Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to give people assistance with claiming PIP?

437 replies

IwasateenagePIPassessor · 25/10/2016 22:08

No, of course I'm not BU. I'm just posting here for traffic. Name changed, obvs.

Bit of background; I was a PIP Disability Assessor for a while this year, until I decided that I couldn't work within the system with a good conscience, and left. I witnessed DA's who were trying their best, mostly, to help people with their claims. They (and I) were hamstrung both by our immediate employers, and a system (whether by accident or design) that discriminated against claimants with certain conditions. In the spirit of the release of 'I, Daniel Blake', which isn't about PIP but other failures of the benefit system, I've decided to give some general advice to those looking to claim PIP.

Firstly, let's look at initially making the claim. I would say the most vital point is this; PROVIDE EVIDENCE. The way that the claim form/questionnaire is worded implies that the DWP/ATOS/CAPITA or whoever will chase letters from GPS, specialists etc to back up your claim for you. In my experience, this doesn't happen. The onus is on you to provide this information, although it would be very easy to assume the opposite. Some photocopies of a recent prescription, letters detailing diagnoses and appointment dates, and evidence of secondary care involvement (especially people with mental health conditions) provide good evidence; if you haven't provided anything, then the DA has to go mostly on that short assessment with you. You may be horribly unwell or disabled for 5 days a week, if you're having a 'good day' on the assessment however, then your claim is in trouble. Evidence, Evidence, Evidence; I can't stress that enough. Don't let the DWP have the easy option; the decision they make is heavily dependent on the report written by the health professional that assesses you. The decision maker at the DWP has no medical qualifications of any sort.

If you have disabilities that cause you to have problems getting out (especially severe MH conditions), ask for a home assessment. The way the system is, if you have a MH condition involving severe anxiety or depression, or agoraphobia; then you attend a clinic appointment, it can be used as evidence that you aren't as bad as you claim that you are. The reasoning is that you can't be that ill if you can get to a clinic appointment. It's profoundly unfair, and a large part of why I left. Once again; evidence is so important.

Don't assume that the health professional that sees you knows much about your condition. In a working and well-designed system, those with certain conditions would be given appointments with HP's with a specialism in that area. It ain't so. You could get a general or MH nurse, an Occupational Therapist, a Physio or a Paramedic. It's completely random. If you can bring along a health professional of your own, then do. I'd advise anyone against attending by themselves. That's not because I don't trust the DA's; the vast majority are good people. It's just easy to forget things, and people with severe MH problems or learning disabilities/Autism really need an advocate of some sort.

If you're asked to do a set of 12 exercises (it's called the Musculoskeletal exam, or MSK), be sensible! I had people trying to please me by trying to do these despite evident pain; tell the DA why it would be difficult for you to do it. If you cannot do it, just do what you can and explain why. Completing those ridiculous exercises at personal cost, especially pain, will count against you. Don't make stuff up to help your claim (they'll see straight through it, and assume that you're dishonest), but don't put yourself at risk of harm by doing something that you can't. The DA has to take your safety into consideration when assessing what you can and can't do. Once again, evidence is key. If you need aids or adaptations to walk, or need to wear wrist supports etc, then bring/wear them. Help the DA to help you. They normally will.

Talking of assessments, if you report any MH conditions at all, then the DA will be observing you throughout the assessment for a Mental State Examination (MSE). In my opinion, this is even more badly designed that the MSK. A HP, who may or may not have any MH experience at all, will continually assess your mood, behaviour, anxiety etc throughout the assessment. It's completely subjective. If you have a serious MH condition, if you are in pain, if you are distressed or anxious then let it show to the DA. The stiff upper lip is the worst possible approach.

We were told that those 45 minutes were key. If a consultant wrote that you couldn't do something, then you did it in that 45 minute assessment (good day or not) then the weight of evidence would be on the assessment.

My opinion, for what it's worth, is that PIP discriminates against those with learning disabilities or MH conditions. Seriously. It's appalling. If you are turned down, then PLEASE appeal. You'd be surprised how many obtain PIP through appeal; it's often through providing further evidence. Don't give the DWP the chance to deny your rightful claim in the first place; provide that evidence when you first fill in the forms.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
fiverabbits · 27/10/2016 12:07

Convincingliar

Thank you for the information. As he gets his DLA every Monday it is easy to check if it has been paid. The first letter he received was in September 2015 and the first date for the assessment was the 28th of April which they cancelled an hour before his appointment. I am dreading if he is turned down having had to appeal his DLA THREE times, the last time 13 years ago, I thought they could then realise he has an incurable disease.

Magpiemagpie · 27/10/2016 11:17

Manckitten
You should have the tribunal award
They the DWP have 28 days if they want to appeal it or take it to the next level tribunal
If they don't you should get it within a few weeks and all the back pay as well
If you ring them they can tell you what's happening especially as it's after 2 weeks it should be on the system by now

Magpiemagpie · 27/10/2016 11:14

My cousin just won her Appeal for PIP she was originally awarded no mobility & low rate care
She got high rate mobility & high rate care at the Tribunal
She did the Appeal herself no help from CAB or anyone legal just family typing everything up for her

Time wise it wasn't that bad 6 months from beginning to end
She applied in feb had Assement in May was refused in June
did a MR in June but was refused that and went to tribunal last week and won.

She got a letter from her doctor outlining her illness and how it affected her .
She enclosed all her medical appointment at her doctors records for the past 2 years she highlighted everything on the records that mentioned her wheelchair use
She enclose a copy of her most recent prescription for the tribunal
A copy of her blue badge that was awarded before she got PIP and a letter outlining that
Her most recent specialist appointments and future appointments at the pain clinic
She attended her appeal in person and got the result in 20 mins . she is knowledgable about her illness and I think that helped as well

The one thing I would say is photocopy the PIP form & anything that you send them so that you can refresh yourself with what you wrote and it's also evidence
And keep a file / box with everything you send them as well
Send everything recorded if possible and also follow up to check that it's been recieved as well one week later

Dawndonnaagain · 27/10/2016 10:50

Hookie Thank you! I shall take a look when they arrive. I'm terrified!

MancKitten · 27/10/2016 08:00

Does anyone know how long it takes for them to sort your money out after winning your tribunal?

I won 2 weeks ago and am still getting the appeal rate of ESA and they are still sending letters asking for fit notes.

Which is annoying as when I 'failed' my original ATOS assessment they had stopped my money, HB, everything within 24 hours Hmm

ConvincingLiar · 27/10/2016 07:42

fiverabbits I have a friend who's a new pip claimant who waited about ten months from assessment to decision. No explanation for it. Does seem a long time though. Might be worth chasing up. His DLA will stop a month after the decision, so keep an eye on it (in case the decision letter is lost in the post).

MatildatheCat tentatively I'd say that was right. If you were no longer entitled it is in your interests to have pip stopped earlier rather than risk a situation where you have an overpayment you have to pay back. The problem is if the first assessment was right and the renewal assessment is wrong. If you think they've got it wrong then I'd disagree with your Dh and encourage you to challenge it (getting on board any medics who are supportive and know you well).

hookiewookie29 · 26/10/2016 21:48

Dawndonna if you go on the Citizens advice website, there are details on there of how to fill the PIP forms in, including things you wouldn't think about putting.We found it really helpful.

fiverabbits · 26/10/2016 21:21

My son who is on Dla and has been for the last 23.5 years had an assessment on the 30th of June 2016 but he has not received any paperwork since then, is this normal ?

MatildaTheCat · 26/10/2016 20:45

Convincingliar , assessing you so early is just another way for the DWP to save money. They gave me a 3 year award and have reduced it after 27 months. This is apparently in my best interests Confused.

I've had another 5 months of misery. My dh thinks I should stop engaging with them and save the torment but it so very wrong.

ConvincingLiar · 26/10/2016 20:05

MatildaTheCat
Be aware they can reassess at any point in the last year of the award. In my case I had a 3 year award and got the letter just two years and one week later.

Actually I think it's policy that they start the reassessment process a year before the end. Should lead to seamless awards where appropriate. The warning is that they can reassess you whenever they like. There's plenty of people on indefinite awards of DLA who haven't got the message that their "lifetime award" isn't necessarily so. Some people are better off on PIP, others worse. If I was on DLA, I wouldn't wait for pip, I'd go and see CAB or similar to ask for their advice about where I'd likely stand.

It's worth knowing that the assessment provider (if agreed in advance) can audio record the assessment. This gives you reliable evidence to contradict any inaccuracies of what was discussed.

Anyway, I second what the OP says about getting your claim right from the outset rather than having to challenge a bad decision later. A letter from your GP saying "Mrs X has depression and takes 20mg citalopram daily" is ok, but not terribly helpful. If there are health professionals who are supportive, print out a copy of the criteria so that they can write useful things about their knowledge of the functional effects of your disability.

.

seasidesally · 26/10/2016 19:41

my experience was good with ESa and PIP

both first claims for both for Bipolar

no medicals needed both paper decisions

esa awarded for a year in the support group,that was in april 2014 and not had to do renewal since even though it was supposed to be for a year

PIP awarded april 2014 enhanced rate for 5yrs

i must of been very very lucky but from my experience not all claims are doomed

Helpisathand13 · 26/10/2016 18:06

I appreciate your honesty. This topic is a highly stressful one for so many people. Thank you

GettingitwrongHauntingatnight · 26/10/2016 17:59

Thank you op. I have been tjinking about applying for PIP as I have several long term health condidtions but have some what been put off by things I've read about how hard it is to claim. I also have other reasons.

LarrytheCucumber · 26/10/2016 17:53

4Cats A friend of mine accompanied an adult with learning difficulties to her assessment and the questions sound very similar. They don't seem to be tailored to individual cases.

hobnobsaremyfavourite · 26/10/2016 17:17

www.rnib.org.uk/launch-welfare-rights-service-people-sensory-loss
Just for info for anyone with sight or hearing loss in Wales (or both) this is a great team who will help with benefit applications and appeals.
The system is shit Angry

debka · 26/10/2016 17:13

Great post OP. My partner is an LD nurse and a PIP assessor and he says the same as you regarding MH and LD. Not an easy job at all, he comes home either upset or angry every day.

4catsaremylife · 26/10/2016 17:09

I wish my 21 yo ASD DD's recent PIP assessment had gone as smoothly as the ops on here did. I was utterly appalled by the DA constantly ignoring my dd's answers to his questions and then twisting them back at her so much so she was completely confused by him. An example of this was DA asked her if she could go out alone? She answered no, he then changed tactic and asked if she had no one to go with her and had to get to hospital because she (or I ) was seriously ill could she go? Again the answer was no! So then again he moved the goal posts asking can you use Google Maps? My DD who was utterly confused at this point said "I suppose I could follow the dot?". That question didn't address the fact that DD is incapable of travelling alone as her anxiety is so great. She cannot use public transport alone for fear that they may deviate from her familiar route and (as has happened in the past) she will be left in an unfamiliar rural spot (we live in the back of beyond) unable to work out how to get back to somewhere familiar. She would not be able to ask for directions as she is non verbal with strangers and mobile coverage is patchy at best so how does Google Map help her then?! I have a background working in MH prior to having my dc 2 of whom are ASD and the other has MH issues and it was commented on in his notes "Mum seems extremely knowledgeable about this condition and dd was clean and tidy in appearance. I came home and cried. Then I wrote a complaint about the DA and sent it but sure enough the report arrived saying DD's ASD and ADHD have no impact on her life.So now I have to appeal the decision. I feel broken.

CheshireChat · 26/10/2016 16:16

It's good to see that some people had a fairly straightforward process and that people were treated decently.

Probably got someone like the OP who was genuinely trying to help.

PermenantLurker · 26/10/2016 15:17

Wellfare Rights can be a great help with benefit forms & appeals for anyone struggling with this

NothingIsOK · 26/10/2016 15:09

Ironically, my PIP claim went very smoothly and was awarded without need for review for another ten years. Go figure.

NothingIsOK · 26/10/2016 15:08

Thanks for posting OP. There's a lot here that I wish I'd known sooner.

I've had my ESA contributions based stopped after a WCA, which is the face to face assessment for ESA. I fell into some of the very traps you describe... struggled to complete a movement and was classed as being able to do it, though I said it was very painful and would cause ongoing pain.... and they totally used the fact that I dragged myself to the meeting at great cost to my well being against me, again, even though I stated clearly that it was a huge problem for me to manage and would break me for the rest of the week.

I've appealed. Slowed down by the fact I've just had major surgery, which doesn't help my claim a true all due to the timing of it in relation to the WCA meeting. Neither of my previous surgeries in the claim period count either because, well, I don't know really. It's a bag of shite that's not fit for purpose.

LarrytheCucumber · 26/10/2016 15:04

Cagliostro my DD has MS and actually surrendered DLA a few years back because she was doing well. She is now receiving maximum PIP because her condition deteriorated. You can always reapply.

user1476900263 · 26/10/2016 14:51

Maybe i was very lucky but none of the postings here or on the Toby young thread rang true for me.

I think its important and fair to post when your claims for both ESA and PIP were dealt with fairly and efficiently as in my case.

I first claimed for ESA two years ago (previously my family provided me with financial help for my needs 9 years) . The reason i never claimed before for ESA/DLA was partly down to these threads 'PUTTING THE FEAR OF GOD IN TO ME'. However, due to changes to family financial situation i needed to claim .

My experiences (though not perfect) bear no correlation to those posted on here ! Firstly i rang the DWP phone line in 'tears' to notify them of my claim it took 20 minutes for them to take the details the man taking the details was very 'calm' and considerate to my feelings. Explaining to me the process that would take place , how i would fill the 50 page booklet ETC.

I was put straight in to the Support Group without a Medical approx 6 weeks after my telephone call ( my evidence for ASD came from a Professor , as well as a letter from my G.P)

Finally in march this year i decided to go for PIP , so i went to a medical with my brother and was dealt with respect and common sense by the health care professional.

The result was i was given 10 points for the care component and qualified for the new standard rate of £55.10 PW . The letter also said that i was given the maximum 10 year period before any re assessment .

This was with the dreaded ATOS.

I think if you routinely condem an organization or government agency , it is only fair to post if you think you were personally treated fairly.

susiella · 26/10/2016 13:58

Further disheartening news for those who are going to a tribunal to appeal against disallowance. DWP is recruiting 86 new presenting officers to help DWP try to reduce claimants' success rates at PIP & ESA appeals. DWP will now also be identifying cases which can be appealed to the upper tribunal. i.e, DWP will appeal AGAINST your winning the appeal.For many 100s of claimants, this means trauma & stress will not end when they win the appeal. Instead, more uncertainty & misery awaits whilst they wait for an appeal to the upper tribunal to be heard. If DWP's further appeal is upheld, then at the very least this will mean another return to first-tier tribunal to argue their case again. In some cases, this will be denied. Another kick in the teeth for the genuinely disabled from the Tory bastards that dreamed this up. They truly cannot have a conscience.

CheshireChat · 26/10/2016 13:48

Unfortunately it seems that the only assessors that end up staying are the ones that believe the propaganda and that people are trying it on.