Our GB is made up of lawyers, education academics, educational psychologists, accountants, CEOs, very experienced teachers, people with experience of managing facilities etc.
Lovely. This would be a high-achieving school with low FSM, excellent results, low staff turning, low levels of SEN and reasonable facilities, in an area in which social workers are relatively uncommon, most parents are in work and the children have high aspirations, yes?
It's hardly difficult to get good outcomes from such schools.
Now, consider a school in a deprived area in an ex-industrial town with >50% FSM, >50% EAL, >30% SEN, >50% of children in workless houses, 5% if that HE takeup in the students and substantially less amongst the parents. How well do you think that governing body is going to work? No one disputes that successful schools in easy locations with biddable intakes and professional governors can work well but, frankly, even without governing body the school would basically run itself: the head's biggest issues are going to be whether to fund A Level Music and whether you do the day trip for raising aspiration to Oxford or Cambridge this year.
There's a massive "let them eat cake" going on here. Failing schools in deprived areas just need to recruit more people like you to the governing body and it'll all be pukka.