Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

doctor strike

158 replies

JudyWilliams · 09/03/2016 15:17

Bit of a rant. Has anyone else been moved three times because of the doctors
Strike? I'm booked in for ELCS originally today, then tomorrow, then Friday. Now Monday!

Slowly loosing hope! That and I'm now sofa/bed bound due to hip/back complications. I'm just wondering if anyone is in a similar situation.

OP posts:
MissTriggs · 11/03/2016 19:38

my dad is now in hospital...

I don't know what I think any more, there are so many people arguing

I wish both sides would stop the advocacy (which is insulting to the public and I mean both sides here) and sit down and plan for the future together.

thecitydoc · 11/03/2016 10:00

peppatax But this strike is not about unsafe working hours is it? Yes it is - Jeremy C has shifted the goal posts since the last strike with imposition but the junior Drs beef is still about unsafe hours, Hunt has just thrown petrol onto the fire. My son is a junior Dr - twice this week on his 8am- 8pm shift he has had his first break at 7pm - which meant he went 11 hours without a drink, food or the toilet. If he had been a patient he would have been put on a drip and given a catheter. Last week, not for the first time, when on 9pm - 9.30am night shift he has phoned me to come and get him as he did not feel safe to drive, but was expected to amke decisions about patient welfare. The new contract puts our lives at risk and must be opposed by all of us

CantChoose · 11/03/2016 09:52

I should add that from my point of view, it is about pay in the sense that the offer is insulting because it assumes we couldn't work out the effect of a rise in basic pay negated by a far larger cut in OOH supplement and also as it devalues our profession and the hard work most of us put in on a daily basis...

CantChoose · 11/03/2016 09:49

Thanks for the support :)
With regards the comments about pay, I'd obviously love a pay rise - who wouldn't! But the issue is that it will result in an overall cut. For my speciality up to a 30% cut.
It's important to note as well that the junior doctors working at the moment will have our pay protected - so we really aren't striking for pay. I can only assume the govt expected an 'I'm alright, Jack' attitude from us but they were mistaken.

AyeAmarok · 11/03/2016 09:44

I think the only way this will be resolved is of the Government back down and the junior doctors end up with better pay and conditions than they had before.

It's become so toxic. That's the only way I see it ending.

Itscurtainsforyou · 11/03/2016 09:27

My baby has had his operation cancelled this week because of the strikes.
We've been in hospital for the last 6+ months and I've seen how hard the doctors work and the situations they have to deal with.

I completely support the strike.

glueandstick · 11/03/2016 09:12

The 10 or so junior doctors I saw who saved both mine and my child's life this week were most definitely at work. They couldn't leave their posts. If it was necessary, they were there.

Each of them were knackered and over worked but kind, professional and didn't rush. They need support rather than being put down further. The government has done a good enough job of that.

Aside from the hours issue, it is disgusting that in that room my husband was the highest paid person with the lowest working hours and stress levels. He may be in a skilled job but never does he have to make life or death calls in the middle of the night. It is so wrong. We need their skills and they should be rewarded for it.

I just hope that these people continue to have the support of the public and it is sorted before it is too late.

ginpig · 11/03/2016 08:56

peppatax you're wrong in your assumption that the strikes are jsut about pay. Yes, that is one issue in a myirad of problems this contract throws up. You are also incorrect when you state that the BMA have refused to negotitate on pay. they actually went to the government with a cost-neutral proposal which both sides believed was feasible and Jeremy Hunt himself vetoed it. It has been the governments steadfast refusal to negotiate (they only offered to open negotiation on 1 out of 23 clauses) that kick started this whole sorry strike action.

The junior doctors are trying to tell everyone that they are already at breaking point. There has been mission creep for a long time, with no change in remuneration or working conditions. They simply cannot fulfill the proposed rotas with the current number of available doctors and still provide a qualirt service. This new contract seems them working more strenuous patterns with fewew safeguards. It is desperately unsafe and I, for one, would be very nervous about receiving emergency care or even elcetive care from people working in these conditions. Tired people make mistakes, I know I do- except if that were to happen in my job noone dies.

FeralBeryl · 11/03/2016 08:30

Laurie, a lot of our junior doctors chose to volunteer with health promotion at our local lung cancer centre for No Smoking Day rather than picket. They were still out helping as usual.

CantChoose · 11/03/2016 08:16

Ps, good luck for Monday, and congratulations in advance!

CantChoose · 11/03/2016 08:15

judywilliams I'm really sorry that your surgery has been moved several times, it must be horribly frustrating.
Having worked as a jnr doctor in obstetrics, I've seen ELCS cancelled repeatedly all the time - regardless of any strike action etc.
This is because the nhs is underfunded for the service it aims to provide.
The rotas and timings are run so tightly that with even he slightest disruption - be that a more complicated procedure than expected, or a single staff member is unwell - the system falls apart.
We already have multiple rota gaps in o&g at my hospital meaning elective procedures are cancelled with alarming regularity when we aren't able to fill the gap.
Unfortunately the nhs I see every day is one at breaking point and the new contract will do nothing but make this worse.

peppatax · 11/03/2016 07:57

But this strike is not about unsafe working hours is it? It's about the refusal to accept a change to the proposal on an element of pay. Government offers a smaller increase to basic pay rise and larger increase to 'antisocial' hours but BMA said 'no thanks'. The flat out refusal to negotiate is always going to damage public support. If I was offered a contract I'd always negotiate but the doctors are saying 'our way or no way'. Similarly for teachers, the job has changed in the same way for doctors in that the environment has changed and adaptation of therefore needed as the model can't stay the same. Higher patient numbers, 24/7 services elsewhere and more complex problems. Public servants seem to think that they can forever stay in a model of 'how things used to be'.

Ickythumpsmum · 11/03/2016 04:14

Laurie it seems like you are saying something bad happened in your career so now you want it to happen to everyone else. Or at least you don't mind if it happens to everyone else.

I am so sad that the junior doctors will on their most part leave the UK. People will have to go private I guess for their medical care, and I guess that this is what the government wants. The NHS was a wonderful thing.

dratsea · 11/03/2016 04:12

Can Jeremy add?

CatchingBabies · 11/03/2016 03:10

Have any of you seen the rotas that have been published? 60+ hours in a week, it's shocking. I fully support the strikes and while I don't like the fact it's impacting on patients there really is no other choice, the new contract is quite simply unsafe!

ginpig · 10/03/2016 22:58

If you look at the consequences of the contract imposition, it is massively sexist. For people like runningwithacheesegrater where both partners are junior doctors working in acute specialties it will be extremely difficult to arrange childcare to cover one of the example rotas published by NHS England.

That, combined with a massive reduction in income will mean that, almost certainly, have to give up work- and we all know that will most likely be the female partner. Plus putting the brakes on pay increment for people not working full time (ie people in research or on maternity leave) just makes this particularly bad news for women.

running I've said it to you before and I'll say it again- come to Wales!

dumbbelle · 10/03/2016 22:48

If you think it's been bad when they're on strike, just wait until August when it becomes clear exactly how many will not be taking up posts then, because they've gone abroad.

We are hemorrhaging UK trained doctors. That's fine, if a doctor is a doctor, and you think people who trained for a different population, in a different system, with English as a second language are just as good. (I'm not saying there aren't excellent doctors from overseas, but I've also heard many people moaning about doctors who struggle with regional accents, or have accents themselves, etc.) Communication is key in medicine, and difficult in a second culture and language. It feels a shame to make native doctors go elsewhere, when they've cost so much to train.

Hospitals appear to run smoothly on strike days in the same way they do on Christmas day- reduce the work right down, cancel electives and clinics etc. The consultants support the strike, and are covering for their juniors. This does not in any way mean the hospital is overstaffed normally, and that comment shows a real ignorance of the way hospitals work.

To the poster who suggested medicine is like the army- no, it's not. They took the housing, and sold it off. Medicine was sold to a generation of very bright 18 year olds as being a certain (not easy, but not army) way of life. Now the government is making that life much much harder, and has sold the NHS off, to boot.

The NHS is gone, people. And if you wait until August, so will the doctors.

CountessOfStrathearn · 10/03/2016 22:43

Interestingly the polls show that it isn't having an impact on support.

www.ipsos-mori.com/researchpublications/researcharchive/3705/Continued-support-for-the-junior-doctors-ahead-of-third-round-of-strikes.aspx

What will certainly affect your care in the future is being operated on by tired doctors in unsafe rotas with few support staff to allow them to provide a proper service.

"especially when only 7-8 doctors were actually outside the hospital during the strike at a big city hospital."

Picket rules state that there should only be 6 official people at a picket line to prevent people feeling intimidated on crossing it. The junior doctors who weren't there were possibly giving blood, teaching CPR to the public in the street, talking to school pupils about careers in medicine (in a non-political way), all things that local juniors have been up to on strike days.

LaurieMarlow · 10/03/2016 22:42

Ginpig, in theory I could have, but at the time it happened there were virtually no jobs on offer in my industry. The vast, vast majority of us put up and shut up - because we had no choice.

I too work in a very unfamily friendly industry, think overseas projects for weeks at a time and at a moments notice. While I think junior doctors have every right to be outraged and fight on behalf of themselves, I think they have to realise that plenty of others, who are also highly qualified and work long hours are also struggling, so simply don't have the reserves or inclination to be very vocal on their behalf.

Runningwithacheesegrater · 10/03/2016 22:37

I best hand my kids over for someone else to raise then, what with both their parents being junior doctors. Or one of us leave medicine, which is what many in our situation will be forced into doing. Or we could just leave England altogether - my current favoured option.

Sammysquiz · 10/03/2016 22:34

Have to say my local hospital runs more efficiently when everyone's on strike

That's because all the elective surgery has been cancelled and consequently there's far less patients than usual.

lu9months · 10/03/2016 22:29

true caughtup , and many of us have made sacrifices, and struggled to get any kind of balance. but if the new contract comes in, its totally unworkable for these young doctors. its not a lack of dedication or commitment. I'm constantly impressed by the teams i work with.

ginpig · 10/03/2016 22:28

Hospitals will appear to run more efficiently as pretty much all elective/ routine appointments are cancelled, so the workload is greatly reduced.

And Laurie yes you may have had a change to conditions and pay, but the difference being that if you really don't like it, you can go to another private company in your sector. The NHS is a monopoly employer, this means that junior doctors can only be employed by 'NHS employers'. There is no other option for them in the UK.

However, they will be able to work abroad. Applications to do so has increased 1000% since the announcement of contract imposition. I think we should all be gravely concerned about a mass exodus of junior doctors- the impacts felt will be far greater than those where junior doctors provide emergency only cover.

CaughtUpNearTimbuktu · 10/03/2016 22:26

But medicine, like joining the army, is known for not exactly being compatible with having a family life.

lu9months · 10/03/2016 22:24

as a consultant i completely support the juniors. they are hard working, and dedicated ; they already work long hours, nights and weekends. this new contract is unworkable for them, because the hours are not compatible with any kind of family life. so many are disheartened and seriously considering leaving medicine or moving abroad - and these are often people in their 30s who have trained for years and years and sat numerous exams to get where they are. hunt refuses to back down because it would mean career suicide for him, so there is a stalemate. the only answer is to replace hunt, but I'm sure that won't happen.
ps many aren't outside hospitals on the picket line because they are picketing at westminster, or doing other activities e.g. providing free paediatric life support classes to families

Swipe left for the next trending thread