Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My dad is making me look wealthier than I am (long)

393 replies

dazedandconfused17 · 13/03/2016 13:15

I know my diamond shoes are too tight and in the big scheme of things I'm incredibly lucky.

When I was 22 I inherited a house and some land from my grandparents. It came to me as my mother had died when I was little. It isn't Blenheim Palace or anything, but it had been in her family since 1693 and parts of it date back to the 12th century. My DF thought at the time I should sell it, as while it is gorgeous, it has always been a lot of work to maintain etc. In the end (after a couple of years of faff), DH (then DP) and I decided to move in and try and keep the place going.

We're now in our late thirties and it's still here. It's been a rough ride, but so far we have kept the place standing and our family going. It has, however, been really financially tough, especially the last couple of years, due to a bunch of unexpected expenses, specifically massive issues with the roof. Last year in a real pinch, DH borrowed £2000 from a friend to cover vets bills for our dog. At the time, he was meant to be starting a new contract (he works freelance to help support the family) and thought he'd be able to pay back in a couple of months. The job fell through at the last minute and we've not been able to repay on time. Currently I'm paying it off at a rate of £400 per month, which is very hard (we have zero spare income at all right now) but it is getting done.

The friend in question has been, quite reasonably, annoyed with us and said she was only able to spare the money for a couple of months and needs it all back. Last time I saw her she had a massive rant about how we clearly could afford to as the kids went skiing after Christmas and we have a nearly new car.

The thing is this comes from my dad. He has always said that he won't loan us money (which is fair) and he doesn't want us to rely on him as we're grown ups, but does like to sometimes give random gifts. So, for example, he and my stepmum took the kids away, along with my half brothers (who are both much younger than me - closer to my kids age) for a skiing holiday. We could never afford it. And when he wanted to get a new car last year, he gave us his old one, which was a decent three year old VW Passat (I know! I know!). But this is all coming together to make us look super rich - we live in a huge house (even if currently we can't heat it) and we have a nice car and the kids go skiing and she is getting really angry that we're drawing out the repayments.

DH is working, but only part time as a postman as he hasn't been able to get a new contact like the one that fell through. I am working, part time out of the home and part time on our business which is meant to get the place a bit more profitable and a bit less of a drain. I did try and explain that we don't have money, just a gift from my dad, and she said that if he could afford to give us a nearly new car, he could definitely afford to give us the money we need to repay her.

Is she being U? I am pretty certain that DF won't loan me the money if I ask, and if he does he'll be really unhappy about it, even though he can afford it. Is he being U? Should I ask anyway?

We have tried to get a bank loan, but after a bunch of financial hiccups last year they pretty much laughed in our face at the suggestion of an unsecured personal loan and we can't take a loan through the business and spend it on a personal debt, I don't think. Loan should be paid off start of May, but it's just getting there.

OP posts:
ClarenceTheLion · 13/03/2016 15:56

*sorry for typos!

ClarenceTheLion · 13/03/2016 15:56

I can see your issues OP, and I hope things work out. It si s agood idea to suggest renting out the big house and renting somewhere small nearby, but is the house in good enough condition for a renter with that kind of money to be interested? As an old property, might the National Trust be interested in helping out?

I think my big worry in your shoes would be about passing the place on. You have to hope one of your dc's will earn enough and care enough about the place to want to take it on. Would you be upset if they couldn't cope and had to sell it?

Branleuse · 13/03/2016 15:53

can you get lodgers?

horseygeorgie · 13/03/2016 15:53

Glad you have talked to your friend.

It is a difficult situation. I wouldn't sell the house, it wouldn't even enter my head. Obviously you need to look at diversifying and make it pay for itself. Depends on size of property/lands etc but there must be some way to utilise it for the sake of the future of the property itself. Could it be opened to the public or used as a wedding venue/conference center? Maybe if you found something viable you DF would be willing to invest in it if you had properly drawn up business plans and a clear view of the future? He must has a vested interest in keeping it alive after all!

Keep going OP, maybe there will be something else you can do to earn some more pennies in the area. Make sure you are economising as well as you are able.

CamboricumMinor · 13/03/2016 15:52

dazed the thing is you are happy to betray the trust of your friend? You can't afford to live in the house can you? I'd like to have lived in my grandparent's large house but I couldn't afford it, you have to live within your means.

BigChocFrenzy · 13/03/2016 15:51

Ah, your post just popped up. She's a very understanding friend.

charleybarley · 13/03/2016 15:51

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

BigChocFrenzy · 13/03/2016 15:50

It is irrelevant whether you live in a 2-bed council house or a big country estate:
when you borrow from a friend, pay her back as agreed.
Or made it quite clear when asking for the loan that she might have to wait several months extra.

Did you even ask the vet about a payment plan, or did you just expect her to suck it up, without being consulted ?
She is totally NBU about the loan not being laid back on time: You put her too far down your list of priorities.

You are massively NBU not to even ask your dad - your embarassment is a price you need to pay, if that gives even a chance that your friend gets her money more quickly. You said he probably wouldn't lend you anything, but he might because your friend is the one suffering.

In your financial situation, taking out an additional loan might be risky.
Better to quickly sell jewelry, electronics, skis, antique furniture, designer handbags, clothes etc. I'd be surprised if you can't raise 2k like that.

Charley50 · 13/03/2016 15:48

That's good OP. And you've had loads of ideas of how to get that house and land working harder for you.

JizzyStradlin · 13/03/2016 15:47

Indeed the 70 acres of farmland isn't sustaining the family ingeniusidiot, OP has made that very clear already. I don't think any of the posters who've suggested selling some of it have been under the impression that it was a lot in farming terms? In fact that's probably why so many people have talked about investigating other uses. As for the masses, there seem to be rather more posts telling OP she's not got enough money than there are posts telling her she's rich!

PurpleDaisies · 13/03/2016 15:47

I'm glad you sorted things out with your friend op.

I think this should serve as a wake up call to really sort out your finances so they're sustainable for the future. It doesn't sound like you can go on like this indefinitely.

Valentine2 · 13/03/2016 15:45

Sorry cross posted. So that bit looks under control then. Hope you figure out the rest too

BitterAndOnlySlightlyTwisted · 13/03/2016 15:44

A house and land that's been in the family for over 300 years and people are saying sell it to pay off a loan of less than two grand? Utterly bonkers. This isn't a bloody bungalow which granny bought for her retirement!

There are any number of families in a similar situation: asset-rich but little-to-no income. But you do have a number of choices:

Ask father for a short-term loan to pay that poor woman back.
Raise some funds through the business, either via a loan or finding a potential shareholder
What does the land produce? Or what can it be made to produce to raise income?
Maybe sell off a small bit of the land
Raise a lease on some of the land for grazing or farming
Or both of you work full-time until you have a savings-cushion.
If the house is large enough you could raise rent by doing an AirBnB

A house that old is nearly always a money-pit. It was originally built by people who had plenty. But that does not generally hold true of their descendants.

Fluffy24 · 13/03/2016 15:44

twinkle I don't imagine anyone is suggesting it's sold to pay this debt, but rather avoid the inevitable catalogue of upkeep costs and future problems.

Valentine2 · 13/03/2016 15:43

I think OP needs to really sit down and do some soul searching about what her children are going to want to do in a decade or so. It does not look sustainable and quite a few people here who are suggestion to take yet another loan to pay back this one. That's wrong I think. It's not a sutainable situation and it's obvious you will end up with a love hate relationship with this house at some point. And the way you have put your youth into it, I am sure your children are going to resent it all too.

dazedandconfused17 · 13/03/2016 15:43

Back briefly. On my phone.

Just want to clarify something. Friend is not facing ruin. It isn't that bad. I double checked with her today following posting this.

She is annoyed because she was having her garden landscaped and was expecting money back to pay for it. We couldn't, so she had to use savings and is now low on them and panicked in case something else happened. She's also unhappy as she says it is the second time she's loaned a lot of money and not got it back - she loaned her sister £10k and didn't get anything back due to sister's marriage breaking down.

She is cross but we had a really long talk and I was super apologetic. I said I was going to get a log book loan on the car and she told me not to be ridiculous - she didn't want me to sell my car, she was just cross at the whole situation. She has told me to just keep paying off at the rate I am as we are nearly there and she won't die without the money in two months.

She did say we were still her friends and she loved us. Just give her a better idea of what was going on next time.

OP posts:
cleaty · 13/03/2016 15:43

Nobody is suggesting OP sells house to pay back the loan. Some posters are suggesting selling as the OP clearly can not afford to run the house.

Charley50 · 13/03/2016 15:43

You've explained the situation to your friend. You could get a loan or a 0% or other credit card to pay it off, or you could offer to sell the car to pay her back ASAP. See what she says. If she really needs the money now there are ways to get it to her.
Or once she sees that you have actively found a way to pay her it all now, she might be a bit happier and wait the two months for when it will be paid off.

BikeGeek · 13/03/2016 15:41

I'm just a little bit confused about the finances. Is there a whole load more debt? Because I can't understand otherwise how someone who owns a property and two holidays lets would not have the means to pay the vet bill on a credit card or be declined an unsecured loan not be able to arrange a temporary overdraft.

lorelei9 · 13/03/2016 15:41

OP, the other thing here is that your friend might well be thinking you should have sold the car to pay the money you owe her. Refusing your kids a holiday wouldn't have made a difference but if she sees you pootling about in a car that you managed without, she's entitled to be pissed off.

I appreciate your original question was sort of that. Realistically, if you are worried that your dad's gifts are making you look better off and all you're worried about is paying the loan, I'd sell the car. How much can you get for it? Can you pay the loan and get a different car?

if your dad is pissed off, he doesn't have the right to be - he gave it to you as a gift so you actually can sell it and if that's to pay off someone to whom you promised a repayment, he should be fine with that because you are doing the honourable thing.

Slightly puzzled at suggestions by pp that your dad loan you money or buy the house off you - especially as he wanted you to sell in the first place.

one reason why I mentioned the house in my original reply - as well as saying "refuse gifts if you are worried what it looks like" - I have this vision of you really suffering to keep the house, then the children inheriting it and having an ancient pile that they can't get anything for either. I would feel wrong not pointing this out to you.

my family tree on the side that's abroad can trace back property for centuries; two siblings were living there but finally sold it as it was impossible to adapt for disability and one of them has a major one. They weren't losing money when they did keep it though. Decisions based on sentiment are rarely good ones.

noddingoff · 13/03/2016 15:40

Sorry to hear about the poor dog OP. To those talking about vet payment plans- we very, very rarely do these and then only for long term clients with an excellent payment history and very short term. Vets are there to treat animals not provide large interest free loans for six months...like any business we have staff salaries etc to pay and depend heavily on cash flow. Payment plans often start well then go to shit after a couple of payments, loads of the practice manager's time is spent chasing them and having to drag people through the small claims court is a pain in the arse and makes everyone miserable.
OP, is the land already rented out? If not, for short term cash get down to the local livestock mart, dairy equipment store and the vet (if it's mixed practice not small animal) and local corner shop and ask if you can put up an ad for grazing for rent. Possibly also ad in farming press. Dairy farmers are your best bet as dry heifers will be going out soon and many people need extra grazing. You might get lucky and find someone desperate for grazing. You can draw up an agreement and get some or all of the cash upfront and you could just let it from now till autumn when the cattle come in. Some of your farming neighbours will know the going rate for land to let. You'll have to accept a bit less if the fencing needs work to make it stockproof or if the tenant needs to repair water troughs, but you can write this into the agreement.

liptolinford · 13/03/2016 15:39

I really think you should sell the car and buy a cheaper one. If your Dad doesn't like it, ask him whether he'll loan you the money first.

DowntonDiva · 13/03/2016 15:37

How about a directors loan from your company? Assuming you have a Ltd company and enough in retained profit? A director can take a loan up to £5000 I believe so long as it's paid back before the company year end. Worth looking into, and fact checking, I'm an accountant but not a tax accountant. From memory there are no rules as to what the director does with the loan, so long as it's paid back and doesn't exceed the £5000 limit (or whatever the current rules are regarding the limit).

MassiveStrumpet · 13/03/2016 15:36

If you bankrupt yourselves to keep that house, how will you feel when your children just sell it?

Twinklestein · 13/03/2016 15:36

I may be missing something but those suggesting that the OP sell the house to pay the friend back. How will she sell it that quickly? Surely it will take longer than it will to give the 800 in 2 instalments

Clearly those who have no fucking idea how long an historic rural property in the middle of renovations will take to sell! It could easily be years.