Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To turn your attention to this article **Trigger warning: Child abuse. Title edited by MNHQ**

503 replies

NedStarksHead · 03/08/2016 11:55

After a long and stressful debate/argument on FB, I'd like to turn your attention to these articles....

If you're one of the people who say "murder them all, they're all scum, they should be shot" then just read these and re-think.

Use different wording. A child molester is so different to a pedophile.

http://www.salon.com/2015/09/21/imaapedophilebuttnotaa_monster/

http://www.virped.org

OP posts:
Grassgreendashhabi · 04/08/2016 08:07

What the OP wants is everyone to say

Oh they can't help it it's a mental state

If they act they are predator

If they seek help then they are poorly and need help

That's fine but stop justifying the act. They can help it they can seek therapy etc

catinthecradle · 04/08/2016 08:07

In an ideal world, we would have enough resources to ensure no child is vulnerable, deprived and abused, and we would never ever again read a story about baby P.
In that world, there might be place for more compassion and possibly help for pedophiles.

In the meantime, I honestly don't think we are dealing with the problem the right way. Our priority should be to protect the kids. Not only we are not doing that, but some people are now trying to empathise. Wow. we are going backwards.

Picture your kid lost after the tsunami, or lost in a refugee camp. Who do you want to protect?

NedStarksHead · 04/08/2016 08:06

The point of my thread was to try and make people understand that branding all pedophiles as child molesters is wrong and ignorant.

There will always be a stigma attached to pedophilia and there always should be.

What I'm saying is, (most) pedophiles don't choose to feel this way - its something they're born with.

They are, however, adults. They DO know right from wrong and I am not in any way shape or form justifying or defending the actions of the ones who act on it and abuse children - that is wrong, and they should be punished.

But I think there should be more access to help for the ones who know its wrong, and who are disgusted at themselves for having these thoughts and feelings.

If less of them weren't so scared to come forward we might have a chance at helping them early and saving one child's life from being destroyed.

OP posts:
verytiredmummy1 · 04/08/2016 08:06

I too thought this might be a troll. I too have empathy for the victims rather than the 'molesters'. Disgusting

verytiredmummy1 · 04/08/2016 08:05

Are you serious?!

PickAChew · 04/08/2016 08:04

While not all paedophiles will do so, any paedophile who uses imagery, even without ever touching a child in person, is still complicit in child sexual abuse.

I have empathy by the bucket load but mostly reserve it for real victims.

Andrewofgg · 04/08/2016 08:03

Nobody can help thinking what they think but they can and must avoid acting on those thoughts.

A man (overwhelmingly; although there are exceptions) who is troubled by such thoughts can stay away from children; hurry past them in the street; not talk to them.

It's not rocket science.

GrimmauldPlace · 04/08/2016 08:02

Op, I'm confused as to what you would like any member of the public to do? I agree that pedophiles who have not abused children should be able to access help, therapy etc but it seems as though you would like the public to be more "understanding" of their "sexual orientation" and have it as accepted as being gay or straight.

If a person has these thoughts and feelings they should absolutely seek help but do you want them to be able to tell people their orientation and not have a bad response? Because that's never going to happen is it?

NedStarksHead · 04/08/2016 08:00

What the fuck? Justify what? What am I justifying?

I'm
Justifying mental illness and something that can't be helped.

Am I justifying the ones who act on it? No am I fuck?!

OP posts:
witsender · 04/08/2016 08:00

Surely this isn't new? I agree with the OP tbh.

Magikarp · 04/08/2016 07:58

Two days ago a man exposed himself to me and my daughter in public. He made aggressive comments towards me while doing so.

However he didn't rape me so should I applaud him for having such amazing self control? Be obviously just needs a big hug, such a brave man. Poor him.

Fuck off mini.

Grassgreendashhabi · 04/08/2016 07:58

Mini - thinking is one thing what this article is going on about is DOING

If people have these thoughts then they need help - they understand wrong from right

If people act on these thoughts they have no understanding and yes should be punished

Ned - you are just as dangerous as you seem to think it's justified

NeedACleverNN · 04/08/2016 07:56

This is disgusting

A paedophile is just as bad as a child molester

Children are innocent and should remain as such. No one should feel attracted to them and using the excuse of "years ago it was seen as disgusting for a black and white together now it's acceptable. It was seen as disgusting for a man and man together. Now it's acceptable"

And adult and a child is always sick and will never be accepted. Ever

NedStarksHead · 04/08/2016 07:54

I'm as dangerous as the person who wrote the article? Jesus Christ

OP posts:
minifingerz · 04/08/2016 07:53

"If people are saying "help me. I know its wrong and i don't want this" why shouldn't they be supported? It might actually reduce offending and keep children safe."

I think what people would prefer is for these individuals to commit suicide.

Unless of course it is their own son or daughter experiencing these compulsions, in which case they may see it differently. Hmm

I just wonder how those individuals who experience these compulsions in adulthood as a result of abuse they endured themselves as children, how do they survive? When the world says: "you are vile and worthless even for having these thoughts, regardless of whether you act on them".

ImOnMyTumbleTap · 04/08/2016 07:52

AIBU is the wrong thread for this. As is a forum for parents and grandparents.

Thingsthatmakeugoummmm · 04/08/2016 07:52

I am concerned about outing myself but this is an area I specialise in. I work with children who are at risk of becoming abusers and offer interventions.

However, not all pedophiles have been sexually abused and only a small percentage of children who have been sexually abused go on to be an abuser and this is not always against children.

I suppose it's difficult for me to be impartial given the devastating effects I see.

Dozer · 04/08/2016 07:50

Haven't read the article and from what posters say am concerned about the mindset and motivation of the peadophile who wrote it.

Also dislike people taking the "poor them" angle on people who are a huge danger to children - for one thing this seems to play into the manipulation that some paedophile offenders use.

there should continue to be help and services for paedophiles, eg from health professionals, if there's evidence that this reduces offences against children, which seems logical.

minifingerz · 04/08/2016 07:48

"It's not a choice no different from murdering someone or raping someone. There is a thing called wrong and right"

People can't help their thoughts.

It's wrong to act on those thoughts, but to have them in the first place?

Disordered thinking - compulsions, people can't help experiencing these. And telling people they are morally disputable simply for having thoughts they can't control will discourage them from seeking help.

Magikarp · 04/08/2016 07:45

I've reported this OP because the article is blasé about a horrific issue. It's not appropriate. Survivors of abuse do not need the likes of you empathising with paedophiles.

minifingerz · 04/08/2016 07:45

"I work with children who are sometimes victims of sex abuse"

Some children who are victims will grow up to become abusers themselves. At what point do you lose all sympathy for them as human beings? At the point where they are 16 and have sexualised feelings towards younger children? Or when they act on those feelings and ruin someone else's life?

Grassgreendashhabi · 04/08/2016 07:44

I think you need to see actual victims that might change your mind

You say I have empathy because it's not a choice. It's a sexual orientation they can't help it.

It's not a choice no different from murdering someone or raping someone. There is a thing called wrong and right

I think you sound as dangerous as the people in the article

ProfessorPreciseaBug · 04/08/2016 07:44

I wonder, If someone is attracted to infants but understands it is not acceptable, do they deserve condemnation for their condition, or help to deal with it?

There are of course others who are fixated, but think it is acceptable.

By way of background, I am a manic depressive. I can be a total pain to live with. I know I can't change so I have to try and manage the effects to the least harm to myself and those around me.

hormental · 04/08/2016 07:44

I'm not sure what reaction you anticipated on a forum full of parents OP.

Thingsthatmakeugoummmm · 04/08/2016 07:43

Part of my role is also working with adults and children who have these thoughts. A large number DO go on to act on these thoughts and the damage that causes is devastating

Swipe left for the next trending thread