Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to want a....

59 replies

spoonfulofgoodness · 16/09/2015 12:39

Prenuptial agreement. My partner and I own property. We live in the house I own and he has a house he rents out. We're getting married in January. We're both good with money and both stand to inherit money as well. He's happy to have a prenup but isn't willing to pay for it. So I guess my question is AIBU unreasonable to want one and AIBU to expect that he contributes to half the costs if it's protecting him too?

OP posts:
ImperialBlether · 16/09/2015 16:27

Then you get the lawyers involved, Rachel!

RachelZoe · 16/09/2015 16:23

ImperialBlether

I think everything's different if you marry when neither of you have anything really. There's no point to a pre-nup then.

Yes there is. How if one of them becomes successful after they get married?

ImperialBlether · 16/09/2015 16:14

Isn't it 1 in 3 marriages end in divorce? I bet those in the 1/3 who had property they then lost to their spouse wish they'd planned ahead.

If the marriage goes well, it all becomes immaterial.

SoupDragon · 16/09/2015 15:58

If you need 'protecting' from each other then you shouldn't be getting married.

why bother getting married if you don't mean the vows?

Because shit happens. Don't be so naive.

whois · 16/09/2015 15:55

God how sanctimonious people are 'I wouldn't be marring you if you wanted a pre-nup' Love blinds all eh?

I'm sure most people don't go in to marriage expecting it to end in a nasty divorce, but an awful lot do end up like that. If you both have pre-marriage assets it is sensible to protect them.

However, since it is only you that wants this, then I would expect you to pay for it really.

ImperialBlether · 16/09/2015 15:34

I think everything's different if you marry when neither of you have anything really. There's no point to a pre-nup then. However, once you've worked really hard for years to save money or buy property, getting married shouldn't mean you risk losing everything. None of us really knows the person we marry - we all think we do and often everything goes well so we think we were proved right, but a lot is luck rather than judgement. Whatever a couple agree to beforehand, it's always better to nail it down with a written agreement in case either of you are not what the other thought you were.

Londonista123 · 16/09/2015 15:10

YANBU, and Hmm to posters who feel this somehow means that you don't love each other / love each other less than others who don't consider the need for a pre-nup.

No-one goes into marriage anticipating a divorce, yet the statistics show that divorces do happen and people do change. The OP and spouse sound fairly evenly matched financially, but why should one spouse or another lose assets they've worked hard to amass in the event of an (unanticipated) divorce?

RachelZoe · 16/09/2015 15:08

Quite right OP

Some people like to live in a fairy tale land where everyone who falls in love stays there, and nothing bad ever happens etc. A pre nup is no different to making a will, obviously nobody wants to die, and nobody would say you were enticing death by writing one, it's no different really.

spoonfulofgoodness · 16/09/2015 14:57

I'm worried that people think that it's "sad" to protect assets that I've worked damn hard for. I've not said I don't share anything. We do share money to a certain extent but I don't believe in giving my partner full control of my money and likewise he feels the same. It doesn't lessen the love we have for each other Hmm it's just how we choose to run our finances and we've done this for sometime. I'm realistic and whilst I think marriage should be for life, I've come to realise that this just isn't always the case. So to the PP who wouldn't marry me since I want to protect my hard earned assets - I definitely Wouldn't marry you for not allowing Me to do so....

OP posts:
fredfredgeorgejnrsnr · 16/09/2015 14:44

Nothing wrong with a prenup, nothing wrong with wanting one, expecting him to pay when he doesn't is unreasonable, so just pay and go for it.

You should also probably ensure you put things in it relating to children and how that might vary things.

Thurlow · 16/09/2015 14:43

Actually, seeing how you are both entering the marriage with assets, I can understand why you might want that all clarified. So no, YANBU.

It's being practical - it's not enormously different from posters telling women to get married to protect themselves should the worst case scenario occur.

RachelZoe · 16/09/2015 14:35

YANBU at all, everyone should have one if it's legally binding where they are/or as others have said, for intent purposes. We've all been through breakups, things get nasty, people can get vindictive during a split and things can get messed up, it's just life. It's sensible. Getting a pre nup doesn't mean you shouldn't be getting married or don't trust each other or anything. You should pay for it though if you're the one who wants it.

DoJo · 16/09/2015 14:27

Marriage is a teeny bit pointless if you'll only do it with a contract that nullifies the one you're about to enter.

There's more to marriage than sharing assets though - nullifying one aspect of a contract doesn't render the rest pointless.

DoJo · 16/09/2015 14:25

YANBU for wanting one, but YABU for expecting him to pay for it if he's not that bothered. You can't force someone to fork out for something just because you think it's for 'their own good'.

DawnOfTheDoggers · 16/09/2015 13:47

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

PurpleDaisies · 16/09/2015 13:40

I agree with posters saying if you want it you should be the one to pay for it.

I think going into marriage planning for what happens if you divorce is a bit sad. We have a fully joint account, fully joint savings (except Isa's where you can't) and my name isn't even on the house deeds (bought before we married while I was a student and considered to be a risk by the morgage company so we'd have had a worse deal). I'm a realist too-we really meant our vows so it's til death do us part for us.

InTheBox · 16/09/2015 13:31

It's sensible, do it. Tbh as you said you never know what's around the corner. Not too long ago an OP was unemployed living with her husband who owned the house and wouldn't put her on the deeds amongst a host of other things. I'm sure she once felt her vows were forever too yet she was posting because she'd found herself up shit creek without a paddle.

Collaborate · 16/09/2015 13:22

Pre-nuptial agreements can be enforceable in England & Wales (apologies to the OP who is in Scotland). This link posted by thebunnyofdoom is way out of date.

If you look at the reference to a case called Radmacher v Gradation in the margin of that web page you'll see they refer to a case that may make the advice given rather meaningless. That case reached the supreme court in 2010. It said that the court would uphold PNAs unless it can be shown to be demonstrably unfair to one or other of the parties.

This is a link to a recent case in which the PNA most certainly affected the outcome.

ImperialBlether · 16/09/2015 13:17

Can I just ask you something? You live together in your property and he rents out his own? What does he do with the rent - do you share it?

Epilepsyhelp · 16/09/2015 13:17

You want it you pay for it. Frankly if I were him I wouldn't be marrying you. I can see the point if there are for example SDC to protect but otherwise why bother getting married if you don't mean the vows?

RainbowFlutterby · 16/09/2015 13:13

If you want it then I think you should pay for it tbh.

Are you planning on having children together?

steppemum · 16/09/2015 13:09

they can be used in divorce as evidence of intent but not binding

steppemum · 16/09/2015 13:09

solictors will draw them up in england too, but they are still invalid

spoonfulofgoodness · 16/09/2015 13:03

Yeah in Scotland and it's available through solicitors. If they offer it as a service is really not enforceable?

OP posts:
PaulAnkaTheDog · 16/09/2015 13:01

Scrap my comment. It's different in Scotland.