Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think children aren't that fussed about the size of their house?

133 replies

UterusUterusGhali · 05/11/2015 11:57

Had an interesting discussion with my BF last night.

He is adamant it's cruel to have children if you aren't able to give them their own room and loads of space etc.

I think you can be poor and live in a small house still be happy.

BF grew up in a large Georgian town house with 6 bedrooms, a library etc.
I grew up in a council house.
BF thinks it's odd that my boys share a bedroom. (He has no DC)
I've said that lots of families live like this, but he thinks overcrowding causes MH issues. Hmm

AIBU thinking kids don't mind living in a cosy home, as long as their needs are met?

OP posts:
PennyPants · 05/11/2015 17:37

I hated sharing and we never had enough space downstairs. I wouldn't have said it was cruel though, we had a happy childhood. All except the youngest left home in our teens, so we didn't hang around Smile .
Since having Dc they've had their own room, so of course they always wanted to share when younger and thought it so exciting to have sleepovers in each other's rooms! Now they are teens we have a bigger house and they have their own den with TV etc that they can hang out with friends. We all get our own space.

Jux · 05/11/2015 16:46

While I shared a room with my brothers, dressing wasn't a problem. When we were small we shared baths and got into pjs in the bathroom (house drafty and only paraffin heaters in rooms). I still don't remember dressing being an issue when we were older either, but mum put me in the tiny bedroom when I was 10/11 but I think even then we were pretty free about wandering in and out of each others' rooms. Turn a back, grab something to drape around you if we felt like it.

No real awkwardness or embarrassment until well into puberty, and that includes when my or brothers' mates were round.

I'm not a nudist as an adult. I'm nothing like as free and easy as my upbringing might imply! I seem to be pretty normal in that regard, don't like communal changing rooms in shops, swimming baths etc. Don't wander round naked at home embarrassing dd's friends. Now, there's a thought .... Grin

honkinghaddock · 05/11/2015 16:42

I shared with two siblings and I think that was overcrowding.

honkinghaddock · 05/11/2015 16:39

If ds who has severe asd and doesn't sleep had to share with a sibling, it would be very unfair on him and the sibling. Generally sharing with one sibling is ok.

Arfarfanarf · 05/11/2015 16:37

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

AutumnLeavesArePretty · 05/11/2015 16:32

I think most children benefit from having their own space. They need privacy, quite time for homework and have individual tastes and their rooms should reflect that.

I'm with your boyfriend, I'd rather have less children and more space and time than a crowded house with little time.

INeedACheeseSlicer · 05/11/2015 16:27

I shared a room until I was late teens. I don't remember getting un/dressed ever being an issue - I can't even remember what we did.

Maybe I got dressed while my sister was in the bathroom? Or maybe I shut the door and so she knew not to open it when I was getting dressed and vice versa. Maybe she was already asleep when I came to bed?

I really have no recollection, (which probably shows how much of a non-issue it was).

howabout · 05/11/2015 16:08

It is cold and wet and dark and miserable for large parts of the year in my part of Scotland. Outside space in the form of private garden in need of constant upkeep is of questionable benefit. Can you tell I'm sitting looking at the rain?

Differentnamesameface · 05/11/2015 15:47

Massive 2 bedroom part of house here, but no garden (2 young DC, opposite gender but will eventually share the biggest room which can easily have a stud wall put up and they will still get a decent space / window each)

We are in London and literally spitting distance of a lovely, big park so outside space hasn't been an issue.

BoboChic · 05/11/2015 15:43

I have a friend with six DDs. When the DDs were all at still at home, they lived in large rambling properties - a huge turn of the century apartment in Berlin, a massive maison de maître near the Fontainebleau forest. It was all very romantic with lots of art and culture (father is an actor, mother an Afghan-Persian-Jewish goddess sort). There were far more bedrooms than children, yet they always slept in groups of 2/3/4 per room, moving around the house seemingly at will.

fiverabbits · 05/11/2015 15:38

I have been on these type of threads before to say that at 64 years old I have never had a BED to myself never mind a bedroom. I grew up with 3 sisters we shared 2 double beds in the biggest bedroom, parents had the middle room and DBro had the boxroom. THEN I got married and have been for 43 years. We don't have a spare room as have adult DD and DS still living at home. I share the living room with everyone and the kitchen hasn't got room for a chair in it. My DH had 2 DBro and 3DSis in a 3 bedroom house with only a outside loo. We have 2 bathrooms which I consider even more important than bedrooms.

BurkiniBody · 05/11/2015 15:04

I'm an only child so I never had to share a room however I was always really ashamed of my parents house. It was small compared with others and horribly decorated. I used to avoid bringing people back for tea because of it.

My DH is one of three and had to share with his brother. He absolutely hated it and I think part of his resentment of his parents is because of this. Well, in fact, I know it is; he says it very openly. His mindset is 'why did they have children that they didn't have room for'.

Hatethis22 · 05/11/2015 14:43

For those that have lived through it, how do older DC that share a room get any privacy? I wouldn't have wanted to be getting changed in front of my siblings. Also, what about the number one teenage pastime? Do teenage boys who share a room just lock themselves in the loo for hours?

Hatethis22 · 05/11/2015 14:38

I think it depends on the individual children.

Some adults need plenty of personal space and time alone to feel content. Others thrive on having people around them most of the time and feel happier with company. Why would children be any different?

Jux · 05/11/2015 14:34

I shared with my brothers until we were quite old. We grew up in a Victorian house, with 8 very large bedrooms, and one very small bedroom. Our house was full of people for years, parent's friends who'd fallen on hard times, relatives who needed somewhere to stay longterm etc.

I was moved into the small bedroom when I was about 10. Gradually fewer people needed somewhere to stay, and by the time I was 15ish we all had our own rooms.

It was really fun sharing with my brothers. I missed it when it stopped (though when we had friends to stay, we'd just all use sleeping bags and sleep on the floor of the same room -up to a dozen kids/early teens on the floor!).

TimeToMuskUp · 05/11/2015 14:29

DH and SIL can disprove this theory; they grew up in an enormous, stable, middle-class house in a lovely suburb. One of them (DH) turned out bright, articulate and tremendously successful in his chosen field. SIL turned out an utter lunatic. Can't get more different than that.

I had a chaotic childhood with many different homes and no space of my own, so I'm very determined not to allow that to happen to the DCs. Ironically, though, we bought a lovely big house so that the DCs had space and time for themselves yet they spend 90% of their time at home together. DS1 has bunk beds and most evenings they're both in there at bedtime. I think it's lovely that they want to share but maintain that having separate rooms will make life easier when they reach their teens.

febda · 05/11/2015 14:27

We have a one bed flat and two teens and they are happy sharing a room. They aren't materialistic or concerned about how their home looks to their peers, and they're doing well at school, well adjusted etc, so I don't see any signs it has damaged them.

JimmyGreavesMoustache · 05/11/2015 14:27

we live in a small 2.5 bedroom house
technically each DC has their own room, but one of the bedrooms makes Harry Potter's cupboard under the stairs look like an aircraft hanger. we don't have a spacious downstairs either. I think it's fine that we're rather cosily crammed in, but I do like that each DC can get some personal space, even if that space is very small. the child in the box room is also welcome to spend time playing or watching TV in my room if I'm not in it and they want some more space.

howabout · 05/11/2015 14:26

Surprised at all the references to teens needing their own space. Social withdrawal is one of the big risk factors for teenage mental health. Too much personal space can encourage this. When I went to Uni many moons ago the Halls of Residence didn't allocate single rooms to 1st years because of this.

Dachshund · 05/11/2015 14:20

I can only speak for myself, and as an only child I never had to share a bedroom, but I grew up in a series of small houses, including multiple year-long rentals, and felt ashamed of my home compared to my friends who all lived in lovely 3 bed plus town houses.

I'd say it's about context. My homes were always comfortable and more than enough for a family of three, but I was the poorest of my peers and friends by quite an obvious margin and that has affected me to this day.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 05/11/2015 14:17

I do think personal space is important. We've moved from a 2 bed flat to 4 bed house with garden. The DC still share (boys aged 8 & 12) but they have the option not to.

The reduction in the stress levels for the whole family was noticeable when we moved. People can get away from each other, the DC can play more freely (rough and tumble games don't really work if you only have one communal space and nerf gun battles are a pain in the arse literally) and if someone wants peace and quiet they don't have to lock themselves in the loo.

I think even if you don't have much space, carving out a bit of space that allows people to escape if they need to makes a big difference. I used to sit in the corridor of our flat to read because it was a quiet space.

imwithspud · 05/11/2015 14:16

We actually moved from a 3-bed end of terrace in a crap area to a 2-bed semi in a nice area when I was pregnant with dd2. For us, sacrificing the third bedroom for a nicer house (bigger downstairs and huge garden), and a better area with good schools and a general better quality of life was absolutely worth it.

There 2.5 years between them and I figured they'll be okay sharing for the foreseeable future. But their room isn't the biggest, and whilst it will be fine whilst they're young and I'm hoping they will get along, I'm not sure it will be big enough for both of them as they approach pre-teen/teenage years when they will want friends round and privacy. Fortunately we've got a long time before we cross that bridge.

x2boys · 05/11/2015 14:08

well my boys are buggered then we live in a two bed council house the boys share a room ds2 has autism and learning disabillities clearly we are cruel parents for inflicting this on themHmm incidentally my dad grew up in a three bed terrace three girls in one room three boys in another all have been very successful and dont seem to have any problems.

Anomaly · 05/11/2015 14:08

I had my own room so did my brother and sisters. Our house was very big with massive garden. Didn't stop my brother developing serious ongoing mental health issues. Both my mum and sister have struggled with their mental health too. Family dynamics are far more important for long term good mental health than whether you share a room or not.

HormonalHeap · 05/11/2015 14:02

I think when little, childrens' happiness doesn't come from space or a big house. It absolutely comes from family, security, stimulation and love. The problem is more long term.. apart from preferring privacy when teenagers, they do compare their lives to those of their friends, and yes I know one of life's lessons is that some people have more.. but I wouldn't put my children into an environment where there was a dramatic difference in lifestyle between them and their contemporaries. Shallow maybe, but that's something I would think about. If it's just a short term problem though I wouldn't be too worried.