Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you were my tenant what would you like me to do about this?

85 replies

Cocklodger · 03/09/2016 12:30

House is let out via an agency.
agents never reported any issues to me.
Tenant gave notice, leaving in 3 weeks. I inspected at 10am this morning.
House is in good condition,however the contents are not.
Boiler is broken.
Sofa legs have snapped.
Washing machine is broken.
tenant showed me 50 emails sent to the agency, some were acknowledged with a 'we'll pass it on to LL'' most weren't,but NOTHING was passed on.
I will never use this letting agent (maybe not any at all tbh as this isn't my 1st bad experience) ever again.
But what can I do to make this right? of course I'll see everything is fixed,in good order and replaced if necessary,but the tenant is leaving now. they've been here for a year. stuff started going wrong after 4 months. Agents inspect every 6 months but I opt to do my own end of tenancy inspection as these are fucked up or over exaggerated by letting agents, like the time where a squash stain on the carpet (which took a steamer and a hoover to get out) resulted in agents attempting to deduct £400 from deposit for a professional clean!
anyhow would you offer any financial compensation? I can't really think of what I can do to make it better :(

OP posts:
lalalalyra · 03/09/2016 17:25

Get rid of the agents. I know very few ll's now who live local to their properties who use one. They are hopeless and, as you've found out are liable to lose you a good tenant.

I'd ask the tenant if they were interested in staying, but if they are moving in three weeks then they've probably already paid out on deposit/credit checks etc on their new place. I'd give them their last months rent back (and if you can afford it then do it now - gives them a cash boost at an expensive time), make sure they get their full deposit back, a good reference and then if you get some sort of refund or compensation from the letting agent split that with them.

Go through all of the emails - you have legal obligations and you need to know if the LA have put you in danger of any sort of legal action. Did your tenant have your details? They should have had a contact for you - why did they not use it? Did your LA refuse to give them it?

If you do consider using an agent again then you need to make sure your tenant can contact you (and knows that if the agent ignores them you want to know despite that opening you up to 3am phone calls about blown lightbulbs). I wouldn't bother. Spend some time on a landlord website (find facts, not opinions), learn your obligations and then run it yourself.

wowfudge · 03/09/2016 16:22

I've sacked agents in the past when I found out they hadn't done anything about broken window hinges which meant a huge ground floor window neither closed nor locked properly. It was December. I got it fixed within two hours of finding out. The tenant, who had a baby and was understandably pissed off, wanted to stay in the house and asked if she could deal directly with me.

Write to the agents setting out the issues in detail, with dates, supporting correspondence, etc. and them x number of days to respond and refund the fees you have paid them. You could send a letter before action - templates are available online, but you'd then need to issue small claims proceedings. If they don't respond, report them to any body they are a member of and issue a statutory demand for the fees. The amount must be more than £750. If they don't pay, you can apply to have the company wound up. That may make them take notice.

Minesril · 03/09/2016 16:04

I seriously doubt they'll want to stay! They've been living in hell really - unable to wash themselves or their clothes, unable to even sit on the sofa!! I'm guessing that they just want to forget, and hopefully enjoy their new place.

JamieLannistersFuckButler · 03/09/2016 15:18

CafeCremeEtCroissant's suggestion is a good one:

I would see if the tenants would like to stay if you get everything fixed & manage it yourself. I'd offer them any loss of deposit if they've already paid one elsewhere.

Good tenants are good to keep, and they'd probably think you are the gem amongst landlords that you sound like.

TheProblemOfSusan · 03/09/2016 15:15

Sorry, mistyped, you didn't say anything about 12 months rent!

TheProblemOfSusan · 03/09/2016 15:13

I would make sure they got all of their deposit back, and an excellent reference from you directly, not the bloody awful letting agency.

I feel like 6-12 months rent is amazing but possibly too generous given that it's the letting agency at fault. If you can get the agency fees back, split them with the tenants, and then what about something like 50% of the tent for the months they were without hot water or had considerable damage?

This would make a big difference to their life and peace of mind which I do think they are owed, given the horrible circumstances they've been living in. That said, it isn't your fault exactly either - though ultimately your responsibility as the owner. If you can get the letting agents to pay up that would be fairer.

tametempo · 03/09/2016 14:41

Well this is an eye opener. I really despise Lettings Agents after dealing with a horribly unprofessional one while I was a tenant, years ago.
I had always thought of the Landlords kind of being in bed with the Letting Agents, but it seems there is a lot of dissatisfaction from their end too.

You sound like a lovely, reasonable Landlord, OP. You deserve brilliant tenants. I hope you get them.

CafeCremeEtCroissant · 03/09/2016 14:30

I would see if the tenants would like to stay if you get everything fixed & manage it yourself. I'd offer them any loss of deposit if they've already paid one elsewhere.

Then I'd go after the Letting Agents, big time. Solicitors letter demanding a full refund of fees, compensation for loss of good name, compensation for tenants & anything else I could hammer them for. Stupid lazy bloody bastards.

I'd see what I got out of them, then decide how much to compensate the tenants.

This is not your fault, I really don't think you should compensate the tenants out of your own pocket. Out of repaid fees, fine. Support them making a climbing against the agency - definitely. But I!d be very careful about making any compensation payment to them until it's sorted out with a solicitor into the agency.

ProppedUp · 03/09/2016 14:11

This isn't an ad / plug (I don't work in property!), but our LL manages direct but has a company to help set up and advertise the tenancy. They use Letting A Property, didn't see it linked to elsewhere but I'm guessing there are other companies like this too?

The company organise the contracts, registering the deposit with a scheme, references and so on. As a tenant, I found them very good and quick, they were really helpful when I made enquiries about the property and connected me with the LL really quickly. They charge referencing fees but they were really low compared with any other letting agent around here (about 30% of what everyone else charges) so I felt that was fair enough. They drew everything up quickly. But, it was the LL who showed me the property, checked us in and decided to take us on, and who manages the property if anything crops up.

Just thought I'd share in case it's handy! I have a relative who does something similar, their arrangement is with their local letting agency (ie small business, not one of the big ones, due to previous negative experiences), and they're very happy with that. I think letting agents are possibly more useful if you have many properties but not the team to manage them all, or if you're letting and live abroad. If you're close enough to help out in an emergency (eg call the boiler repair) and you have the odd evening or weekend free (ie not travelling the globe for work!) then you should be fine.

Reality is unless there are major issues with the property, you're unlikely to get regular calls from tenants unless they're a bit of a nuisance. In this case it was just 3 things, so whilst unusual and 3 big things, you would have just been contacted about 3 things.

blankmind · 03/09/2016 14:04

I'd base the tenant's recompense on the amount of inconvenience he's had to put up with.

How long has the boiler been broken, is that just hot water he's had to do without, or did it also negate his central-heating through the winter?
Has he been able to use a separate shower, or has he been having to boil a kettle for washing and washing-up?

Same with washing machine, if he's within fairly easy walking distance of a launderette, then pay for the inconvenience and extra costs. If he lives rurally, the nearest one could be a 20 mile round trip.

Put yourself in your tenant's shoes, how much inconvenience has there been and for how long?

Take the agent to the small claims court and report them to their statutory body.

You will do a much better job than the agent because you have your priorities right.

anotherdayanothersquabble · 03/09/2016 14:03

I don't think I would refund 6 months of rent. This is your agents fault, not yours.

I would demand your agents respond to the claims that the tenants informed them of broken boiler and washing machine.

Calculate what could have been due to the tenants if they were to have received compensation for lack of boiler. Suggest that the agency need to compensate the tenants for this amount in addition to refunding you your entire agency fees and any fees the tenants have paid.

In no way should you take the brunt of this as it is not your fault plus had you known, you would have corrected long before.

Happyhippy45 · 03/09/2016 14:02

I have a very strong dislike of letting agents. We rented our flat out when we moved abroad through a property management/letting agency.
They charged a ridiculous amount of money for repairs and did a shit job of them too. Cleaned the gutters on our property and adjoining ones and properties billed it all to us. Lied their arses off about everything. Charged us £50 for attaching a padlock to a shed.
We were home on holiday and went for a wee inspection. I was heartbroken. Place was falling apart. We had left it pristine.
Needless to say we manage our own property now. Bit of extra work but worth it to get the job done properly and know that your tenants have somewhere nice to live where everything is in good working order.
I'd sack letting agent, demand money from them, apologise to tenants and maybe see if they'll stay, offer them 2 months rent free if they do, or if they leave give them a gift?

alreadytaken · 03/09/2016 14:00

Assuming this is England or Wales I'm surprised that no-one has pointed out that tenants have a legal right to obtain contact details for their landlord. The tenants should have asked for these details.

I think agents normally take something like 12-15% of the rent? That seems a good starting point for compensation plus an apology and advice to use their right to obtain landlord details in future.

There are landlord associations and they run training courses designed to help those who want to do it themselves e.g. www.rla.org.uk/landlord/courses/landlord_training_courses.shtml

Galdos · 03/09/2016 13:57

Broken boiler also may open you to a legal claim, as your statutory responsibility as landlord included keeping in good working order the facilities for hot water and space heating. If the agents knew of the disrepair, and did nothing about it (like telling you) they are almost certainly in breach of contract (but check the small print carefully). If there are doubts about a legal claim, report them to Trading Standards.

Ohb0llocks · 03/09/2016 13:41

Rightsaid I'm 99% sure that's the agency I also worked for, and the morning meetings were exactly that. utter bastards.

eurochick · 03/09/2016 13:35

We had a similar issue with the agent not passing on notice of problems with our flat. Unfortunately the tenant was not a nice guy and reported us to the council (who found no issue in terms of fitness to live in) and threatened to sue us. We are both lawyers and knew he had a very weak legal position as none of the problems were serious but we also know how awful and expensive litigation is. Plus I was miscarrying following IVF treatment at the time, so we were not in a good place to fight him. So we ended up writing a fairly hefty cheque to go away. And all for things that could have been sorted out cheaply and easily if the agent had done his job.

JennyOnAPlate · 03/09/2016 13:26

I don't think you need to go as far as giving them 6 months rent back. I do think the agents need to refund you in full for whatever fees you've paid them during the tenancy, and you could pass some of this on to the tenants as compensation.

I would be absolutely raging with the agents in your shoes, op. If they won't fully refund you, despite the evidence you have of their incompetence, I would be speaking to a solicitor.

CheesyWeez · 03/09/2016 13:22

My friend has had this and stormed into the agency and said "Can you show me ONE thing that you've done to manage his property in the last 5 years?" (they couldn't) "So why exactly have I paid you £3,000 to do that then?"

Drives me bonkers. Easy money for them, meanwhile your tenants are sitting there with no heating/mould on the walls or whatever and cursing you. I just wish this was an unusual story Angry
You sound lovely OP.

99percentchocolate · 03/09/2016 13:19

I wish all landlords were like you. I think 6 months rent is very generous and about right (if you can afford it). My previous house had problems with the heating and we had to go a month without hot water once. It was awful and we couldn't stay at the house full time. Unless you've lived through it you don't know how difficult it is, especially in the winter. I would definitely give the agent hell for this.

rightsaidfrederickII · 03/09/2016 13:17

PS I once knew someone who quit working for a letting agent because they felt that they weren't enough of a bastard to do the job! Apparently this (large chain of) agents had a meeting every morning where they thought up lies to tell LLs and tenants to screw more money out of them. It says it all really....

rightsaidfrederickII · 03/09/2016 13:16

You sound lovely - if only all landlords were like you!

I'd suggest ensuring they get their whole deposit back (assuming that the broken items are fair wear and tear, not someone taking a pickaxe to them or something ridiculous). Once that's done, go after the agency for breach of contract, get your management fees back, and pass on an appropriate portion to the tenants (but I'm sure that even a £50-100 Ikea voucher for things they'll need in their new home would be much appreciated)

Needmoresleep · 03/09/2016 13:13

Do not take any deductions from the deposit. Write clearly to the Agent saying this, copy to the tenant, and asking that the deposit is released immediately. This way the tenant can chase.

Very few agents are good at management. Either they keep referring problems to you so you might as well as well do it yourself, use horribly over-priced workmen (Central London agents are particularly guilty) or do nothing.

monkeygone · 03/09/2016 13:13

I have to agree that 6-8 months refund is rather a lot. If my landlord gave me that as recompense for a broken boiler and furniture, I'd feel like I had won the lottery!!

Ohb0llocks · 03/09/2016 13:07

Stuff like this makes me so angry and is exactly the reason I quit working at a letting agency (chain, of a very large company). You will probably find that the staff are so lazy and unmotivated due to a complete lack of regard by senior management. And even if they did want to help (such as I did) you'll find that their hands are tied due to corporate bollocks from people who are more senior simply because their face fits. Blush sorry for the rant but you really are better off managing property yourself nowadays.

Ohb0llocks · 03/09/2016 13:04

Report the agency, take yourself down to the office and kick up merry hell (busiest times are usually around 3-4pm).

They've treat your tenants in an absolutely disgusting manner, demand a refund of management fees, as they have lost you your tenant! If they refuse to co operate escalate the complaint (if a corporate company) or off to the papers, social media if not.