Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is 16 and adult or a child?

114 replies

CalleighDoodle · 04/03/2016 13:26

Not a thread about a thread. Actually a thread about two threads so technically...

Ive read today very different responses to questions about people the same age. Similar issues (sexual relationships). different sexes.

How can a female at 16 be called an adult who should be allowed to do what she wants, despite that behaviour being very risky, yet a male at 16 is a child who shouldnt date one person 6/7 years older?

I know a number of late-teen women who married men at least 10 years older than them. Is that ok because they are a more adulty adult that a 16 year old woman, and much more of an adult of a 16 year old 'boy'?

Aibu here or is the sexism on a women's forum towards women really quite unbelievable?

OP posts:
Schwabischeweihnachtskanne · 04/03/2016 18:17

I travelled the world (well part of it - India, Nepal, Vietman, Thailand, Malaysia, Singapore, Inonesia, Australia) alone for a year and left three weeks after my 18th birthday. I phoned home once a month and wrote more often but the letters took weeks or longer to arrive. My parents may have been shitting themselves but the wisest thing my mother ever said was that she knew that if she tried to forbid me or stop me from going she knew I just wouldn't come back. The immaturity is in the selfishness of not worrying about them worrying I guess - but that kind of maturity can hold you back from properly living ... Looking back from a distance of over 20 years I do not think I was a child at 18. I returned to visit my parents for a couple of weeks then went to university, and stayed in my uni town or went abroad to work every long holiday.

I guess parents generally keep the leash a lot shorter these days, putting their own psychological discomfort about not knowing exactly where their adult children are what they are doing before letting the adult children spread their wings and embrace all the world has to offer, make their own mistakes and have real, genuine, incredible, independent adventures - and and technology enables that, so maybe that is part of what keeps people from growing up by 18. 18 though, not 16 (though I did also travel alone internationally at 16 I wasn't an adult).

Joeperrysguitar · 04/03/2016 18:15

At 16 you are an adult in Scotland. You Can get married without permission and can vote in Scottish elections. The fact that 16 year olds can not vote in Westminster elections is wrong, whatever happened to the law of 'no taxation without representation', but that is a whole other thread.

Hulababy · 04/03/2016 18:10

Most 16 year olds are still children.

Many may well think they are adults, but when it comes down to it most are still pretty dependent children. Older children certainly, but children none the less.

  • from a quick online search, re definition:

What is the legal age of a child?
In England and Wales and in Northern Ireland a minor is a person under the age of 18; in Scotland, under the age of 16.

Katarzyna79 · 04/03/2016 18:10

I think I was mature very young I was forced to grow up by my mother. If I had been thrown out at 16 I would have been scared but I knew how to access benefits since I had done all applications for parents as a young child. I knew how to get on the housing register too, and get a job, I had one from 15 anyway. so I think I would have survived but education would have been non existant i'd have to work to survive.

but today I look at my 15 yr old nephew he can't even vacuum a room, plate his own food, h doesn't attend gp on his own. My youngest brother is 26 and squabbles with my 9 year old and gets moody about it, I wonder whats happened to the new generation?

IPityThePontipines · 04/03/2016 18:09

Having read threads on MN, I have wondered about this too.

Certainly I have read on fervent condemnation of 15 year olds having sexual relationships with older men - rightfully so.

Yet on here I've also read that 13/14 year olds having sexual relationships with children of a similar age, or even older is absolutely fine (no issues with coercion or anything) and you apparently can't stop teenagers having sex at all, ever.

We hear about Cool Wives on here, but there are quite a few Cool Parents on here, who can't wait for their children to grow up, so they can hang out with them, instead if having to parent them.

Narp · 04/03/2016 18:08

Child

Young adult if you want to nit-pick, but that's another way of saying an 'old child'

Katarzyna79 · 04/03/2016 18:05

the law contradicts, on the one hand they're old enough to have sex and drink according to the law (not in my parental books). On the otherhand they're still protected by child protection laws until 18? I think it's messed up, the USA has got it correct with a higher age. They base it on the fact the brain is still developing hence the restriction of 21.

If my child thinks its ok to have sex at 16 I will be telling them to get a job and their own place, because they're not doing that under my roof. if you want to play like an adult behave like one. So many teen pregnancies and a lot of them stay with mummy and daddy, and bank of mum and dad pay for everything, and do most the childcare. if you're old enough to dabble in sex accept the responsibilities like an adult too.

Schwabischeweihnachtskanne · 04/03/2016 18:05

I think the argument that when you look back on your behaviour at 18 you think you lacked the maturity you thought you had and therefore 18 is a child makes less sense than those saying it assume, because for a lot of us looking back from our late 30s, 40s, 50s exactly the same could be said of ourselves at 25 tbh - you can't just not let anyone be an adult til they are 5 / 10 years younger than however old you happen to be at the time :o

16 is not an adult though it is not a child - 16-18 is an in between phase of young-adulthood, though I wouldn't have a problem with that young adult phase being 15-18 or even 14-18....

We live in Germany and my DD is the youngest in her school year - education is only compulsory for 9 years, and as she was still 5 (and 11 months) when she started school (which is unusualish) she could leave school at 14 (and 10 months). She won't, but she could.

I work with a very capabe, competent, mature young woman who has almost finished her 3 year apprenticeship as a specialist nursing home carer (I don't know what the equivalent would be in the UK, but it is a full time 3 year course with a mix of work and college, probably like an NVQ level 3 in health care - she can do a lot of things a nurse can do) .

She is 17. If she's not an adult then I'm probably not either, and I'm 40.

Owllady · 04/03/2016 17:59

Child

Pinkheart5915 · 04/03/2016 17:59

I think 16 is a child, I don't personally think you are mature enough to be classed as an adult until 18

BabyDubsEverywhere · 04/03/2016 17:57

I was 16 when I got with my exdh, he was 23, with a new born and a 2 year old... We were together for 5 years and got married, no children. It wasn't the best relationship in the world - obviously, as it ended, but it wasn't all bad either, we travelled the world together (with the youngest child, as she mainly lived with us from birth), we had a mortgage when I was 17! My friendship group was mainly male (same class from primary school who had grew up together) they were in no way ready for the sort of life I was living, but I was, I have no regrets as such.

I generally don't believe we should treat male/female too differently, but my own experiences go against those beliefs somewhat.

Would I want my own DD or DS with a partner so much older at 16, I really don't know - its not a definite no though, I would probably have to judge cases on their individual merits really.

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 04/03/2016 17:29

Youth ( or Yout as they said in "My Cousin Vinny" )

I have a 16yo DS and he is very much still a child IMO .

I read the first few posts on the other thread.

The sea would froth with blood if a 23yo with a child of their own took a shine to my DS Hmm

ZiggyFartdust · 04/03/2016 17:18

There is no context that makes a 16 year old an adult. There is context that can make them a very mature 16 year old, or the opposite, but that does not change anything.

merrymouse · 04/03/2016 17:16

Even a 16 year old who acts like an adult lacks experience and maturity and this makes them vulnerable.

AnyFucker · 04/03/2016 17:16

I don't care about any context. To me, a 16yo is a child and should be protected appropriately depending on the emotional maturity of the individual.

Both my kids have been emotionally immature at 16, despite their protestations to the contrary.

TrinityForce · 04/03/2016 17:10

It's the transition time from child to adult, so somewhere in between.

Actually sorry just realised there's a word for it, teenager Confused.

LordyGoodness · 04/03/2016 17:09

by any age, I of course mean 'adult' age!

LordyGoodness · 04/03/2016 17:08

Legally a child. Absolutely. I work in child protection, and we very definitely consider a 16 yr old a child (although obviously taking into account everything that goes with adolescence).

However, they are at the age of consent so can have sexual relationships with anyone of any age (although obviously someone in a position of trust - teacher etc - will face consequences professionally if they enter in anything of that nature).

ItsAllGoingToBeFine · 04/03/2016 17:07

Technically/legally I'd say they were an adult (in Scotland).

However, in reality I don't think adult should start until 21. I like the German system, when I run the country minors/children will be U15, Young people will be 15-20, adult 21+

Trills · 04/03/2016 17:04

That's a meaningless question without context.

Even legally, someone is considered an adult in some ways before they are an adult in other ways.

Fratelli · 04/03/2016 17:02

Child definitely.

ZiggyFartdust · 04/03/2016 16:58

You've started from a faulty premise, OP.

16 is a child, male or female. You've decided that "Mumsnet" as if that is an entity with one voice has said that 16 year old girls with older guys is ok, whereas the other way around is not. When in reality, only a handful of lobe voices said anything remotely like that.

All 16 year olds are children. Boys and girls. We know they are because we don't let them vote, live alone (generally), get married, leave school without permission, get credit or even drink in a pub. Because they are too young to make good choices and look after themselves properly.

I'm surprised anyone needs to ask, to be honest. Seems fairly fucking obvious to me.

Out2pasture · 04/03/2016 16:52

The brain continues to mature as well as the body well into the 20's.
The world has changed since laws were written 200years ago.
16 Child with the possibility of taking on some adult tasks.

SloaneRanger88 · 04/03/2016 16:35

When I was 16 I was in a relationship with a 25 year old, moved in with him and had a baby not long after I turned 17. Thanks to useless parents I grew up fast.

Samcro · 04/03/2016 16:33

these days children.
when I was 16 we were pretty much adults as had left school and were working ft.
not most kids are at school/6form untill 18/19