Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to date this guy?

231 replies

Destinysdaughter · 16/01/2016 22:11

I had a blind date tonight with a guy who seemed really nice online and he turned up to the pub and he was in a wheelchair! He hadn't mentioned his disability before so I was a bit taken aback by it. He was nice but don't think I want to date someone in a wheelchair. Does that make me a v shallow person? He broke his back in a motorbike accident when he was 30, is 50 now. He was nice company but I do feel annoyed that he didn't mention this at all before we met. I feel bad about not wanting to meet him again, I'd be happy to see him again as a friend but as sex would be impossible, I don't see it being a relationship. What would you do?

OP posts:
wannaBe · 18/01/2016 07:30

The issue here isn't necessarily the fact that someone might not want to date someone with a disability. The issue is that there seems to be an expectation that the disabled somehow have a responsibility to declare that disability up-front in case the non-disabled might find it uncomfortable/so they can choose not to be associated with that person. But actually, anyone's discomfort over a disability is their responsibility not that of the disabled person.

If you choose not to date disabled people then that is your prerogative. However, if you make those kinds of choices then it is up to you to own them, not the disabled person for being blamed for not declaring their disability up-front.

And the ultimate realisation here is that you have a choice whether to date a disabled person. The disabled person didn't have a choice over whether to be disabled or not.

Reality is that society doesn't want to see able bodied people dating the disabled as normal. Programmes like the undatables on channel4 exist to emphasise that fact. Should either of the two people with facial disfigurements have to make that clear up-front in case someone doesn't want to date them? Obviously they should, otherwise they wouldn't have to go on programmes the title of which confirms that nobody actually wants them. Hmm

GeordieBadger · 17/01/2016 19:41

He might have functioning use of his penis, but perhaps requires his partners to "do all the work"? That would turn me off tbh. Call me what you like.

TopHat33 · 17/01/2016 19:01

Cannot imagine he would be on a swinging site if he's not up for having sex...which probably means he's perfectly capable in that department. To start making assumptions is pretty daft and yabu.

and....if you met on a swinging site and are looking for physical fun couldn't you just ask him about sex and what he's up for?

Supermanspants · 17/01/2016 18:10

Oh, and I did just pick out a bunch of random attributes based on a thread that was on here a while back Smile

Supermanspants · 17/01/2016 18:08

I think they do itsbetter. Obviously everyone is different and certainly there are those who have utterly ridiculous expectations. Bit then OLD facilities that level of pickiness because of the way it is set up IMO
I was ditched because I had two kids (one would have been ok apparently Hmm )where I lived and the best one, I wasn't 'sophisticated' enough (something to do with opera, art galleries and wearing dresses)
In an ideal world it would be like the film Shallow Hal.
I suppose OLD is a bit like a shopping list in some respects. Plus it is a case of one thing that someone may not like and it's 'Next'

itsbetterthanabox · 17/01/2016 17:56

Superman none of those things would put me off someone if I liked them as a person. Do people genuinely think like that?
Except maybe being a right winger but that is having a completely different set of values to me. I would still talk to and get to know the person but if they were ultimately a selfish person I wouldn't like them. That is not superficial however. The rest of your list would have no bearing on whether I liked a person.

Supermanspants · 17/01/2016 17:43

Ultimately, as had been pointed out by previous posters, people know what they like and know what they don't like when it comes to dating. That can be a whole raft of attributes including disability.

You also could argue that not wanting to date someone again because they were too old/too young, they were of a certain height, they had kids, they were a rampant right winger, their hair was a certain colour, their hands were incredibly small, they were unemployed, they worked in a low skilled profession, they spoke with a certain accent blah blah blah are also shallow reasons to not date someone but why do dating websites have search filters?

Does it make someone a nasty, bad person because they do not wish to date/shag someone with a disability?? How is that attribute any different to any of the other reasons to not date someone (and yes, on the face of it many ARE pretty superficial in the eyes of others but it does mean they deserve a good kicking for it)

By the same token, people with seen and unseen disabilities do date successfully and are in long term r'ships. Why shouldn't they be.

Supermanspants · 17/01/2016 17:26

I wonder how 'perfect' you are, OP
Hmm

itsbetterthanabox · 17/01/2016 17:08

Mutton you should be nice to anyone. Especially someone who is ill. Don't Sex with them if you don't want to. Having sex isn't being nice. Being a nice person is being nice. If he wasn't nice to you then fair enough leave him but him being ill, or 'infirm' wasn't the problem here.
I feel sad for the partners of people on this thread. If they get seriously ill they've got to battle that and deal with your disgust of them.

scarlets · 17/01/2016 16:58

I reckon you should go on another date if you're unsure. If this man is suited to you, it would seem a shame to let a knee jerk reaction get in the way. Give him a call!

Cinnamon2013 · 17/01/2016 16:51

I wonder how 'perfect' you are, OP.

MuttonWasAGoose · 17/01/2016 16:45

I think I personally have a fear of infirmity. Years ago I'd just begun dating a man when he was struck by Guilliame Barré syndrome. (An autoimmune disorder, I think, that paralyses). I wasn't all that crazy about the guy but felt bad for him and continued to see him for a while. He was wasted and emaciated for a while, but slowly recovered. But it was a big turn off while he had stick limbs and could only move weakly. Because I was young and stupid and thought it was my duty to be nice to men, I would have sex with him, concealing my revulsion. I'm shuddering thinking of it now. As it turned out he was a manipulative twat and I dumped him with no guilt. But I still feel angry when I remember how I used to think I "had" to be "nice."

I'm not nice anymore.

To be fair, my horror of infirmity includes myself. When I broke my arm, I was unable to look at it or even look at the x-rays.

itsbetterthanabox · 17/01/2016 16:33

What other disabilities should people disclose in case it makes you awkward? Visually impaired? Deaf? An amputee? A glass eye? A stutter? Dyslexia? When is it ok not qualify that someone else is ok with you not being 'perfect'?

ApplePaltrow · 17/01/2016 16:23

A lot of people on this thread seem like the kind of people who would spend twenty minutes describing a person's physical appearance in increasingly awkward ways because they don't want to use the word "black".

I wish there was a middle ground between being nasty and being holier than thou. Because threads like these would make me LESS likely to want to date anyone who used a wheelchair since apparently discomfort = bigotry.

MaisyMooMoo · 17/01/2016 16:05

I've only skimmed through most of this but I don't for one minute think it was a casual sex/swinging site. When you read the OP statement it really doesn't give that impression at all. I think the OP started getting slated and decided to back track in some way. That's just my opinion.

WhatALoadOfOldBollocks · 17/01/2016 13:18

The only experience I have of a man who uses a wheelchair was a hook-up. He was paralysed from the chest down (after a motorbike accident) and had no sexual function apart from slightly sensitive nipples. He wasn't able to get an erection but was able to use his hands and mouth. This was OK as a one-off but wouldn't have suited me in a relationship because my favourite part of sex is for the man to get on top and fuck me. And sorry, but I would assume (rightly or wrongly) that a man using a wheelchair couldn't get on top and fuck me because that involves the use of legs as support.

user7755 · 17/01/2016 12:13

The assumption that being accepting and non-judgemental and caring about people is unusual, is sad. Fortunately it doesn't reflect my experience of the world.

The tendency for people to use the words passive aggressive and disingenuous to silence people who have an alternative view from them on here is disappointing. I wonder what would happen if a woman posted on here that her husband shut her opinions down by using those strategies?

We are all adults (i think), we are all capable of understanding that the world does not exist according to our belief system.

PaulAnkaTheDog · 17/01/2016 12:13

Well said NN.

JollyXmasJumper · 17/01/2016 12:12

I wonder how many authors of bitchy comments are currently dating here.. Going on a date and finding out the person you have been messaging is in a wheelchair is not something most of us expect. So yeah, it does come across as a shock.

Whether it would be a turn off really depends on the dynamic of the date. And do not get me wrong, I think that man is perfectly entitled not to disclose his disability if he wants to. He probably is totally aware he is playing Russian roulette here.

Anyhow OP, whether he is able to have sex or not is not the question here. Fact is it was a turn off to you, so you are not attracted to him. Meaning if you keep dating him it won't come from a place of attraction but pity. And that is not a good starting point for anything.

Much as with anyone else, this is time for the "no spark" text.

NNalreadyinuse · 17/01/2016 12:11

I would not date someone who I knew to have mental health issues. I just wouldn't want to take on all the additional problems it causes in life, when I could meet someone I was just as attracted to, who didn't come with those problems.

As for being on a wheelchair, that in itself wouldn't be an issue for me on a hook up site. My main concern would be physical attraction. If I was looking for a long term relationship, then I would want early disclosure abour anything which was likely to impact on my life. So genetic conditions, if I wanted to have dc, whether a potential partner would need a carer and whether they saw me as fulfilling that role.Tbh, I wouldn't want to take that on. So these things would affect my choices on a dating site.

If I knew someone in my everyday life and grew to love them and they had disabilities, that would be different, I think, because I already knew them and cared about them.

On a dating site, I don't think anyone should be condemned for wanting the easier life.

mrsjskelton · 17/01/2016 12:11

Hmmm for a "hook up" site I don't really think it was necessary for him to mention a disability. As in, which disabilities could you get away with not talking about - a mental health issue? He wanted to find a hook up presumably not a relationship... If he was looking for a life partner I'd have been disappointed at him not coming forward about the disability first IMO, I think that's of similar importance to whether you already have kids as there's life choices to be discussed here.

itsbetterthanabox · 17/01/2016 12:06

They met for a drink. Not immediate sex. If you meet someone and don't feel comfortable going back to their house then that's that whether they are disabled or not. So what that they may need to only be there. Get to know them then. If you feel so unsafe with a person that you can't go to their house then you shouldn't take then to yours either!

Aeroflotgirl · 17/01/2016 12:01

If dh feel ill that would be different, but if I was looking at a serious relationship, that would be a factor.

Quiero · 17/01/2016 11:58

My mam broke her back and was paralysed from the waist down and used a wheelchair.

Unless my brothers are a figment of my imagination, I think she could have sex.

Aeroflotgirl · 17/01/2016 11:58

In op case it is a casual sex site, well with the wird swinging in, so I would not have been bothered about disability, but if I was dating I would have to think carefully and the level of disability. Like lockheart has said, it is not easy. My cousin has MS and is in a wheelchair, deteriorating physically, his elderly mum is looking after him as he never had a relationship or kids, it is physically hard and exhausting work.

Swipe left for the next trending thread