Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

doctor strike

158 replies

JudyWilliams · 09/03/2016 15:17

Bit of a rant. Has anyone else been moved three times because of the doctors
Strike? I'm booked in for ELCS originally today, then tomorrow, then Friday. Now Monday!

Slowly loosing hope! That and I'm now sofa/bed bound due to hip/back complications. I'm just wondering if anyone is in a similar situation.

OP posts:
TheSinkingFeeling · 14/03/2016 20:04

I can say what I like; I'm not a junior doctor, I'm not involved in their fight. I can just offer my deepest support from the sidelines.
You know what? Teaching is not equitable to medicine. Not in the slightest.

Peaceandloveeveryone · 14/03/2016 20:01

This happens all the time, it's not a competition and it doesn't help the cause.

doctor strike
TheSinkingFeeling · 14/03/2016 20:01

The junior do tors seem to be the only people standing up to Hunt, and this bloody awful government. The Royal Colleges have failed; the RCN is a joke.
I'm fed up of people trying to make this about money, and to try and equate it with other 'professions'. It's a question of safety, of stretching the current NHS service until it breaks, so that it can be reconstructed with private companies instead. I'm sick of people from the private sector deriding the efforts of junior doctors, just because they haven't the gumption to defend themselves.

Peaceandloveeveryone · 14/03/2016 19:56

Hey, neither have I. I came on to say that deriding other professions isn't the way to go and has been done. It's exactly what you have done.
People are allowed to discuss this without you volleying abuse at them you know?

TheSinkingFeeling · 14/03/2016 19:53

Hey, I'm not someone who's come into this thread knocking junior doctors who are trying to defend the NHS.

Peaceandloveeveryone · 14/03/2016 19:50

Don't be such a twat, you think bitching about other people trying to earn a living is 'showing solidarity' ?

Peaceandloveeveryone · 14/03/2016 19:49

grasping cunt ? Jesus, I am out of here, you are clueless about how most people are selling their souls to try and survive.

TheSinkingFeeling · 14/03/2016 19:48

Well, show some fucking solidarity them!

Peaceandloveeveryone · 14/03/2016 19:47

You private sector fuckers don't have a clue about responsibility

That's a bloody outrageous thing to say and alienates support- and I say that as a nurse of 27 years.

MissTriggs · 14/03/2016 19:47

thanks parallax, very helpful.

parallax80 · 14/03/2016 19:46

Yes. But what I'm getting at is that nurses give drugs, so they can make an error by giving the wrong drug / wrong amount / wrong route

Doctors also administer drugs. I'm an anaesthetist - I regularly give up to 20 drugs in the course of an operation which I mix and administer myself. So i can make all these mistakes too. But there are lots of things I do that nurses don't (prescribing, making diagnoses, ordering investigations, giving other instructions to nurses) so there are lots of other ways I could make mistakes too.

TheSinkingFeeling · 14/03/2016 19:46

All this talk about 'finance professionals' and lawyers equating to junior doctors really boils my piss. If someone decides not to work in finance, they'll be another grasping cunt along in a minute to replace them.
That's not the case with junior doctors.

TheSinkingFeeling · 14/03/2016 19:44

It the nurses who are actually administering these drugs and doing the monitoring in many cases.

Don't try that divide and conquer bulkshit. The vast majority of us support out doctor colleagues.

gonetoseeamanaboutadog · 14/03/2016 19:42

...increased level of clinical responsibility - the scope for lethal mistakes as a doctor is larger than for a nurse because it includes misdiagnosis, wrong or omitted investigations and wrong or inappropriate instructions to other people, as well as drug errors and failing to appreciate / escalate serious illnesses / changes.

It the nurses who are actually administering these drugs and doing the monitoring in many cases.

gonetoseeamanaboutadog · 14/03/2016 19:38

I do agree with you about all that running. Those conditions aren't right for anyone. It's the surrounding, knock-on arguments I have a problem with.

TheSinkingFeeling · 14/03/2016 19:38

And don't fucking start about public sector pensions, we've been royally screwed over there.

parallax80 · 14/03/2016 19:37

I think historically the pay has been higher for doctors because of:

a) probably a bit of hungover entrenched class privilege (plus a bit of sexism? Until relatively recently most doctors were men and most nurses women)

b) increased level of clinical responsibility - the scope for lethal mistakes as a doctor is larger than for a nurse because it includes misdiagnosis, wrong or omitted investigations and wrong or inappropriate instructions to other people, as well as drug errors and failing to appreciate / escalate serious illnesses / changes. In addition, doctors have and are still the person where the buck stops. As an example, as a junior SHO i used to manage a lot of (not pregnant) people with epidurals - one of the side effects is a low blood pressure. The nursing staff are told to contact anaesthetics if the blood pressure falls below a certain number. This is good, because for some people that can be harmful. Other people will tolerate a lower blood pressure just fine, and making it higher unnecessarily can cause other side effects and be harmful. Others again actually need their prescription reviewing to set a higher "trigger" to call, as they have different physiology. My job was to see the patient, assess them and make a judgement about what needed to happen. Do I think it was the hardest job in the world? No, of course not. A lot of it is experience, and knowing what to look for. Most of the senior nurses could probably have done it fine. But, they weren't. So it was my name in the notes and my responsibility for the judgement call.

c) increased levels of non-clinical responsibility including for teaching, audit, service development. The aim of training juniors to be consultants is for them to have ongoing responsibilities for all of these things (in varying amounts). The majority of nurses have not historically been expected to have these responsibilities. Nowadays some do, which they often do very well, and those who do have extended practice (whether teaching or independent prescribing) do have this reflected in their salaries (though not to the extent that perhaps they should - though many of the extended practice roles have relatively little out of hours work, which may be part of the discrepancy). The whole medical education system is essentially a giant Ponzi scheme, where you tell the more senior people they have to demonstrate ongoing involvement in teaching to pass their revalidation / appraisal and therefore they have to do it, but are rarely given any paid time to do this in.

I think there is a lot of blurring of roles in healthcare happening at the moment with advanced nursing practice, physicians associates etc etc developing new roles. I'm fairly ambivalent about this (far more than many of my colleagues), I think there are both good and bad things about it, but at the end of the day there will still need to be a group of people who have final responsibility for non-protocolised judgement calls and tbis will require considerable training and a salary to reflect the investment in training, the level of responsibility etc. Whether we'll be calling them doctors in 50 years time is another matter.

As an aside there was some discussion in 2007/8 about moving junior doctors onto the Agenda for Change payscale which nurses and most allied health professionals are on - it's supposed to reflect the particular skills and responsibilities of a post rather than the job title. It was abandoned because it was thought it would lead to increased Drs salaries.

Apologies for the stream of consciousness.

TheSinkingFeeling · 14/03/2016 19:37

I can't believe that you're comparing doctors to professions outside medicine. If a doctor makes a mistake, it can be lethal. Lawyers are ten a penny, so are 'finance professionals' (whoever the fuck they are). Doctors are the brightest and best in any society, and I say that as a nurse of 25 years experience. You private sector fuckers don't have a clue about responsibility.

Runningwithacheesegrater · 14/03/2016 19:14

Of course JDs haven't been immune. We have seen study budgets slashed, workload practically doubling, rota gaps are now the norm and pay has not kept pace with inflation despite GMC, indemnity, college, exam and course fees all rising well above inflation. All of which is paid for by ourselves - this is not the case in other countries. But we have carried on.

The outcry over this contract is because there is a very very real risk of burn out and mistakes being made. Make a serious enough mistake and there is no going back, your entire career is over and there is great appetite at the moment in prosecuting individual doctors despite their working environments setting them up to fail. Stress I can deal with, but there comes a point where it makes no sense to carry on. So the options are to leave the nhs or leave the country.

There is a shortage of doctors, nurses and teachers in this country. A massive shortage. So I don't see how actively making pay and working conditions worse and telling them to lump it is going to help. There is a reason why these are called key workers, if you don't want to hang on to them then other countries will poach them.

LaurieMarlow · 14/03/2016 18:56

Yes, I guess that's it. And unsurprising given they're a relatively insular group and mix among themselves a great deal.

The investment banker comments always make me smile. As if there are tens of thousands of highly paid investment banker jobs just waiting for them to step into.

A tiny, tiny handful of people are making those kinds of big bucks. The unions should be presenting their case more honestly.

gonetoseeamanaboutadog · 14/03/2016 18:44

But the consequences of a nurse's mistake very often also has the potential to be lethal (I speak from personal experience!), and to some extent a paramedic also has the responsibility of acting in a skilled way in a short space of time, in the knowledge that not doing it right could cost a life. We don't feel the need to reflect this level of risk in their lifetime salary however.

MissTriggs · 14/03/2016 18:14

"I think they genuinely haven't clocked it TBH. The private sector has changed a lot in the last 10 years."

I agree. I really wonder whether the union is telling drs that lawyers earn lots of money so they should too. The many many privileges they have that we don't have are invisible to them though - eg the pension, the sick pay, the non-pyramid structure whereby experienced people are genuinely wanted to stay in the job rather than routinely bullied out, etc, etc.

That's how they end up saying daft things like "I could go and work in the city tomorrow and earn a squillion" (and make fools of themselves by saying it).

But it cuts both ways. We have no idea what it feels like to have no possibility of working elsewhere unless you emigrate and the point about the consequences of their mistakes is pretty incontrovertible :(

peppatax · 14/03/2016 18:09

They definitely haven't clocked it. Neither have teachers. I know they work long hours, it's stressful and they do work in the holidays but most of the time I come and go at the same time as my teacher colleagues (also working at evenings and weekends) but I do it 48 weeks of the year. This is the common problem between the two professions - both appear to think that no one else has it tough.

AyeAmarok · 14/03/2016 17:41

As if JDs have failed to clock what's been going on with the vast majority of similarly skilled professions in terms of stress levels, pay, conditions, expectations. Or they did clock it and somehow expected JDs to be immune.

I think they genuinely haven't clocked it TBH. The private sector has changed a lot in the last 10 years.

Yes, there are still a few exceptions to the rule that everyone pulls out to point score "my friend's DH was earning over 100k by 28 only ever doing 9-5" etc etc. And there are plenty who had worked their way up before the crash and are still doing OK.

But in reality in the private sector now is pensions are shot to pieces, entry level wages are low for the professions (as in, in the teens), unpaid internships are rife, low job security, people have to pay for their professional exams and membership themselves, unpaid overtime is expected, travel is expected with no time back, no or weak unions, it's stressful, and there is no guarantee of progression.

It's just generally a bit shit to be a younger worker these days.

LaurieMarlow · 14/03/2016 15:20

Professionals generally. Lawyers, accountants, architects, engineers, finance professionals (of which the vast majority are not investment bankers and on those salaries) third level teachers, upper management in big corporations, consultants, etc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread