Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

for believing that people

135 replies

3andnomore · 10/02/2007 22:58

shouldn't be doing something (nothing in particular right now) because on just shouldn't , rather because one fears punishment?

OP posts:
welliemum · 11/02/2007 23:16

Wow, brilliant thread - I am learning! I have this intuitive distrust of pasta jars, yet I know that I'm constantly shaping dd1's behaviour (she is 2).

Jimjams, your story about holding wrists being a positive reinforcer really resonated for me, because I'm battling with exactly that sort of puzzle with dd1. She's NT so I realise that our general experiences are very different, but I feel I have to be constantly on my toes to figure out which bits of my reactions are unintentionally reinforcing.

Just as a matter of interest - did you see the Scientific American articles on autism recently? Mirror neurones which I guess you know all about, and a suggestion that autism could be diagnosed very very early on the basis of that and lack of imitation.

3LoveHeartsAndNoMore · 11/02/2007 23:14

so, any theories then why adults find it sometimes so difficult to follow simple rules unless they are scared of punishment or can't break the rules because of change of circumstances....

MerryMarigold · 11/02/2007 23:08

This is really very interesting and I am only just getting my head round it as. Please could you give me some examples of:

positive and negative reinforcement
positive and negative punishment

How do you withdraw approval from a child without them feeling you are withdrawing love? How do you teach that bad actions have consequences, whether they be directly on you or on someone else? How do you/ should you teach a recognition of authority/ obedience (particularly at a young age before 'reason' kicks in)?

If everything boils down to 'behaviourist' then I am assuming there are no other options...didn't seem like that at the beginning of this thread.

aviatrixxx · 11/02/2007 22:40

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

moondog · 11/02/2007 22:29

Yes Sunny.
I remember working out when I was about 14 that we are only friendly with people for what they give us (in other words,something about these people is intrinsically reinforcing) and mentioning it to my teacher.
She was horrified and argued that we like people because we just do.

I was a teenage behaviourist me.

We each have our own highly idiosyncratic reinforcer/punishment system going on. The skilled behaviour analyst has to work it out and take it from there.

sunnyjim · 11/02/2007 22:25

'just shouldn't' how would you define this?
I suppuose if one takes a normative stance - believing that there are such things as abstract moral rights and wrongs then you would expect/want people to do 'whats right' rather than to avoid punishment.

Personally I find the normative theorists a bit too Utopian and Niave. People do what works best for them. Even those of us who like to take the moral high ground and claim that we do things because they are 'right' or 'good' actually behave in that way for rewards/to avoid punishment.

Your reward might be getting into heaven, it might be getting a smile from your parent/partner/teacher, it might be having people around you to socialise with or support you (friends). Reward doesn't have to mean financial in any way.
Similarly punishment might be as simple as NOT getting a smile/kiss/approval from society or important individuals.

I prefer to think about it in these terms because I find that any other attempt to justify or enforce 'moral' behaviuor relies too much upon something outside of every day life and society. I don't want to believe there is an abstract moral force which decides what is good and bad. If that was the case it casts me in the role of an uncomprehending child, unable to contribute to the rules, unable to express my own views, I must merely obey.

I want to believe that the society I live in decides the rules which work best for it. Because I am part of that society so I get a say in what those rules are. As an individual who wants to be part of that society I then have motivation to obey the rules and do what is considered 'right' by my society or to work to change them. (as Rosa Parks did when she refused to give up her seat, even though it was considered morally acceptable for blacks to be treated differently)

HeartOnMyGreensleeve · 11/02/2007 22:25

Well as long as I win, Scummy, that's the main thing

moondog · 11/02/2007 22:24

They would see that the behaviour is different of course they would but would be more concerned with whether it achieved its purported aim.

Example from my work...

1.)Two kids are self injuring in exactly the same way more or less.Functional analysis reveals that one is doing it for attention,the other to escape task demands

Same topography,different function

2.)Two more kids.
One escapes from the classromm repeatedly,another one constantly teases another child. Functiona analysis reveals that they are both doing it to elicit more adult attention.

Different topography,same function.

HeartOnMyGreensleeve · 11/02/2007 22:23

I do have the odd Undignified Moment, ds1 is very opinionated, I can't think where he gets it from

ScummyMummy · 11/02/2007 22:23

If you go for a bath you will be punishing us with a withdrawal of your attention which will make us stop saying things you don't like because there will be no one reinforcing us so you will win.

Aloha · 11/02/2007 22:22

I think you are a silly old soppy Greensleeves! Nah, I don't go much for naughty steps etc and my kids are certainly no worse behaved than others, and better than quite a few, but I do think the odd 'leave that ALONE THIS MINUTE OR I WILL BE VERY VERY CROSS!' is valid!

HeartOnMyGreensleeve · 11/02/2007 22:20
moondog · 11/02/2007 22:20

Theory of Mind they call it Aloha.
Some peopel have tried to teach it to autistic kids-with limited results natch!

HeartOnMyGreensleeve · 11/02/2007 22:19

Well I'll have to take your word for it that a behaviourist wouldn't see the difference, moondog.

I rather think children do, though, or mine at least. I think that's probably the crux of of our disagreement.

Aloha · 11/02/2007 22:19

I found that very interesting btw!

Aloha · 11/02/2007 22:17

There is also evidence that the development of empathy is innate and doesn't have to be taught - it is developmental. And develops more by normal peer interaction than by parent-child intstruction. ie by trial and error during play. Probably partly because children give very direct feedback or behavioural reinforcement! Of course certain types of brain injury, certain medical conditions and an abusive upbringing will interfere with this development as well.

moondog · 11/02/2007 22:16

It may seem removed from it GS,but they function in the same way and from the point of view of a behaviourist,this is all that really matter.

In a nutshell,topography is different but function is identical.

HeartOnMyGreensleeve · 11/02/2007 22:15

It depends on the severity of the injury I suppose - mine aren't particularly given to violence (yet) although they tussle over toys and push each other over etc. I do usually try to respond to these incidents with a calming tone and concern for the falling-out between them, rather than being angry with the other one or pointedly giving my attention to the injured party.

But as I said, I'm not always very good at it. That's what's great about discussion forums, we can debate what we think the ideal would be, while accepting that we are not and never will be ideal.

I do see that in a sense everything a parent does in relation to a child is either a positive or negative reinforcer - such is the nature of human relationships. But IMO that's wholly different from deliberately applying a set of contrived artificial reinforcers with the aim of producing a specific effect. If my son feel "punished" by my discomfiture as I pick his brother up off the floor, that's an incidental function of us both being sentient human beings who are aware of and affected by one another's feelings. A far cry from star charts, or paying children to behave themselves

moondog · 11/02/2007 22:13

The withdrawal of approval is negative punishment by the way.

'Negative' refers to removal of something,in this case,your attention

moondog · 11/02/2007 22:12

Ah Aloha!!
Tis simple isn't it but it takes people a long time to get their heads around it,especially when you then subdivide into positive and negative reinforcement and positive and negative punishment.

ScummyMummy · 11/02/2007 22:10

i think a lot of time kids completely miss the point whatever you do, though. I remember being mean to my sister and getting gently told off by my ma in a greensleevesesque way and I was always v upset and would stop my bad action of the moment. But not because i had hurt my sister's feelings, which was the wrong that my mum was patiently trying to encourage me to view as a bad thing. I was sorry because my mum was sad and thought I'd done something mean and I wanted her to think the best of me. Granted, I think "oi stop being a little shit or I will give you a cross on your star chart" would have been equally ineffective but empathy didn't come to me till later in life despite my mum's best efforts and i do think a little more STOP that right now and a little less explanation would not have gone amiss at times.

Aloha · 11/02/2007 22:09

But do you smile and cuddle the biter/hitter/pusher while you tell him how sad his brother is? I bet not! You look serious and stern and cuddle his brother instead. Then, when he kisses his brother etc you smile and cuddle him..?

HeartOnMyGreensleeve · 11/02/2007 22:07

But he doesn't lose my approval. I'm sad because my other child is crying, not because I'm angry with ds1. I generally get them to cuddle/rub each other better and then I give the offending child a hug and reiterate the point about being kicked feeling the same whether it's him or someone else on the receiving end.

(Although obviously I cock this up ALL the time, lose patience, etc - I'm arguing this as what I try to do and what I would do if I were perfect in my own eyes, which I am not )

Aloha · 11/02/2007 22:07

I understand that a 'punisher' does not have to be punishment in the sense of being a hit or a withdrawal of privileges, but could be the withdrawal of your approval (such as not smiling at a child who bites) or being asked to do something they don't particularly want to do, such as kiss their brother/say sorry. The resumption of your approval when they do this is the reinforcer. I am a huge fan of this kind of behaviourism, and we don't have naughty steps or star charts or pasta jars in our house either

moondog · 11/02/2007 22:05

Exactly so Aloha.