Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Safe Play Sand for Sandpit?

116 replies

FriskyFrog · 27/04/2016 15:58

Sorry, posting for traffic.

Just bought a sandpit and was about to order some nice cheap playsand from Tesco when I found out about crystalline silica and asbestos tremolite. Both known carcinogens. Common to find them in play sand apparently if the sand is manufactured from crushed rock instead of being natural sand taken from a beach or river.

Am looking at playsand that claims to be non toxic and conforms to BS EN71-3-2013, e.g. ELC and others, but the standard does not cover silica or asbestos tremolite, and none of them say how the sand is produced / sourced.

Has anyone already done the homework on this and know of a properly safe playsand?

I am rather shocked to see that Tesco's playsand is silica sand now.

OP posts:
wheresthel1ght · 27/04/2016 19:49

Poundshop specials for me

You won't get a say in what sand is used at playgroups/nursery/school/other people's houses.

Frankly there are better things to tie yourself in knots over

FriskyFrog · 27/04/2016 19:46

Juxta. It's not relevant that the study I linked to happened to be American, or that it's older. The same risks still exist.

I sought knowledge here, but it seems that many have adopted an aggressive stance, possibly through fear. But if the risk exists, is it not better to be aware of it so people can do their own research and decision making?
Although for clarity, I did not post in order to inform, I posted to ask for info, and I think that is very clear in my OP.

Why shout me down for seeking info to enable me to make a safe choice for my children?

I think many responses on here have been out of order. If you don't agree with my decision to seek info on safer toys and do not have the info I seek, then move along.

OP posts:
murphyslaws · 27/04/2016 19:36

Juxta so far all you have done is criticise and offered no advice what so ever.

Anyway Murphy you will pleased to know I bow out of this conversation now too.*

Really !!! I'm sure your going to HAVE to add something more. As you seem to be the one goading. Asking the same question and saying the same things again and again and again and again!

FriskyFrog · 27/04/2016 19:34

Arf! Lacontessa thinks she's a cross between Marie Curie and Peter Kay.

OP posts:
FriskyFrog · 27/04/2016 19:29

Juxta murphy what exactly are you adding to this thread apart from goading everyone along?

That is the most ironic thing I've read this month. Grin

OP posts:
LaContessaDiPlump · 27/04/2016 19:28

Watch out for dihydrogen monoxide op - it's everywhere.....

FriskyFrog · 27/04/2016 19:28

MrsPigling
No, the risk is not avoided by buying play sand tested to British Standards.
BS EN71-3-2013, which is the relevant standard, covers neither tremolite nor silica.

Thus, play sand in this country could contain any amount of each. They are unregulated carcinogens in play sand. And most play sand is not true sand, it's ground quartz and similar.

OP posts:
JuxtapositionRecords · 27/04/2016 19:27

murphy what exactly are you adding to this thread apart from goading everyone along?

Op I couldn't care less what you want to do. What I do care about is when people scaremonger based on no actual facts. You have chosen a parenting website to ask this question and make your claims regarding cancer and children, which is inevitably going to worry people. You know full well 99% of people on here will have the sand you are trying to say is unsafe. You answered your own question in less than 30 minutes by going to the manufacturer directly anyway. And you chose AIBU to do all of this.

Your only frame of reference is an American study from 30 years ago, even though you specifically asked for something that conforms to a EUROPEAN standard. You don't seem to be able to grasp what I and others have said about the risk, the dust particles etc. So either you don't know what you are talking about or you just wanted to start an argument where you can look like a perfect parent protecting her child from all danger.

Anyway Murphy you will pleased to know I bow out of this conversation now too.

blueberryporridge · 27/04/2016 19:16

or what its worth I used play sand from Early Learning centre for my 3 dc 20 yrs ago (bought several times I may add)...hasn't done them any harm
I'd be more worried about my kids being taught in old school buildings with asbestos in the roof tiles!

Sorry but this statement doesn't really stack up as evidence. First of all, personal anecdotes are not statistical studies and secondly, asbestos tiles are OK unless they are broken and release particles which are ingested, which is exactly what OP is concerned about with play sand.

OP: FWIW I agree with you. There are lots of risks in life we can't avoid but there are some we can avoid. I've had the same thoughts as you about play sand and also do my best to avoid potentially hazardous substances in toiletries, cleaning materials, plastics etc. This does not make me an over-anxious mother or a crank. In fact, concern about health risks from commonly-used substances in the home is becoming more of a mainstream concern and has been the subject of various reports recently.

tilder · 27/04/2016 19:15

Interesting thread.

If I used a single reference more than 30 years old, which relates to conditions in a different country, with such an interesting publication record I would be lynched.

Seriously op, if this is a genuine concern please use references that actually mean something.

Also MrsPigling knows what she is talking about.

I would of course be interested in the results of any further research. My childrens sandpit has been made into a chicken nest and is in need of new sand for the summerGrin

murphyslaws · 27/04/2016 19:11

I'm now shrugging my shoulders and moving on.

AT LONG LAST Grin

EvansOvalPies · 27/04/2016 19:03

Evans Feel free to call me Frisk, it's of no consequence. Perhaps now I understand more why my position annoys you. It seems to take not much.

Not annoyed in the slightest, simply slightly irritated, and wondering why you hadn't replied to the questions. It is impossible for you and your DC to go through life actively avoiding anything that MIGHT contain a carcinogen. Almost everything does, Fact. Just by breathing, you are inhaling carcinogens left, right and centre. You appear to be obsessed with the sand (and I haven't said that previously) yet are fine with everything else that might be slightly carcinogenic.
Play sand in this country will have been researched to be as safe as it possibly can be and is probably the least of your worries. You have been pretty much told this by someone very knowledgeable in the field', yet you still choose to argue. You asked the question in AIBU, you have been told that you are BU, yet you still choose to argue. I'm now shrugging my shoulders and moving on.

MrsPigling · 27/04/2016 18:59

But you are avoiding risk by buying play sand certified to the relevant BS. There is minimal respirable silica in play sand, trace amounts, certainly not enough to cause cancer.

Voteforpedr0 · 27/04/2016 18:53

*far more likely

Voteforpedr0 · 27/04/2016 18:52

Hairy, it's unhealthy to label people obsessed and not to think about stuff like this. Leave the bloody op alone Shelter from Plastic toys is hardly a comparison either as the child is for likely to inhale sand (dust ) than plastic toys (unless mouthing still going on). Op seriously get yourself down to the beach and start digging

FriskyFrog · 27/04/2016 18:51

Evans Feel free to call me Frisk, it's of no consequence. Perhaps now I understand more why my position annoys you. It seems to take not much.

You seem pointlessly antagonistic, so I am not inclined to answer your questions. But since it bothers you so much, then rest assured that I am aware that we cannot avoid unavoidable carcinogens in life. But I seek to minimise avoidable ones, as anyone sensible does.

And no, of course I'm not about to run shrieking over to my children at the sight of an unfamiliar sand pit, but if it's in their own garden, so likely to be used much more frequently and over a longer period, then yes, I will seek to put something non-toxic in there.

Is that OK by you?

OP posts:
Hairyfairy01 · 27/04/2016 18:44

Sorry op, but you are way over thinking this. What are you going to do when your child plays with sand, plastic toys, mud etc at nursery / school / friends houses? Life is full of risks and there are dangers in everything, but it's unhealthy to be quite as obsessed as you sound.

EvansOvalPies · 27/04/2016 18:39

Frisk. it is a known fact that carcinogens exist in detergents and meat. (Yes I know you are Frisky, but you do keep calling me Evan. (with the full stop) rather than Evans) Sorry - was starting to find it mildly irritating.

I haven't wondered if you are clinically anxious at all - have just mentioned that neither you nor your children can avoid carcinogens totally throughout their/your lives. Life itself is carcinogenic.

And for the fourth time of asking - are you intending to stop your children from playing in sand that hasn't met your exacting standards? I really am curious now, not trying to be difficult. I just wonder how you will enforce this.

FriskyFrog · 27/04/2016 18:31

Correct MrsPigling. The sand particles are not the carcinogen; I never meant they were. The whole product is more finely ground, is the point.

Evan. I don't intend to do more research. It is a known fact that carcinogens exist in some play sands.

My time is better spent asking the companies about their products, and seeking existing knowledge on social media. Both of these are sensible approaches.
This thread was only ever intended, as per my OP, to establish whether anyone knew of a playsand without the named carcinogens.

I see no reason for people to be irritated by that. Yet, so many unhelpful posts, demanding to know if I eat meat, if I am clinically anxious, and other such nonsense.

OP posts:
NeedACleverNN · 27/04/2016 18:21

If you are seriously worried about research done 30 years ago, you are going to have big problems.

Nothing will be safe in that case

MrsPigling · 27/04/2016 18:19

No really, the sand particles are NOT the carcingoen. It's the respirable silica, which is the danger, these are mcuh smaller than the grains of sand. Most of the play sand is the non-respirable bit and is not carcinogenic.

I write COSHH assessments for a living and do know a bit about this....

EvansOvalPies · 27/04/2016 18:15

Okay - you carry on with your research then Frisky. I'll be interested in your findings, and would really like to know if you are never going to use any of the products suggested above as they may possibly be carcinogen-carrying. Will you allow your children to play with sand at school or nursery, or indeed, at other friends' houses (I've asked that question twice before, but you haven't answered it yet)

And again - the only research link you have managed to provide is old, old, old. Anything more recent we may be able to relate to? Things have probably moved on since then.

scotsgirl64 · 27/04/2016 18:11

for what its worth I used play sand from Early Learning centre for my 3 dc 20 yrs ago (bought several times I may add)...hasn't done them any harm
I'd be more worried about my kids being taught in old school buildings with asbestos in the roof tiles!

scotsgirl64 · 27/04/2016 18:08

sand is made up of silica...so don't know how you're going to avoid that Im afraid!

FriskyFrog · 27/04/2016 18:06

Evan. No, I do get it. The risk can show up years later. It is an avoidable risk that I choose to avoid. I expect them to use the sandpit at home a lot over quite a few summers.
ELC sand, that you bought, may well be safe, I am confirming their source / production method. If it is, then great.

MrsPigling it is prcisely because play sand is so much finer that it does pose the risks of inhaling tiny particles.

OP posts: