Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My dad is making me look wealthier than I am (long)

393 replies

dazedandconfused17 · 13/03/2016 13:15

I know my diamond shoes are too tight and in the big scheme of things I'm incredibly lucky.

When I was 22 I inherited a house and some land from my grandparents. It came to me as my mother had died when I was little. It isn't Blenheim Palace or anything, but it had been in her family since 1693 and parts of it date back to the 12th century. My DF thought at the time I should sell it, as while it is gorgeous, it has always been a lot of work to maintain etc. In the end (after a couple of years of faff), DH (then DP) and I decided to move in and try and keep the place going.

We're now in our late thirties and it's still here. It's been a rough ride, but so far we have kept the place standing and our family going. It has, however, been really financially tough, especially the last couple of years, due to a bunch of unexpected expenses, specifically massive issues with the roof. Last year in a real pinch, DH borrowed £2000 from a friend to cover vets bills for our dog. At the time, he was meant to be starting a new contract (he works freelance to help support the family) and thought he'd be able to pay back in a couple of months. The job fell through at the last minute and we've not been able to repay on time. Currently I'm paying it off at a rate of £400 per month, which is very hard (we have zero spare income at all right now) but it is getting done.

The friend in question has been, quite reasonably, annoyed with us and said she was only able to spare the money for a couple of months and needs it all back. Last time I saw her she had a massive rant about how we clearly could afford to as the kids went skiing after Christmas and we have a nearly new car.

The thing is this comes from my dad. He has always said that he won't loan us money (which is fair) and he doesn't want us to rely on him as we're grown ups, but does like to sometimes give random gifts. So, for example, he and my stepmum took the kids away, along with my half brothers (who are both much younger than me - closer to my kids age) for a skiing holiday. We could never afford it. And when he wanted to get a new car last year, he gave us his old one, which was a decent three year old VW Passat (I know! I know!). But this is all coming together to make us look super rich - we live in a huge house (even if currently we can't heat it) and we have a nice car and the kids go skiing and she is getting really angry that we're drawing out the repayments.

DH is working, but only part time as a postman as he hasn't been able to get a new contact like the one that fell through. I am working, part time out of the home and part time on our business which is meant to get the place a bit more profitable and a bit less of a drain. I did try and explain that we don't have money, just a gift from my dad, and she said that if he could afford to give us a nearly new car, he could definitely afford to give us the money we need to repay her.

Is she being U? I am pretty certain that DF won't loan me the money if I ask, and if he does he'll be really unhappy about it, even though he can afford it. Is he being U? Should I ask anyway?

We have tried to get a bank loan, but after a bunch of financial hiccups last year they pretty much laughed in our face at the suggestion of an unsecured personal loan and we can't take a loan through the business and spend it on a personal debt, I don't think. Loan should be paid off start of May, but it's just getting there.

OP posts:
HPsauciness · 14/03/2016 20:35

Your dad sounds quite rigid in what he expects- on the other hand, I can see he wouldn't want you to sell the car he just bought you, given as a car and not to be realized for cash. Your instincts were right there, he doesn't want to give you money and that's that.

The rest sounds positive, good luck with it all!

BudsBeginingSpringinSight · 14/03/2016 20:34

wow agree with mavis - very harsh of your df, surely he would be proud of you to do anything to keep this house going? has he ever suggested you sell it now? maybe he still thinks you should and this is why he wont help?

LeaLeander · 14/03/2016 20:32

I'd be inclined to tell him to keep his next round of "gifts" since they apparently are "given" more for his gratification than for yours.

Hope it works out with the house. I'd fight to keep it in my hands, as well.

OohMavis · 14/03/2016 20:24

Then I got the third degree on every present he's given me or the kids in the last three years. I have apologized profusely for even thinking about it

Sad
OohMavis · 14/03/2016 20:22

The grant sounds positive Smile

Your dad is being a bit unreasonable imo. He doesn't want to help financially by loaning you £800, but if you downgrade the car he gave you to help yourself he'll essentially shun you for life... Has he always been emotionally manipulative?

dazedandconfused17 · 14/03/2016 20:14

Well, good news and bad news today.

Good news is that one of the grants we applied for came in, which is a massive step forward in getting the house stabilized and in good shape. DH also has a meeting in London on Wednesday which he has managed to get the time off for which could lead to a two year contract which would also help massively.

Bad news in that I had a chat with my father which went pretty badly. I mentioned the log book loan idea which he took really badly. He is currently furious with me and explained at length that he doesn't give me presents so I can sell them and 'exploit our relationship for financial gain'. And if I do 'abuse his generosity' like this he'll won't be able to help at all in future as he won't be able to trust me. Then I got the third degree on every present he's given me or the kids in the last three years. I have apologized profusely for even thinking about it - I get that a lot of posters probably think I should burn that relationship to pay off the debt, but that's difficult. He's my DF. It is hard to deliberately choose to alienate him.

I do appreciate all the comments, even the ones which are a bit harsh. I do read them, and I get that they are all sincerely meant. There's been some really helpful advice in here too. TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams - thank you for the advice in particular. It was really solid practical advice. The field DH is in is still very much contract based - getting a permanent job would involve moving back into the related field he came from (which would be quite difficult as he's been out of that for ten years now) or making another career change, but we're looking at that.

All the money making schemes are great! I am making notes on every one.

OP posts:
5tardusty · 14/03/2016 19:06

As heartbreaking as i agree it must be, i highly doubt your GPs would want to see you struggle like this. Maybe a stupid question, but can you not mortgage the house and release some equity to get some of the a critical work done?

harshbuttrue1980 · 14/03/2016 18:48

Always, the problem is that her rough patch is having a negative impact on other people. She is months late paying back a loan to a friend who is much less wealthy than she is. That is unfair and very selfish. i don't think she should sell the house to pay an £800 debt, but she could sell the car and get a cheaper one and give her friend back the money that is due.

Alwayscheerful · 14/03/2016 18:19

Harsh - OP has may have just hit a rough patch. It can sometimes be more cost effective to be self employed and work from home. I know several people who run holiday letting type businesses and earn enough to live on. we are not talking huge amounts but 35 - 50 K gross, with no mortgage and a generous Father some people would manage just fine. Throw an expensive roof repair in to the mix and we could all run in to temporary problems.

Beaufort Belle- made some kind and measured suggestions, yes get the experts on board, get some valuations and pick out the best money making ideas.

If you love your home you will find a way to make it work.

harshbuttrue1980 · 14/03/2016 17:51

You don't sound like much of a friend. Being months late paying back a loan isn't acceptable. You seem to have the attitude that its OK for you and DH to play around doing pieces of work here and there, and that's all fine because you can just scrounge off friends and your Dad.

Sell the car and get a cheaper one. Use the money to pay back your friend. Then get a full-time job and stop playing around pretending to work, relying on other people to pay for holidays, cars and vet bills.

JizzyStradlin · 14/03/2016 17:17

Exactly purple. We must have had at least half a dozen posts now from people decrying others telling OP to sell the house and/or land purely because of an £800 debt. But that's not why people are saying she could consider cashing in on some of her substantial assets!

sallialli · 14/03/2016 15:43

I think it is lovely that your dad wants to take the children on holiday. They are making memories with him that they will cherish in the future. And he can obvs see that you needed a car and so gave you his when he upgraded. What is wrong with that?!

You've got a good friend there though so hang onto her.
Also, I know what it's like having a freelance husband. Most of my friends don't understand why anyone who want to work that way but when it works it really works. Hang on in there, things will turn around - just follow your vision and it will come together. We often have to sink to the lows to appreciate the highs when they come along - especially when we have worked so hard for them.
I don't understand why people are getting fixated on your children not wanting the property. Surely that is their decision as and when the time comes. If you follow your vision it could be a great income for them, even if they want to get someone else to live there and manage it. We can't all sell our homes in case our kids don't want them in the future! However, I do agree that you should consider leaving it equally to them all rather than just one. It is likely to cause resentment. Good luck!

MackerelOfFact · 14/03/2016 14:56

OP I don't really have any practical advice, but it just seems as if you need to stop being (or feeling) to obligated to everyone - to your grandparents, to the house, to your dad, to your dog, to your friend.

This is YOUR turn to have the house and YOUR turn to be alive - you don't somehow 'lose' by living by your own rules and not doing what someone else (dead or alive) apparently wants you to do.

Obviously the debt to your friend needs to be settled ASAP but currently you're using the excuse that other people don't want you to do X, Y or Z, so you can't possibly.

But you can. You absolutely can. I know what it feels like to be so bound by obligation that you are practically paralysed, but it's not healthy or beneficial at all.

makingmiracles · 14/03/2016 13:43

Can't believe people are suggesting op sell the car, what help will that be?! I'm guessing op needs a car to get around if she's rural and it would be madness to sell it for something cheaper which will probably keep breaking down/needing repairs, much better to stick with 3yr old car that's reliable.

Would second others suggestions of trying to make some cash from the land- temp measures such as renting out some fields for horses/livestock could be a good move and requires zero effort on your part, also hiring out the land for weddings/events.

It sounds like the house will be affordable once the ventures such as the renovations are done, along with the bees and small business, it's just getting over the rough patch and getting the work completed etc

Personally I think I'd look into a logbook loan against the car to repay your friend in the meantime as its only two more payments and think about getting pet insurance if there are any other pets you're responsible for.

Good luck op, once the rough patch is over sounds like you'll have a great venture.

PurpleDaisies · 14/03/2016 11:16

piece the op's lifestyle is unsustainable-not this single debt. People aren't stupid enough to advise her to sell the house over £800z

PiecesOfCake · 14/03/2016 11:15

Going against the grain I think, but...

ONLY TWO PAYMENTS TO GO! C'mon, YOU CAN DO IT! Hang on in there.

DO NOT sell the house. Friends come and go, years of history you would be regretting it forever, and ever.

Chalk the debt up to a bad experience. If you are able to salvage the friendship do, otherwise remember if the bank's not lending you the money there's a reason they've decided that. Don't borrow or lend money from friends again!

I am in a similar situation with Grandad paying school fees. We look quite loaded but our income is minimal. Why would you turn gifts down because of an entirely separate situation? It would just make you poorer all round and probably upset your Dad.

dandydesmond · 14/03/2016 11:12

Im sorry but I think your loyalty to the trust (though admirable) is unsustainable. You clearly need to move house.

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 14/03/2016 11:05

You don't say what sort of work your husband does but it sounds as though the most lucrative stuff comes from the London area.

I've watched a lot of contractors go permanent in the last 2 yrs. Odd as they rode out the recession but the market has changed quite a lot I think. Day rates are much more aggressively negotiated now especially by the banks. They [apart from RBS] are mostly in profit but there is very tight cost control especially around headcount and resource generally.

The last two years have been tough and work hard to come by. IMO your husband needs to consider looking for and accepting a permanent job elsewhere asap as a tactical step. The long term impact on his CV and skills is too great. It's not just the direct skills to do his job but also the working environment? Regulations change, laws are passed, it's easy to become out of touch very quickly and contractors are expected to be top of their game. Of course it's slightly different if his expertise is more niche like bat conservation or paintings restorations where time passing is less critical.

I'm sorry to hear you are both having such a tough time. I think that the advice from Beaufort Belle is very good.

I'd also consider selling one of the holiday let cottages on a leasehold basis? Then you get a hopefully hefty capital chunk of change, a possible side income as a managing agent/cleaner for sublets, and the possibility of the cottage returning to the "estate" for a later generation. Either that or look at long term letting for a reduced but more stable income.

morningtoncrescent62 · 14/03/2016 10:25

I haven't read the entire thread, but I gather from the first and final few pages that you've had advice on how to make your finances work.

Basically, it seems you currently have a lifestyle you can't afford, so it's time to make some tough decisions. Either change your lifestyle (which painful as it would be might mean selling the house and land) or get more money coming in somehow. Go through your finances carefully and thoroughly, and if you can't see a way to make ends meet in the long term without needing to borrow off friends, something needs to give. Your situation is the same as anyone living beyond their means whatever the reason, and you need to stop doing it - it's unsustainable and stressful.

Re the loan from a friend. You need a quick fix for this - I would be furious if it was me having lent you the cash and seeing you driving around in a fancy car. Selling the car and replacing it with a cheaper one so that you can repay the friend and have a bit of a cushion to tide you over the next few months seems like an obvious thing to me. Apologies if you've explained up-thread somewhere why this isn't possible - but on what I've read, I can't see why you haven't done it.

Bumblesquat · 14/03/2016 10:21

Firstly OP, I wanted to say how sorry I am about the loss of your dog. It is devastating to lose a pet Flowers.
Secondly living in a big old house is a labour of love, and nine times out of ten, people who aren't in your shoes just wont get it. The costs appear out of nowhere and blindside you.
It sounds like you've had a run of spectacularly bad luck with your earnings and with the restoration projects - I think your repayment plan and heartfelt apology to your friend is the best course. Someone up thread suggested buying her a plant for her new garden when the repayment is done, I think that is an excellent idea.
I suspect there is vast backstory with your dad, so this advice might not be appropriate, but I would sit down with him and explain how hard you are fighting to keep your heads above the water. Even his understanding, if not his assistance may help you feel less frazzled.
Perhaps most importantly, it is worth considering what your mum would have wanted for you: if the business is not going to turn enough money longterm to pay back your investments, would she want you to go down with the proverbial ship, or tie her grandchildren to the same fate? It is so hard to be clinical about such emotive stuff, but when you find a calm moment, try and think it through: a decision to sell some or all of the estate once the house is closer to finished doesn't have to constitute failure, I think all most mums hope for is that their children be happy and secure. The rest is a bonus if it can be pulled off.
Again Flowers for your losses.

Persistentdonor · 14/03/2016 10:16

I have read the entire OP and thread.
I feel some unkindness coming throught the replies, but a lot of good, (if not always workable,) suggestions too.
For what it is worth:

  1. I would explain to father as you have explained to us... if he will help out, pay back "friend" immediately. (I hate lending my sons money, but would rather do so than have them paying interest to banks.)
  2. Pay back father at £400 installments as now paying "friend".
  3. Either insure pets against future treatments, or the pets have to go. Sorry.
  4. Review situation with "friend".... Seems to me she is a very jealous sort? imo she isn't really helping anything much and perhaps she should go too!!
  5. Sit down with husband and write out your budget carefully, you may then see areas where you can make strategic changes.
Good luck and best wishes.
Alidoll · 14/03/2016 10:02

If there is land, could some of that not be leased out e.g for a horse or something. Wouldn't generate a large amount but would take some of the pressure off perhaps? Sure you could charge a couple of hundred for a field if there was a tap (for water) and access from the road so owner could attend to horse.

As there's only £800 left I'd be tempted to get a credit card and pay that way then pay that off in fixed instalments.

Selling house to fund a £800 loan is stupid as legal fees alone would be more than that!

foolssilver · 14/03/2016 09:56

I also don't think you should sell because of one rough patch but perhaps you need to build in review periods of for example two years. That way you can look at how business plans have gone and review finances.

Do you have actual written down business plans? If not that is a practical thing you can start on to take control. You can good templates online.

I do feel for you, it's hard with the emotions that are tied up in the property. Dps parents live in a part medieval building similar to what you describe and I have no intention of moving into when he inherits it (he knows this) but I also know it will be hard for him to let go when the time comes. It has been in the family a long time but times change and someone else will get to start a history in it.

I think you will be fine and seem sensible. In terms of your dad I think he does sound generous especially with your dc. Does he feel resentment that he never got a chance to live in the house? Is that doesn't want to help?

RhodaBull · 14/03/2016 09:12

I don't understand why people are saying the dad should help OP with the house. It was not in his family, but from the mother's side, and now he has another family as the OP says she has young half-brothers. He obviously is generous in terms of holidays/car etc but I doubt whether his financial situation is good enough to pay for a country house renovation.

This reminds me of that Country House Rescue programme and one particular man who had a disintegrating country pile but whatever was suggested he sort of half smiled and said it wasn't possible. He just wanted to live as if it were 1910. I think OP has to think what is possible. There are some good suggestions on this thread. Waiting for a Lottery win ain't one of them.

lookingforafriend · 14/03/2016 09:01

I can totally understand why your friend is annoyed about not receiving the loan back as promised.....he or she obviously trusted you.....

I also feel that you should maybe cut your losses, sell the house and at least be able to have a life hopefully without as many financial hardships and worries.....seriously think about it before it's too late...

No one knows what is around the corner, what will happen one day to the next, God forbid neither of you will have to overcome ill health....

Take care and good luck