Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

for believing that people

135 replies

3andnomore · 10/02/2007 22:58

shouldn't be doing something (nothing in particular right now) because on just shouldn't , rather because one fears punishment?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NightWotcher · 11/11/2022 00:05

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

aviatrix · 13/02/2007 11:41

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

Blandmum · 12/02/2007 21:29

funny thing, I said just about that last year when someone told me they couldn't do 30 minutes revision every night for their A level biology because 'They were working in MacDonalds' So I asked her if she wanted to make the gig permanent!

moondog · 12/02/2007 21:29

More than one eh??
Blimey,fail 'em all.

moondog · 12/02/2007 21:28

MB,it will only be positive reinforcement if he gets the feckin' thing done though.
Otherwise it will be a positive punisher.

Why not just scream

'Like I give a shit???? Flip burgers for the rest of your life if you want.'

Blandmum · 12/02/2007 21:26

I'd love a cattle prod for my sixth form who still have not given me their bloody course work to mark, in spite of having 2 fing months to finish it!

They will be having the negative reinforcement side of my tongue tomorrow!

welliemum · 12/02/2007 21:24

awful.

moondog · 12/02/2007 21:20

Yes
Devastatingly effective but highly immoral.

Actually the reason also that behaviour analysis has a bad name is that in 60s and 70s,lots of very dodgy work done with people with learning disabilities.
Things like squirting lemon juice in the faces of self injurious children or administering shocks.

welliemum · 12/02/2007 21:16

Am I right in thinking that a cattle prod would be a fairly unconditioned punisher?

Now please don't do drugs. I have presented you with the information and the facts.

Cool.

moondog · 12/02/2007 21:08

lol

welliemum · 12/02/2007 20:57

custardo.

For teenagers and drugs, I'm thinking the "positive punishment" square.

Will invest in a large cattle prod when the time comes.

moondog · 12/02/2007 20:55

Sorry,I mean a fine or a sharp word is a conditioned punisher.

moondog · 12/02/2007 20:54

Yes Wellie.
So an unconditioned reinforcer is something like sex (no learning involved really to make it fun!) whereas conditioned would be money.

Unconditioned punisher is something like a parking fine or even a sharp reprimand to a child. Unconditioned punisher is something like a smack!

Tortington · 12/02/2007 20:48

i will piss my kecks when your kids are 13 and your saying calmly. now please don't do drugs. i have presented you with the information and the facts.

blah de blah

you airy fairy bunch of shytes

welliemum · 12/02/2007 20:47

Yikes.

wot's "conditioned" then? Does it mean something learned over time?

moondog · 12/02/2007 20:45

On top of that,you then have to work out what is a conditioned and unconditioned reinforcer and what is a conditioned and unconditioned reinforcer........

moondog · 12/02/2007 19:06

Wellie,that is exactly how it is mapped out!!!!

Aviatrix,at present we have just written a short piece in response to a quote.I could send it to oyu when I get it back if you are interested.I will read the whole thing asap.

Exactly JJ,people forget that reinforcers refer to anything which is, well.....reinforcing!

It could be a chocolate button,it could be a clap,it could be a swing or it could be a quiet 'Well done!'

Jimjams2 · 12/02/2007 11:38

although the weird thing is he's been able to tease for years- which shws some understanding of other minds....

Jimjams2 · 12/02/2007 11:37

it is fascinating isn't it. I suppose without it you don;t understand that anyone else's actions can apply to you (and vice versa).

welliemum · 12/02/2007 09:30

I find it fascinating to think that theory of mind, empathy, "do as you would be done by" ethics - complicated, subtle stuff that is the essence of social living - all have their basic starting point in simple imitation.

Brilliant news that your ds1 has cracked it jimjams.

Jimjams2 · 12/02/2007 09:16

I don't agree aviatrix- I've worked wiith the 16-19 age group and found on the whole they were fairly well balanced, decent individuals. Most wanted to do well in exams becuase they wanted to do their best for example. Yes in some cases people are still being rewarded by some form of payment, but that may be the nature of the child rather than anything else. As I think Aloha said earlier a lot of this stuff is developmental (empathy certainly is), and so will follow its own developmental pathway in each child. For some children that sort of understanding may take a long time. Most people do start to become reinforced by social things because we are social creatures and want approval from the group in general (so as long as the group from which you are seeking approval has a strong moral code....) If someone isn't reinforced that way then you have to use some sort of payment system - you don;t have any choice- or you'll end up with someone unsocialised. The "payment" could be something like "well done" though.

My main problem with sticker charts etc is that they are often used too much, or without a real understanding of reinforcement. I think they're usually faded when they can be because they're quite hard work to keep going.

aviatrix · 12/02/2007 09:08

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

Jimjams2 · 12/02/2007 08:43

mirror neurones are so interesting wellie- when we were concerned about ds3 we knew that if he was autistic then he would be higher functioning than ds1 because he's always been able to imitate. I still can't quite believe that ds1 can imitate- he was doing it again this morning and it just wows me.

M beef wiith AK is that he didn't seem to understand that his methods were just using social reinforcement - although admitedly I haven't read much- the bit I did read did seem to be using social reinforcement though. No he doesn't use tangible rewards, but social rewards fulfil the same function (providing the person they're directed at is reinforced by social things- if they aren't then you have to use tangible rewards or you simply won't get anywhere- full stop).

Behavioural programs tend to work towards social reinforcement anyway- any program would prefer to use social reinforcement where possible, sometimes you have to start with something that is more motivating for that particular child though. The first thing you do in any program is suss out your reinforcers, and you need to keep doing that repeatedly. You have a hierarchy, when we started we had about one reinforcer- chocolate buttons- so they're cut into quarters and used. First ds1 would get one for sitting at the table when told, then for copying someone putting an object into a box/for clapping etc . If he did it then hoorah chocolate button plus loads of swinging round- swinging round quickly became another strong reinforcer. Now 3 or 4 years later he gets reinforcement from imitation itself- he understands the social pleasure of imitating someone- even his brother- he enjoys the game itself- although he still loves to be cheered when he gets it right. Of course you don't actually need to do all that with NT children because they don't have to be taught imitation. But you can still have situations (like that I described with ds2 at the dinner table) where you start by using social reinforcement- if that;s strong enough- if it isn't use something stronger which will probably be tangible- and by doing that and getting the child to participate they discover the pleasure of the activity itself.

welliemum · 12/02/2007 00:01

You could almost map that as a 2X2 grid, reinforcement/punishment along the top, positive/negative down the side.

Then in the middle if a situation, you think: what square am I in now? what square should I be in now? as a quick way of figuring out what you're doing.

moondog · 11/02/2007 23:24

Gah,it's late and work tomorrow but will give it a whirl.

Positive reinforcement = something added to a situation that increases relevant behaviour.

So..kid does something,gets praised and he does it again.
Or....you masturabate and orgasm so you do it again (I aim to make examples memorable!!)

Negative reinforcement = somethng taken away from a situation that increases relevant behaviour.

So..you want your kid to clean his teeth b ut every time you get the toothpaste out,he runs away screaming.You put the toothpaste away so of course he is more likely to scream and run away next time.
Or..you put on sunglasses to avoid glare of sun.It works so you do it again next time.

Positive punishment =something added to a situation that decreases relevant behaviour.

So...your kid has his list of chores added to when he behaves badly.
Or...you touch a hot stove with the result that you get burned.You are less likely to do it in future.

Negative punishment=something removed from a situation that decreases relevant behaviour.

So..your kid hits his brother.He is then not allowed to go swimming with you.
Your dh approaches you for sex. You get out of the bed in a huff.

It is really quite difficult to tease it all out.Also,many different reinforcement contingencies working at same time.

I haven't yet read Kohn's book (but will) Essay was only a 500 word personal reflection on a quote fro it.