Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to give people assistance with claiming PIP?

437 replies

IwasateenagePIPassessor · 25/10/2016 22:08

No, of course I'm not BU. I'm just posting here for traffic. Name changed, obvs.

Bit of background; I was a PIP Disability Assessor for a while this year, until I decided that I couldn't work within the system with a good conscience, and left. I witnessed DA's who were trying their best, mostly, to help people with their claims. They (and I) were hamstrung both by our immediate employers, and a system (whether by accident or design) that discriminated against claimants with certain conditions. In the spirit of the release of 'I, Daniel Blake', which isn't about PIP but other failures of the benefit system, I've decided to give some general advice to those looking to claim PIP.

Firstly, let's look at initially making the claim. I would say the most vital point is this; PROVIDE EVIDENCE. The way that the claim form/questionnaire is worded implies that the DWP/ATOS/CAPITA or whoever will chase letters from GPS, specialists etc to back up your claim for you. In my experience, this doesn't happen. The onus is on you to provide this information, although it would be very easy to assume the opposite. Some photocopies of a recent prescription, letters detailing diagnoses and appointment dates, and evidence of secondary care involvement (especially people with mental health conditions) provide good evidence; if you haven't provided anything, then the DA has to go mostly on that short assessment with you. You may be horribly unwell or disabled for 5 days a week, if you're having a 'good day' on the assessment however, then your claim is in trouble. Evidence, Evidence, Evidence; I can't stress that enough. Don't let the DWP have the easy option; the decision they make is heavily dependent on the report written by the health professional that assesses you. The decision maker at the DWP has no medical qualifications of any sort.

If you have disabilities that cause you to have problems getting out (especially severe MH conditions), ask for a home assessment. The way the system is, if you have a MH condition involving severe anxiety or depression, or agoraphobia; then you attend a clinic appointment, it can be used as evidence that you aren't as bad as you claim that you are. The reasoning is that you can't be that ill if you can get to a clinic appointment. It's profoundly unfair, and a large part of why I left. Once again; evidence is so important.

Don't assume that the health professional that sees you knows much about your condition. In a working and well-designed system, those with certain conditions would be given appointments with HP's with a specialism in that area. It ain't so. You could get a general or MH nurse, an Occupational Therapist, a Physio or a Paramedic. It's completely random. If you can bring along a health professional of your own, then do. I'd advise anyone against attending by themselves. That's not because I don't trust the DA's; the vast majority are good people. It's just easy to forget things, and people with severe MH problems or learning disabilities/Autism really need an advocate of some sort.

If you're asked to do a set of 12 exercises (it's called the Musculoskeletal exam, or MSK), be sensible! I had people trying to please me by trying to do these despite evident pain; tell the DA why it would be difficult for you to do it. If you cannot do it, just do what you can and explain why. Completing those ridiculous exercises at personal cost, especially pain, will count against you. Don't make stuff up to help your claim (they'll see straight through it, and assume that you're dishonest), but don't put yourself at risk of harm by doing something that you can't. The DA has to take your safety into consideration when assessing what you can and can't do. Once again, evidence is key. If you need aids or adaptations to walk, or need to wear wrist supports etc, then bring/wear them. Help the DA to help you. They normally will.

Talking of assessments, if you report any MH conditions at all, then the DA will be observing you throughout the assessment for a Mental State Examination (MSE). In my opinion, this is even more badly designed that the MSK. A HP, who may or may not have any MH experience at all, will continually assess your mood, behaviour, anxiety etc throughout the assessment. It's completely subjective. If you have a serious MH condition, if you are in pain, if you are distressed or anxious then let it show to the DA. The stiff upper lip is the worst possible approach.

We were told that those 45 minutes were key. If a consultant wrote that you couldn't do something, then you did it in that 45 minute assessment (good day or not) then the weight of evidence would be on the assessment.

My opinion, for what it's worth, is that PIP discriminates against those with learning disabilities or MH conditions. Seriously. It's appalling. If you are turned down, then PLEASE appeal. You'd be surprised how many obtain PIP through appeal; it's often through providing further evidence. Don't give the DWP the chance to deny your rightful claim in the first place; provide that evidence when you first fill in the forms.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
unweavedrainbow · 17/11/2016 11:37

yeah right Hmm Wink

LurkingHusband · 17/11/2016 11:16

In simple terms: the change from DLA to PIP isn't saving the government any money

Well good job it wasn't meant to do that then, isn't it ? It was all about a better way to get help where it was needed.

unweavedrainbow · 17/11/2016 11:15

Lurking I know how she feels, my powerchair is my life line. Without it I'd never leave the house. This PIP crap is my way of giving back something to the world.
The drill is that even if a claimant only uses a wheelchair some of the time they should still bring it to any f2f that they might have. If they don't and simply write on the form that they sometimes need one you can guarantee that the dwp will assume that they can walk 200m+ repeatedly, reliably and safely...

unweavedrainbow · 17/11/2016 11:10

In general though, and statistically speaking, the stats around PIP are much, much nicer than first feared. In simple terms: the change from DLA to PIP isn't saving the government any money. At first instance claimants have about a 50% chance of being successful. Of those rejected about 25% are successful at appeal. In other words people have about a 3 in 4 chance of being successful. Way way higher than the government first anticipated.
PIP stats This doesn't include appeals statistics which are generally between 60% and 65% successful in favour of the claimant.

LurkingHusband · 17/11/2016 11:07

unweavedrainbow

p.s. tx for the detailed layout of stats Smile

LurkingHusband · 17/11/2016 11:06

I presume that you know the drill about wheelchairs

he drill is without one, MrsLH gets to watch the world go by Sad.

unweavedrainbow · 17/11/2016 10:59

Lurking that 69% transfer is at "first instance" ie without appeal/MR. If you take appeals and mandatory reconsiderations into account the transfer rate is nearer to 85%-and this includes people who had very short or low level DLA awards in the first place. This is one of the reasons they attempted to out through the PIP cuts that failed-this transfer rate is much higher than expected. Generally, claimants who had high level or indefinite DLA awards are virtually guaranteed to transfer over to PIP without much bother, at least in terms of Daily Living. Mobility is a slightly different kettle of fish (far too many people who were on Indefinite HRM being dropped to Standard Mobility and having to appeal for my liking...) but I presume that you know the drill about wheelchairs. I volunteer filling in PIP forms for my sins and IME you shouldn't worry too much, it does sound like you have the form situation under control. Evidence is everything Most people I have helped in your DW situation have transferred over without too much bother.
Joffrey I'm sorry about your DH. You're right-the PIP system does discriminate against deaf people. There's no two ways about it. I worry about coming across as a bit "grandmother sucking eggsy" but the deaf community has been campaigning about this since the first set of PIP criteria was released back in 2010. The way PIP is around autism is a little strange. It is possible to get a decent award (my dh gets PIP for autism at Enhanced rate) but the time limiting of awards is weird. Although the general mantra of PIP for all conditions appears to be "higher level awards for shorter lengths of time". Weird.

Sunnysky2016 · 17/11/2016 10:31

Morning all. I just wanted to give a positive experience with a PIP assessment:-
I haven't read through the entire thread, but just wanted to say that I had a home assessment and my assessor (paramedic) was brilliant, and I was awarded enhanced rate daily living and standard mobility. I had my mental health support worker with me and I found the assessment easy going. I suffer from fibro, hyper mobility, early osteoarthritis, b12 def, heart murmur and am awaiting spinal surgery.
I filled in every available space about how not only my conditions but the medication affected me on a daily basis. I was told I needed have put so much info as they only take a few bullet points from each section I.e- can't hold a full saucepan
Fall in the shower
And so on.

JoffreyBaratheon · 17/11/2016 09:42

EveryDay - it may depend on the area where you live. We suspect they arent doing so many where we live as neither son nor husband got called for a f2f and one got full, enhanced on both (although lost his life time award so now it's only 5 years) and the other lost at every stage including appeal. In other words - don't assume it means anything, having no f2f. We had none with both the success AND the failure. We had loads of evidence in one case yet lost because we were told we didn't have enough....

In the other we won, because we were told we had loads of evidence. That evidence they cited was one 5 word sentence scrawled by our GP (who has never even met my son as he was diagnosed years ago).

When I was going through this (twice, in less than a year), I'd get my hopes up at every little thing. In retrospect - don't do it. There is no sense, no consistency, no logic. The old DLA system worked. PIP simply is a failure. Don't waste your mental energy on trying to second guess the significance of anything.

LurkingHusband · 17/11/2016 09:17

RepentAtLeisure

LurkingHusband - Have you called and asked for an extension? Apparently they are often granted, and if you can get one it's worth it to make sure your form is as detailed as it can be.

Thanks for the thought Smile It's a tricky balance ... having the form uncompleted was becoming distressing for MrsLH - the last thing she needed was dragging it out any longer. I don't think our form could have been any more detailed - there were over 25 pages of scanned letters and documents which were referenced multiple times. The actual submission was over 50 pages, as all the questions were copied onto a separate page and answered there. The intention being that not only could the entire thing be reproduced at will, but that they can see it can be reproduced at will.

Also, ever since ESA back in 2012, we have been preparing for this. So already there were copies of letters and a lot of research (via the B&W forum) to make sure we had it all covered.

It shouldn't be necessary, but from our experiences with ESA I think an early signal that you mean business, and are prepared to take them on does no harm whatsoever.

The form(s) (separate copy to the decision maker) were sent Monday afternoon, and we got a text yesterday saying it has been received.

Just to echo about prescriptions (our list was over a page Shock), but the side effects should be mentioned if that affect an activity. There's no getting away from the fact that any anti-spasticity medications all result in muscle weakness, which has a great effect on day-to-day living. There's also a medicine chain where antibiotics prescribed for recurrent UTIs lead to digestion problems (diarrhoea) which in turn requires higher levels of care.

Hopefully we had a stroke of luck ... last month MrsLH was assessed for a new treatment for leg spasms. It was a very thorough consult, and the consultant kindly summarised their findings in a 2-page letter full of medical gobbledegook. So that letter was used as a reference for almost every explanation.

The first letter scanned was MrsLHs confirmation of DLA for life from the early 1990s, with a note that things have only got worse (i.e. losing sight) since then.

My minds a blur now, so I apologise for not backing it up, but in the last few weeks I did read a statistic that 69% of people receiving DLA are transferred to PIP. I also read that there have been assessments where - despite the statement that ESA and PIP are unrelated - it has been evident that the PIP assessors have had access to any data submitted for ESA. To be honest, that seems more sensible than trying to make them exclusive. Although I suspect the reason is they are trying to "catch people out" with contradictions in ESA/PIP. They're welcome to MrsLHs ESA details - we (obviously) kept a copy, and they actually show things were easier in 2012.

I'll post when we hear back from the DWP.

BannedexPIPassessor · 17/11/2016 08:00

EveryDay, In my experience it certainly is.

RepentAtLeisure · 17/11/2016 02:06

LurkingHusband - Have you called and asked for an extension? Apparently they are often granted, and if you can get one it's worth it to make sure your form is as detailed as it can be.

NoSuchThingAsThePerfectParent · 17/11/2016 00:19

Banned from a different thread all about bans, MN don't email you, they wait for you to email them to ask why, or to find out how long the ban is for. Even then, people report it takes several days to get a response. Probably part of the punishment? I dunno. I can imagine it's a horrible feeling though. I got kicked off once for sock-puppeting but when I gave my reason (had name-changed when I didn't want to out myself after a new thread was a bit too personal, and had forgotten to change back for a final post. It wasn't even controversial). Anyway, they let me back in straight away. I was horrified and still live in fear of sock-puppet even now!

EveryDayIsASchoolDay · 16/11/2016 23:46

@Banned
If you don't have to have a f2f appointment is that a good sign?

BannedexPIPassessor · 16/11/2016 22:25

I don't know; I've had no communication from MNHQ at all, and they're ignoring my messages.
I'm more than a bit annoyed, I thought they'd be more professional than this.

NoSuchThingAsThePerfectParent · 16/11/2016 22:23

How long is your ban, Op? You're such a valued resource I think you should be let off the hook!

BannedexPIPassessor · 16/11/2016 22:05

You're welcome.

SingaSong12 · 16/11/2016 21:07

OP Thank you for this - I sometimes help people with the forms and there are some new bits I'll add to what I tell them.

xcinema · 16/11/2016 20:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

BannedexPIPassessor · 16/11/2016 20:42

The Night Watch are slow in getting to me tonight, obviously 🙃

BannedexPIPassessor · 16/11/2016 20:41

ESA and PIP are quite distinct, whether someone was receiving ESA wasn't taken into consideration when assessing for PIP.
You can receive PIP whether you're working or not, of course.
As for how many claims are accepted without an assessment, I don't have those figures. All I can can think of is 'not many'.

JellyBelli · 16/11/2016 20:37

AliceInUnderpants I claim ESA and it doesnt help with PIP. I need a carer for 16+ hours a week and dont qualify I only need a carer for 3 out of the 4 physical tasks and get 6 points. You need 8.
A lot of things are no longer covered. For example, I need help with shopping, but this Govt says I can do my shopping online and get it delivered.
I need help with housework but that doesnt count either. Its not personal care.

DLA used to give me help for the expenses involved with my disability, such as the aids I need.

AliceInUnderpants · 16/11/2016 20:28

Banned whilst you're still here, and I'm still gearing up to a PIP application (by the way, I've been advised ESA is easier to claim and I may want to do that first, does having a current ESA claim help at all with a PIP claim?), I just wondered if you have any statistics or knowledge of how many claims are allowed without an assessment, and which type of conditions those would be most likely to include?

Smartleatherbag · 16/11/2016 20:23

Sorry you're being banned, op. Your info has been very helpful and is much appreciated. Flowers

JoffreyBaratheon · 16/11/2016 20:17

Also I'm still intrigued as to how the DWP have not shared with us their cure for autism. That 'review' can't possibly be in order to increase his award as he already gets enhanced. Yet, from age 2 or 3 he got DLA for life. I think someone, somewhere has broken a contract with my son and disabled people like him who were promised support for life. Unless, as I say, the DWP have a cure they have yet to share with us?

The reason for review in 5 years? He might go to university. Derp. We just wrote all over the forms that he is already there and these are his needs when he's both at uni and at home. Basically - they didn't even READ the forms! But as I say, I didn't appeal as the chances were they'd take it all away from him.

Swipe left for the next trending thread