Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that DH - a teacher - could take a day off work?

460 replies

BackAche21 · 28/04/2016 12:46

I have been a SAHM for 2 yrs after redundancy and now I have got myself a job interview, which happens to fall on the day that DS (4) has an allergy challenge in hospital. DH says he can't take the day off teaching as his Y12s are close to AS exams, and he is head of department so it looks bad, plus notoriously stingy Headteacher may not give permission. But aside from permission (there were sickies in my day) he doesn't even want to ask. I don't know what solution he thinks is possible.

I am already asking the hospital if they can change the date - but we've already changed it once owing to DS being unwell - and they might not let us change it again. It won't be an option to ask potential employer to change the date as they have a whole load of obstacles lined up for candidates on the day, involving meeting other people too.

IMHO it puts me in an impossible situation as I don't think anyone other than a parent can really do the hospital gig, and our family needs me to get a job. before redundancy all sick children etc fell to me to take time off work, and I feel like he's just staking this ground again - his teaching time is untouchable. Makes me mad, but AIBU?

OP posts:
DarkRoots · 01/05/2016 20:28

Ah, but would I get time off for my child's hospitals appointments? That is the question Wink

TendonQueen · 01/05/2016 18:45

Darkroots I really wish you would! You'd have lots of support for such sensible thinking Smile

MrsGuyOfGisbo · 01/05/2016 16:29

Unforeseen emergencies are one thing - of course they will be covered.
Planned absences are another matter.
I know only too well the systems in place for cover, as I am a supply teacher and so meet and talk to lots of Cover Managers, whose task it is to allocate teachers to classes in emergencies.
The simple fact is that regardless of 'rearranging revision sessions', 'extra sessions on bank Holiday' etc, timetabled classes need a teacher to supervise them.
Ad-hoc swaps are in most schools now prohibited, for the simple reason that the CM needs to rely on the fact that a teacher with a free period can be used to cover an absence - if that person has done an informal swap with another it throws out the algorithm , as the person is shown as being available to cover...
In that case the Cover manager would over rule the informal arrangement.
In indies, it is simpler as staff have fewer timetable teaching periods, and so are more able to cover absences.
If I were minister Grin I would reduce the number of timetabled periods for teachers precisely for this reason, and increase the number of working weeks as a quid pro quo..
However, this would be unpopular with teachers, so thjy have to suck up the no time off except for unforeseen emergenices in term time rules.

DarkRoots · 01/05/2016 15:41

Am thinking of running for Education Minister, Fleck Grin

Fleck · 01/05/2016 11:20

Nicely put DarkRoots!

DarkRoots · 01/05/2016 08:28

Regarding 'who pays?', there (as ever) is a process in place. Some schools employ a cover supervisor. But all schools should have a budget allocated for cover. Managing the budget is the head teacher's job - any head without a budget for cover would be seriously financially mismanaging the situation. The third option (for absences due to favours, etc) is internal cover where you ask colleagues a favour for something that you aren't entitled to time off for. Allowing this is at the discretion of the head.

Teachers get sick, need to meet with social services, need to do job interviews, break their legs, get stuck in a snow drift, have funerals of loved ones to attend and so on and so on. And even have important hospital appointments. These absences are inevitable and have to be covered by the budget.

Of course, budgets are being slashed for schools at a frightening rate, and head teachers are trying to economise everywhere. Cover budgets is an obvious one to address. I understand why heads are reminding teachers that absences cost money to the school.

However: teachers also take time off with stress and depression, fatigue-related illness and so on. Or when they are interviewing frantically for jobs elsewhere, or throwing sickies to be able to actually manage their lives. These will end up being paid for from an emergency cover budget as well, but any good leadership should take all steps available to them to minimise these absences through developing a healthy environment to work in, just like any other business. And schools ARE a business, and an employer. Our profits are results and well-nurtured students, but it is still a business nonetheless.

Like a majority of employees who work in vocational jobs, most teachers go way beyond what their job requires them (and pays them) to do. For this, our county is lucky. However, encouraging this culture where teachers do not believe they are entitled to time off for things they are legally entitled to have time off for is a short-sighted nonsense which creates resentful teachers and wary parents. No-one wins.

I am very thankful that my GP squeezed my DD in for an emergency appointment between surgeries because I was worried. I know this was his lunch-time, or admin time, and that he did not have to do it. That was a favour and is over and above what's expected. It is much appreciated. Ditto the midwife who stayed late on her shift to deliver DD, the home help who popped out on her day off to see my DG, etc etc. I am glad to say that I could go on and on. These people are doing vocational jobs. And yet! I would expect a locum GP, my midwife to be changed, etc if their child was in hospital or their spouse was ill or they were at their DM's funeral. It happens and we have systems in place to provide for it. Use those systems or we lose them, and then it really is an impossible job where the most vulnerable suffer.

Anyway - enough of my essay! Your DH is experienced and established enough to man up and ask his HT for a day off. Again, I suspect this is not really the issue.

Hope the allergy challenge goes well.

Fleck · 30/04/2016 21:41

I would go with your second guess! Expensive holidays is something you do just have to lump, even for your honeymoon.

CalleighDoodle · 30/04/2016 20:32

fleck my first guess would be the date was significant to the couple. My second guess woul be the honeymoon would be significantly cheaper.

mirime · 30/04/2016 16:03

On rearranging the job interview - my employer is completely reasonable, and time off for an appointment or having to rearrange days during the probationary period would be absolutely fine. When we advertise a job the interview date is in the advert and we can't change it if people can't make it - there is a section where all candidates work as a group, plus the day will have been chosen so that the panel can have service users, staff members and management committee members.

Sometimes however good a candidate is, however good the employer is interview dates can't be changed.

And last time I cancelled a hospital appointment I had to be re-referred by my GP three times as the hospital kept cancelling the referral, which meant about five GP visits in all. Luckily, as I've said, I have an understanding employer.

80schild · 30/04/2016 14:22

At the end of the day, it is one day out of his life. As for his yr 12s - if they are putting the work in, they will still get As and missing one lesson is not going to hurt their grades. I think he needs to ask.

Rainuntilseptember · 30/04/2016 13:16

Posted in 20 years time:
"AIBU to think that my dad should have put my health first, not his job?"

Fleck · 30/04/2016 12:12

A week off for a wedding/ honeymoon is completely different though! Why would a teacher get married during term time anyway? The 'current climate' for me is that maths teachers are bloody hard to find. If I was disciplined for taking a day off in the OP's husband's situation then I would be looking for a new job (if they are unable to rearrange the appointment, I agree it is reasonable to try to do this). Yes teachers get a lot of holiday but it doesn't mean they own you body and soul in term time, there has to be some give and take. We get 5 days a year paid parental leave and everything above that is unpaid. To the poster who said 'take it unpaid pay the additional cost of supply', I would be surprised if it cost much less than £200 a day for a head of dept anyway if you include NI and pension costs, but I really don't see why he should take it unpaid when he's been working hard for them all year. My head of departing works harder than anyone I know with countless hours of unpaid overtime.

Noodledoodledoo · 30/04/2016 12:12

Jonah apologies for typo.

Noodledoodledoo · 30/04/2016 12:10

Jobah no UK teachers don't have an allowance to use for personal reasons.

As others have said it really is dependent on school and ethos.

YonicTrowel · 30/04/2016 12:06

Your friend wanted to take a week off for an event she had the power to set the date of and which was nothing to do with her health or that of her child?

That isn't the same. Not even close.

YonicTrowel · 30/04/2016 11:49

It isn't a standard hospital appointment. It's all day. I don't know any friends who aren't either working or have young children of their own to care for as SAHPs. Many people don't live near parents, have parents too frail to do this or have parents who are still working.

People with caring responsibilities do have additional protection over "optional" things like weddings.

Again, what if both OP and her DH were teachers and the clinic didn't run in school holidays/was already fully booked then?

noblegiraffe · 30/04/2016 11:48

The person you had to request cover from at my school used to be very difficult to deal with and would definitely make things difficult for you if she thought you weren't the last resort (e.g. taking a day off for a sick kid would lead to a detailed interrogation about why all other possible options weren't being used, taking a second day would be a non-starter). That recently changed and the person now in charge is much more reasonable about the demands of children and will sign stuff off no problem. They're retiring and it's a bit of worry about who will take over.

So what happens in other schools doesn't mean it will be the same in the OP's DH's school, and it could definitely be a problem.

StarUtopia · 30/04/2016 11:39

The school pays for a supply teacher; I think op's DH is fairly senior so if he has a day unpaid, the books probably balance pretty well.

Supply teacher is minimum £200 a day cost (obviously the actual supply teacher doesn't get that)

If your DH wanted to take the day unpaid and pay the difference, I'm sure the school would be fine with it (to an extent)

But surely you can find family, friends, support from elsewhere?

Just to give insight to those non teachers on here (plenty), one of my colleagues requested (a year in advance) for her wedding during term time. A week away abroad. She had had zero sickness or other requested time off. It was refused.

Seriously. You're all in denial if you think that in the current climate, a teacher can just waltz off to a standard hospital appointment! 13 weeks holiday a year...Rebook your non-emergency appointment.

Hairyfairy01 · 30/04/2016 11:29

My dp is a ta and isn't allowed anytime off during term time, even unpaid. This is what the parent governors have decided. We have 2 kids with additional needs, I work full time. Most of my a/l goes on the kids appointments. If you can't get a grandparent or anyone to go op you should enquire about moving the appointment. You are giving them plenty of notice, it's only if you fail to attend X 2 that you have to go to the bottom of the waiting list.

gandalf456 · 30/04/2016 10:54

Shoddily

gandalf456 · 30/04/2016 10:54

My father was a teacher and he always said don't go into teaching you will hate it.

This thread would be a good example of how I would hate it too.

Basically, if you don't have a good head, you have to sing for your supper because of the 13 weeks holiday you get a year. Sure, it's fantastic but not if it's going to be so inflexible that you literally cannot have any other time off - including in an emergency, including funerals, including sickness. I think I would happily stick with my 6 weeks thank you very much.

In any case those of the people I know who are teachers spend a lot of time prepping during the holidays- maybe not the summer holiday- but certainly the other holidays and they work long hours in term time so they see the holidays as a reprieve from that and also these holidays are for the students as well. They can't cope with a proper working structured environment because they're too young.

Of course, we all aim to attend work every day, come what may, but unfortunately people do fall ill in term time, people do die during term time,people's dependents to get sick in term time and ultimately that have to be some degree of catering for that.

What shocks me most is that many teachers seem to agree with being treated very shortly so no wonder nothing changes

YonicTrowel · 30/04/2016 10:42

If both the OP and her DH were teachers, how would you solve it, MrsGuy?

As noted above, her DH's employer has benefitted over time from previous appointments all being covered by her, not split 50:50.

YonicTrowel · 30/04/2016 10:39

The school pays for a supply teacher; I think op's DH is fairly senior so if he has a day unpaid, the books probably balance pretty well.

Sick leave for staff and unpaid carer's leave both have costs to cover in many jobs (NHS as well) and it's a part of budgeting for a staff member, just as NI contributions are.

Fleck · 30/04/2016 10:31

Schools have a duty of care to their staff as well as students and this means that some of their budget must go to meeting their needs too, including providing cover when needed. I don't know any teacher who doesn't give up their time to do non contracted tasks such as revision sessions, why should the school not be willing to help them out when they need it? In fact if you have a happy staff you are likely to have reduced absence levels for sickness anyway, which reduces costs long term.

Jonah23 · 30/04/2016 10:03

Don't teachers in UK have an allowance of hours every scholastic year for emergency reasons, such as medical appointments? We do in our country. We have about 27 hours allocated to us for such necessities, obviously not to be abused, but one can even get a cover note from the hospital. It would be wise to check with the Union of teachers. I am sure our country union follows UK and European teachers' unions. This wasn't heard of years ago but now fortunately teachers' needs are realized and catered for too. After all, they are human too.