Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

doctor strike

158 replies

JudyWilliams · 09/03/2016 15:17

Bit of a rant. Has anyone else been moved three times because of the doctors
Strike? I'm booked in for ELCS originally today, then tomorrow, then Friday. Now Monday!

Slowly loosing hope! That and I'm now sofa/bed bound due to hip/back complications. I'm just wondering if anyone is in a similar situation.

OP posts:
80schild · 13/03/2016 21:06

I always thought doctors were paid okay, and that in my mother's words they should just "get on with it" until I saw what doctors in other countries were paid. Most countries pay between £20-30k more which I think is huge. Health and safety aside this does mean the government are taking the piss. Also, not entirely sure where the money will come from to pay them? There is no money (apparently).

bananafish81 · 13/03/2016 21:04

But it's not just about pay

It's about increasing elective care across 7 days a week (without any of the allied services to make it possible)

Currently you have 7 days acute + 5 days routine care

The Tories want 7 days acute + 7 days routine care

Which is great and what everyone in the NHS wants.

Except that with the same amount of Drs and no additional funding this means

  • compromising acute care by reducing staffing levels during the week to staff the extended routine care at weekends
  • doctors stretched even more thinly than they already are to do the same job but with fewer resources

The new contract removes the safeguards that penalise hospitals that allow doctors to work dangerously unsafe hours

It's not safe

And it's not fair

To have 7 day routine care you need more funding, more doctors, more nurses, phlebotomists, porters, radiographers, pharmacists. Oh and 7 day social care services at to deal with all the patients that can't be discharged at weekends because of lack of social care provision

But fuck it. It's a manifesto pledge. We don't have to say how we're going to make it happen. Just repeat 7 day NHS ad nauseam and blame the greedy doctors

MissTriggs · 13/03/2016 20:48

Thanks Countess

I see the issue with maternity leave- but isn't that a rather narrower point on equality legislation?

Isee it is always hard to be the first year group facing a new regime. that is a point on loss of status

But these are not pay cuts in the way that the crude campaign would have us believe

I would be more taken by the point made above that the strikers will not have their pay cut but are thinking of those coming after them. but that was not the Bma's line...

imagine going to your gp when you are ill and getting cheap misleading rhetoric instead of distilled facts that would help you make an informed choice. you would not listen to that dr and you would be right not to- and that could lead to tragic results. that is howI feel about this campaign

Hotbot · 13/03/2016 20:40

The majority of staff apart from the jnr doctors have already seen a real decline in their take home pay. Staff at higher grades who have left have been replaced at a lower grade for the same job , if indeed they have been replaced. No real pay increase in yrs. I am actually getting a bit sick of the jnr Drs complaining tbh. The strike is about money ......

Sothisishowitfeels · 13/03/2016 20:36

I have to say my 4 month old dd was in hospital during the strike and I had no idea it was even on. My gp sent us to A and e where we were seen straight away, admitted and checked through the night. I really had no idea it was the strike day.

CountessOfStrathearn · 13/03/2016 20:33

gonetosee, let's look at your points:

  1. How have doctors been "annoyingly emotional emotional and at times hysterical"? We haven't lied, like Jeremy Hunt has in Parliament, misleading the public on papers that consultants don't work weekends (less than 1% have opted out), more people die at the weekends (the highest death rate day is a Wednesday, the weekends in those papers were defined as Friday-Monday, juniors are already there 24/7).

As for "many many employees (especially in the NHS) could also talk at length about what a crap time they're having", there is real support amongst the vast majority of staff and a real understanding in the NHS that this is only the first battle and that once the junior doctors have been defeated, next comes the consultant contract (currently under negotiation), the nurses contract (the student bursaries have already been removed for student nurses working proper nurses' shifts), the "ambulance drivers" as our Health Secretary likes to refer to paramedics etc.

  1. I've not seen anyone say, "We're only doing this because we love the NHS so much but if you don't give us the same deal as we could get in the private sector we're off." Doctors would get paid far more in the private sector but the juniors haven't asked for the same pay (no one asked for a pay rise), just fair terms and conditions and not for a pay cut for doing the very essential out of hours work.

I can't be bothered with really dealing with Point 3 because it did come across as a bit of a nonsensical rant. I knew very few doctors who do private medicine and the vast, vast majority of consultants I know are already working well beyond their contracted hours for free already. You also demonstrate that you don't really understand how the NHS and doctors work. I can't just do an extra clinic as a favour on my own. All the admin needs sorting out, you need a receptionist, a clinic nurse, the specialist nurses on hand, the phlebotomy department to be open to do the required blood tests. Doctors don't work in isolation, but need the infrastructure in place, for which there is no extra funding appearing to do these magical extra clinics.

Point 4 is interesting. Most doctors stay in the UK, working for the monopoly employer of the NHS (no one will want to employ you privately until you are a qualified GP/consultant), for the 5-10+ years that it can take, working unsociable hours for years and years, paying for their own GMC fees/professional indemnity insurance/postgraduate exams etc. Really the number leaving before paying a decent amount of blood, sweat and tears isn't much.

CountessOfStrathearn · 13/03/2016 20:18

"Right, but it is rather misleading to suggest that anyone will get a paycut isn't it?"

misstriggs, no, it isn't misleading, but the truth.

Doctors taking time out to do research or have maternity leave will definitely be losing pay because their pay is only protected at the job they were last in rather than where otherwise they would be. The Equality Assessment is yet to be revealed and wasn't going to be done until the contract was decided but it is clear that anyone taking time out of training to have babies/do life saving research/travel to learn new skills/volunteer abroad will be penalised.

Also, the junior doctors doing the same jobs from August 2016 (so our current final year medical students) will now be paid remarkably less than they were expecting for doing the same job but on a harder rota.

Mysteriously Jeremy Hunt claims that the vast majority of doctors will actually get a pay rise, which is a puzzle given that the overall "pay envelope" remains the same, which means that some people WILL be getting a pay cut.

gonetoseeamanaboutadog · 13/03/2016 19:37

I don't support anyone being forced to work hours that will leave them with no family life at all.

At the same time, medicine has always been a career that involves sacrifice, and I don't think we can hope to avoid that, especially with the NHS the way that it is.

If the following were different, I'd support the doctors' strikes whole-heartedly:

  1. They have been annoyingly emotional emotional and at times hysterical in their campaign. I feel manipulated and it was excessive when many many employees (especially in the NHS) could also talk at length about what a crap time they're having. Not saying they have no justification. It was just excessive and quite obviously a determined streamlining of public opinion.
  1. The money argument is deeply contradictory; also annoying. 'We're only doing this because we love the NHS so much but if you don't give us the same deal as we could get in the private sector we're off' simply doesn't wash. No reason why doctors should be mistreated in the NHS, but also no reason why doctors are obliged to take the highest paying job. There are plenty of people in Britain working for lower wages (and not the least gifted people either) because they recognise it's where they can make the most difference.
  1. Likewise, the pension thing needs to be sorted out if I am to believe that doctors love the NHS so much. If they love it enough for us all to support them, they should love us back by working until proper retirement age, like the rest of us. And they should not be finding it so easy to live comfortably on part-time wages. Similarly, I daresay I don't know anything about anything, but if I was an NHS consultant and the NHS could only afford to pay me for one or two of my sessions in the week, I wouldn't hurry off to a private clinic where I could make more money, or not much. I would offer to work more for the NHS for less. I would do it because I care about the patients. If doctors care as much as they say they do, they would do this too, regardless of the rights or wrongs of it, because (a) NHS consultants are not starving and (b) it's the patients who would benefit. Apparently consultants don't care about the money and care deeply about the patients, too, but this is not reflected at all in their career choices. When you look at the gap in salary between those working in the charitable sector and those who don't, it's clear that some people in the UK are capable of doing this sort of thing and if they didn't, there would be a great deal more suffering in the country.
  1. Every time a junior doctor says 'I'll leave the UK if you don't give me a better deal', (as well as feeling genuine sympathy), I feel like thrashing out some kind of a deal regarding tuition fees. If the NHS is skint and haemorraging doctors, it can at least not be providing cut-price education for doctors working in other countries. And yes, let's include everyone in this, but doctors are a stand-out case because they are so very expensive to train and so many of them are leaving. Many people are feeling this and doctors are failing to address the fact that they're having their cake and eating it in that respect - which shows a lack of decency IMO.

So yes, I would support the doctors whole-heartedly were it not for this. Rant over :)

MissTriggs · 13/03/2016 17:16

Right, but it is rather misleading to suggest that anyone will get a paycut isn't it?

bananafish81 · 13/03/2016 11:42

The pay protection only lasts till 2019 BTW

MissTriggs · 13/03/2016 11:40

Ahh,realized you have other things on your mind.good luck

bananafish81 · 13/03/2016 11:39

Because they're getting rid of banding so most Drs who got increased banding for unsociable hours specialities now get an overall pay cut

My friends are leaving the country in droves

MissTriggs · 13/03/2016 11:37

judy, is there not protected pay under the new contract? How can your friend be getting a pay cut?

Panicmode1 · 13/03/2016 11:13

JudyWilliams - wishing you all the best for tomorrow! How very exciting. I hope you are spending the day being TOTALLY self indulgent - last time for a while (12 years and counting here Wink )

(And sadly, I agree with everything you've said on the NHS - scary times).

ICantRememberAnything · 13/03/2016 09:58

We unfortunately ended up in A&E on Thursday because my son lost his memory. All the doctors we saw were completely brilliant and I cannot fault the care he got.

I support the doctors strike 100%

JudyWilliams · 13/03/2016 09:46

Thank you panicmode1. Tomorrow is the day and we are so excited!

I really do support the docs. From
My experience the strength of the NHS is in its staff. All of us. Regardless of age, grade, profession. We all have a sense of pride and vocation. As let's be honest if we wanted to be in it for the money we have gone about it the wrong way!

I do now and will forever campaign for the NHS and to preserve and protect it but sadly I'm not convinced we can fix this one. It's such a terrible shame

I have many doc friends too and I really feel for them. One for example has recently got their first mortgage based as per the norm on his salary to be hit with a considerable pay cut. So in that sense, I don't see how it's wrong to say yes it is to do with money in part. He will be working another few years of promotions to earn what he currently does.

OP posts:
Panicmode1 · 13/03/2016 08:22

YANBU to be upset about your ELCS being cancelled. However, I 100% support the doctors - my brother is a senior surgical registrar (so still a junior doctor) and is actively looking at other professions (he doesn't want to leave the country) because he doesn't want to be part of a 'company' that is going to routinely end up killing people due to the unsafe practices that Hunt is trying to impose. It is NOT about the money - he left a very lucrative career in the City to retrain as a doctor and would be earning a much larger multiple of his salary for probably slightly more family friendly hours if he'd stayed. He says several of the excellent doctors he works with are moving abroad later this year - to Australia or Canada mainly.

RIP NHS. I pray that no-one in my family is going to be ill after August this year - God help us all!

CountessOfStrathearn · 13/03/2016 08:13

What more detail do you want, MissTrigg? What do you think is awful about the BMA advocacy?

Negotiations have been happening for 3 years now, and the BMA pulled out when the DoH team said that they would only negotiate on a few (fairly minor) points if the BMA agreed to have the rest of the contract and that the contract would just be imposed anyway, which is what happened.

Jeremy Hunt refused the BMA's offer to go to ACAS as independent mediators: (I'm trying to find the videos of the discussions in Parliament but can't and need to get the children dressed, but can come back later.)

www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/labour-jeremy-hunt-should-be-stripped-of-responsibility-for-negotiations-with-junior-doctors-a6739656.html

The history of the negotiations are on the BMA website:

www.bma.org.uk/working-for-change/junior-and-consultant-contract-home/negotiations-background

You can see the letters sent by the Junior Doctors' Committee chair, Johann Malawana, here:

www.bma.org.uk/working-for-change/junior-and-consultant-contract-home/junior-doctor-contract-negotiations-home/timeline-of-correspondence

The first one there will give you a very detailed response to doctors' issues with the now imposed contract.

Finally, here are some local junior doctors (along with a medical negligence lawyer who has got so irate at the whole thing he has joined up with people he normally sues!) giving blood this week:

www.cambridge-news.co.uk/Junior-doctors-strike-Cambridge-positive-thing/story-28899519-detail/story.html

MissTriggs · 12/03/2016 11:17

"They can't sit down and talk it out because it's David and Goliath.
It's like playing chess with a particularly bullying pigeon.
No one can negotiate with someone who says "I know you want to discuss nearly 30 points, but we've decided we can only discuss 3 of them." Or says "If you don't do what I say, I'll force you." That's not negotiation. It's rape."

wow what a post! Can you give more detail? my frustration with the two sides is that they seem to be playing the same game- they both seem very powerful. The Bma advocacy is awful.

I think the vast gulf in experience between nhs employees and the rest of us makes it hard to understand each other.

There are a few helpful posters around like Mamadoc who provide hard facts but they are a rarity in all the noise

peppatax · 11/03/2016 21:09

Sorry - with Gove previously in charge.

peppatax · 11/03/2016 21:09

Is the NHS going down the toilet with Hunt in charge and is teaching going down the toilet with Gove in charge because of this Government or having to right wrongs from previous Governments? Just as most managers controlling budgets have to make choices, it's no different here other than people are quick to blame the effect rather than the cause.

weegiemum · 11/03/2016 20:32

It isn't affecting us in Scotland but my dh worked 96 hour weeks as a junior in the 90s. He's a gp now and still works 70+, but as a senior doctor with his own practice thats his choice.

It wasn't safe in 1995, it really wasn't (he missed his train stop on several occasions as he was so exhausted, he once worked 3 days on 45 mins sleep) and its not safe now. If he could he'd be striking in support.

The English NHS is going down the toilet with Hunt in charge.

LaurieMarlow · 11/03/2016 20:20

Feral, that's admirable and I'm sure that will help in winning the battle for hearts and minds. But they need to be sure that story has permeated public perception.

Maudofallhopefulness · 11/03/2016 20:13

I'm backing the doctors 100%. It is so unfair and dangerous what is being imposed on them. The government want a 7 day NHS on the cheap and expect the staff to pay for it. They want the NHS to fail so it can be privatised.

dumbbelle · 11/03/2016 20:08

They can't sit down and talk it out because it's David and Goliath.

It's like playing chess with a particularly bullying pigeon.

No one can negotiate with someone who says "I know you want to discuss nearly 30 points, but we've decided we can only discuss 3 of them." Or says "If you don't do what I say, I'll force you." That's not negotiation. It's rape.

Swipe left for the next trending thread