Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you were my tenant what would you like me to do about this?

85 replies

Cocklodger · 03/09/2016 12:30

House is let out via an agency.
agents never reported any issues to me.
Tenant gave notice, leaving in 3 weeks. I inspected at 10am this morning.
House is in good condition,however the contents are not.
Boiler is broken.
Sofa legs have snapped.
Washing machine is broken.
tenant showed me 50 emails sent to the agency, some were acknowledged with a 'we'll pass it on to LL'' most weren't,but NOTHING was passed on.
I will never use this letting agent (maybe not any at all tbh as this isn't my 1st bad experience) ever again.
But what can I do to make this right? of course I'll see everything is fixed,in good order and replaced if necessary,but the tenant is leaving now. they've been here for a year. stuff started going wrong after 4 months. Agents inspect every 6 months but I opt to do my own end of tenancy inspection as these are fucked up or over exaggerated by letting agents, like the time where a squash stain on the carpet (which took a steamer and a hoover to get out) resulted in agents attempting to deduct £400 from deposit for a professional clean!
anyhow would you offer any financial compensation? I can't really think of what I can do to make it better :(

OP posts:
Fadingmemory · 03/09/2016 13:01

Report the agent to a professional association if he/she belongs to one and ask what you can do. Let the tenant know you have done so. Refund what you can afford. There are review sites for agents but they may not be reliable. You may not wish to divulge where you are but perhaps a MNer might recommend an agent or perhaps there are MNers who are agents. I am a LL but I lease to a housing association used by our local authority - rent is lower but I get paid every month even during "void" periods and the HA notifies me of work required. How the agent has the brass neck to charge a percentage for doing nothing, I have no idea. Try posting in Property.

PoshPenny · 03/09/2016 13:01

I'd hit the roof at the "managing" agents, see where that gets you, then follow up as necessary/whatever it takes to get a refund of the management fees they've taken and done nothing to earn. Then and only then I would give something back to the tenants if you actually get any money back. Or you could give them something now with the promise of more to follow if you're successful clawing back management fees. Clearly you'll need email address and phone numbers off them to do that. Are they registered with any professional body you could report them to- there used to one called ARLA?

Going forward, is there another agent you could use, who might be better. I'd make sure any future tenant has your contact number as a last resort if they aren't getting anywhere with the agents. If you've got a good plumber electrician and general handyman it's not hard to manage your own property. It's harder when the tenant stops paying rent and you need to start eviction proceedings but when that happened to me I took advice from Shelter (the housing charity) on the correct process to follow, and even that worked out OK in a funny way as the tenants moved out immediately I served the first notice on them so I didn't need to start formal court proceedings.

PGPsabitch · 03/09/2016 13:00

Give the estate agents he'll. Ask your tenants for the emails and report the agents to the ombudsman.

Our agent is just like this, they say it's the landlady and it may well be but since we can't contact her at all we'll never know.

GabsAlot · 03/09/2016 12:59

complain with your evidence to the agent and ask for fees back as they clearly didnt earn them

then give a months rent back to the tenants form that

i thin k 6 months is excessive

thecatneuterer · 03/09/2016 12:59

I agree with Justwanttowee. And it's very easy to do it yourself. Join the National Landlords Association and that will guide you through everything, enable you to complete all contracts etc online and they have a really good telephone helpline should anything go wrong.

Justwanttoweeinpeace · 03/09/2016 12:56

Appologise, write lovely reference, fire agents, do it yourself next time.

It's physically impossible to do a worse job than a letting agent; unlike them you actually give a shit.

Justwanttoweeinpeace · 03/09/2016 12:55

Appologise, write lovely reference, fire agents, do it yourself next time.

It's physically impossible to do a worse job than a letting agent; unlike them you actually give a shit.

1frenchfoodie · 03/09/2016 12:55

I agree with Breakfast, demand a refund of management fees and pass it to your tenant.

AngelBlue12 · 03/09/2016 12:53

We've had an agent (built in oven that they never told ll about, blown down fence, broken gate, plaster falling off the walls) like that so now we deal direct with our landlord and he's great :)

ItsAllGoingToBeFine · 03/09/2016 12:53

6-8 months' rent refund is way too much, they were living in your propert but with some loss of amenity

The boiler was broken. No hot water is a fairly significant loss of amenity...

OrsonWellsHat · 03/09/2016 12:52

I've no idea how to claim back for the agency. Can you demand some sort of refund? I guess threatening them with small claims court will end up costing you money. I hope you find a solution.

OlennasWimple · 03/09/2016 12:52

I would also hand over the management fees to the tenant - pay it first and then chase it from the agency if you need to. 6-8 months rent seems incredibly generous; 1-2 months would feel about right? (I'm just going on gut instinct rather than anything else, though!)

Marcipex · 03/09/2016 12:51

Horribly familiar from when I was renting... Couldn't get the simplest repair done, agents just lie and lie.Angry

MatildaTheCat · 03/09/2016 12:51

6-8 months' rent refund is way too much, they were living in your propert but with some loss of amenity. Just do as suggested and make a stink with the agent. If you threaten the small claims court I'm almost certain they will refund a portion of your fees.

Then give the tenants a few hundred. They will be delighted. You do need the email evidence and perhaps a log of phone calls made.

I've managed my btl for 10 years with almost no hassle. You just need a few good property people on your phone and anything can be sorted. Not much different to managing your own house, in fact.

OrsonWellsHat · 03/09/2016 12:51

If only all LL were as nice as you Smile
After this debacle, would you consider renting it privately instead of agency, so you have direct contact with your tenant?

ItsAllGoingToBeFine · 03/09/2016 12:48

I would try and get some/all of the management fees back from the letting agent, and give those to the tenant, and tell the tenant that is what you have done.

BreakfastAtSquiffanys · 03/09/2016 12:48

I'd demand a refund of agency fee since they clearly weren't doing their job, and pass any refund on to your tenant

Gmbk · 03/09/2016 12:46

I'd go after the letting agent.

Contact the tenants direct and apologise should be your first priority.

Explain re the emails and ask if they would consider staying. Are they moving to buy or rent still?

Some kind of financial recompense would be nice. 6 months is probably too much but if you could stretch to 3 it would be a nice gesture. And it shows you're putting your money where your mouth is.

Then go after the agents will full force. Kick up a fuss left right and centre. Via email, phone, in person. Get your money back.

Cocklodger · 03/09/2016 12:45

Will look into what route I have to take to get up the agents ass about it, as its really not on to be honest. They have my phone, landline number, address, email...

OP posts:
Cocklodger · 03/09/2016 12:44

Tenant has attempted to call/visit/email but obviously could only show me proof he emailed, but I can't see him having reason to lie. I'm not sure how much of a fuss they could've made but I wish they had. If I'd known I would've run around like a blue ass fly to get it all fixed and apologized profusely but now it seems the ship has sailed in a way :(

OP posts:
acasualobserver · 03/09/2016 12:41

I would be looking to get a substantial refund from the letting agency for the service it failed to provide. Perhaps use this to compensate your tenant?

TheresAJaffaCakeInMyPocket · 03/09/2016 12:41

I would ask for fees back from agent and pass some to comp the tenants

Cocklodger · 03/09/2016 12:40

Matilda-I've gotten to the point where I am seriously considering it I wanted to last time but DH threw his toys out of the pram as we were 'bound to mess something up'... I'll be winning round 2 of that argument after this I think... I've had enough of agents making an arse of things.
I can afford to refund some of their rent paid in the last year, just not sure that is the right way to go about things or if there is a better way (no matter the expense) Hence why I'm asking. I think refunding 6-8 months of their rent may be the way to go, though.

OP posts:
Pigeonpost · 03/09/2016 12:39

I think an apology to the tenant is sufficient, you can't give them money back presumably. You may want to consider a very strongly worded letter before action to the agents claiming breach of contract and seeking repayment of the fees you've been paying for them to do fuck all. Is the tenant happy to forward you the emails so you have evidence? Maybe if you get money back via the small claims court from the agency you could make a goodwill payment to the tenant. Although if I was the tenant I would have been jumping up and down to make sure the agency were dealing with the problems. They were clearly being fobbed off and could have/should have been more pro-active to ensure that the agency were doing what you as landlord were paying them to do. I find it odd that they've just put up with no reply to emails for 8 months, why didn't they make more of a fuss?

Lolimax · 03/09/2016 12:39

It might help if you were willing to give them a reference in the future? That would mean a lot. And an apology. If you could afford some financial recompense (even though this is not your fault) that would be really nice.