Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

And crossed the line? (Wedding related sorry!)

60 replies

CuppaSarah · 06/05/2016 18:47

My sil is getting married in 18 months and wants to slowly start the dress shopping process so she can take her time and keep her options open. Tomorrow we're off to a sample sale for her first ever time trying on dresses. I'm super excited to go, but there's one problem.

To be blunt my sil is plus size and this sample sale does not have any plus size dresses. So her first time ever trying on wedding dresses will be trying on ones way too small. I can imagine that it could very easily leave her feeling shitty and bad about all wedding dress shopping, her self confidence is isn't great as it is.

So I've secretly booked an appointment in a bridal boutique with plus size gowns in her budget and have the money set aside for a deposit just in case(as she won't have all the funds till the end of the month) this way she can try on dresses that fit and get that princess feeling she deserves. But now I'm thinking it's a bit 'sorry you're too fat so we have to go somewhere else' or that I'm being pushy. Basically aibu to book her first boutique appointment behind her back?

OP posts:
MiddleClassProblem · 06/05/2016 22:44

I didn't need a bra (DD bosom) with my dress as it held me well and a bit of tit tape for security. I just had some m&s blue pants on underneath Grin

dustarr73 · 06/05/2016 22:34

You sound lovely and it sounds like the relationship you can be outstraight without it sounding rude.

Shes probably just looking for ideas in the first one but you can say the 2nd is where you can try the dress on.

summerainbow · 06/05/2016 22:09

Remember underwear is the key to looking good in a wedding dress

Clockworklemon · 06/05/2016 21:44

If you're both big boobed it's fine! Agree - is completely different and acceptable.

It's the ones (small pert breasted friends, school mums, practical strangers) who think it's ok to comment "God your boobs are massive aren't they??!" And for me the one thing I regret about my wedding is having been so limited dress wise due to enormous chest..

And even though I knew it was fact, it still hurt me to be reminded of the blindingly obvious when wedding dress shopping... Less of a "what would I like?" And more "what wouldn't make me look too booby". Sigh. I stupidly settled for "something that didn't make me look too bad" and your friend needs to feel absolutely fabulous. She's very lucky to have you helping her.

Wedding dress shopping is way more emotional than every day clothes shopping I guess.

teafortoads · 06/05/2016 20:07

No advice but you sound lovely! She is one lucky lady.

TheUnsullied · 06/05/2016 19:51

Clockworklemon there's no offence meant by it, it's just the way me and other top heavy women I know would likely tackle it. Especially those whose bust is far larger than the rest of their bodies, like mine. I was shopping with a friend recently who said something along the lines of "get a bigger size for that or you'll need one for each boob" to me. She was right. I'd have been pissed off if a stranger said it but friends and family can be fairly frank with me about my size without me being offended...I know I'm big and I know they're not trying to be offensive.

PotOfYoghurt · 06/05/2016 19:43

At the end of the day it sounds like you know her really well, as opposed to a SIL you aren't really friends with, so if you think she'll like it then she most likely will.

I think you've been very thoughtful and hope your SIL finds a dress she loves.

CuppaSarah · 06/05/2016 19:39

Though I'll change the word 'boobs' to 'glorious bossom'

OP posts:
CuppaSarah · 06/05/2016 19:34

Clockwork my sil is top heavy and loves it! We have many conversations on not fitting our boobs in clothes, I wouldn't say it to anyone else but to with us, it's standard conversation Grin

OP posts:
Clockworklemon · 06/05/2016 19:33

Ummmm I don't think unsullied's suggestion is at all tactful! I would have been crushed by that remark..

I think you sound very thoughtful OP Flowers

MrTiddlestheFatCat · 06/05/2016 19:27

You seem like a lovely SIL- very thoughtful.

I would say something along the lines of what PP have said...

'Oh I've just found this lovely place near to the sample sale & thought we could make a whole day out of the dress shopping!! I made a provisional appointment when I was having a look through, but just tell me if you'd rather not go!!'

Middleclassmumnetter said it the best, I think.

CuppaSarah · 06/05/2016 19:26

Well we talk a lot and she's told me she already enquired about sizes for the sale and knows the biggest size is too small. She was also telling me how she was worried about not fitting in any today. So she's going to the sample sale knowing which is good.

I also know she is planning on loosing some weight, but she is not intending on using her wedding dress as motivation or even planning on being smaller than what's currently considered plus size. We are very close and open with each other. I was also thinking sample sales are very busy and chaotic, so that might leave her disappointed too. It might be nice to have a proper appointment where she isn't rushed and can try on those two dresses I think she would look amazing in

This is one of those really personal ones where to some people I wbu and others I wnbu isn't it? Fx she's the latter

OP posts:
mountaintoclimb · 06/05/2016 19:24

When my dngot married she was overweight and didn't fit into any of the sample dress sizes. but most people wouldn''t as they are usually about 8-10 dress size.

She should be able to try some on even if they can't be done up. It's normal in my experience for wedding dresses to be altered to fit. That's why you have to allow 6-9months from choosing the dress through to alterations and fittings.

MiddleClassProblem · 06/05/2016 19:23

Plus size here, I think what you have done sounds lovely and very thoughtful

Blueberry234 · 06/05/2016 19:20

I think that is lovely I was plus size and being squeezed into a dress was hideous

Noodledoodledoo · 06/05/2016 19:12

When I booked appointment for my dress shopping I enquired if they had plus size dresses in for trying - making the point there was no point me wasting mine and their time if they didn't as I wasn't going to buy something drapped round my neck.

A couple of stores were quite rude when I enquired.

One shop had 2 dresses in when I went for the appointment - both I hated! Same shop tried to get me in to a size 10 when I am a size 20! The ripping sounds made me feel so good about myself.

I did howeve,r in a lovely shop, have success with trying lots on including a size 14 - if they aren't figure hugging style you do get a good idea of how it will look.

I was recommended one shop who 'specialised' in plus size alongside a 'normal' range who refused to let me look at the other rails, I didn't go back to that one!

ThinkPinkStink · 06/05/2016 19:10

I'm a size 16, and I think I'd want to be warned ahead of time that the sample sale might be full of sample size dresses. I would absolutely not be offended if my sister or friend said 'isn't a sample sale full of size 8-10 clothes?' I'm not blind, I know what clothes size I am. Is your DSis a bit sensitive or could you try a really factual, direct approach?

If it softens the blow, it's worth mentioning that wedding dresses come up super small (in my experience) so it's not that she's big, the bloody dresses are tiny X

Littleallovertheshop · 06/05/2016 19:10

As long as you don't mention size it will be fine. What a lovely thing to do

JeanGenie23 · 06/05/2016 19:09

How thoughtful of you.

YANBU to book it but I think you should tell her before hand so she doesn't feel like you have gone behind her back. It may be that she wants to find a sample size so she has motivation for weight loss? Or perhaps she is just doing it so she can get an idea of what style dress she likes?

MissBattleaxe · 06/05/2016 19:08

I think you sound absolutely lovely. I hope you both have a lovely day.

hilbil21 · 06/05/2016 19:05

I think what you're doing is lovely. However, she must know what size she is and if she wanted to go somewhere with plus sizes then she would. She's decided to go to the sample sale and I think although it's a lovely thought, I would be offended if it was me xx

CuppaSarah · 06/05/2016 19:05

Middleclass I will be using that exact line if the sample sale doesn't work out. Along with your line about breasts Unsullied.

To be honest plus size isn't the only reason I picked this place it has a couple.dresses I am dying to see her in. I love weddingd

OP posts:
Witchinghours · 06/05/2016 19:03

I think it's a really good idea. My 1st time trying on dresses was in a very naice shop in Knightsbridge where all the sample dresses were size 10. I was a size 12 at the time and felt terrible that none fitted.

Fortunately I had a 2nd appointment booked that day where the samples were 12 or 14.

CuppaSarah · 06/05/2016 19:00

Yes they're on the same day, sample sale first. Then we're having an early lunch and the bridal appointment is early afternoon.

I'm glad you guys don't think I'm being a weird control freak sil/bridesmaid. I just know she's waited so long to be a bride and I want her to love every minute of it.

OP posts:
Middleclassmumnetter · 06/05/2016 18:59

I think it's quite thoughtful of you if played right. Don't mention plus size, and certainly not as the reason you booked the other boutique. Could you play it as 'Cuppa is excited SIL caught up in wedding fever couldn't help myself, booked you in to boutique, oooh we can have champagne, I'm so excited!'
Go to the sample sale, be supportive, if it comes up remind her that 'sample sales are well known for having tiny sizes, it's ridiculous, we'll go to a proper place next time'