Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think mixing up your food on a plate is bad manners?

292 replies

Moonatic · 14/10/2015 21:15

This is dh I'm talking about. Made a pastry-topped chicken and leek pie at the weekend. Served with sweetcorn and carrots. Before eating it, he cut his whole serving into small pieces (size of a penny), then mixed it up. I got really annoyed, as dis the kids and asked him not to eat that way, because it was really bad manners. He said it wasn't. Who is right?

To add: this was just one example. If it's mixable, it gets mixed up. Cottage pie, fish pie, lasagne, pasta, curry and rice - it all turns into a big plate of mush.

There is also a sub-question: is it rude to cut your food into small pieces before eating it? By which I mean, cutting everything into small bite size pieces before starting to eat. Again, I say it is, dh says it isn't. (This is what he does with food that is less easily mushed up - e.g. something like chops, new potatoes and vegetables.

OP posts:
MissHooliesCardigan · 15/10/2015 08:34

YANBU. I'm very relaxed about table manners at home and I couldn't care less about which way someone tilts their soup bowl or whether they use a knife or their fingers to break a bread roll. However, turning a meal into something that resembles a plate of vomit is gross and disrespectful to those around you.

apinchofsugar · 15/10/2015 08:28

I am amazed that table manners seem such a new concept for some people. I wonder if convenience food and take-aways in front of the tv are to blame, and people have forgotten the most basic concepts?

Shakey15000 · 15/10/2015 08:21

I'm surprised there's so many people with big issues on how other people eat food.

AllMyBestFriendsAreMetalheads · 15/10/2015 08:18

I have honestly never heard that this is rude before. I don't really notice how someone else is eating, I'm mainly focussed on my own food.

I am very common though Grin

lottiegarbanzo · 15/10/2015 08:15

YANBU. I think that it is bad manners but not necessarily rude. Not quite the same thing.

Personally I would find that unpleasant to watch and a bad example to children, who do learn primarily by copying.

Is it something he's always done, from childhood? Or a habit he got into when living alone? Could he keep it for informal home eating alone or when the children aren't there, and just put up with modelling proper/ normal eating habits when eating with them?

justwondering72 · 15/10/2015 08:02

I wouldn't say it's rude as such. He's not spitting, burping, eating with his hands, criticising the food etc.

But going by the standards of table manners that I was taught, it's certainly uncouth. It says to me that the eater might as well be given a bowl of pig swill to eat, given that he appears to be unable to appreciate the distinct flavours of the individual components of his meal. That he'll eat any old crap if it's mashed together and shovelled in.

My FIL would do this.

I am aware this is horribly snobbish and that your OH may be a true gourmand, but the table manners and rules that I was taught as a child are my default setting.

WizardOfToss · 15/10/2015 07:56

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

fanjoforthemammaries7850 · 15/10/2015 07:22

He did it in front of one of his friends who want visiting recently and the friend both commented on it and looked pretty unimpressed

Sorry ..to me..THAT is rude

fanjoforthemammaries7850 · 15/10/2015 07:20

Sorry..I think it's ruder to try to control how some one eats their food, unless they are burping and eating with their hands.

beautygal29 · 15/10/2015 07:17

I think it is very annoying (am laughing at man sized baby) but not necessarily bad manners? But then if you are annoying everyone by doing it maybe it is?

Senpai · 15/10/2015 07:15

I think it sounds like a hang up from childhood. Does he leave crusts behind too? I wouldn't find it atttractive but rude? No, I think you are going too far, a bit of tolerence is a beautiful thing.

It goes both ways. He can respect that something he does bothers her and stop doing it. There's a few things I do that irritate the shit out of DH I try not to do them while he's around. He does the same for me. We don't just carry on with no regard for each other and expect the other to deal. Respecting each other is a beautiful thing. Tolerating differences that you can't help or are part of your personality is a beautiful thing. Letting someone take a proverbial shit over your dinner you put effort into preparing for them is not a beautiful thing.

Finding a plate of mush to be repulsive doesn't have to be a childhood hang up. I never had any bad experiences with mixing food, it's just gross. It looks utterly unappealing, and then it makes moist squishing noises as you shovel it up. -cringe-

I would not tolerate it if DH did this. Not even a little. If he had been a gross eater, I wouldn't have gone on a second date with him.

StormyBlue · 15/10/2015 07:14

YANBU at all OP, like you said, you go to the trouble of making a nice meal and then feel you might as well have mushed it up and handed it over in a bucket.

My dad does it, I wouldn't care so much but he's always so judgey of what he perceives as being bad manners from other people but won't accept that anything he does could be bad manners! [Personal grumble]

to think mixing up your food on a plate is bad manners?
Chiggers · 15/10/2015 07:11

YABU. I refuse to go out for a meal with a friend due to her idea of manners. She once told me that I was being rude for mixing my mash with gravy. I refused to eat my meal as she made me feel incredibly uncomfortable when watching me. It felt like she was waiting for me to slip up in my manners.

I have more important things to do rather than dine with people who are intent on judging me.

fieldfare · 15/10/2015 07:01

Yanbu op. I'd not be able to tolerate that and would probably end up eating separately.
I like nice manners. Dh gets short shrift sometimes as he'll shovel it in, normally because he's thinking about something else (work) so hard his mind isn't in the here and now of enjoying the meal, it's in his office on whatever he has to do.
Or he'll pick at whatever is left in the saucepans or roasting dish while I'm finishing dishing up, regardless that he is about to have a plateful. I shouted last night because he was eating out of the pan what I was putting aside for my lunch today. It's just a bit greedy!

OfficeGirl1969 · 15/10/2015 07:01

I'd only ever police how someone eats as far as general manners goes (i.e.eating with cutlery, not chomping with your mouth wide open ie taking with your mouth full)
Quite honestly if I cooked a meal and someone devoured it I'd be happy if they ate it in it's neat component parts or mixed them up!

Notoedike · 15/10/2015 06:51

I think it sounds like a hang up from childhood. Does he leave crusts behind too? I wouldn't find it atttractive but rude? No, I think you are going too far, a bit of tolerence is a beautiful thing.

Littlefrenchmummy · 15/10/2015 06:36

Yes as manners go its very rude to A/ cut everything up B/ mix it all together. And yes it would annoy me if my husband taught that to my children.

Having said that maybe if he only does it at home and thats how he loves eating and your children know not to do it then thats ok.. Id hate my husband having bad table manners but Id also hate the idea of him not feeling comfortable in his own home.

Good luck xx

Senpai · 15/10/2015 06:30

People who cut their entire plate of food up before swapping the fork to the right hand and shovelling.... do you not find your food goes cold very quickly if it's all in sat in little pieces for a while?

Well, here in the US, we cut a strip at a time and cut that strip into pieces, switch our fork over, then eat the pieces. Then pick up our knife and cut a new strip with new pieces. So no cold food. Grin

But back to the OP, the mixing sounds disgusting. I wouldn't be able to watch.

Then again, if it were socially acceptable for adults to eat on plates with dividers I'd be doing it. I hate my food mixing.

Stanky · 15/10/2015 06:25

My dh does this at home as well. It ends up looking like something you'd feed a farmyard animal. It does gross me out, but so long as he doesn't do it in public, we're fine.

PunkrockerGirl · 15/10/2015 05:48

Not sure whether it's bad manners or not, but mil does it and it drives me mad. Makes a nicely presented meal resemble a pile of slop Confused

Onthepigsback · 15/10/2015 04:25

So funny op because I was just having this conversation with a friend 2 days ago. My dh does this. We've been together 8yrs and lived together 5, and it's only this last few months I'm noticing it. Possibly because of the food I am making now with little ones is more family meals, I don't know.

But yes, I find it horrible manners and a bit upsetting to watch. Especially when I have carefully plated up something, with just the right amount of crispy topping etc. I'm just not sure my upset over it is worth upsetting him over it and making him feel like he can't enjoy his food so I haven't said anything. If our kids start it though, I will tell them off.

Whatever about at home, I would have to say something if we were out.

He did it in front of one of his friends who want visiting recently and the friend both commented on it and looked pretty unimpressed. So I guess it's not just you and me OP.

wannaBe · 15/10/2015 02:20

The thing with food though is that it is such a fundamental part of us and is so important that it is also vital that it doesn't become an issue - iyswim.

We live in a society where eating disorders are on the increase, and much of that is attributable to the fact that there is so much expectation around food.

you can't have x food with y sauce or cut your food into bites or put ketchup on your mashed potato and and and, before too long our enjoyment of food is overshadowed by the need to conform to someone else's standards. I'm not talking about eating with your mouth open or talking with your mouth full etc, but things which are based on preference, and really, what works for one bothers someone else and so on.

I love food. I am an excellent cook, and people enjoy my cooking immensely. I am also VI, and there are some foods which I don't eat when out because when I'm out I like to just be able to eat what's on my plate, so I can't be arsed to wrestle with whole fish or spaghetti etc, for instance. But sometimes I will encounter something which might be difficult e.g. a bit of fat on some meat for instance and then I have to deal with it.

I've told this story on here before. About two years after I got together with my now xh we went on holiday. We went to a steak restaurant, and both ordered steak - I think it was new york strip or something - this is relevant, because it was a cut which had a streak of fat in the middle. And I struggled with it, because it was almost impossible to tell just while cutting which was fat and which was meat, until you sank the knife into it - iyswim. And because i couldn't see it I was reliant on being able to tell. So I ate some chips then struggled with this steak a bit more, while xh became quieter and quieter. I asked him what was wrong and he got annoyed and said "your table manners are appalling!" Sad Confused it was just a steak. And it wasn't even a habit or a manner - I had just struggled with the fat on it. I stopped trying after that and left nearly all the meal. When the waitress came to collect the plates she remarked that I hadn't eaten the steak, and I just apologised while trying not to cry. Ex did apologise later but the upset had already been caused. And I suppose that the way I ate that steak was off-putting to him so much so that he had to say something. I have never eaten any cut of steak with fat on it when out since, so only fillet will do now. Smile But in truth while this isn't on the same level as mushing up food for instance, it was still something which was apparently bad manners even though it was unforeseen.

If I was genuinely put off by a habit of someone's I would ask them about it rather than get annoyed. Open-mouthed chewing, talking with mouth full etc are basic manners and cannot IMO be compared with the order/way in which someone eats their food.

BumpTheElephant · 15/10/2015 01:42

YABU. I can't stand noisy or messy eaters but really don't care how someone gets their food from plate to mouth or if they mix it up. as a teenager I used to mash up my dinners with gravy and eat them with a teaspoon

Dietcherrycola · 15/10/2015 01:20

YANBU.
My dad does this and even though I love him I find it so disgusting I try not to look at him at the table.
I'd say it is worse than starting before everyone has sat down and as bad as talking with food in your mouth.
Makes me queezy.

Garrick · 15/10/2015 00:51

Perhaps you could give his meal a quick whizz in the processor, Moon? And serve it in a bowl.

Btw, one of the things I really hate about being poor is the number of meals I have to make myself that don't have 'edges'. I'll eat whatever worthy mess I've cooked, as long as it tastes OK, but it invariably does look like vomit or poo to me. I've been subjecting myself to this for years; it's evidently not something I can just get over.

I'd be upset if I'd made someone a lovely pie - pies being composed in such a way as to sit within their pastry 'edges', affording a planned combination of taste & texture - only for them to bash it all to smithereens!

The chances of my making a lovely pie, however, are zero. Pastry isn't my forte.

Swipe left for the next trending thread