Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

for believing that people

135 replies

3andnomore · 10/02/2007 22:58

shouldn't be doing something (nothing in particular right now) because on just shouldn't , rather because one fears punishment?

OP posts:
3LoveHeartsAndNoMore · 11/02/2007 20:37

Hm...reading the below posts I can see how valuable behaviourable management is with sn children, especially in the autism spectrum, and of course that has to be a winning point....however, with non sn children, who should be able to get the whole emotional stuff...surely greensleeves way is the better way, i.e. let them act to it because they want to , not because they fear punishment or just non-"ackonodgement"....
hmmmmmmmm

peanutbutterkid · 11/02/2007 20:32

I want to read your essay, Moondog.

Jimjams2 · 11/02/2007 20:26

oh moondog am interested in that- because I read his website and thought that he seemed to misunderstand what reinforcement was.

There are times that I would use some sort of negative response to a situation like the poor behaviour of ds2 at the table one. I don't with ds2 because one of the reasons he kicks off is because ds1 gets an awful lot of attention at the table (he's still hand fed at times) - so me directing lots of negative shouty behaviour at ds2 is likely to be reinforcing for him if he is trying to get atention (which I think he is). So instead he gets lots of lovely positive attention when he's eating nicely and nothing when he's not.

Mwah nadine- although I wish I knew who you were

moondog · 11/02/2007 20:18

Aviatrix,if punishment was used correctly,it to would be faded as the child would discover the intrinsic worth of having a tidy room,as JJ's ds has discovered the intrinsic worth of positive social interaction.

I do agree about the value of tidying the room though-I don't think it is worth getting in a tizz about.

Interesting that you mention 'Punished by Rewards' by Alfie Kohn.He os on my reading list too and is referred to extensively by my lecturer.....as an example of someone who really doesn't understand correct use of punishment and reward.

I have just done an essay on one of his quotes.

Jimjams2 · 11/02/2007 20:17

and I'll jump in before someone says it- If ds2 is fussing at the table I don;t do anything other than tell him he can leave his food and get down- no problem. He's not punished for not eating his food- he just doesn't get me saying "wow you ate that so well today- I'm really pleased with how you behaved at the table". So he just gets no reinforcement for fussing- it;s a null response rather than a negative one. Since I've started laying it on thick in the way described above his table behaviour has improved dramatically.

NadineBaggott · 11/02/2007 20:16

jimjams - mwah!

Jimjams2 · 11/02/2007 20:13

I was pondering all this tonight- Several times today I've played a game with ds1 and ds3 where I dance around making funny faces and they copy me. Dh looked up and said "If you'd told me 2 months ago that ds1 would have beeen joining in that I wouldn't have believed you". Later ds1 played a copying game with ds2- someone he has pretty much blanked until the last 3 months (when he began to get imitation). Later he came over and started trying to drag dh up from his chair - I said "PECS card ds1" and off he went came back 10 seconds later with "cuddle" (he wanted dh to lift him onto his shoulders". That was in the space of a couple of hours.

All that social interaction was made possible because of lots of work with tangible reinforcers. He wasn't doing any of those things because we were holdiing a chocolate button in front of him (we weren't), but he was given the tools to do them, and discovered the enjoyment of them from years of work at a table and generally in the environment using tangible reinforcers. Tangible reinforcers have developed social skills in him.

It's extremely powerful - and used properly can be extremely effective with NT children as well- although often you can use something much simpler. When we sent videos to our consultants in the States who set up our programme with ds1 they suggested things for ds2 and ds3 from watching the videos. Really simple things like (having seen ds2 kicking off in prevous mealtimes- he's a bit nof a nightmare at the table- lots of eatiing issues) "oh ds2 seems to be stting nicely- reinforce him periodically for eating so well when he does that"- by which they mean I should say something like "wow aren't you sitting nicely and eating well today". Nothing evil about that- and pure behaviourism. And it really works with him.

aviatrixxx · 11/02/2007 19:40

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

snowisgone · 11/02/2007 19:06

With a thread like this i do believe that the saying "There is no handbook for rearing children" i think mumsnet is changing that a little bit.

my d/d1 is very sensitive and was trying to get two wee boys that where chasing d/d2 at indoor play area to say sorry!?! d/d 2 is a bit of a drama queen has to be said.

If only there was a handbook. There is a strong religious element at my d/d 1 school and it is all thinking of others etc..... sometimes i get exapperated that i am bringing my child up to have respect for others and be manerly etc... I don't know in contrast to this i work in two different practices one in a extremely affluent area most of the children attend private schools; this is not a sweeping statement as there are always exceptions to the rule but they have no manners. Not all of them but I don't know what i am trying to say it is as if to say sorry is a sign of weakness.

In the nhs practice people are so appreciative of the job you do. Is it all upbringing. Ultimately I am a product of my upbringing. Ofcourse I want to leave the bad bits out but not to the extent of arrogance iykwim!

moondog · 11/02/2007 19:00

It all depends on the individual.There is no blanket method.

Zog · 11/02/2007 18:58

Well yes, that's the kind of thing I do at the moment but GS seems to be suggesting that it doesn't work and there is another way of dealing with it. Am interested to hear more.

moondog · 11/02/2007 18:52

Zog,you could use a punishment (ie something that lessens the not doing homework behaviour)
No tv perhaps or less pocket money.

Zog · 11/02/2007 18:09

This is such an interesting discussion and I'm keen to get some tangible examples (to help those of us who find it hard to get our heads round such concepts).

How, for example, should I deal with an 8 year old reluctant to do their homework? Or tidy their room? The first I guess that I could leave to the school to sort out but the 8 year old would quite happily leave the room to fester for years. Are you therefore saying that the right way of dealing with these behaviours is not with rewards/punishments? How else would you deal with them?

HeartOnMyGreensleeve · 11/02/2007 18:07

No, I'm using tangible reward systems (sticker charts, sweets etc) to illustrate my points, because those props are fashionable with younger children at the moment and most people have heard of them. But I think the same arguments apply as to other, less blunt-instrument behaviourist practices/reward-punishment systems. They proceed from the same ideas and have the same limitations when it comes to bringing up NT children IMO.

Jimjams2 · 11/02/2007 18:04

But GS- I think when you talk about behaviourism you are only talking about tangible reward systems. I'm using it to mean something much wider. I don't really use sticker charts etc- don't need to with ds2 - he can't help but be well behaved as he has a very strong wish to please people- ds3 (very strong willed) may need tangible rewards more to begin with- will wait to see what unfolds. With all my children I use an understanding of reinforcement though- which really is at the core of behaviourism. Don't Shoot the Dog is a great book- it's not a how to book at all- it just clearly explains reinforcement. And I interpret punishment in the way moondog describes it.

moondog · 11/02/2007 17:51

'Don't shoot the dog' is a brilliant (and very readable) book.Available widely.
It is on my MSc reading list.

JJ,one of the girls on my course is a marine biologist so many fascinating discussions unfold.

3LoveHeartsAndNoMore · 11/02/2007 17:45

wow, this discussion is definately not what I thought it would be when I started with the OP....but it's really interesting indeed.

moondog · 11/02/2007 17:36

I agree GS.

What I have come to believe is that these techniques are overused with neurologically typical children and underused with children with developmental disabilities such as Autism.

I don't believe an NT child should be doing regular stuff (like tidying,going to the loo,helping at home) for stickers. they have the inteleectual capaCITY TO UNDERSTAND THAT THIS IS WHAT PEOPLE DO.

hOWEVER,REINFORCERS MASSIVEly useful in case of,for example an autistic child,if their use means he can go to a local leisure centre and join in a swimming group without ripping his clothes off/hitting people for example.He doesn't necessarily need ot know this is ethically/morally wrong,he just needs to know that it really isn't worth his while to do this stuff and that by not doing it,his world becomes altogether more interesting.

HeartOnMyGreensleeve · 11/02/2007 17:31

I know behaviourist techniques are the product of much research over many years moondog - which is why they are so reliable and efficacious. However my point is that they are only effective in what they are designed to do, which is to modify behaviour. They don't and can;t educate and develop the character or aid the childn't maturation into an empathis and social being. In the case of a severely autistic child where the capacity for making complex empathic/ethical judgements is impaired, all well and good to use behaviorism - it works. But to bring up NT children in the same way is a mistake IMO.

The assumption sadly seems to be that if a child can be trained/induced to behave in a way which looks socially responsible/moral, then it doesn't matter what motivations lie behind it or at what level the person understands what is appropriate and why. IMO it's a symptom of our increasing preoccupation with the world of appearances. It will be interesting to see what kind of adults the "positive parenting" movement produces.

moondog · 11/02/2007 17:31

Good example of reinforcing 'bad' behaviour is this:

My two year old loves messing with the ignition thing on stove.
My six year old (very safety conscious) freaks out and runs in screaming every time he does it. Therefore he does it more.

The way to stop this behaviour is to punish it.This is used in a very different sense by behaviourists.Punishment refers to anything which lessems behaviour (and reinforcement refers to anything which increases behaviour.

Thus we could punish his messing about with the ignition bahaviour by my six year old not rushing in screaming every time he does it,as that is what he loves.

Jimjams2 · 11/02/2007 17:28

would love to see it moondoog thanks- have to go back to tea now (complete with constant reinforcement to get ds1 to eat ) will email you later- although suspect I've lost your address as my inbox has deleted itself so might come via a cat.

Jimjams2 · 11/02/2007 17:27

colditz- sorry- am short of time- but for starters I would never take anything away. If a child was reinforced by pleasing me then I would sit down and explain about it not being nice etc- he would understand from tone of voice etc that I was displeased etc.

If the child wasn't reinforced by pleasing me (ds1 and to a certian extent ds3- he's still very young) then how I would respond woud depend on whether it was a one off, whether it was a pattern and the reason for the kick etc etc.

moondog · 11/02/2007 17:27

True
The whole fading thing is at the core of misunderstanding ABA I think.

By the way,found interesting article in my 'trade magazine' the other day.
It is written by a salt criticising ABA.

The next month's edition has a riposte from a mother of an autistic child who is accessing ABA explaining why she thinks it is good.

Am going to photocopy both for my classmates.
If you like i could pass onto you-send me your address if so.

Jimjams2 · 11/02/2007 17:24

NO that's not what I'm saying at all colditz.

Yep - agree MD- and a mistake that people using pasta jars etc often make I think is not fading. I made the mistake however of trying to fade too quickly- which also doesn't work(!).

moondog · 11/02/2007 17:15

I am fairly new to ABA (Jimjams knows more than me) as am a salt and have just started my course.
Needless to say,I feel that the standard salt approach just doesn't work with a lot of people.
Behaviourist approaches are based on years of painstaking lab based research.