Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think children aren't that fussed about the size of their house?

133 replies

UterusUterusGhali · 05/11/2015 11:57

Had an interesting discussion with my BF last night.

He is adamant it's cruel to have children if you aren't able to give them their own room and loads of space etc.

I think you can be poor and live in a small house still be happy.

BF grew up in a large Georgian town house with 6 bedrooms, a library etc.
I grew up in a council house.
BF thinks it's odd that my boys share a bedroom. (He has no DC)
I've said that lots of families live like this, but he thinks overcrowding causes MH issues. Hmm

AIBU thinking kids don't mind living in a cosy home, as long as their needs are met?

OP posts:
sugar21 · 05/11/2015 13:53

I had my own room in a big house and I'm an only child. Hated it, I wanted siblings like everyone else and hated that I was shunted off to boarding school just to fufill my DPs ambitions for me. Didn't bother to ask me if I wanted to go to that god awful place. Wasn't allowed to play outside in the holidays and any friends were vetted by MI5.
I don't think it matters how big your house is so long as their is love in it

Osmiornica · 05/11/2015 13:51

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Bubbletree4 · 05/11/2015 13:48

I think children under 10 and children over 10 are in different categories here.

My children (7 and 9) happily sleep in the same room. They actually have a room each but prefer to be together. So we aren't "overcrowded" but the kids choose to be.

My ds has a friend who has a gigantic house and my dc1 was terrified of it! My dc2 has a friend with a massive house but thought it was great to explore. So, difficult to say really. Dc1 also has a friend living in small flat and very happily slept over on the floor of the main room.

I think teens ideally would need more space and privacy but we aren't at that stage yet.

Donnerwetter · 05/11/2015 13:47

I agree that it brings people together, makes you feel more of a unit.
We also live in a nice area - it would be harder if we were stuck in a horrible one.

Artandco · 05/11/2015 13:40

I don't think so. We have a one bed flat and children.
It brings us closer at home I feel, and makes us be proactive about getting out and going places and doing things.
The huge benefits are location so everything walking distance, and therefore everything to go and explore is right on our doorstep.

Holstein · 05/11/2015 13:39

I think it makes a big difference actually. We moved from a two-up, two-down to a fourbed detached. The effect on the children was huge- they grew inches in the first few months, were calmer, happier, more relaxed etc. Our income remained the same. Quality of life is now just far better.

INeedACheeseSlicer · 05/11/2015 13:37

I think everyone needs some space to get away sometimes, from the rest of the family.
But I don't think that space needs to be your own bedroom.
Communal spaces can be private if you are the only one in them, and the rest of the household can respect other's needs to be quiet and alone sometimes.

We have a 2 bedroom flat, and 2 DC. DC1 will sometimes retreat to the (shared) children's bedroom to get away from it all. I will then encourage DC2 to leave them alone and to play in the living room instead.

If I want a bit of peace I tend to retreat to the kitchen, as does DH (obviously it doesn't work if we are both in there!)
At the moment, DC2 is still young and tends to want to be around others rather than behind a closed door - but if the time comes in the future when both DC need somewhere to go, then one can use our bedroom during the day - neither DH or I ever really enter it except at bedtime anyway. They will need to negotiate who goes in which room - but negotiating skills are a good thing Grin.

I think that sharing can also be very positive for sibling relationships.

stubbornstains · 05/11/2015 13:35

I'd say it's outside space that's most important. 4 years ago I moved into a tiny little dolls' house cottage with DS1- then 16 months. Now I have DS2 (5 months), and DS1 is a massively energetic 5.5 years...and we have a tiny, tiny back yard. We need a proper garden so badly, to stop DS1 quite literally bouncing off the walls (this is after a typical day of school followed by club, or a typical weekend involving a trip to the woods or beach Hmm). DS1 is pretty keen to share with his little brother, but his box room has a sloping ceiling, so you couldn't fit 2 beds in there.

There are normally houses coming up for rental quite regularly in our village, but for the last couple of months there's been nothing- I'm going mad! Plus, I bid on some new social housing last week, but don't think I got it Sad.

evilcherub · 05/11/2015 13:34

Unfortunately sharing is going to become the norm seeing as most young families have been priced out of anything resembling decent sized accommodation!

Orrla · 05/11/2015 13:31

I shared with a sister and we hated each other. But it taught us to respect the need for personal space and how to share and compromise that stands us in good stead as adults. We don't have issues as a result.

I also know a family who had 6 children, mixed genders, a grandmother (who had her own room!) and set of parents all living in one three bedroomed house, where there were mixed genders in the bedrooms until late teens and are now close friends and enjoy each other's company as adults with their own families. None have mental health issues and have successful careers and social lives and are respectful of other's privacy and kind and thoughtful people.

HorseyCool · 05/11/2015 13:31

I misread this as "Size of their horse".

Anyhow size of house only becomes an issue if privacy and independence are being compromised, normally in older children.

Otherwise children just accept it generally as the norm. I shared a room with Dsis as a child, out of choice as we were really close and got on well, I only went off to my own room when I was older and fancied it, around 10-11 I think.

I know someone who has just found out her 1 bed room flat is being rented out to a family of 5, 2 adults and 3 under 5. I don't think that this could be comfortable for anyone.

elementofsurprise · 05/11/2015 13:31

WHy are PP's saying "Oh, it was fine for us! No harm done!" when they stopped sharing at 8-10? That's when it really starts to matter and presumably what the OP's BF is on about!

FWIW I shared until the age of 11 when my parents decided it was better for me to have the box room and my younger DS and DB share (their room was later divided). One of the main reasons was me being very tidy whilst my sister was messy, it used to make me really stressed and anxious. I actually remember my parents telling me I was getting the box room - that's how exciting it was for me! I was overjoyed.

I suppose it depends on the children in question though. Ideally the option should be there. I don't think OP's BF is being "spoilt", just gong by what he's observed.

Donner Just thinking about sharing one room with my family growing up makes me anxious! Nooooo way! I reckon it would be ok now though... but when you're a teen there'd be no freedom... Confused

GasLIghtShining · 05/11/2015 13:28

I shared with my two sisters and then in my teens we moved and I shared with one of them. I was about 16ish before I had a room of my own. I also went to boarding school which involved sharing and didn't get a room on my own until sixth form

ouryve · 05/11/2015 13:26

DeoGratias - your house is 5-6 times the size of a typical 3 bed! It's not a little bigger, it's flipping enormous!

SnozzberryPie · 05/11/2015 13:25

I shared a room with my sister and tbh it wasn't ideal, especially during the teenage years. We also didn't really have any quiet space in the house to do homework or bring friends home. This was quite normal where I grew up but I do think it led to my friends and I hanging around on the streets a lot and getting up to all sorts of mischief. I personally wouldn't plan to have more kids than I could give their own bedrooms, but life doesn't always go to plan and sharing a room is not the worst thing that can happen!

Damselindestress · 05/11/2015 13:25

My younger brother was unplanned despite our mum being on very effective contraception. My parents had already purchased a small, 2 up, 2 down house and couldn't afford to move. I shared a bedroom with my brother till I was 13. We took turns getting changed in the bathroom. I didn't feel that I had one tiny scrap of private space to myself growing up and it was extremely frustrating, so yes some children are absolutely 'fussed' about not having their own room, maybe not when they are younger and sharing can be fun but if they are older and still forced to share for financial reasons. I know there are much worse situations but it definitely wasn't ideal. Sometimes these situations are unavoidable but I don't think they should be romanticised in a sort of 'our house is small but full of love' way, it's uncomfortable, undesirable and should be avoided if possible.

ouryve · 05/11/2015 13:22

We're in a house with 2 decent sized bedrooms and have 2 boys. Unfortunately, they are now struggling with sharing a room. Their sleep patterns and habits are disruptive to each other and it doesn't help that they both have ASD and a big need for space and do not get on at all.

For most kids, there are worse things than having to share a room with a sibling, though. Some even like it!

BeautifulLiar · 05/11/2015 13:18

I agree with you.

I grew up in a huge detached house with my own bedroom/bathroom (well, until my mum turfed me out into the smaller room because I was arrogant Hmm).

DH grew up in small council houses and always shared bedrooms. His childhood was full of love whereas mine contained none.

It makes me feel less bad that my DC share... we'll have three girls in one room when baby is here!!

LaContessaDiPlump · 05/11/2015 13:16

Interesting thread. We have a 3-bed with a loft space that we will put stairs up to, so loads of space for our 2 DC (3.3 and 4.4) to colonise. However, they very rarely leave the same room that we're in; they trail around after DH and I and whinge if left alone. We have a large open-plan living room that leads down to the kitchen, so you can see all the areas from the sofa. I find it rather chaotic as I grew up with a large sterile bedroom of my own that no-one else ever entered. I must admit I sometimes hide in the loo for private time Blush I am looking forward to the days when they discover a sense of privacy and leave me alone for 5 minutes tbh.

I think your bf is taking it rather far though op.

Nicky333 · 05/11/2015 13:14

I grew up in a 3 bedroom house and my sister (3.5 years younger than me) and I shared a room and a double bed until I was about 9 or 10, when I moved into the smaller third bedroom. No harm has come to us.

Apart from when my sister was sick in the night once, all over her hair and a bit on me and my pillow...

29herzie · 05/11/2015 13:08

Following the arrival of DC2 I have been surprised how many people have commented on us not expecting them to share a room. We have 4 bedrooms so made sense to us to combine the office and spare room so that the new baby could have his own room. ( Or more importantly his big sister could have her own space) but loads of people seem to think we should have made them share and kept the office where it was. Seems very strange to me - I'd have no problems with them sharing if we were short on space but think if we can give them a room each it will be best.

thelittleredhen · 05/11/2015 13:06

Your BF sounds a lot like one of my exes - we broke up because our views on life were too different.

Fantastic in many other ways, but I couldn't get past how bloody spoilt he was. Is.

SisterNancySinatra · 05/11/2015 13:06

My sil's adult kids still live with her in tiny council house and have screened off the bedroom they share so they can both have double beds with the boyfriends .

SheGotAllDaMoves · 05/11/2015 13:00

Personally I think it's better for DC to have some personal space, especially teens.

But it's hardly the end of the world if they don't.

Donnerwetter · 05/11/2015 12:59

I wonder about this more than most. Due to some very bad luck my 2 children (age 13 and 10) and I share a very small flat, including sharing 1 bedroom. This was meant to be a short term arrangement, but we have been stuck with it for a while.
Most of the time it is fine. We have always gone out a lot, as the children have loads of interests, and the time spent at home is largely spent curled up on the sofa having family time watching TV or whatever. I leave the bedroom to the children during the day, and they chill out there. But it's a pity that there is only one family room, with the kitchen being open plan to the lounge diner, which severely limits the options for having some time away from the rest of the family! On the other hand, you can always pop out for a walk, or go to the park.
I think that living in such a small space arguably brings us closer together, though the children fighting for the best place on the sofa is wearing me down.
I think it is totally fine for children to share a bedroom - my 2 always have.
Did anyone watch the American TV series where they took some rich families who lived in very large houses, and got them to live as settlers for a few weeks, with each family living in a one roomed house? They came to love it, and to grow much closer as families.