Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed that I seem to lack presence?

38 replies

Flamingoblue1 · 29/01/2016 20:42

Hello all. It's came to my attention that I appear to lack presence. I'm in quite a senior job and have been for a while. Never had an issues getting a job or getting on with colleagues. I, however, lack presence. I find that my point, although valid, often go overlooked and people talk over me. This has been a problem in all 4 jobs I've had in my career. Today it happened again and I feel that other people are stronger characters. I won't talk or run my mouth if I'm not right and don't like confrontation so maybe that's an issue. It's started to become apparent that I'm a weak person and that doesn't feel good

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Okaaaay · 26/03/2024 21:36

@Flamingoblue1 realise this is really old but I’m having the same issue and your post resonated. Did you take any action in the end (either to improve your presence or change your role)?

feckitall · 01/02/2016 11:23

I'm reading this with interest as I have the same problem...infuriating when people in management couldn't manage a tea party but have come in as managers from other companies. and clearly promoted the generally useless
I get the part about looking the part but when you wear a uniform then that's irrelevant.
I've worked on body language and I know others have said I'm more confident. The issue I have is I'm good at my job and because of poor management they have a high turnover of staff they just keep me there, or they are screwed.
I'm frustrated and bored but I do like where I work and the job is not bad. If I didn't need more money it would be easy to sit back and coast.

Its just very annoying to hear about the opportunities they offer to 20yr olds who then leave anyway when the reality is I'm overlooked because I'm middle-aged so they don't want to train me and I'm generally invisible as a result.

TurquoiseDress · 01/02/2016 09:30

Very interesting thread!
And some nice practical tips.

It's only when you realise that your behaviours/ways of expressing yourself in emails/writing send off a certain strong message (& not always a good one!), then you can do something positive to change it for the better.

RhiWrites · 01/02/2016 09:10

Perfect timing! You need 'Presence' by Amy Cuddy. She's awesome. Look up her TEDtalk and you'll see what I mean.

Her book's just out. Here's the link: amzn.to/1P5Lu4a

everdene · 01/02/2016 08:39

Putting Gravitas on my reading list! Great thread.

neolara · 01/02/2016 08:31

I was also going to recommend the book Gravitas..

pinkiponk · 01/02/2016 08:28

I'm loving this thread! As an officer in the armed forces it's difficult as a woman to have presence. Especially as I'm 5 foot nothing and am constantly surrounded by very tall men, the place whiffs of testosterone! I've taken on board so many of these tips, especially the 'head bob' I do this all. The. Time. And have tried to do it less, now I will really try as you're absolutely right, I think it does look desperate!
I really like the tips for meetings as well, pick a central seat and try and say something first.
This is one of the most relevant and fascinating threads I've read for a while!

ShotgunNotDoingThePans · 01/02/2016 00:55

This thread has reminded me that I must get around to looking into Transactionsl Analysis (alongside the other books/videos recommended). I'm Ok, You're Ok looks like a good place to start - might be worth a look, OP.

IguanaTail · 01/02/2016 00:06

Amy Cuddy has her first book out last week called "Presence" - it's good so far!

Keep your head still is my tip. Woman bob their heads about all the time to look empathetic and kind and unsure. It's very low-status but nobody ever tells us. Look at good speakers like Obama etc. They keep their heads still and although they do smile, there isn't a desperate "like me, please" smile all the time.

The thing that makes some men tough interviewers is the fact that they keep their heads still, they don't fanny around with little "fillers", their expression is neutral and they are more direct. Women, by default, try to please and bond. Try and stop that.

Destinysdaughter · 01/02/2016 00:00

This is such a fascinating thread!
Really want to read Gravitas book now!

LizardBreath · 31/01/2016 23:38

This a bit odd. But you know when someone talks over you, but you assume you know more/they are a bit of an arse. Just keep talking: I only ever back down if I assume the person I'm speaking to/ over, knows more than me and has a valid opinion. If not, I just keep on talking. Just do it. If you are right, people will listen.

FanDabbyFloozy · 31/01/2016 23:22

Here's a tip that helped me in this situation. Attend a meeting that is important for someone else and watch the dynamics. Are people routinely talked over? Do others start points that get ignored? It was a complete revelation to me that this happens all the time and not just to me. Other people just have thicker skin.

trixymalixy · 31/01/2016 23:22

Watching with interest.

HilarysMantelpiece · 31/01/2016 23:15

Flamingo...are you saying that it's just how you feel yourself, and not feedback from manager/mentor?

Have you heard of Impostor Syndrome

I like this quote..

"There's a fine line between self-deprecation and self-destruction"

The thing is....feeling 'good enough' is a decision you make. No-one can tell you that you are, because (if you're like me and many other women, I suspect) when someone tells you 'well done', or that you are admirable, there's a little voice in your head that counteracts it with 'no, no I'm not. If only you really knew'.

Feeling good enough then must be your decision to believe it- not look for evidence that you're not.

It's scary....there's almost a comfort in staying small and not believing in yourself. It becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy..
"I've not got presence, so people do't listen to me, so I don't talk, so I haven't got presence".

I don't think your issue is presence at all; I think it's fear of taking things to the next level of seniority (not judging you..but you asked).

Flamingoblue1 · 31/01/2016 15:54

Hello thanks all. This hasn't come from an appraisal: they've always been good I just feel dwarfed by people. Should change my name to mouse lol

OP posts:
Canyouforgiveher · 31/01/2016 15:45

Presence isn't something that you can cultivate. If you don't have it, tough.

Disagree completely. You can fake it if you don't have it naturally.

Some good advice on this thread already. here are some more tips I got from an executive coach.

  1. Dress really well and dress so you are comfortable too. So wear power clothes that make you look serious and senior but don't you require you to tug at your hem or fix your collar etc. Wear shoes that are comfortable enough that you can literally keep up with the pack, if a meeting/conversatioin is happening on the go.
  1. Like others said, don't use any qualifying words. "I think that" "perhaps we should consider" etc. At your next meeting notice how the louder confident people (men) don't do this. Say "we must look at our figures before we proceed" rather than "have we thought about looking at our figures because I was thinking that ... "
  1. if you feel you are being overlooked at a meeting but have something you want to contribute, get up from the table, walk over to get a glass of water, and then say your piece before you sit down again - you are more likely to be attended if you are the leadership/standing position.
  1. Get in first - as in ask the first question/make the first contribution. I forget where I read someone suggesting those of us not good at figures point out a particular line of the excel spreadsheet and say "could you explain the importance of these figures" I tried it. It is surprisingly effective at eliciting information.

Every single woman I know in business has had the experience of making a contribution, being ignored, and then listening to a man make the identical contribution and being praised for it. Many times. It is infuriating.

HilarysMantelpiece · 31/01/2016 15:34

I agree- it IS being a woman.. culturally and socialising into "helping" roles, Sheryl Sandberg being in a Wall Street office where none of "boys" knew where the ladies loo was (cos no woman had ever been there to ask).

Woman DO get heard less than men for saying THE EXACT SAME THING.

I've found that trying to compete with them doesn't work for me...what does work is learning how to go very still, quiet and powerful with absolute conviction of being in charge and being the most knowledgeable. Self-doubt is fatal.
I walk into a meeting and take up space immediately..I take the time to consider where I sit...as close to the centre of power as possible. I don't address the meeting, I may make my point to the chair only, recruiting them as my ally.

It sounds arrogant...and it is to an extent... but I keep my wobblies for my own office.

I'd love to continue this if you come back OP. You said you're in a senior position and it sounds as if this sense of lacking presence came from an appraisal?

InionEile · 30/01/2016 17:50

It's called being a woman. HTH Grin

Am only half-joking. I just have noticed in working life that women managers tend to get heard less than men and their ideas are often overlooked or attributed to someone else who has a penis

iamworkingonit · 30/01/2016 17:35

Hello Flamingoblue1 I can (unfortunately) identify with your problem, I am too often at staff meetings and will start to talk and someone will talk over the top of me. It is humiliating. I am about to google the books recommended and go from there. It is all very well for people who don't have this problem thinking it's not really anything to feel bad about but from my experience it isn't a great feeling.

redexpat · 29/01/2016 23:24

I was going to say try reading nice girls dont get the corner office.

GratuitousSaxandViolins · 29/01/2016 23:12

I second Gravitas as a book. Are you always so hard on yourself? Do you tend to up and down or have you felt like this constantly?

I only ask because I'm also in a senior position - sometimes I feel like superwoman and can do anything, sometimes I feel like everyone feels I'm rubbish, I don't feel as capable as others and that I'm out of my depth.

It's often a state of mind in my opinion and you'll be surprised at how many senior people feel this way. Alot are just good at pretending.

A simple trick I use is just smiling and saying hello to people as I walk around the office rather than keeping my head down and walking without interacting. I've seen others do it and it radiates confidence, presence and actually can gradually lift your own spirits.

Making your voice heard is covered really well in Gravitas.

thesandwich · 29/01/2016 22:20

Yes- patsy rodenburg book and YouTube stuff is excellent and what Hilary was talking about

Phineyj · 29/01/2016 21:59

The Patsy Rodenberg book is called Presence - it's very good and also practical.

HilarysMantelpiece · 29/01/2016 21:57

Gravitas by Caroline Goyder

HilarysMantelpiece · 29/01/2016 21:49

Above post not very coherent- had a sick child last night.

Ingredients are: deciding that you are as cut out for a senior role as anyone else. There is no magic dust that gets sprinkled on people who get there; they decide they want it and do the work to get there.

Some of that work is on their own internal dialogue.

Who are you to decide that you are not good enough?

Swipe left for the next trending thread