Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Safe Play Sand for Sandpit?

116 replies

FriskyFrog · 27/04/2016 15:58

Sorry, posting for traffic.

Just bought a sandpit and was about to order some nice cheap playsand from Tesco when I found out about crystalline silica and asbestos tremolite. Both known carcinogens. Common to find them in play sand apparently if the sand is manufactured from crushed rock instead of being natural sand taken from a beach or river.

Am looking at playsand that claims to be non toxic and conforms to BS EN71-3-2013, e.g. ELC and others, but the standard does not cover silica or asbestos tremolite, and none of them say how the sand is produced / sourced.

Has anyone already done the homework on this and know of a properly safe playsand?

I am rather shocked to see that Tesco's playsand is silica sand now.

OP posts:
MrsPigling · 27/04/2016 18:01

The stuff you'll be reading online about the dangers of respirable silica is aimed at those in the construction industry who are exposed to this on a daily basis, in larger quantitie, day in day out for years. Respirable silica is in plaster dusts and cements which are very fine powders, much easier to inhale. Someone working with it every day, without any respiratory protection is much more likely to get ill.

Using play sand in a sand pit is not going to cause cancer :)

EvansOvalPies · 27/04/2016 17:54

But this is the point, Frisky, that you're not getting. We've bought safe sand. My DC are fine, strapping, healthy young adults. As are all the friends that played in our sand pits, and all of those children in each other's sandpits.

When your DC go to Nursery and School - will you forbid them from playing in the sandpits provided (you will look like a bit of a loon if you do). Just because you don't like the contents of the sand. And have you stopped them from using certain washing products and toothpastes and shampoos and bubble baths and ... and ... and ...!
The point some posters are trying to make is - you cannot stop your children from coming into contact with anything that might be the slightest bit carcinogenic. LIFE is carcinogenic. How will you cope with that if you can't manage a bit of sand?

MrsPigling · 27/04/2016 17:52

All sand contains silica (that's what it is!). The stuff that can cause cancer is the respirable silica, the very, very fine bits that can get deep into the lungs and cause damage.

Only a tiny portion of play sand (or beach sand) will be the respirable stuff. They extract it cos it's worth £££ as it's useful for other things.

You really do not need to worry about the silica in play sand causing cancer [:)]

FriskyFrog · 27/04/2016 17:51

Juxta, Tesco's sand is manufactured silica sand.

You seem to have a problem with the fact that I care what carcinogens are in my children's toys. I don't know why.

OP posts:
FriskyFrog · 27/04/2016 17:47

If you're that worried, either return the sand pit or turn it into a water play instead.

Or, y'know, just do a bit of homework and buy sand that's safe?? Hmm

OP posts:
JuxtapositionRecords · 27/04/2016 17:46

Ok sure so clearly it's just play sand you are fixated on, everything else you are relaxed with...

It's pretty ridiculous to accuse Tesco of supplying kids sand that can cause cancer and try and make everyone else who doesn't have this obsession with it sound like we don't care about our children's health when you have no evidence to back it up.

Anyway, good luck with your sand search.

FriskyFrog · 27/04/2016 17:45

No evan. manufactured sand, from quartz I believe, is the problem both in US and here.

OP posts:
EvansOvalPies · 27/04/2016 17:44

Chocomochi If you're that worried, either return the sand pit or turn it into a water play instead

You cannot be serious! Do you have any idea how much bacteria WATER harbours?

FriskyFrog · 27/04/2016 17:44

Vote. Now, that is a good idea! I never even thought of that.

OP posts:
Voteforpedr0 · 27/04/2016 17:43

Genx, diagnosing someone with anxiety on a forum isn't normal behaviour.

EvansOvalPies · 27/04/2016 17:42

UK Evan. But it's a rather relevant study regardless, with its focus on early childhood exposure etc

But not particularly relevant then, if you live in the UK. As sand worldwide differs, surely? Manufacture of play-sand in the UK will surely be different from the manufacture of similar play-sand in the US (much the same as their production of meat, just as an example). US meat is more likely to be filled with antibiotics and other chemicals, whereas in the UK free-range and organic is more easily accessible. You can't really compare the two.

And, as others have pointed out, that report is very out of date. You are worrying too much.
Relax, breathe, let your children play and have fun. (Meant in the nicest possible way)! Really

FriskyFrog · 27/04/2016 17:41
Grin

No anxiety here Gen, I can assure you. Are you anxious that there might or should be?

OP posts:
Voteforpedr0 · 27/04/2016 17:39

Frisky frog - we got ours from the beach due to the very reasons you've mentioned and it stayed in our sand pit for 5 years, played with almost every day. To the Posters who say there are do many cancer causing chemicals we come into contact with every day, it's not relevant because it's unrealistic to think we could prevent that but clearly making an informed choice about something we know to be toxic is wise no ?

FriskyFrog · 27/04/2016 17:39

Gen. I avoid those plastics for my kids, doesn't almost everyone?

Juxta. There is more out there, if you care to look.

OP posts:
chocomochi · 27/04/2016 17:38

We bought play sand from Argos too and didn't even think about the other stuff.

If you're that worried, either return the sand pit or turn it into a water play instead.

Genx77 · 27/04/2016 17:37

I think juxta has it.
To spend so much time researching playsand, starting a thread about it, dragging up old reports from the Internet etc is NOT normal behaviour. You sound like you have a problem with anxiety, in fact you sound well in its grip.....

specialsubject · 27/04/2016 17:35

that link is indeed relevant to what you are saying, but it is nearly 30 years old and American. Asbestos use and control have changed considerably since.

the sand concerned had come from somewhere with asbestos deposits. They aren't that common and I doubt that playsand is dug from these places.

other links on the subject of playsand safety are full of babble about 'no silica'. What is their sand made of, we ask?

life can be carcinogenic, I'm afraid. It isn't safe so the trick is to assess risk. In short, step away from google and don't worry.

FriskyFrog · 27/04/2016 17:34

UK Evan. But it's a rather relevant study regardless, with its focus on early childhood exposure etc.

OP posts:
JuxtapositionRecords · 27/04/2016 17:31

That is a very old study. Anything more recent?

FriskyFrog · 27/04/2016 17:31

Juxta

Your "bet" is incorrect.

OP posts:
EvansOvalPies · 27/04/2016 17:29

Your link is for an American study, OP. Do you live in the US?

Genx77 · 27/04/2016 17:26

You're more likely to get cancer from the plastic sand pit than the sand......BPA? Phthalates?
Of course you must already know about the risk from these and never use plastic cups/beakers/bottles/toys/packaging etc???

HermioneJeanGranger · 27/04/2016 17:25

I really don't think you need to worry, OP.

Everything we use has carcinogens in it - aerosols, shampoo, washing up liquid, meat, milk, toothpaste...the list goes on.

I understand you're concerned, but it's not rational when you consider how much of what we eat/use/inhale everyday is full of carcinogens. Play-sand isn't going to have any impact in the grand scheme of things.

FriskyFrog · 27/04/2016 17:25

Ha! Good point re: the one time purchase! Grin

Well, a one time decision making process then!

This link is relevant.... Dry though.

www.upstate.edu/pathenvi/studies/cases/case7.php

OP posts:
JuxtapositionRecords · 27/04/2016 17:25

WE are being condescending to the op, murphy?? Ok... And what nasty comments?

Op, with respect, I think what people are trying to say everything is a potential risk for cancer or other diseases. Swimming pools, parks, toys, food, toiletries - the list goes on and on. Presumably if you can't find sand that is good enough for you, your DD won't have it which is a shame for her to miss out based on a microscopic potential threat. I'm willing to bet if you are like this about play sand, many other aspects of yours (and your DD's) life are heavily impacted by your worries.