Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why so many relationships fail after having children

90 replies

Yummymummy30s · 16/08/2016 19:23

I have a few friends whose relationships went bad after having a child ; some were together years before having children. I have also read a lot of posts where the partner/husband had changed during pregnancy / not long after birth.
Is it more common for relationships to break down after having children? Why is this ??

OP posts:
Dontyoulovecalpol · 17/08/2016 07:52

It's an interesting point Suzy. The way I have dealt with that is childcare is 50/50 (housework has never been) I maintain this by working full time nand refusing to interfere with his part. I have friends who have left their children uncollected at childcare (after the 5pm phone call saying he's working late could try just do pick up today) to show him that his Job isn't more
Important.

You do what you have to do but who is really suffering? Our children I suppose. Life with young children is tough

raincy · 17/08/2016 07:44

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

SuzyLucy · 17/08/2016 07:20

Personally I think it is in part due to the reality that most of the shite parts of being a parent fall to women and their lives often change the most. I have found the relentless drugery has mostly fallen on my shoulders. IE, the majority of housework, the everyday organisation of a family, arranging the childcare, etc. I collect the children from after school club so cant just go out on a whim with colleagues like DH doe so my social life is affected. I worked FT for a while and felt pressure from many to reduce my hours so now I work PT in a "little admin job" which is well below my abilities. I dont think I am unusual for many women and if my relationship was weaker then I can see why it may end. Basically, my life has changed alot more than his and I do more of the crap stuff.

OnionKnight · 17/08/2016 06:35

Having children is like throwing a hand grenade into the middle of a relationship, some survive but some don't.

Houseconfusion · 17/08/2016 06:17

It's amazing people are giving the fodder to such a blatantly obvious op. It's a student with an essay to write or a "journalist" with the daily hate

SpongeBobJudgeyPants · 16/08/2016 21:19

Odd that the OP hasn't come back to comment. She has lots of interesting -daily fail fodder well considered viewpoints.

raisedbyguineapigs · 16/08/2016 21:12

I think the dynamic changes so much when you have children, it is easy to lose yourself or become resentful of the other partner. As others have said where as a couple, you might have shared household chores, gone out together, had less to do around the house, suddenly you have gone from being equals to one person, usually the woman giving up work or going part time, so doing more of the drudge work, going out less and losing herself and the man still having g a social life, drinks after work etc.
I also know quite a few long term relationships that have broken down within a year of marriage. If there was a reason why they didn't get married for 10/20 whatever years, what's changed? Sometimes the relationship has run its course and it's a last ditch attempt to save it, or one person wants to get married and has worn the other down. Who knows? It's sad.

frumpet · 16/08/2016 21:10

I had my first child relatively early for MN at 23 as a single parent . I didn't have much 'me' time before that as I was always counted in the numbers when it came to my parents 'childcare' , so in 45 years I had the years 0-10 care free and happy , then 18-22 , other than that I have been looking after a child . DH on the other hand was child free until he was 40 ! So we have had and still have the odd tricky time ! Leaving him has crossed my mind on several occasions Smile

Dontyoulovecalpol · 16/08/2016 21:09

Lanaor that's really interesting- is that unmarried at birth or never married? Everyone I know who had children outside of marriage got married a year or two later

BikeRunSki · 16/08/2016 21:08

My DSis once told me that she and her husband were never closer to splitting up than when their 2nd child was 2.

A few years later - and parents to a non-sleeping 2 year old and her might-be-on-the-spectrum 5 year old - I found out exactly what she meant.

BettyCrystal · 16/08/2016 21:08

I know women who have married "a" guy because they wanted to have kids (and a wedding). Age is usually a factor. They did not marry "the" guy. It's not even settling, it's prioritising having a family over a romantic relationship. It's a choice.
Also, I think we're sold an idealistic version of marriage & motherhood. It wasn't like that in our grandmothers day. Lots of women stayed, didn't get divorced. And children weren't considered the Holy Grail that they are nowadays...

Dontyoulovecalpol · 16/08/2016 21:07

We were together 20 years before having children. We went through a situation worse than most people ever experience and I knew having children would be a walk in the park in comparison and it was- we got twins too. The divorce rate amongst twin parents seems very high anecdotally.

That said after such stress children could've been the straw that broke the camels back and we could've just got fed up with each other

OTheHugeManatee · 16/08/2016 21:04

I'm sure this isn't always the way but I've seen a few relationships implode post-baby because the dynamic was very much one partner being the 'parent' to the other. It can work fine for ages pre-children, but when a real baby enters the picture and the partner in the 'child' role is suddenly expected to step up they feel confused and neglected, while the partner in the 'adult' role feels angry and let down. They can't resume the roles that made their relationship stable and unless they can adapt to new roles the relationship collapses.

GnomeDePlume · 16/08/2016 20:55

A friend of mine described something which he called 'second child syndrome'. Goes something like this:

Couple are as happy as larks, decide to have a baby. Baby arrives and then hell's teeth it is hard work. No longer happy as larks but it will soon get back to normal wont it? Somehow they have another child and then they realise this is the new normal. One or the other of them looks outside the marriage and the marriage is then dead in the water.

I a have seen it happen many times over at work.

LanaorAna1 · 16/08/2016 20:53

The facts are pretty clear in terms of yer statistics: married people stay together more if they've got children, whereas 80 per cent of partnerships break down before the first child is 5.

I've often noticed that MN seems to be something of a sanctuary for the endangered lady partner, rammed full of posters saying they've been happily unmarried for 30 years, etc.

This is UK only, mind you. Most other countries have fewer single parents.

Houseconfusion · 16/08/2016 20:52

Are you a journalist? Student with an essay to write?

Unicornsarelovely · 16/08/2016 20:51

It is interesting. There is the utter exhaustion with a newborn and the clear demarcation of responsibilities. I found it very hard although we didn't split. The tiredness was a killer - 5 hours of patchy sleep for 18 months each time while working and doing the house stuff because I was on maternity leave and it didn't readjust.

My relationship with DH is still tenser than it used to be. I'm the default parent so end up spending evenings supervising homework, practise, activities, play dates etc while working and doing more of the housework.

He works long hours in a job he loves and stays late when he wants to because I'll make sure I'm home in time. None of this was an issue before kids. I would meet friends or work late or whatever. I love the DCs to my bones but miss the freedom which DH hasn't had to give up.

midlifehope · 16/08/2016 20:50

well let's see

  1. one if not both of you will be woken through the night every couple of hr for years at a time.
  2. Only one of you will ever be able to leave the house alone at a time.
  3. One of you will have to sacrifice career aspirations.
  4. Different parenting styles.
  5. Less time, money, time together.
  6. Having subdue even your basic needs much of the time... for the kids' sake.
  7. Holidays not relaxing anymore 8)Children talking to you costantly - you can't have an adult conversation any more, or a quiet lunch or dinner. I could go on
alltouchedout · 16/08/2016 20:47

Exhaustion. Less money. Lack of freedom. Lack of privacy. Toll it can take on your sex life. Huge shift in dynamics. Stress. Disagreements in how to parent. Inequalities. I could go on and on.
(Ten years of parenting and we're still happily married, but oh my god the strains it has placed in our relationship over the years!)

Writerwannabe83 · 16/08/2016 20:45

Someone I met at baby group was bed shaping with her baby and had relegated her hubby to the spare room which can't be good for your relationship.

I agree with this, it obviously causes distance between a couple. Me and DH spent about a year in separate bedrooms because I was co-sleeping (BF) but also because DH needed sleep so he was fit for work and when DS was up every 1.5-2 hours (and usually awake for ages) it was just unfair to subject DH to that during his working week.

Bogeyface · 16/08/2016 20:45

My friend and I had a conversation about this not long ago. The happiest marriages we know are the ones without children! Of those, 3 are childless through infertility yet their relationships are clearly happier and stronger than those of us who have kids. Thats not to say that they wont have their struggles, every marriage does, but without fail they are the ones who are still together 25 years later when all but 1 of the other marriages has failed and the 1 that hasnt has involved cheating on both sides and is currently very very disfunctional to the point of no sex for years and seperate lives. Not sure why they are still together tbh!

As to why that is...I dont know for sure but I suspect that in the chaos that is young children people often drift apart.

Redcrayons · 16/08/2016 20:43

It's perfectly possible to be in a long 'stable' relationship or marriage, for many years, without ever having to really do anything you don't want to do, because you have a lot in common, like the same things etc.

This.

AvengeTheDoc · 16/08/2016 20:36

I think it's a good question, whilst I don't have children now, nor am I in a relationship, I would be apprehensive of beginning a family and would be interested in why relationships fail. And then try to honestly and being unbiased as much as possible consider if these things had any foreshadowing that I could see. I'm already apprehensive about starting a family in my head so when the time comes I will be wary and making sure I feel it's the right decision for myself, partner and possible baby

Essexgirlupnorth · 16/08/2016 20:36

It's hard to have time to work on your relationship once you have kids as they are all consuming. We have been lucky that my in-law live near and are happy to babysit so we get some time together.
Someone I met at baby group was bed shaping with her baby and had relegated her hubby to the spare room which can't be good for your relationship.

Aoibhe · 16/08/2016 20:36

Resentment
Tiredness
Lack of (unable to) communication
Over bearing and interfering inlaws who before now had little or less involvement in your life

Swipe left for the next trending thread