than just being about HIS pasta jar or HIS star chart or HIS being in trouble - it's not all about him! If he had no capacity for empathy he wouldn't feel bad in response to stimuli like me being cross or his brother crying anyway - only the lost star/pasta/time-out would produce a reaction. I believe there is a correlation between that message and the fact that he will rush to help another child who has fallen over and hurt himself. I'm not teaching him to punish himself internally, I'm teaching him that other people exist, just as he does, and that he can make the right decisions without self-interest (ie desire for reward or fear of punishment).

Teaching children to sit up and beg for rewards or conform purely in order to avoid punishment reduces them to the level of dumb animals and deprives them of the joy and dignity of a proper connected relationship with other people and a sense of participating in society. I think it's horrible cynical to suggest that basic human decency - not wilfully abusing others - is just a construct for controlling behaviour in the same way as a star chart/sweetie jar/cane.

But I suppose to someone who genuinely doesn't believe in the human capacity for altruism, empathy and self-punishment could appear synonymous - that's appallingly sad, IMO.

charliecat · 11/02/2007 12:15

Ive always thought its a bloody good job that the majority arent thieves ands rapists and thugs etc as who would stop the majority if we were all breaking into houses and smashing cars and mugging old ladies etc?

aviatrixxx · 11/02/2007 12:09

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

3LoveHeartsAndNoMore · 11/02/2007 10:01

expat, don't think though it's that much of a matter of carrot via stick...I honestly thnk people should just do things because it's the right thing to do...i.e. follow simple rules, etc....there shouldn't really be the need for a carrot nor a stick...iykwim.
What always makes me love, is those that seem to be unable to follow a rule are then also those that complain the most about any new measurements put in place to enforce that the orginal rule is followed.
Example....fair few years ago, 30mph zone, ion front of a school, but people didn't necessarily feel they had to follow that rule and kept speeding....and I knew a fair few of those people, and those people than started moaning when they put in speedbumps, roundabouts and made the road narrower at one point...this of course could really slow things down big time...!
I must say, I just turned around in one of those moaning session and told them, that if people could just go 30mph because it says so (because obviously there is a reason for it to be a 30mph zone, right), and not continously break that rule, there woldn't be the need to spend loads of money on roundabouts and shite like that...I mean...it's simple really...is it not?

expatinscotland · 10/02/2007 23:48

the old chesnut carrot v. stick.

depends on the situation, entirely.

Jimjams2 · 10/02/2007 23:39

2 posts back- should be challenging behaviours!

TheArmadillo · 10/02/2007 23:39

that's really interesting.

As you may have gathered my knowledge of natural selection/evolution is poor but I do find this stuff interesting.

Jimjams2 · 10/02/2007 23:38

sorry - crossed post- no - I would say that students looking attenitve is reinforcing for people giving lectures±!

Jimjams2 · 10/02/2007 23:36

natural selection doesn't really work at a species level (except in very special cases), so if empathy has evolved it will be for individual gains.

There's a very good book by Karen Pryor ( a dolphin trainer of all things)- Don't shoot the dog- gives a very good, easy to follow explanation of reinforcement and shaping. I was once advised by a very wise man that if a dolphin trainer ever offered to work with ds1then we should bite their hand off as they have such a detailed understanding of reinforcement and shaping behaviours (which is bloody difficult to do). For example at the moment we have chalening behaviours in that ds1 will pinch and pinch and pinch. My hands are covered in bruises and my neck in scratches. I've taken at times to grabbing his wrists (to stop him repeatedly going for me), that is I was grabbing his wrists until it was pointed out to me that for him having his wrists squeezed was probably wonderful, so I was inadvertantly reinforcing the pinching behaviour. I need a dolphin trainer- they'd never make that mistake (now he can ask for a squeeze but I make sure he doesn;t get one for pinching).

TheArmadillo · 10/02/2007 23:31

JJ do you think that would suggest some kind of innate empathy/morality or a need to conform to some societal rules?

TheArmadillo · 10/02/2007 23:29

Do you think that there is some biological/evolutional reasoning to some empathic feelings? For example do not kill as they may lead to a problem in passing on your genes or that your specie's survival may be damaged as a result.

The way that (most) people are protective towards children - is that an evolutionary response.

Would these therefore be inherent? and as a result have these formed the basis for a basic/general moral code for the human race as a whole?

Jimjams2 · 10/02/2007 23:29

You go into a lecture. You agree with the whole class beforehand that every time the teacher smiles, you'll sit up straight and look more attentive. The lecture before you record the number of smiles per lecture from the teacher (do it a few times- take an average- it's more accurate). Then you implement your plan; smile= whole class sitting up straight and looking more attentive. And you record the number of smiles from the teacher. do it for a few lectures - take an average

Guess what happens to the number of smile? They triple or quadruple or something- significant difference. (That's been done btw)

Using behavioural methods properly does not have to be about blatant bribery.

3LoveHeartsAndNoMore · 10/02/2007 23:27

hm...if everyone would respect eachother, I think that would be quite nice....
i know to simplified, of course!

aviatrixxx · 10/02/2007 23:25

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

3LoveHeartsAndNoMore · 10/02/2007 23:24

and I think what greensleeves means is not so muhc that one judges themselfs harshly, but respects others....