Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why so many relationships fail after having children

90 replies

Yummymummy30s · 16/08/2016 19:23

I have a few friends whose relationships went bad after having a child ; some were together years before having children. I have also read a lot of posts where the partner/husband had changed during pregnancy / not long after birth.
Is it more common for relationships to break down after having children? Why is this ??

OP posts:
JeanGenie23 · 16/08/2016 20:34

Me and my DP have found it hard losing the spontaneity of just going to see a film, or just out for dinner/drinks, and as a result we forget to make time for each other. One of us will babysit whilst the other goes out, 18months down the line and we have been out together three times. We have been together 10yrs and it's hard. I've also found that any disagreements we have had feel bigger because of sleep deprivation/lack of communication. We are just coming through the other side of a hard few months, I can see why happy couples can seperate after children.

Babyroobs · 16/08/2016 20:29

Having kids is a stressful time. Mum is often exhausted for years on end ( I know I was). There was financial pressure to go back to work after a few months and then we have always worked around each other ( me doing mainly nightshifts when the kids were young). It meant no family time, as I worked at weekends and evenings, which meant we were both exhusted as dh worked all week then had the kids all weekend, we both felt like lone parents. I think whilst it is great that women can keep their career going after kids it is often a massive juggle to do so.
Fortunately our marriage has survived the hard years when kids are very young but I think this is only because my dh is very patient and does his fair share of the housework and childcare and has been totally devoted to his kids. He also doesn't have much desire to go off doing hobbies or going out much with mates so doesn't feel resentful.

Writerwannabe83 · 16/08/2016 20:25

I walked out when DS was four months (taking him with me obviously) because me and DH seemed to do nothing but argue. We were incredibly sleep deprived and stressed and we just took it out on each other. One morning I woke up, something really simple made me snap and I thought I just couldn't take it anymore. I went to stay with my mom for a while but did eventually go home and after a breather things seemed to improve a little. Things then got hard again when DS was 7 months, as we were seriously sleep deprived (maybe getting 4 hours broken sleep a night) and I felt angry/jealous that DH's life seemed easier than mine and again we argued lots. We actually did speak of breaking up as things just didn't seem to be working anymore but then we had a really good chat and addressed all the issues that were negatively affecting our marriage and things slowly returned to normal. DS is now just over two and everything is five but God, the strain a baby can put on a relationship is huge.

My friend is due a baby in two months time and she's already in quite a volatile relationship: he thinks babies are women's work and they have huge arguments about all sorts of things (think swearing at each other all the time) so I do worry how things will be when baby arrives.

As a previous poster said, if there are cracks in a relationship then having a baby can blow things apart, but on the other hand even fantastic relationships can't withhold the strain because until a baby comes on the scene there's no way of knowing how the new parent (mom or dad) will react to the difficulties a baby brings.

blueturtle6 · 16/08/2016 20:20

Because having a babies completely changes life, and some people don't like change. They say of you can survive first year you have a good chance of lasting....

HairySubject · 16/08/2016 20:18

From my own experience my partner became abusive whilst I was pregnant, it escalated when da was born and eventually ended with me in hospital getting my head glues together.

PenelopeChipShop · 16/08/2016 20:15

I think this is a really good question. Am happy to be honest and say DH and I have been in a really rocky patch but are working really hard on coming through it. In our case it absolutely was related to becoming parents and all the differences of opinion that exposed.

Talking about having kids before they arrive is ABSOLUTELY USELESS IMO - I suppose it's worth a shot, but when I look back on the conversations we had before an actual baby had appeared and wrecked our sleep, sex life, social life, etc it's incredible how naive we were. It reminds me of that Michael McIntyre sketch about childless couples vs those with kids. 'Oh you'll be such a good dad!' Fast forward to having an 8 month old and said dad has got up in the night precisely twice...

stegosauruslady · 16/08/2016 20:13

In my case, it was jealousy. Ex-H was very jealous of the time I spent with our babies. I'm a care-giver type (I work in a caring job, have always cared for relatives etc) and I tend to be lavish in my attentions to my partner. Obviously, the pressures of having a baby and breastfeeding (combined with him not helping!) caused me to have less energy for that.

He became resentful and emotionally distant. I couldn't get him back after they were older.

lifeissweet · 16/08/2016 20:11

Mine ended because I had always been previously very independent. I was the bread winner and I did everything in the house. That suited us both fine.

Up until DS was born in the most awful circumstances which resulted in us both in intensive care and a 2 month stay in hospital for both of us followed by a year of not being able to work due to ongoing operations for me and the baby.

Suddenly, I was dependent on my DH - and he was hopeless and let us both down in numerous ways.

In an attempt to provide for us, he eventually took a job 3 hours away from home and only came home at weekends.

I coped, but began to make a life without him.

Finally, when I was better and DS was bigger and stronger and had had his final operation (a cochlear implant - he is profoundly
Deaf) I retrained, I became strong and independent again and realised I didn't need someone as a partner who could fail so completely to support me when things were tough.

It changed the dynamic. Being the strong, independent one is all good - up until it's the weaker, less capable partner who has to take over.

practy · 16/08/2016 20:10

When life is easy, relationships are easy. Anything that makes life very difficult will expose how strong your relationship really is.

OhhBetty · 16/08/2016 20:02

Mine ended because my ex cheated. Nothing to do with my son.

WhatTheActualFugg · 16/08/2016 20:02

I thin it's because they never should have got married in the first place (which is why they didn't) but get married because they dint know what else to do, then suddenly realise the gravity of what they have committed themselves to.

LRDtheFeministDragon · 16/08/2016 20:00

Expectations of mothers have shifted less than expectations of women.

Youvegottobekidding · 16/08/2016 19:59

Apologies for going slightly off topic but - put having kids to one side, how come lots of couples that have been together absolutely in totally happiness for a long time, like several years or even longer, decided to get married, then divorced within a year?! I find that bizarre!? I know a quite a few couples that have done this. They have either had kids together already or not.

Scarydinosaurs · 16/08/2016 19:53

My DH and I never argued before having children. We disagreed about things, had the odd 'row' but nothing that exposed any kind of fundamental difference between us.

Since having children it has revealed really horrid aspects of (being completely honest) both our personalities, and at times has really tested us as a couple. At times it has been really hard work: illness, work pressure and family deaths have all contributed to a difficult few years, and once you add children into the mix everything kind of implodes.

Until we had children the division of personal time/family time/couple time wasn't a problem. Now it is our biggest problem.

But we work on it. Try and be better. Children definitely have enhanced our relationship, but I can see why so many break down once they enter and change the dynamic.

WhatTheActualFugg · 16/08/2016 19:53

Babies = permanent lack of sleep
Permanent lack of sleep = grumpy people
'Entitled' modern attitudes + grumpy people = lack of willingness to stick to wedding vows in order to seek greener grass because they are 'worth it'.

Pretty simple I reckon.

pinkdelight · 16/08/2016 19:53

Louis CK does a thing on this in his current show. I think the line was something about trying to do the hardest thing in the world with someone you've chosen on the basis of their tits.

Trills · 16/08/2016 19:52

It's perfectly possible to be in a long 'stable' relationship or marriage, for many years, without ever having to really do anything you don't want to do, because you have a lot in common, like the same things etc.

Very good point there.

Deliaskis · 16/08/2016 19:49

From my observation, it is often because one (or both) partner(s) has never had to sacrifice (or even consider sacrificing) their own interests before having a child. It's perfectly possible to be in a long 'stable' relationship or marriage, for many years, without ever having to really do anything you don't want to do, because you have a lot in common, like the same things etc. Then a child comes along and one of you has to get up at night, one of you has to pace round the block with the pram trying to get them to sleep, you often can't socialise as frequently, you can't have impromptu weekends away, etc. I see a lot of people struggle with the notion of not having the freedom to basically do exactly what they want.

Lots of relationships are never really tested until children enter the picture. Those that are tested and last, end up stronger for it.

zeezeek · 16/08/2016 19:48

What the - that's a mean post. It is actually a valid question and one which I have wondered too at various points in my life before and after children.

At the risk of sounding smug I've often wondered why couples I've known have split up when they've previously seemed so compatible and happy. Some of them had children, some didn't - sometimes it is a big event, like children, or illness, bereavement or other life events changing the dynamics. Other times it seems to be a number of little things over a long time that pushes people further apart, or even just realising they want different things from life.

It can be useful, however, to have threads like this to highlight difficulties that people have and could even help a relationship. I don't know, but I do remember that just after my eldest was born I had a conversation with my DH's first wife about why their marriage broke up that was helpful and illuminating and yes, it helped me to understand him.

honeylulu · 16/08/2016 19:47

I think a lot of men don't really want children but go along with it. Then it's hard work.
Lots of people (including me) had/have a romanticised notion of what marriage and then family life is like. And then find it's not like that. Children who won't sleep, who won't do as they're told. The sudden poverty having a baby can cause and how hard it is to struggle financially even though you're working your arses off. The focus on domestic drudgery/routine. The sudden imbalance if one partner becomes financially dependent on the other to become a SAHP.
Of the people I know (with children) wove divorced or separated recently the reasons given were as follows:

  1. We had grown apart /never spent time together (Male - he'd also found someone else it emerged! )
  2. I'm bored with family life and can't face this being all there is. (Male)
  3. Very similar to 2 above (female)
  4. Couldn't cope with partners financial irresponsibility once we had a child (female).
  5. She never paid any attention to me any more once we had children (male)
Just a few ideas.
WhatTheActualFugg · 16/08/2016 19:39

Errr... I can only assume the OP not only doesn't have children but has never actually met a child - definitely not one of the baby varieties.

and they say there's no such thing as a daft question Hmm

DragonsEggsAreAllMine · 16/08/2016 19:38

Numerous reasons, the relationship wasn't long enough to start with, it wasn't work so they had a baby to try and fix things, it wasn't working but the woman wanted a child, cheating with contraception etc.

mamas12 · 16/08/2016 19:38

I think it's also to do with the pressure of trying to do it on your own
In years gone by, you lived near family and the family (good or bad) would help look after you when you hd a baby as well as your dh, so at least you could take a nap or not worry about the house and just proper,ly recover and within that was your relationship with your other half.
Now I'm not saying that's everyone's ideal with all the problems some families bring but at least the pressure was off on coping on your own.

BikeRunSki · 16/08/2016 19:37

Pressure on - free time, time to yourself, money, sleep, space. We have no regular or reliable babysitter, so DH and I rarely go out together. Discovering that - in practice - you have different parenting styles and aspirations, regardless what you may have talked about. Resentment of parents over balance of perceived time to yourself / time looking after children / time working.

PurplePenguins · 16/08/2016 19:37

*weren't strong preDC

Swipe left for the next trending thread