Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My dad is making me look wealthier than I am (long)

393 replies

dazedandconfused17 · 13/03/2016 13:15

I know my diamond shoes are too tight and in the big scheme of things I'm incredibly lucky.

When I was 22 I inherited a house and some land from my grandparents. It came to me as my mother had died when I was little. It isn't Blenheim Palace or anything, but it had been in her family since 1693 and parts of it date back to the 12th century. My DF thought at the time I should sell it, as while it is gorgeous, it has always been a lot of work to maintain etc. In the end (after a couple of years of faff), DH (then DP) and I decided to move in and try and keep the place going.

We're now in our late thirties and it's still here. It's been a rough ride, but so far we have kept the place standing and our family going. It has, however, been really financially tough, especially the last couple of years, due to a bunch of unexpected expenses, specifically massive issues with the roof. Last year in a real pinch, DH borrowed £2000 from a friend to cover vets bills for our dog. At the time, he was meant to be starting a new contract (he works freelance to help support the family) and thought he'd be able to pay back in a couple of months. The job fell through at the last minute and we've not been able to repay on time. Currently I'm paying it off at a rate of £400 per month, which is very hard (we have zero spare income at all right now) but it is getting done.

The friend in question has been, quite reasonably, annoyed with us and said she was only able to spare the money for a couple of months and needs it all back. Last time I saw her she had a massive rant about how we clearly could afford to as the kids went skiing after Christmas and we have a nearly new car.

The thing is this comes from my dad. He has always said that he won't loan us money (which is fair) and he doesn't want us to rely on him as we're grown ups, but does like to sometimes give random gifts. So, for example, he and my stepmum took the kids away, along with my half brothers (who are both much younger than me - closer to my kids age) for a skiing holiday. We could never afford it. And when he wanted to get a new car last year, he gave us his old one, which was a decent three year old VW Passat (I know! I know!). But this is all coming together to make us look super rich - we live in a huge house (even if currently we can't heat it) and we have a nice car and the kids go skiing and she is getting really angry that we're drawing out the repayments.

DH is working, but only part time as a postman as he hasn't been able to get a new contact like the one that fell through. I am working, part time out of the home and part time on our business which is meant to get the place a bit more profitable and a bit less of a drain. I did try and explain that we don't have money, just a gift from my dad, and she said that if he could afford to give us a nearly new car, he could definitely afford to give us the money we need to repay her.

Is she being U? I am pretty certain that DF won't loan me the money if I ask, and if he does he'll be really unhappy about it, even though he can afford it. Is he being U? Should I ask anyway?

We have tried to get a bank loan, but after a bunch of financial hiccups last year they pretty much laughed in our face at the suggestion of an unsecured personal loan and we can't take a loan through the business and spend it on a personal debt, I don't think. Loan should be paid off start of May, but it's just getting there.

OP posts:
Floggingmolly · 13/03/2016 16:47

Nobody's jealous of op's lifestyle, neonrainbow. Don't be silly.

silvermantela · 13/03/2016 16:45

Your friend is lovely. I think you were right to be completely honest with her, although I would imagine, whatever she says she is still a bit annoyed with you. I also think that, when things are better financially you should treat her massively - next time your dad suggests treating you ask for a spa day for you and take her! (maybe not that exactly...but I think she definitely deserves more than a bottle of wine for being so understanding).

Definitely look at some of the suggestions in this thread - I think even if things do get better financially the hiring out for filming will always be a good option to have available for extra income.

I know you don't want to hear this, but I think you and DP need to sit down and decide exactly how long you give the house a chance to pay for itself, and when you are going to draw a line under it. You know you can't just keep struggling hand-to-mouth forever, particularly when you don't have to. Yes, hopefully it will start making money and everything will be lovely, but I really think you should have a timeframe (say 2-3 years) whereby if you are still struggling you have to consider what is best for you & your DC futures. I know your GP wanted to pass it on for future generations - but they probably envisioned only the positives (the history and heritage, lovely home) not the negatives (possible huge debt, feeling of guilt).

I know this is none of my business but your dad doesn't sound very nice. Yes it's his money and he can do whatever he likes with it (and of course it's lovely that he gives you anything, which he doesn't have to do), but by taking away your choice and only giving you gifts dependent on conditions he is treating you like a child who can't organise her own finances or decide what is better for you and your family. It's almost like he's punishing you for keeping the house rather than selling it like he advised you to - sort of a 'I told you so - you got yourself into this mess now get yourself out of it' attitude. I could be completely wrong of course, I know I don't know your family dynamics.

sleeponeday · 13/03/2016 16:41

If you don't do this it will sink you. Take it from someone who inherited a mill stone with similar conditions although nowhere near as old as yours and it has ruined us in every sense trying to keep up with a deathbed wish.

I'm really, really sorry to hear that. I hope things are on the up now.

noddingoff · 13/03/2016 16:41

Other ways to make money

  • get planning permission for a dwelling on a plot with "room for a pony" as hyacinth bucket would say and sell it (forget it if you live in a National Park though)
  • rent out a small plot for somebody to put polytunnels on (veg in summer, turkeys in winter, indoor early lambing ewes after Christmas)
  • if you have very secure farm buildings with decent access for machinery then rent them as workshop space for cars/motorbikes, woodturning, welding
  • or just as a secure lockup for stuff
  • or overspill storage for a tree surgeon to season firewood for sale
  • if slatted sheds then housing for beef cattle or dry dairy heifers over the winter
sleeponeday · 13/03/2016 16:40

I think, with the friend, that I would plan something nice but not extravagant as a thank you when you've paid off the final instalment. If she's getting the garden done is there a plant or a garden thing that would be around the £100 mark she might like? That would be thoughtful and appreciative, and you could buy the month after the one where you settle the debt? It's saved a lot of money in interest, after all, and it will show you are really grateful etc and didn't mean to mess her about. These things happen and it sounds like she gets that, so a gesture of thanks might be good.

In terms of the house... I do understand the sense that it's over 300 years of family history, but it's also making your life sound a panicky and stressed and impoverished one. You can't enjoy a lifestyle that your combined earnings would actually have allowed, and nor can your kids. And you're coping with this so that your children can, in their turn, feel that guilty panicked sense that you left it to them for their children and grandchildren. To be brutal, it's a house. It's bricks and mortar. And it is also a millstone. What if they'd rather live in Australia or Paraguay? What if they have a passion for teaching or if their only child is severely disabled? A house such as you describe is as sensible a hobby as a racehorse, and at least with that it's been chosen by the hobbyist. You are binding burdens for the next generation to carry, as far as I can see, just as your ancestors have for you.

I don't see you as someone in pinchy diamond shoes, I'm afraid. I see you as someone in concrete boots.

Notimefortossers · 13/03/2016 16:37

Glad you sorted things out with your friend OP and hope things improve for you soon

PurpleDaisies · 13/03/2016 16:36

I think a large part of the negative responses you've got is down to jealousy.

Where's your evidence for that?

IAmNotAMindReader · 13/03/2016 16:36

Once it is restored is there a way you could make it pay for itself by turning it into a wedding venue. If its too small for a traditional venue there is a going market for boutique style wedding venues.
Make the land pay for itself any way you can.
Approach every organisation you can for grants. This is no longer your home it has to be become a business which supports itself, it is the only way it can survive and not be a millstone to further generations.
If you don't do this it will sink you. Take it from someone who inherited a mill stone with similar conditions although nowhere near as old as yours and it has ruined us in every sense trying to keep up with a deathbed wish.

neonrainbow · 13/03/2016 16:35

I think a large part of the negative responses you've got is down to jealousy. Ultimately youre normal doing your best and i think you should be applauded for trying to keep this going and not just taking the easy route and selling it to move into a 3 bed semi. This is your families history. Id have been gutted if a house like that was in the family and someone just decided to sell without exploring all the options. Just keep swimming op.

jay55 · 13/03/2016 16:33

To what end would be the house passed on, if the area is too rural to get a decent job? Is this grand plan just tying the kids to a (potential maybe) family business and living with their parents forever?
Or are they meant to go and make their way and then give all that up to come home?

dazedandconfused17 · 13/03/2016 16:26

Italiangreyhound - not insuring the dog was an awful decision on our part. I regret it massively. But it is done. Dog sadly died and isn't being replaced.

I didn't want to ask my dad for money as he really dislikes giving money away and it is something that has caused massive tensions before. But all is resolved with friend now and so we move onwards and upwards.

OP posts:
PurpleDaisies · 13/03/2016 16:24

The dog is dead italian. Readjng the op's posts would at least be a start if you don't want to read the whole thing.

Italiangreyhound · 13/03/2016 16:23

dazedandconfused17 I have not read all the posts so feel free to ignore me!

I can't quite believe you asked in your opening post if you friend who lent you £2,000 is being unreasonable! She is not.

Why not ask you dad for a loan, the worst he can say is no.

You could sell the car.

I might be tempted to try and rent out the house and live elsewhere cheaper to save money.

I hope it works out for you.

I hope you now have your dog insured for medical bills (or did you already and if so why was it £2k - nosy question feel free to ignore!)

Wink
PlaymobilPirate · 13/03/2016 16:16

Op i agree - it sounds like it could be a decent business eventually. It sounds like you're having an awful time at the minute but that you're trying to sort it.

Could either of the cottages be a permanent rental rather than holiday lets?

Could you release any equity in the house? It sounds like you actually need a fair chunk to get you sorted.

Something that worries me though is how you'll feel long term though if neither of your kids want to keep it on?

Long term - would you have room to set up an outdoor kids play space? They seem to make money.

Chin up op, it sounds like your heart is in the right place ans that you've had a tough couple of years.

SauvignonPlonker · 13/03/2016 16:14

Glad you have sorted things out with your friend. Perhaps when you have paid back the money, you could send her a bouquet of flowers, or get vouchers, night in a hotel or something to show your appreciation.

sonjadog · 13/03/2016 16:10

Glad you sorted it out with your friend. I was going to post that you should just keep up the last couple of months repayments with her and deal with her being annoyed. Yes, it is bad that you couldn't pay it back as planned, but life doesn't always go as planned. Tbh, if she had had such a bad experience before, then she should know better than to lend out large suns of money again!

I don't think you ahould sell the house, but when the renovations are done, I think you and your husband really need to get going on finding ways to make it generate income - weddings, concerts, fairs, sales, campsite, etc.

dazedandconfused17 · 13/03/2016 16:08

Oh and to the poster who talked about getting my passion back - thank you and bless you for understanding. That really helped.

OP posts:
Icompletelyunderstand · 13/03/2016 16:06

She sounds like a lovely friend.

charleybarley · 13/03/2016 16:02

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

dazedandconfused17 · 13/03/2016 16:02

Re: ways we have tried to make money.

When I first inherited the house, both DH and I worked during the week and used it as a holiday home. That turned into a bit of an issue because there wasn't someone on hand to keep an eye on things so we didn't know when a window got broken and water got in, and we had squatters one summer which was a total pain. Plus in our area of the country there is a huge problem with young people leaving due to lack of jobs, house prices being pushed up by holiday lets etc and we felt like we were part of the problem.

So then I moved in full time and DH worked away. That worked until we had the kids. At the time, DH had the opportunity to move to contracting which would have made a bit more per year than he was earning working away and would cut back on the costs of him needing to rent a place to live during the week and he'd get to see the kids.

For nine years that worked - tough at times but with forward movement. If you'd asked me four years ago I would have said we were solid. We weren't rich - we had an old banger for a car, didn't have holidays unless dad wanted to take the kids, clothes were mostly Christmas presents or second hand - but stable.

The last two years everything went wrong. We had a total disaster with the roof which turned up some major structural issues which had has gone undetected. At the time we had to raise money by mortgaging the holiday lets to the hilt to get enough cash to get the house back into "structurally sound" so we could look at mortgaging or selling it. It wasn't the kind of 'repairs that always come up' - more 'once in generation problem facing medieval building'.

And that's been the last two years. Then last year, DH's last contract ended, right when we were in the middle of things. We made some bad calls because we thought he'd get a new one quickly and got ourselves into a hole with the renovations. We are digging ourselves out but it is tough.

Re: full time jobs - we can't both work full time, keep the house and land, and get the kids to school. I have three kids at two schools. They can't fly to and from school. I work part time, and then I do enough to keep the other businesses going. Home business + part time job earns more than I'd get in any full time job I could get around here, and there isn't much.

DH is actively seeking full time/contract work all over and will move away part time. It is just hard to get while working part time which limits his ability to go and pitch people etc. But we need the part time income.

We will get better. If he gets another contract, that gets us back on our feet and back in the game straight away. We have applied for several grants which would also let us finish the restoration of the house and mean the business stops being drowned paying for that. But right now it is tight.

OP posts:
Tram10 · 13/03/2016 16:02

Can you split some of the land and sell off a building plot ?

Icompletelyunderstand · 13/03/2016 16:00

A house and land that's been in the family for over 300 years and people are saying sell it to pay off a loan of less than two grand? Utterly bonkers. This isn't a bloody bungalow which granny bought for her retirement!

Do some people just wilfully and deliberately try to not understand? Confused It's not about the flipping loan it's about the roof and the fact that the place is obviously a millstone that makes them miserable and puts them under stress.

cleaty · 13/03/2016 15:59

BuggersMuddle - Yes I would if it would cause my friends real problems, Glad to hear it does not.

MistressDeeCee · 13/03/2016 15:57

A house and land that's been in the family for over 300 years and people are saying sell it to pay off a loan of less than two grand? Utterly bonkers. This isn't a bloody bungalow which granny bought for her retirement!

^ This

OP as well as suggestions PPs have made, is there any way you can let out a room/part of the house? I wouldn't ask my dad, in your shoes. He is already helping you out in a number of ways ie holidays for the DCs, giving you his car. He does enough. & anyway the price of all this is him having inside knowledge and commenting on your financial affairs. Your house needs to "work" for you in some way.

You aren't being realistic about your life. You and your DH are grown adults with a family of your own. One of you is going to have to work very hard at least for now, to fund your lifestyle. & the other, if possible, is going to have to work too, at least part-time. If it means somebody working harder/longer then so be it. You can't spend your life turning to other people whenever you hit financial crisis. What happens next time?

As understanding as your friend is being, if a friend had been kind enough to lend me money in a crisis Id be so grateful I wouldnt care if I had to work 12 hour shifts or get a part-time job on top of what I already do - paying her back in a short space of time would absolutely be my 1st priority, there wouldn't be an opportunity for anybody to say I was taking too long to pay the money back. She lent you the money when you needed it, not 3 months after you needed this

Although I think you should stay in the house - doesn't make sense not to, & if it needs a huge amount of work would anyone buy it in the near future anyway, and it doesnt seem you'll have the money to do it up - you sound entitled "Friend is not facing ruin. It isn't that bad" I mean, so what? Thats hardly the point and nor is it relevant. & also, you aren't going to be able to rely on enablers always being there so, either way you and/or DH need to get up and improve your financial circumstances. Plenty of people have no choice but to do exactly that

BuggersMuddle · 13/03/2016 15:57

Good you have sorted it out OP, there are have been some frankly bonkers suggestions on this thread.

Long term, it sounds like you definitely do need to find ways to generate more income, but I do wonder if posters would really sell off a 3 year old Passat (possibly pissing off father) to buy a POS car (probably cost more in the long run) for the sake of paying a friend £800 now, as opposed to in 7-8 weeks Hmm

Sounds like your friend has been lovely and was worried because of the situation with her sister. Having said that, if she's fretting over £800, she probably ought not to have lent the money in the first place (and I'm guessing you won't ask her and she won't offer in the future).

Swipe left for the next trending thread