Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My dad is making me look wealthier than I am (long)

393 replies

dazedandconfused17 · 13/03/2016 13:15

I know my diamond shoes are too tight and in the big scheme of things I'm incredibly lucky.

When I was 22 I inherited a house and some land from my grandparents. It came to me as my mother had died when I was little. It isn't Blenheim Palace or anything, but it had been in her family since 1693 and parts of it date back to the 12th century. My DF thought at the time I should sell it, as while it is gorgeous, it has always been a lot of work to maintain etc. In the end (after a couple of years of faff), DH (then DP) and I decided to move in and try and keep the place going.

We're now in our late thirties and it's still here. It's been a rough ride, but so far we have kept the place standing and our family going. It has, however, been really financially tough, especially the last couple of years, due to a bunch of unexpected expenses, specifically massive issues with the roof. Last year in a real pinch, DH borrowed £2000 from a friend to cover vets bills for our dog. At the time, he was meant to be starting a new contract (he works freelance to help support the family) and thought he'd be able to pay back in a couple of months. The job fell through at the last minute and we've not been able to repay on time. Currently I'm paying it off at a rate of £400 per month, which is very hard (we have zero spare income at all right now) but it is getting done.

The friend in question has been, quite reasonably, annoyed with us and said she was only able to spare the money for a couple of months and needs it all back. Last time I saw her she had a massive rant about how we clearly could afford to as the kids went skiing after Christmas and we have a nearly new car.

The thing is this comes from my dad. He has always said that he won't loan us money (which is fair) and he doesn't want us to rely on him as we're grown ups, but does like to sometimes give random gifts. So, for example, he and my stepmum took the kids away, along with my half brothers (who are both much younger than me - closer to my kids age) for a skiing holiday. We could never afford it. And when he wanted to get a new car last year, he gave us his old one, which was a decent three year old VW Passat (I know! I know!). But this is all coming together to make us look super rich - we live in a huge house (even if currently we can't heat it) and we have a nice car and the kids go skiing and she is getting really angry that we're drawing out the repayments.

DH is working, but only part time as a postman as he hasn't been able to get a new contact like the one that fell through. I am working, part time out of the home and part time on our business which is meant to get the place a bit more profitable and a bit less of a drain. I did try and explain that we don't have money, just a gift from my dad, and she said that if he could afford to give us a nearly new car, he could definitely afford to give us the money we need to repay her.

Is she being U? I am pretty certain that DF won't loan me the money if I ask, and if he does he'll be really unhappy about it, even though he can afford it. Is he being U? Should I ask anyway?

We have tried to get a bank loan, but after a bunch of financial hiccups last year they pretty much laughed in our face at the suggestion of an unsecured personal loan and we can't take a loan through the business and spend it on a personal debt, I don't think. Loan should be paid off start of May, but it's just getting there.

OP posts:
greenfolder · 14/03/2016 06:30

I do have sympathy. When there was that series on about country houses I alawys thought, surely you would just flog it for several million quid to a hotel chain and have a nice life? But then , how could you be the one to sell it after 350 years in the family? And go down in family history as the one to sell?
Totally see the friends PoV tho. I would think I'd hit the jackpot if someone gave me a 3 year old car, let alone all the rest. Lesson learnt I guess both ways. Hope things improve for you.

JohnThomas69 · 14/03/2016 04:28

You should have stuck to the terms of the loan. Regardless of houses, cars, holidays and how they were paid for. If it was a bank loan then fair enough, they're big and stupid enough to look after themselves. A personal loan from a generous friend us another matter altogether.
Shouldn't have accepted if there was any doubt whatsoever you could not pay it back on the agreed date.

Icompletelyunderstand · 14/03/2016 03:47

But people the only reason is gets left to one child only is because the intention is that they shouldn't ever sell it or profit the sale of it, merely live in it for nothing but pay for its upkeep and have the chance to profit from any income it makes, then pass it to their eldest child. It isn't possible to have that sort of arrangement when ownership is split equally between several children.

It's all a bit of a nonsense in this day and age frankly. Like the OP said, it's not Blenheim Palace, but if it is of considerable architectural importance and size and deserves to be preserved for future generations then let the National Trust take it over, or sell it to a hotel group or something. I find the idea of gifting something to a child that is in effect nothing more than a giant gilded cage that imprisons them and severely limits all their life choices just to kowtow to the wishes of a bunch of dead ancestors all a bit silly.

Unless the OP can get her act together and quickly come up with a plan for an effective and profitable business from the place it simply needs to go. And even if she does that I still think that leaving it to one child is unfair. But if this is not uncommon in families that are landed gentry types so I guess they grow up with an understanding and acceptance that it's just how it is.

I would be looking for a way to keep ownership of the house but as a business rather than residential property and split it as an asset between all my children. For example, owning the freehold jointly between the children and leasing it to a company that runs it as a business premises. Or setting up a business in partnership with experts in that field (maybe conference centre/hotel/retreat/residential special school/care home for the elderly) and benefitting from an income/shares from that business. That way any repairs are tax deductible too.

Italiangreyhound · 14/03/2016 01:35

dazedandconfused re "My will currently leaves it all to my oldest, but I don't know if that's the right thing to do. He might not want it. I really don't think I'm going to make any major decisions about that right now, however, until things stabilize a little bit."

IMHO please do not leave it to one child. It feels very divisive to do so. Please change your will to leave it equally to all your children. You can ask a solicitor to make whatever stipulations you wish. I know at the moment you won't have money to make changes to your will but once you have that money I would suggest you do so.

Your children will grow up to value and love each other (equally, ideally) and for you to leave this massive item to one child is utterly unfair IMHO.

My mum has just died (a month ago) and had she left such a big thing to my sister and not to me, I would be devastated. Knowing in advance that you planned to do this could be very inhibiting for your kid's relationship with each other and with you, IMHO.

The child who gets the property may not want it and may sell it, they may have the ideal to make provisions for their siblings but by that time they may be married to someone who feels differently!

Re "I guess we'd probably want to talk to our kids as they get older and work out what they would like to do. Ideally, if the house can be made self supporting and the business work, it would be all turned into some kind of trust..." That sounds much better.

Good luck.

TowerRavenSeven · 13/03/2016 22:53

Op I read the entire thread and I do feel for you. I can also see friend's viewpoint but glad you patched things up. I hope things work out for you. I don't think you sound entitled at all, this was all thrust upon you. I hope it all works out how you want it, I think you sound hard working. Good luck to you.

bakeoffcake · 13/03/2016 22:44

I too think you should leave it to all your DC.
You and your dh are struggling to keep things going, why would you put that stress onto one child?Confused
I know a lot of farming families and whilst it used to be he done thing to leave everything to the eldest son, it's much more common now to leave the farm equally to all DC, thank goodness!

NNalreadyinuse · 13/03/2016 22:39

Yes, I do think it is unfair to leave it to one child only. You should ensure that your children are given equal assets.

Twinklestein · 13/03/2016 22:35

Personally I think if you cannot envisage leaving your kids enough capital to run the place then you should sell it. It's deeply unfair on them. Only one of them can inherit it as it stands, doing that is going to create a whole other set of injustices

There's nothing more lovely than growing up in a big old place, with leaking ceilings or without. I don't think it's the OP's responsibility to build capital for the kids to run it at all.

Personally I would do what the French do which is leave it to all the children equally. They can jointly decide what they want to do with it.

expatinscotland · 13/03/2016 22:21

'Boutique camping seems to be a bit of a money spinner. Can't cost that much to get in a few compost loos and a couple of showers?

Can start off with BYO tent but people lay stupid amounts to stay in a yurt/bell tent/gypsy van.'

They don't, really. If you charge more than a commercial campsite it's going to be very stiff competition.

Since you say you're in a place where it's hard for locals to afford housing I think wally has a good suggestion.

A place round here has done that with their old, extensive servants' and staff housing. Borrowed money to seriously work on them, they needed it, and now full of long-term tenants. A lot of people wanted to retire there but couldn't afford it and they take housing benefit from OAP tenants. They have one row of housing for seasonal workers.

They also rent space in the grounds for people to garden. Not all councils have allotments, and rural ones often don't, as well as cottage housing with only yards.

They also rent some of the land to football clubs and bowling clubs.

SuperFlyHigh · 13/03/2016 22:17

Everyone I know with big houses either has the money to live in them, or if they don't work or work part time they hold courses etc.

Some friends of my parents were artists/art teachers living in converted barn in countryside, they did B&Bs for a few years then teaching holidays for German teachers etc, which went down well for a few years. Eventually they sold and now do lithograph and art holidays in their house in foothills of Pyrenees. People don't appreciate how hard it is to do B&Bs or holidays, when their son was diagnosed with Aspbergers it made life even harder for them as the mother in particular was strung out with cleaning/cooking with little or no extra help and then they took the tourists on day trips to various places.

tupperwareAARGGH · 13/03/2016 22:15

Jeez you are getting a hard time. My boiler just broke and I didn't have money to pay for a new one so had to borrow off my mum and put some on a credit card not a single person told me to sell my car or sell my house!!

If anything else goes wrong with the house I would be in a bit of trouble and again would have to sue credit cards and again I'd doubt that anyone would be telling me to sell my house or car.....daft comments. Most people I know would struggle with a large bill and most people I know have bugger all savings.

Sometimes shite things happen in amongst the good. You'll get back on track I'm sure and what you are trying to achieve sounds lovely by the way. The holiday cottages on 70 acres sounds divine too.

I'm glad your friend has said no to you getting the 'log book loan' what ever that is. I would be pleased that someone was paying me back money and £400 a month is a decent amount too.

Sorry to hear that your dog died Sad

wallywobbles · 13/03/2016 22:12

Frankly holiday cottages make almost no profit. If you factor in the time cleaning preparing meeting and greeting. Replacing stuff. Furnishing to high level. Sheets and towels from ikea for our 2x2 bed cottages came to 1000€ for starters. Long term rentals are much better earners, with almost no out lays. Most holiday rentals get around 12 to 20 weeks a year max. The exception to the rule is large beach houses.

Your land should be making you some cash. At the very least as grazing for sheep.

I think you probably need to find someone more business orientated to take a look at the place. Without wishing to offend your ideas are really just fiddling while Rome burns.

Long term could it be a conference centre or the like? How many bedrooms is it?

Try and get on location scout books for filming.

Personally I think if you cannot envisage leaving your kids enough capital to run the place then you should sell it. It's deeply unfair on them. Only one of them can inherit it as it stands, doing that is going to create a whole other set of injustices.

We have cousins with piles on both sides. They won't be being inherited they'll be sold. This isn't the world your grandparents new. It's an unfriendly place for the landed poor. And you are that.

Floggingmolly · 13/03/2016 21:58

I prefer pig minded Grin

TrollTheRespawnJeremy · 13/03/2016 21:55

English isn't my first Flogging! DP tells me it is Pigheaded. (I don't see the difference?!)

Many people live in houses where they are getting by ok until they have a bad patch. If they lived in a 2 bed Ex-Council house somewhere nobody would be telling them to sell, just to economise.

Clearly if OP's plans do not work out and also her DP's work issues then they could be in a big problem. But I wouldn't bail out just when the going gets hard. No point in walking away at the first obstacle.

Floggingmolly · 13/03/2016 21:43

Pig minded Grin. I agree that two grand is a ridiculously small amount of cash (relatively speaking), but the whole point is that op doesn't either have it or have a way to raise it; signifying that she simply can't afford her current way of life.
Things are pared to the bone, with no cushion whatsoever for the next bill that comes in.

EmbroideryQueen · 13/03/2016 21:42

I don't think your situation sounds especially dire OP. Just seems like a bit of a rough patch. I can see why your friend is cross, but I'd just explain the situation to get and I'm sure she will understand.

Longer term, i DONT think you should necessarily sell the house as it sounds like you have some good ideas for generating income from it.

I think if you ride out the next few years, get your various income generating plans fully up and running then STILL can't make a decent amount then consider selling off part of the estate eg. some land / cheaper cottage / other building which may get planning permission. Then only if you still don't have enough consider maybe splitting the main house and selling half or the whole thing.... I think there's lots of steps you can take before having to sell the entire property.

TrollTheRespawnJeremy · 13/03/2016 21:37

There's so many pig minded people on here. If OP hadn't mentioned what kind of house she lived in there's no way that people would have suggested selling up over £2k worth of debt!!

Fwiw, OP I'm glad your friend is on board, anyone who would want you to sell your assets for the sake of £800 isn't a friend.

I understand your sentimentality towards the building- if you grew up running around there, you naturally picture your kids having the same great experiences and want the same for them and theirs. It's a tough call and a challenging time for Country homes.

BeaufortBelle · 13/03/2016 21:03

I luffed my flat. I don't think there were many light bulb types 30 odd years ago!

whois · 13/03/2016 20:58

Boutique camping seems to be a bit of a money spinner. Can't cost that much to get in a few compost loos and a couple of showers?

Can start off with BYO tent but people lay stupid amounts to stay in a yurt/bell tent/gypsy van.

lorelei9 · 13/03/2016 20:56

Beaufort "Oh when all I needed were 60w standard bulbs for a two bed flat with a centre light and shade in each room and the odd table lamp."

I live in a tiny flat and whoever set this place set it up so there are different light fittings everywhere. And crappy spot lights. And crappy bathroom lights.

suffice to say your light bulb cupboard wouldn't scare me and I don't even have lots of space to cheer me up!

BeaufortBelle · 13/03/2016 20:33

DH does the bulbs on the first weekend of the month. He would be so irritated if they weren't organised and there.

charleybarley · 13/03/2016 20:27

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

frami · 13/03/2016 20:22

There are some ways you can makesome moeny from your house. Old historic houses are in demand from Tv/film companies for use in period shows etc this could be a way of generating some income from your house. Also contact some of the magazines such as Period Homes they might be interested in using your house in one of their publications for which they will pay you. Depending on the area you may be able to make some money offering B&B or advertising on Airbnb.

BeaufortBelle · 13/03/2016 20:21

I am very much looking forward to the Mnet Festival though. Can us southerners hire a double decker bus!

BeaufortBelle · 13/03/2016 20:20

Ha, in the cupboard next to the keys I have the light bulbs arranged over three shelves annotated with post its. Skinny bayonet candles for wall lights, fat bayonet candles for hall chandeliers, halogen golf balls for sitting room, etc, etc. Oh when all I needed were 60w standard bulbs for a two bed flat with a centre light and shade in each room and the odd table lamp.