Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

for believing that people

135 replies

3andnomore · 10/02/2007 22:58

shouldn't be doing something (nothing in particular right now) because on just shouldn't , rather because one fears punishment?

OP posts:
HeartOnMyGreensleeve · 11/02/2007 22:04

I would usually say something like "Oh dear, poor XXX, that has really hurt him and he is very upset" and then get the kicker/hitter to rub/kiss it better. I don't think that's punitive, but it does seem to work. Although of course my children are 4 and 2, so very little still.

Aloha · 11/02/2007 22:03

Ah, but I very strongly suspect he is much more 'punished' by the withdrawal of your approval than by his 'innate sense of empathy' kicking in! Really, I am. Most children hate to lose their parent's approval and warmth, so just using a stern tone and a severe/serious face is a punishment. It is aversive. while showing your approval is reinforcing. Other things may be accidentally reinforcing. Even a star chart could reinforce bad behaviour if it means they get your one to one attention, good or bad.

HeartOnMyGreensleeve · 11/02/2007 22:02

first sentence totally ungrammatical, sorry

I mean I don't think it is a punishment to point out that the brother is crying because he has been kicked, and it hurts. Children don't automatically understand that other people actually feel things the way they do - they need to be taught it.

moondog · 11/02/2007 22:01

You think saying something like this is a punishment??

To a behaviourist,anything that decreases a behaviour is a punisher.

To a behaviourist anything that increases behaviour is a reinforcer.

HeartOnMyGreensleeve · 11/02/2007 22:00

I was answering Aloha's post

moondog · 11/02/2007 21:59

I'm a bit lost now GS.....

HeartOnMyGreensleeve · 11/02/2007 21:58

No, I don't think saying "Your brother is crying because you hurt him - if he kicked you, how would you feel?" isn't a punishment. If the child feels bad, that is because his own innate sense of empathy is being invoked and developed. His feeling bad is a by-product of his learning WHY hitting people is wrong. A child who had no natural empathy wouldn't be upset by that being said to him. It's a completely different phenomenon from saying "Right, you hit your brother, you've been told not to, so you're getting no telly today". A child with no empathy whatsoever would probably eventually give up hitting after repeated applications of that type of behaviourist punishment, but he wouldn't understand that hitting people hurts them and he wouldn't learn to respond emotionally to somebody else's suffering.

moondog · 11/02/2007 21:57

Yeah,whoever can 'cure' a stammer will make a million.

Enid · 11/02/2007 21:57

I bloody hate sticker charts

ScummyMummy · 11/02/2007 21:55

Maybe she would have still stammered whatever salt therapy was used though, md? So hard to know! If so, it is great that she felt comfortable with her stammer. But if it was possible to 'fix' it somehow then learning to be comfortable with it rather than learning to eliminate it seems like a bad move. And that's true for all sorts of things really, i guess, Sometimes a problem is a problem simply because we view it as a problem but sometimes we do really need ways to lose weight or not hit our siblings or stop smoking or not moon at our headteacher.

moondog · 11/02/2007 21:54

Yes

Aloha · 11/02/2007 21:53

Saying, 'When you hurt your brother he is very sad' and giving him a bit of lecture and looking sad is a 'punishment' to children in that they feel bad that you are clearly not happy with them. Saying 'great sharing! That's wonderful! Look how happy your brother is now!' with a big smile is reinforcing. Surely that is behaviourism?

moondog · 11/02/2007 21:47

Yeah,I think so.
I am not criticising them you understand,just musing on nature and purpose of thread.

moondog · 11/02/2007 21:45

Yeah,I think so.
I am not criticising them you understand,just musing on nature and purpose of thread.

3LoveHeartsAndNoMore · 11/02/2007 21:44

Weightloss section?

moondog · 11/02/2007 21:43

Q lot depends on whether purpose of thread is to lose weight or not feel bad about being large I suppose.

An example from my own profession is something like one of the approaches for stammering (not my field but studied as a student).It is about being comfortable with the stammer rather than eliminating it and spending a lot of time exploring emotional issues.

A woman with a stammer came to talk to us about her therapy.She was happy but she still stammered.
At the time (10 years ago) I thought that was great,but now all I can think about is that she still stammered!!!

moondog · 11/02/2007 21:40

Yep

3LoveHeartsAndNoMore · 11/02/2007 21:39

BigMoFos thread?????????

moondog · 11/02/2007 21:30

I think everyone raises some really interesting and valid points.
No one system is perfect and no system should be used without a really in depth look at the (to use some jargon) function (ie purpose) of the problem behaviour.

I do worry when I read people on MN advocating star charts left,right and centre.In one case tonight (no names mentioned) it was suggested for a child who obviously has issues with his father's departure.All the star charts in the world aren't going to get to the bottom of that.

I am interested in severe behavioral problems and self injury-things that impact significantly on the lives of the individual who perpetrates them and the people around them.Let me tell you this;appealing to the 'better nature' of a severely autistic kid who is gounging out the eyes of his brother does not work.

A functional analysis will (if successful) uncover the purpose of the behaviour.Is it to elicit attention? Is it to escape a demand? Is it due to low stimulation?'

The great thing about a behavioural approach is that it does not blame some inner state/characteristic for problem behaviour.Thus a child is not labelled as bad or vicious or sly.Instead,the belief is that the environment has created this behaviour and the environment can eliminate it too,if manipulated correctly.

So much of our helping serves no purpose,being mentalisitc.Behaviourism is a science and therefore only concerned with measurable data.Thoughts and feelings can't be measured (which isn't ot say they don't exist) therefore a behaviourist doesn't concern him/herself with them.

I am facinated by the Big MoFos thread which I often read. Classic example of a mentalistic approach.It focusses on feelings a great deal.It is now 40 weeks in.I would be really interested in knowing how many people have actually lost weight who post on it.

ScummyMummy · 11/02/2007 20:54

I think it depends. Imo many of these methods work supremely well when you feel like a crap parent and have got into a cycle of feeling that your kids are monsters. If you can use 'artificial' reinforcers like stickers or chocolate to get them to behave better in the short term it can be the start of something good. I agree it won't teach them the whys and wherefores but once they aren't annoying you so much you have time to explain to them why their behaviour is impressing you so much more than before and how lovely they are which will up their empathy and self esteem. So I think star charts and the like can be excellent for starting a virtuous circle when things are feeling shit. Mostly because they make parents notice what is going right and comment on it/reward it. Many parents are surprised at how much is going right when they start keeping a proper check, I reckon. When parents are thinking positively about their children they naturally reinforce their good behaviour and raise eyebrows at cheeky bananaheadedness without going ott, I think, but life isn't always so rosy and at those times a bit of a behavioural strategy can be a life saving shortcut I think.

Jimjams2 · 11/02/2007 20:53

above?? durr below!

Jimjams2 · 11/02/2007 20:52

ds2 doesn't have SN either. But he still responds well and can discover things like the social value oef enjoying a family meal through reinforcement in the way I described above.

Using it for something like potty training is slightly different as you're using it as a teaching method in terms of teaching a skill. Again it can be extremely powerful- everything ds1 has learned has been through using this method (that may change now he's got imitation). It should also be fun for the child. We've just restarted a table programme where ds1 does an hours work a day after school with tutors- using ABA/VB (behaviour analysis) as the teaching method. One day in the first week we'd started one of the tutors was ill and had to cancel- at 4.15 ds1 came and found me carrying a packet of chocolate buttons and dragged me downstairs and sat me down at the table, then waited for me to do some work with him. He wasn't interested in the choc buttons (allthough he knew that they were part of the system)- he wanted the session and the interaction. For him its a game and fun.

3LoveHeartsAndNoMore · 11/02/2007 20:47

ntw, what youdescribe I do do with ms and his pooing issue....if he does the poo on the pottty and the bigger/more proper it is, the more I praise,aand I do use a chart for that....ms is non sn, but pooing is an issue and he is on movicol....

Jimjams2 · 11/02/2007 20:44

Using my behavioural method- I praise him now "wow you ate so nicely today" "gosh I'm really pleased with how well you're eating" It's OTT at the moment. Once he's learned to sit and eat nicely I suspect he'll begin to enjoy other aspects of eating- the chat, the food etc- and he won't need me to say all that stuff because he'll have found the pleasure of eating and so the reinforcement is- as moondog has said- faded. The reinforcement for him then comes from the whole social side of sitting at the table and enjoying the meal. But he discovers that through more directed reinforcement.

Jimjams2 · 11/02/2007 20:41

But hows he going to learn to sit nicely at the table? 3 months ago ds2's behaviour at the table was terrible. Mainly due to ds1's existence- and ds1 getting lots of attention at mealtimes. How can I make ds2 want to sit nicely if he doesn't understand the value of that? He doesn't particularly enjoy food, and he'd rather be off playing that sitting eating food. Ds1 requires attention at the table full stop, so how would I get decent behaviour at the table if I didn't use reinforcement of some sort?