Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think children aren't that fussed about the size of their house?

133 replies

UterusUterusGhali · 05/11/2015 11:57

Had an interesting discussion with my BF last night.

He is adamant it's cruel to have children if you aren't able to give them their own room and loads of space etc.

I think you can be poor and live in a small house still be happy.

BF grew up in a large Georgian town house with 6 bedrooms, a library etc.
I grew up in a council house.
BF thinks it's odd that my boys share a bedroom. (He has no DC)
I've said that lots of families live like this, but he thinks overcrowding causes MH issues. Hmm

AIBU thinking kids don't mind living in a cosy home, as long as their needs are met?

OP posts:
Longcovid21 · 22/01/2022 21:15

It's not about the size of the house but the atmosphere in it. My dcs lived in a big house with a terrible atmosphere when me and their dad were together, now we live in a small, warm cozy house with just me and them. I'd love to live in a bigger place but the former would have been worse long term.

Wavypurple · 22/01/2022 21:13

‘Cruel’ is an interesting choice of words Hmm

Mumsmet · 22/01/2022 21:10

Sorry, I think I have resurrected an old post.

CamomileTeabag · 22/01/2022 20:53

Children don't generally mind sharing. Teenagers might though, especially if their friends have their own rooms.
DD does have her own room but has changed schools for 6th form and is now going to a school in a much wealthier area and I think it's become clear to her that our [albeit cosy & pretty] home is pretty modest compared to most of her new friends.

TheSnowyOwl · 22/01/2022 20:43

I wouldn’t want older children sharing if it could be helped. At the moment, two of mine share because they want to but that has worked out well for us as it means we’ve been able to have two offices and a play room for the pandemic. Once they stop sharing, we’ll have to rethink the layout of the house.

safclass · 22/01/2022 20:39

I was one of 4 kids in a 3 bed terrace. Brother had the very small box room and me and 2 sisters (1 older 1 younger shared). I think we spent so much time playing out etc you didn't need your separate space as much. Bedroom was pretty much for sleeping in, occasionally played in it, whereas now it's also a 'daytime' room.
Never had issues sharing, and as siblings grew up and moved out, I ended up living at home and sharing with my son (teen mum).
I worked out that I was around 30 when I slept in a room on my own for the very first time 😲 when my husband went on a school residential! Much prefer sharing!

Mumsmet · 22/01/2022 19:05

My BF used to belittle my rented home. I gave it up, moved into his home and married him and he's been financially controlling ever since. Currently trying to divorce him....

Imogentlasting · 06/11/2015 12:41

I shared with my older sister until she left home. It did cause a lot of rows and arguments when we were in our teens, but it didn't kill us. I'm sure my parents often wished they could give us separate rooms for the sake of peace and quiet, but I don't think it would ever have been a major consideration in considering the number of children they wanted.
The 'cruelty' implication is very silly. When I was a child it wasn't unusual for 3 or 4 children to share a bedroom.

DepecheNO · 06/11/2015 12:37

Children usually don't mind. Sharing as teens is a different story. I had to share with DB until I was fourteen, and to make matters worse I was used to having my own room at DF's. I.m.o. that was absolutely neglectful, but stepfather was abusive so it wasn't much better when we weren't sharing. Also not so much a male/female issue there as general privacy.

I think it was assumed that as a girl I would not be masturbating. (As it happened, I was a prude at that age.) Had this out with DM a few years ago when I questioned why she'd started knocking before entering DB's room but never mine. (He's younger. I was 19!)

In spite of the above, I couldn't be with someone who judges me openly over something like this.

madmomma · 06/11/2015 11:39

I did both and liked both. And I agree with the poster who said everyone has to suck it up.

UterusUterusGhali · 06/11/2015 10:55

Nah, Deo, he wants babies. Just not with me I think.
There's a bit of a back story to what sparked the debate, but that's another thread. :(

OP posts:
DeoGratias · 06/11/2015 09:04

Ut, many men don't want children until forced into it, so the boyfriend saying he won't have children until not only are your existing children housed but the new one could be is really just him saying no babies.

imwithspud · 06/11/2015 08:31

Many years ago whole families used to share one room, I'm sure most weren't mentally damaged as a result. Having a room each is a nice luxury, great if you have the room, but not the end of the world if not.

treaclesoda · 06/11/2015 08:18

I'm only 40 and when I was growing up everyone I knew shared a bedroom with their siblings if they were the same sex. No one thought anything of it. And I didn't go to school in an area where people lived in small houses, very much the opposite. I'm trying hard to think of a friend from school who didn't share a bedroom and I am struggling. The only one I can think of was a friend who was an only child. But she was the only person I knew who was an only child, so she really stood out.

I know plenty of people didn't like it, but I'm not sure I would go so far as to say that it actively damaged their mental health. If that were the case, almost everyone of my generation and older would have suffered terribly through their childhoods.

imwithspud · 06/11/2015 08:08

Sometimes there's no choice though.

Whatthefoxgoingon · 06/11/2015 00:14

Depends on the kids. If they don't want to share, then it's very important for them to have their own rooms. I would never make them share if they weren't happy with it.

Leavingsosoon · 05/11/2015 23:18

I don't think children mind; I think teenagers do, though.

Our present home is small and a little cramped and my girls will share (still in with me at the moment) but I'd certainly want them to have their own rooms by the time they are secondary age.

KatieLatie · 05/11/2015 23:12

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

SkandiStyle · 05/11/2015 22:49

IME primary school children are largely oblivious to the size and spec' of houses. They certainly couldn't care less about soft furnishings or paint colours.

We have spent years carefully renovating and tastefully (well, I think so) decorating our 5 bed Georgian house. Both DDs have a large bedroom each and their own, large, shared bathroom and den/playroom.

Yet they are totally uninterested in their home. They are far, far more impressed by a friend's house (average, 3 bed, new build), and consider it far more 'posh' than theirs because it has a fitted TV in the bathroom and twirly bar stools in the kitchen.

Http · 05/11/2015 22:05

I know someone who lives in a small 2 bed house with 4 kids. They were desperate to move to a bigger house but didn't want to pay for it so tried to swindle the husband's elderly parents house off them. Luckily his brother realised and put a stop to it.

UterusUterusGhali · 05/11/2015 20:54

Really interesting, mixed responses!

I'm doing the BF an injustice; I'm not sure he said "cruel", I'm paraphrasing tbh. He said it would be unfair on the other children but thought it very odd that I wasn't bothered that they do share atm. He wouldn't consider having a child without a room each.

I do worry about when they're older and smellier and want, ahem, privacy.

We are pretty close; the boys get into my bed. When we're in the living room we all squeeze onto one sofa although there are two. Grin The children love camping as we're all together. (Even the teenage girl gets into it eventually.)

OP posts:
fiverabbits · 05/11/2015 20:46

When I was 11 in 1962 I was friends with a boy who lived in the next street he was the oldest of 11 boys and he had 2 older sisters and then one younger one. The house had 4 bedrooms, one living room, one bathroom and a small kitchen.

Believeitornot · 05/11/2015 19:32

My two currently share a room even though they don't need to. They're 6&3 (boy and girl). In a couple of years we will split them up
They love it, we love it. They get lonely at night so keep each other company. I like hearing them giggle and plot when they wake up!

I shared with my brother until old enough to need my own space. Dh also shared until he left him. Did us no harm!

Marynary · 05/11/2015 19:29

Children certainly are fussed about the size of the house once they are above a certain age. Most would much prefer to have a room to themselves. That said, two sharing is hardly overcrowding.
Some children wouldn't like to live in a house like the one your BF grew up in either though. I always hated the fact that my parent's very big six bedroom house was larger than everyone elses. I was really embarrassed by it and thought twice before inviting people around..

TheDowagerCuntess · 05/11/2015 17:47

I think there are two separate issues at play.

A family living in poverty, in over-crowded, chaotic conditions, sharing a room because they have to, well beyond the age most children/people would expect to be sharing a room.

And then those who are perhaps still sharing because they have to, but it's a loving environment, and those sharing because they want to, even though there is plenty of space.

The former's more likely to be detrimental. The latter nowhere near as much. There is nothing inherently damaging about sharing space, especially if it's in the context of a healthy, loving, family environment.