Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to give people assistance with claiming PIP?

437 replies

IwasateenagePIPassessor · 25/10/2016 22:08

No, of course I'm not BU. I'm just posting here for traffic. Name changed, obvs.

Bit of background; I was a PIP Disability Assessor for a while this year, until I decided that I couldn't work within the system with a good conscience, and left. I witnessed DA's who were trying their best, mostly, to help people with their claims. They (and I) were hamstrung both by our immediate employers, and a system (whether by accident or design) that discriminated against claimants with certain conditions. In the spirit of the release of 'I, Daniel Blake', which isn't about PIP but other failures of the benefit system, I've decided to give some general advice to those looking to claim PIP.

Firstly, let's look at initially making the claim. I would say the most vital point is this; PROVIDE EVIDENCE. The way that the claim form/questionnaire is worded implies that the DWP/ATOS/CAPITA or whoever will chase letters from GPS, specialists etc to back up your claim for you. In my experience, this doesn't happen. The onus is on you to provide this information, although it would be very easy to assume the opposite. Some photocopies of a recent prescription, letters detailing diagnoses and appointment dates, and evidence of secondary care involvement (especially people with mental health conditions) provide good evidence; if you haven't provided anything, then the DA has to go mostly on that short assessment with you. You may be horribly unwell or disabled for 5 days a week, if you're having a 'good day' on the assessment however, then your claim is in trouble. Evidence, Evidence, Evidence; I can't stress that enough. Don't let the DWP have the easy option; the decision they make is heavily dependent on the report written by the health professional that assesses you. The decision maker at the DWP has no medical qualifications of any sort.

If you have disabilities that cause you to have problems getting out (especially severe MH conditions), ask for a home assessment. The way the system is, if you have a MH condition involving severe anxiety or depression, or agoraphobia; then you attend a clinic appointment, it can be used as evidence that you aren't as bad as you claim that you are. The reasoning is that you can't be that ill if you can get to a clinic appointment. It's profoundly unfair, and a large part of why I left. Once again; evidence is so important.

Don't assume that the health professional that sees you knows much about your condition. In a working and well-designed system, those with certain conditions would be given appointments with HP's with a specialism in that area. It ain't so. You could get a general or MH nurse, an Occupational Therapist, a Physio or a Paramedic. It's completely random. If you can bring along a health professional of your own, then do. I'd advise anyone against attending by themselves. That's not because I don't trust the DA's; the vast majority are good people. It's just easy to forget things, and people with severe MH problems or learning disabilities/Autism really need an advocate of some sort.

If you're asked to do a set of 12 exercises (it's called the Musculoskeletal exam, or MSK), be sensible! I had people trying to please me by trying to do these despite evident pain; tell the DA why it would be difficult for you to do it. If you cannot do it, just do what you can and explain why. Completing those ridiculous exercises at personal cost, especially pain, will count against you. Don't make stuff up to help your claim (they'll see straight through it, and assume that you're dishonest), but don't put yourself at risk of harm by doing something that you can't. The DA has to take your safety into consideration when assessing what you can and can't do. Once again, evidence is key. If you need aids or adaptations to walk, or need to wear wrist supports etc, then bring/wear them. Help the DA to help you. They normally will.

Talking of assessments, if you report any MH conditions at all, then the DA will be observing you throughout the assessment for a Mental State Examination (MSE). In my opinion, this is even more badly designed that the MSK. A HP, who may or may not have any MH experience at all, will continually assess your mood, behaviour, anxiety etc throughout the assessment. It's completely subjective. If you have a serious MH condition, if you are in pain, if you are distressed or anxious then let it show to the DA. The stiff upper lip is the worst possible approach.

We were told that those 45 minutes were key. If a consultant wrote that you couldn't do something, then you did it in that 45 minute assessment (good day or not) then the weight of evidence would be on the assessment.

My opinion, for what it's worth, is that PIP discriminates against those with learning disabilities or MH conditions. Seriously. It's appalling. If you are turned down, then PLEASE appeal. You'd be surprised how many obtain PIP through appeal; it's often through providing further evidence. Don't give the DWP the chance to deny your rightful claim in the first place; provide that evidence when you first fill in the forms.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Soozikinzi · 30/10/2016 13:21

My husband had a stroke and had to give up work as a teacher.we had a couple of these awful interviews until they he got his occupational pension so didn't qualify for any payments and we still have to pay back the money he got till his pension came through.He was in tears after each interview. I recently thought that his state pension my be short a couple of years due to him not going for the awful interviews anymore even though we aren't entitled to any benefits could still get the pension credits but I honestly can't put him through the interviews again.

seasidesally · 30/10/2016 13:05

to add last week i did read that some chronic conditions longterm will be exempt from the test if their was no chance of an improvement

so mixed bag if its true

seasidesally · 30/10/2016 13:00

on the radio Wave 105 this morning they said the Goverment are going to review the work test on ESa to get people back to work

Conservative's want a major overhaul,

sorry cant link at the moment

whatishistory · 30/10/2016 08:00

Holme. Yes, PIP in Scotland is the same as elsewhere. I've been wondering whether applications are assessed at a regional base, in which case maybe PIP can be harder to get in some postcodes than others. (?)

ConvincingLiar · 30/10/2016 07:29

BTW2017 have you seen this? www.actiononhearingloss.org.uk/~/media/Files/Factsheets/Benefits/pdf/Personal%20independence%20Payment_v1_April_14.ashx

WankingMonkey make sure to provide the new ESA assessor and decision maker with a copy of the tribunal's recent decision. Did it include a recommendation for when you should be reassessed? It's not binding, but might help. Although if it took you such a long time to get to a tribunal then you might be due for reassessment now anyway.

BTW2017 · 29/10/2016 23:20

Do you have any advice for people applying for PIP who have hearing problems at all? It isn't like they can do tests in different environments so we can "prove" the problems we have.

holme4andy · 29/10/2016 17:14

I presume 'Whats' that the Benefit system in Scotland is run by Westminister .?

Does the Scottish Government have no control over benefit payments.

whatishistory · 29/10/2016 17:09

I'm definitely not in a Tory area. I'm in Scotland. In a city with a lot of poverty and unemployment--although we're doing OK ourselves.

WankingMonkey · 29/10/2016 15:13

Thank you for this. I was denied PIP, but only by a couple of points and it was changed pretty quickly on mandatory reconsideration. The PIP advisor did note most things..along with taking a while to look through my evidence (she said she had already read it but went over it again with me) I said but she understated a couple of issues, which the decision maker accepted hence me getting the extra few points. However my ESA assesment was the absolute opposite. He wouldn't even look at evidence I provided, which included a thick letter detailing my illness from my consultant, along with (at the time) at least twice monthly A+E visits and the very strong (oxycodone..along with others) medication I was on constantly to have even a half normal life. He outright lied about the assessment. I got 0 points and had to go to tribunal which took 2 years. At the tribunal I didn't even have to say ANYTHING. As soon as I entered I was told they were changing the decision before they even spoke to me. This was 3 months ago and I have now been called for a reassesment...nothing has changed but I expect I will be cured all over again :S

holme4andy · 29/10/2016 14:08

Perhaps each area has a 'maximum' amount of money that can be spent on benefit payments. Maybe because a Tory town has relatively low no of claimants they became more likely to get benefits....

holme4andy · 29/10/2016 14:04

Perhaps people who live in 'Tory' areas might be more likely to get ESA and PIP payments !.

Think about it they would not want people in 'shire' towns that vote Conservative seeing desperate people 'die' in front of them thus making the poor and vulnerable invisible to potential voters.

Also Conservative voting areas are also likely to have less benefit claimants, because they are more likely to be affluent !

whatishistory · 29/10/2016 13:42

The system seems so random. I have bipolar and get the higher rate of living allowance on PIP. I was awarded it without a face to face assessment and they didn't consult my CPN or psychiatrist. I provided copies of my own mood diary, my medication, dates of admissions and when I was under the crisis team. I was surprised because I was preparing myself for the long haul.

Maybe the hospital admissions every few months made the difference. But then I've heard of people with similar problems and they're denied PIP. I know I filled my form out well. I gave specific examples of episodes with dates that corresponded to my admissions and mood diary. I sent in about 4 pages of typed information.

Is there a postcode lottery at play here? Or do applications all go to the same central department?

MUjunkie · 29/10/2016 13:41

Well it must just be DLA renewal forms then. They are still a pain in the arse tho lol

Mishaps · 29/10/2016 13:24

Poeple with head injuries and the subtle cognitive changes that go with it also slip through the benefits net.

I admire you for getting out of a system that your conscience told you was fatally flawed and dishonest. I left social work after 30 years for similar reasons and was deeply sad that my ability to help people with disabilities had been taken away from me - I was in the end just a financial gatekeeper, when in law my role should have been just the opposite.

tallwivglasses · 29/10/2016 13:24

OP I saw your first post on a private Facebook page before reading this thread. Your message is spreading! Thanks so much for taking the time x

GrumpyInsomniac · 29/10/2016 13:20

It seems I was very lucky. For one thing, I had DH on my side and he researched everything he could find ahead of the assessment, as well as providing a statement that went with the application, as my carer, because I have both mental and physical issues and a tendency to stuff upper lip.

He purchased the recording equipment for the ATOS assessment on eBay for £50, and insisted they put the assessment closer to home - they wanted to send us 40 miles to Watford, and even them paying for a taxi there and back would have been too painful.

On the day of the assessment, my impression was of someone decent, but overwhelmed by the needs of the report. At one point, we'd just discussed something and she said 'so I'm writing this' and her attempt to put what had been discussed into report language completely changed the sense, so we corrected her and got the wording right.

My assessor was clear for the physical stuff that I shouldn't do anything that would cause me pain, but I'm a people pleaser and gave it my best shot, even though that meant giving up in tears for some of them, and utterly failing to do others.

I'd been expecting a battle, followed by an appeal. Instead I got enhanced rate everything on the first time of trying, but I can clearly see where and hiw this could have gone awry if I hadn't had DH to be with me every step of the process. I strongly suspect the recording to have been the clincher, though, and that is very hard for most people to manage, not to mention expensive to get the approved kit.

PigletWasPoohsFriend · 29/10/2016 12:59

Dawn when I did mine, rather than doing it all at once DH and I did a couple of questions at a time. It made it more manageable iyswim.

Flowers for you. It stressed me to. I had a 5 year award and I'm dreading having to go through it again even though my condition has dramatically deteriorated from then.

Biscuitmadness · 29/10/2016 12:56

Gosh I find all this so sad and depressing - it must be so stressful to go for these assessments and have someone determine your outcomes total disempowerment

NotCitrus · 29/10/2016 12:55

Oblamov One good thing about PIP is it does actually take multiple conditions into account reasonably well. If you provide info for each question explaining why he can't do (all the individual aspects of X) SAFELY, REPEATEDLY and RELIABLY, ie what happens if he were to try, then it should be possible to get at least 2 points on relevant ones - I got 12 over 5 different areas thanks to that. I'm certainly less disabled most of the time than people who've been turned down, but I meet at least those criteria.

Dawndonnaagain · 29/10/2016 12:47

My forms have arrived. I haven't even opened the envelope. I spent yesterday in hospital (I'm fine) suspected heart attack, but no, it was stress. So this is adding to it.
Aaarghhh!

Oblomov16 · 29/10/2016 12:14

This thread is seriously depressing.
Are you alive? Do you breathe? You are not dead?
Oh well, no PIP for you then.
I can't imagine Many people getting it. I applied recently for dh. I'm starting to think I shouldn't have bothered. He has 8 different medical conditions. But none of them are THAT awful. But they affect him a lot. But I bet we won't get PIP.

NotCitrus · 29/10/2016 11:25

The Benefits and Work site is worth every penny. They explain what is meant by every question, eg "preparing a meal" covers getting, peeling, chopping veg, using a hob, getting hot food safely onto a plate etc. And how to reply, so if you don't have problems burnig yourself because you only use a microwave or have a kettle tipper or get DP to dish up, then you have to write what would happen if you did try all those. Equally I might think I can get myself dressed because I can do so and get kids to school without having to help from DP, but actually I have Velcro or pop-up boots, it takes a long hot shower and then another 10 minutes effort to get a bra on, I can't grip earrings to go in my ears, my trousers are generally full-on with no buttons, I don't wear button-up shirts, I can't hold a hair dryer for more than a few seconds so have to just clip back wet hair, can't do eye makeup as hands too wobbly... that's the level of detail you need for every question. Explaining why you can't just make 'obvious' changes to do something is critical.

I got awarded basic care straight away (after a year of faffing and failure to book terps and losing my paperwork - always send recorded delivery!), though oddly for different criteria than I expected.

For the MSK assessment, try the exercises without exerting yourself at all - refusing some because then you'd be too exhausted to get home would be reasonable. State formally every single time when appropriate, "I could do that maybe once a day, BUT I could not do it repeatedly or reliably when necessary." Anecdotes of when you have been stuck because you couldn't do X even though sometimes you can, also helpful.

I suspect taking DP who introduced himself as Dr Hisname probably helped. He's not a medical doctor but we didnt feel the need to mention that.

ChunkyMcBitch · 29/10/2016 10:50

Thank you so much for this. I've just been through an extremely stressful 9 months waiting for transition from DLA to PIP, I researched and read everything I could and represented my husband myself. Thankfully we got a MH nurse who totally understood the issues we faced, we had a home assessment and ended up awarded more than we had under DLA.

I have a huge gripe at the moment with the group Fightback. They started off helping everyone, provided invaluable advice and asked for a donation if successful. Then suddenly they had a wish list on Amazon (including a coffee machine). Now they offer a three tier system: if you pay nothing, chances are you will not be helped (I emailed/phoned them 3 times and received no contact back whatsoever). Then you can pay £5 a month to access some of their information. Then the top level is £11.99 per month which gives you example forms to fill in for specific illnesses. Now we were never in a position to be able to pay for this kind of service, but I do feel that this could end up being a fraudster's wet dream. I know of someone who is trying to claim for made up illnesses (family member, and yes I have reported them more than once) because they are working while claiming they have that extra monmey to pay for a copy of whichever illness they claim to have this week.

Sorry to go off topic, but I worry that groups like them that set up trying to genuinely help could be doing more harm than good.

IwasateenagePIPassessor · 29/10/2016 10:42

My understanding is that you have to be 16 to receive PIP though?

OP posts:
MUjunkie · 29/10/2016 10:24

Yes she's been taken off dla and awarded pip. It's her sons I'm stressing about now! He already gets dla, (I can't remember off hand whether it's renewal for that, or the pip tbh) It's so hard to fill the forms in without a diagnosis because nobody knows exactly what's going on with him! All we've had is global development delay, he may have autism but it's 1 year waiting list for the assessment