Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is 16 and adult or a child?

114 replies

CalleighDoodle · 04/03/2016 13:26

Not a thread about a thread. Actually a thread about two threads so technically...

Ive read today very different responses to questions about people the same age. Similar issues (sexual relationships). different sexes.

How can a female at 16 be called an adult who should be allowed to do what she wants, despite that behaviour being very risky, yet a male at 16 is a child who shouldnt date one person 6/7 years older?

I know a number of late-teen women who married men at least 10 years older than them. Is that ok because they are a more adulty adult that a 16 year old woman, and much more of an adult of a 16 year old 'boy'?

Aibu here or is the sexism on a women's forum towards women really quite unbelievable?

OP posts:
Jw35 · 04/03/2016 16:31

It's a child who's almost an adult. Simple! 18 is a young adult.

RufusTheReindeer · 04/03/2016 16:27

Child

Sallystyle · 04/03/2016 16:20

Child.

My 16 year old certainly is.

Hygellig · 04/03/2016 16:19

I think 16 is a kind of limbo-land. Legally it seems to be a bit of both, although you are not completely a legal adult until 18. I remember feeling like neither one nor the other when I was 16. I didn't really feel like a child as I had done say, three to four years earlier, but I didn't really feel like an adult either. I remember once being out with my mum's friend when I was 16 and my sister 14 and the friend's children were 18 and 16. My mum said something like "Can I have a child please" (probably to ask one of us to run an errand) and her friend replied "There are none left". Also remember one of our teachers saying when we were about 14/15 that we weren't really children any more and in some countries we'd probably have our own children.

I suppose the concept of a teenager is fairly recent; people used to leave education much earlier and were out working, earning and being independent at a younger age. So at the end of the day how long you are considered to be a child depends on the society in which you live. I don't think of 16-year-olds as adults - legally they're children (but less so than 15-year-olds) but I would probably refer to them as young people or teenagers. However when mine reach the age of 16 I will probably be still thinking of them as children! I suppose there is a fine balance between giving them some independence in accordance with their age and gradually preparing them for adulthood whilst recognising that they may not have much life experience or maturity.

RoseBud999 · 04/03/2016 14:35

When I look back at my behaviour (which to me now is unrecognisable) I believe even at 18/19 you have the life experience and mentality of a child. The only difference is by 16 most are reaching physical maturity.

OneMagnumisneverenough · 04/03/2016 14:34

There is a difference between legally an adult and whether they behave in an adult fashion. I'm in Scotland so 16 pretty much the legal age for a lot of things and yet still remains 18 for others i.e. could be married and in the Army and voting but still can't buy alcohol or watch an 18 rated movie.

People all mature differently though. Surely it's our job as parents though to make it so that there isn't suddenly a switch flicked on their birthday and then that's it?

I couldn't really force my 14 year old to do very much if he didn't want to. Thankfully though I am able to talk and guide him and he is pretty sensible. I appreciate that others aren't in the same position. I would also expect still to be giving guidance and support for many many years though obviously it's up to them whether they take it.

There is also an element of "while you are living under my roof" I suppose.

CantWaitForWarmWeather · 04/03/2016 14:33

Child.

Is a 17 year old still a child or young adult?

Archfarchnad · 04/03/2016 14:32

"The LA definition is 'Young Person', or vulnerable young adult, there is now very specific guidelines, under the law."

That's interesting, Birds, I'd not heard of that. Does that apply to 16-18yo then? So technically speaking, people of that age group are still minors, but classed as young people not children? Because if so, the message hasn't really got through to the general public...

Aeroflotgirl · 04/03/2016 14:29

Technically a minor, therefore a child.

ExConstance · 04/03/2016 14:28

Jason Burt Jack Cornwell Bravery by 16 year olds that clearly show these were men, not children. I do think we infantalise young people these days and that 16 year olds are perfectly capable of being adults if they are encouraged to be responsible.

VertigoNun · 04/03/2016 14:21

It's a weird one.

People my parents age could leave full time education at 15 and my age could leave aged 16. My children are part of the stay in full time education until 18 generation.

Birdsgottafly · 04/03/2016 14:21

""The difficulty in the UK is that there is no status separating being a child and being an adult.""

The LA definition is 'Young Person', or vulnerable young adult, there is now very specific guidelines, under the law.

Sparklingbrook · 04/03/2016 14:20

I have a 16 year old DS and I would say child with frequent glimpses of the adult they will be.

seaweed123 · 04/03/2016 14:20

I also left home and went to uni at 16, and felt very much an adult. I was in a relationship with a 20yo, and it didn't occur to me to ask my parents advice on anything. I didn't have a mobile phone or even a landline at the time either.

I think teenagers are a bit "younger" these days though, with less opportunity to be independent in their early teens, to prepare them for that sort of thing.

Iggi999 · 04/03/2016 14:18

16, not 6 obviously

peggyundercrackers · 04/03/2016 14:18

I would say an adult - the age of legal capacity in Scotland is 16 meaning they can enter into any transaction they want.

www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1991/50/section/1

Schwabischeweihnachtskanne · 04/03/2016 14:17

Mind you I disagree that 18 isn't an adult - I remember going to the USA with my parents at age 20 after living (a long way) away from the parental home for two and a half years (only ever going back for 3 or 4 night visits a few times a year, not long university holidays) and feeling humiliatingly infantilized by the US system of defining a 20 year old woman as effectively a child! Maybe when my eldest gets closer to 18 I'll change my mind, but I hope not - I hope I'm raising my kids to be capable, independent, resourceful, strong young adults in a few years time, those are my aims almost above everything else (apart from happiness and health of course) but I guess time will tell!

Iggi999 · 04/03/2016 14:17

The Rights of the Child thingy apply up to 18. Obviously some -6 year olds can be very mature, but the vast majority are children with the level of responsibility appropriate to being a child.
I think anyone ten years older than a teenager should not be dating the teenager, of either sex. Ten years at this age is a vast difference of life experience compared to say a 25 and a 35 year old.

Birdsgottafly · 04/03/2016 14:17

Also from a services POV, a 16-18 year old is considered vulnerable, so would be housed, 'looked after'. The LA has a Duty of Care towards them.

The Children's Act was amended to include that age group.

TheCrimsonPleb · 04/03/2016 14:16

I would weigh it on a case by case basis. When I was 16 I was living in a bedsit and working. I know 16 year olds now who are more sophisticated and street smart than others. Some are still children, some are young adults. It's not black and white.

Mousefinkle · 04/03/2016 14:16

16 and 17 is a weird in between stage. Not a girl not yet a woman to quote Britney Wink. They're neither. They're capable of working, getting a house at a push, having sex and deemed responsible enough to potentially win millions on the lottery. Yet 18 is the beginning of true adulthood. I personally don't think you're mature or responsible until you're at least 21 and even that's at a push for some, especially males.

sonjadog · 04/03/2016 14:15

Definitely a child. I work as a secondary school teacher and have met hundreds of 16 year olds. Even the most mature ones are still children. The maturity is largely a front and underneath they are still very young. I'd say the same about 18 year olds as well. They aren't children in the way ten year olds are, but they aren't quite adults either. I would say adulthood begins properly about 22ish.

GummyBunting · 04/03/2016 14:14

I didn't say doing one or all of the above would make you an adult, just that it feels weird to class them as a child.

They're certainly a step up from a child. A young adult at the least.

blindsider · 04/03/2016 14:14

The correct answer is it all depends on the person there are lots of very together 16 year olds who I would happily consider adults and my two SD's who frankly struggle to tie their own shoe laces or remember their address:-(

Archfarchnad · 04/03/2016 14:14

The difficulty in the UK is that there is no status separating being a child and being an adult. So one day you're a child, the next an adult, with all that it entails. There's an interesting an effective solution to that in Germany: children (Kinder) are up to 14, then 14 to 18 are young people (Jugendliche), then adults at 18. Both children and young people are still minors (they can't sign contracts, for example), but young people do have more rights and responsibilities than children. It's a legal recognition than people from 14 to 18 are in a very different position from pre-teens, and I think it prepares them much better for adulthood.

Swipe left for the next trending thread