Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is 16 and adult or a child?

114 replies

CalleighDoodle · 04/03/2016 13:26

Not a thread about a thread. Actually a thread about two threads so technically...

Ive read today very different responses to questions about people the same age. Similar issues (sexual relationships). different sexes.

How can a female at 16 be called an adult who should be allowed to do what she wants, despite that behaviour being very risky, yet a male at 16 is a child who shouldnt date one person 6/7 years older?

I know a number of late-teen women who married men at least 10 years older than them. Is that ok because they are a more adulty adult that a 16 year old woman, and much more of an adult of a 16 year old 'boy'?

Aibu here or is the sexism on a women's forum towards women really quite unbelievable?

OP posts:
PUGaLUGS · 04/03/2016 14:13

Young adult I would say.

Arfarfanarf · 04/03/2016 14:13

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Birdsgottafly · 04/03/2016 14:12

I class them and classed my DDs as young adults, still needing guidance, but free to start to become their own person and in some cases that will include having completely different sex lives than their parents did, especially young women.

In the second instance, there are very few 17 year old young men that could sustain a relationship, unless bought up in a certain culture. Quite honestly, do you think that she's actually fell in love with him, to the extent that she couldn't see sense?

I was running my own home at 17, but in hindsight, I shouldn't have been, I should have been able to study and enjoy that time.

I think the same of the Mums I have met, living in Mum and Baby Units etc.

My DD met her BF at 17, he was 23, she was very mature and they started off dating, she wouldn't have considered it, if he'd had a child. At 19, she got pregnant, unlike a pp, I wasn't unhappy about that. Me and my eldest DD still see her as needing guidance, which she asks for, but we wouldn't try to tell her what to do.

Previous generations may have looked as though they had independence, because they worked etc, but the family and the Church, interfered, very often until the couple were 30+.

Helenluvsrob · 04/03/2016 14:12

Trick age legally. For instance locally treated in adult hospital and expected to sign own consent and not have a parent necessarily present at. If consultant chats even when significantly I'll ( friends dc need surgery for crohns).

Ss the "owner" of a 16yr old I'd say definitely a child -and she is very mature and articulate too.

AndNowItsSeven · 04/03/2016 14:12

16 is a child , it makes me irrationally angry when people say otherwise. It makes me seriously doubt that their own dc are 16 or older x

BertrandRussell · 04/03/2016 14:10

"I know a number of late-teen women who married men at least 10 years older than them. Is that ok because they are a more adulty adult that a 16 year old woman, and much more of an adult of a 16 year old 'boy'?"

I would do absolutely anything I could to stop a 16 year old of mine of either sex having a relationship with anyone 10 years older than them. Hell, 5 years older than them.......

Where does the sexism come in?

Schwabischeweihnachtskanne · 04/03/2016 14:09

On the age of consent theme - many countries have a kind of sliding scale on ages of consent - so I think (but am not sure as I didn't grow up here) that here in Germany the age of consent is technically 14 but the 28 year old footballer would still have gone to jail because 14 yos can only consent to sex with other people roughly similar in age (could look up the exact age brackets - under 17 maybe)... The same for the 16-18 age range, it could technically still be punishable by law for a 28 year old (say) to have apparently consentual sex with them if the judge ruled that they had used the unequal power balance to persuade a 16/17 year old to consent to sex....

I think its a complicated age bracket, between 16 and 18, and not clearly child or adult - it will depend from case to case, from person to person, from situation to situation...

ciabattav0nbreadstickz · 04/03/2016 14:08

I think it really depends on the person. I was very mature at the age of 16, as were lots of people I know who were all responsible and sensible at that age. But I think we were the exceptions rather than the rule and there are a lot who aren't. I also know teens with children who are still very immature so being a parent isn't necessarily a guarentee of maturity.

I haven't read the thread about the 16yr old sharing pictures of herself but I would advise caution to her in that case as 16yr olds are legally still children and anyone found to be sharing nude pictures etc even of themselves can be charged with distributing child pornography Confused

WhoWants2Know · 04/03/2016 14:08

GummyBunting-- a 16 year old can't do all of those things in England. Not without parental consent.

And having a baby shouldn't really come into it. I can google dozens of 10 year olds who have delivered healthy babies across the world, and who certainly wouldn't be classed as adults.

blindsider · 04/03/2016 14:06

If they are living at home they are children (and subject to be treated as such) Grin

Haffdonga · 04/03/2016 14:06

Being legally allowed to have sex, join the army or marry does not make anyone an adult.

It just means that it is legally permissable to have sex as a child, marry as a child bride or join the army as a child soldier .

TooOldForGlitter · 04/03/2016 14:04

Can't get married or join the army without the permission of the parent.

A girl could probably have a baby at 12, doesn't make it a good idea does it.

Haffdonga · 04/03/2016 14:03

Legally a child. Morally a child. Emotionally a child.
Sometimes physically and socially an adult. Sometimes not so much.

GummyBunting · 04/03/2016 14:02

I'd like to think that any parent would want to guide their DC if they were engaged in risky behaviour? Whether the DC was 6 or 26?

16 is a young adult. Totally weird to call someone who can get married, join the army, have an NI number, work, buy premium bonds, have a baby, leave home, and join a trade union a child. So not a child!

If your 16yo is not ready or equipped to do any of the above, that doesn't mean they're not perfectly entitled to if they wish.

AgentProvocateur · 04/03/2016 14:00

I feel (with nothing to back this up) that it's an adult in Scotland - because you can get married at 16, and I left home and went to uni at 16 - but a child in England. I know that doesn't really make sense, but that's how I see it Wink

Arfarfanarf · 04/03/2016 13:59

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

TooOldForGlitter · 04/03/2016 13:56

Child. 18 is too young to be classed as an adult IMO but nothing is going to change there.

Dumbledoresgirl · 04/03/2016 13:54

Child, definitely.

And yes, to CaptainCrunch's post of 13.42. I don't contribute to threads like that but I secretly smile. I accept that 18 year olds are adults in the eyes of the law, but I wouldn't be happy if either my 18 yo or for that matter my 19 yo took it upon themselves to, for instance, get married right now or have a child.

Which is not to say that some 18 year olds aren't very mature, but my kids are amongst them. There is something to be said for the old age of majority 21 being re-instated for some things.

WhoWants2Know · 04/03/2016 13:53
  • the 16 year old would not be considered an adult in other ways.
WhoWants2Know · 04/03/2016 13:52

It sounds like you're confusing the age of sexual consent with adulthood. An adult can have consensual sex with a person over the age of 16 without legal penalty. So on that thread, yes, a girl of 16 can have sex with who she wants to. As you say, it is risky and I don't think anyone on that thread was in a rush to say it's a great idea.

The 16 year old would be considered an adult in other ways. They can't legally do many of the things that adults do: buy alcohol, buy cigarettes, join the army (without parental consent) get married (without parental consent), get a driver's license, vote...

So in your example of an older adult marrying someone in their late teens- yes, that is a much different thing than an older person entering into a relationship with a 16 year old. It isn't a sexist thing, in that it doesn't matter in that case whether the 16 year old is a male or female. The trouble is that the older adult probably has the advantage of life experience that the 16 year old doesn't have. The older person potentially has their own home, job, car, and (in the case of the other thread you're referring to) child. It isn't a level playing field, and I think that's what people object to.

Once everybody is fully an adult in the eyes of the law, those differences won't necessarily apply.

notarehearsal · 04/03/2016 13:44

16 is a young person, not a child anymore but a young adult imo

KoalaDownUnder · 04/03/2016 13:44

Child.

I haven't seen the thread about the 16-year-old girl, but I have nieces that age, and their parents certainly consider them children. And would intervene (aka do their job as parents) if they were engaging in 'risky behaviour'.

CaptainCrunch · 04/03/2016 13:42

What I find strange about MN is so many threads go on about 16 and 17 year olds being "children" but the minute someone posts about having an issue with dc aged 18 the same posters start screeching "they're an ADULT".

MrsJayy · 04/03/2016 13:42

Tbf not everybody said let her do what she wanted not read the other thread 16yr olds are teenagers so imo older children and need protecting

MrsSteptoe · 04/03/2016 13:41

On the whole, I would say a child on the basis that they have not yet been exposed to life as an adult (i.e. I'm assuming still in FT education, living with parents)
But I also think it's contextual. Is a 16 year old with a baby a child? Yes, in some ways - but they are also a parent, which is to some extent (not entirely) antonymous.
It's an interesting question today, because there are at least three relevant threads running parallel.

Swipe left for the next trending thread