Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Coach leaving my son out of the team

256 replies

Mousybrown · 08/09/2015 18:09

I'm really not if I should say anything or not as I'm normally pretty easygoing about kids stuff but this has really got my back up.
my son has played for the same football team for the last 7 years, every training session and match, he is there no matter what the weather...even if he is just on the bench but following a text from the new coach ( who has just taken the team over)he has been left out of the squad for the first two matches of this coming season ( not even on the bench, he has been told not to come...unless he wants to each from the sidelines).......this would be fine (ish) was it not for the fact that the new coach has taken on severl new players over the summer, some who already play for other teams and theses 'new boys' have been included in the team in some capacity either as players or as subs.
My son is gutted ( he is 11) and he doesn't want to go at the weekend to watch with all the other boys asking him why he isn't playing or in the kit and I really want to tell the coach to shove it......I know he isn't their star player and they want to put a good team out but......the kids has been a loyal player for years and he has been overlooked for kids who are only just signed and I feel so sad for him.......so would I be unreasonable to speak to the coach or not??

OP posts:
budgiegirl · 08/09/2015 23:18

And if there are too many children for one team, have two.

That only works if there is a parent or two willing to step up and run the second team. There's usually plenty of parents willing to moan about how the club is run, but not so many who are willing to do something practical to help the situation.

budgiegirl · 08/09/2015 23:14

The OP's ds has played for the team for years. The new coach brought in extra players. If the squad is now much bigger than the team, that situation has been deliberately caused by this coach.

I doubt very much that the coach has deliberately brought in new players. He was probably approached by children who wanted to join the club and told them they could join.

LyndaNotLinda · 08/09/2015 23:13

Barbarian - why take so many children then? If the team is full, then it's full. Surely if children are massively dedicated and go every single week then they're the team. The coach shouldn't take on a load of extra kids unless there are spaces.

And if there are too many children for one team, have two.

I really don't understand how people justify the shitty way children are treated in football. It wouldn't be accepted in anything else.

Choir? Oh - you've been in it for 7 years ever since you were 6 but now we've got some new choristers, we don't have a space for you any more. Oh wait - we'd like you to come to rehearsals but we just don't want you showing up to performances.

Drama club? Not only do you not get a part, you can't even help out backstage. Please stay home and we'll call you when we need you.

Orchestra? Thanks for being a stalwart of the first violin section. Unfortunately, we've found some other children who play a bit better than you do so we don't need you to come along to any performances. We'd like you to come to rehearsals though in case someone injures a finger or is on holiday and then you can stand in.

Oh - and be sure to ask your mum and/or dad to fork out for you to come every week, just in case we decide we do need you. Make sure your phone's charged!

jonicomelately · 08/09/2015 23:12

Barbarianmum The OP's ds has played for the team for years. The new coach brought in extra players. If the squad is now much bigger than the team, that situation has been deliberately caused by this coach.

budgiegirl · 08/09/2015 23:11

Why don't you find her another team where she can play sunday matches budgiegirl? Is she fine with the fact that she's never chosen to play? Sounds really crap to me

It's not at all crap, and she is genuinely fine with it. She still gets to play 2 hours of cricket at training on a Friday, and loves it. The coach is a lovely, genuine man who spends hours organising youth cricket, because he believes all children should have the opportunity to play sport. Which my daughter is doing, just not competitively. But he chooses a strong team for matches. If she wants to make the grade, she'll just have to work hard at it. In the meantime, she's enjoying herself.

maddening · 08/09/2015 23:07

The coach is living out his premier league fantasy at the expense of reliable and loyal club members.

BarbarianMum · 08/09/2015 22:59

Although I agree that winning shouldn't be the be all and end all, it seems obvious to me that if you have more children training than places on the team, then some will be left out. Put in that context, is it such a terrible thing that the OP's child miss 2 games?

LyndaNotLinda · 08/09/2015 22:59

Why don't you find her another team where she can play sunday matches budgiegirl? Is she fine with the fact that she's never chosen to play? Sounds really crap to me

budgiegirl · 08/09/2015 22:53

Its the same for many team sports IME, once they get past about 11 or 12. For instance, my DD plays cricket. About 25 kids go to training on a Friday night. Only 11 can be picked for the matches on Sundays. My DD is never picked.

And I'm fine with that. She's not one of the best players, so actually I think she shouldn't be picked. The team want a chance of winning. But she goes every week to training and loves it. They do exercises and play mini matches. She's not excluded, she just doesn't play Sunday matches. She still gets to play cricket at training, just because she doesn't make the team doesn't mean she can't enjoy the sport.

LyndaNotLinda · 08/09/2015 22:50

How sad kids' football is. It's no wonder so many give up sport and spend their weekends sitting on their arses playing computer games when it's pretty much accepted that those who aren't brilliant players get relegated to the benches once they get out of primary.

Honestly, who bloody cares who wins? They're not playing for money are they? Why on earth do they need leagues?

I'm probably being naive but you don't see chess clubs getting like this. Or choirs. Or even swimming.

There's something about Football.

Is it men?

Regularhiding · 08/09/2015 22:43

happened to my son exactly as you describe with the local kids football team when he was 11.
Broke my very robust son's heart .

The coach is an idiot.

find him a rugby club

littledrummergirl · 08/09/2015 22:36

Mine both stopped when this win at all costs attitude kicked in. Ds1 was 9, ds2 8.
Both my boy's do different sports now, ds1 competing nationally. We tried a number of sports including: rugby, gymnastics, dance, swimming, martial arts, athletics before they found the sports they preferred (both different hobbies).

Contrary to popular belief football is not the be all and end all. I know an international medalist who was not picked for football as he was told he was not sporty!

jonicomelately · 08/09/2015 22:18

Our coach won't take on too many players thus avoiding the squad being too large. I think any half decent coach would do the same.

BackforGood · 08/09/2015 22:12

All the people who say everyone should play - that's fine if it's 9 a side, and there are 12 or 13 in the squad, or 11-a-side and 15 or 16 in the squad. I absolutely agree.

However, if there are 23 or 30 that have been coming to training, it's just not realistic or practical. Here's an idea - why don't the parents of the players that can't get a game, form another team, so everyone can get a game?
Too many people are not looking at the bigger picture.

My ds never made the cut as a footballer. He loves the game. But, in life, we can't all be great at everything - he found his niche elsewhere, and sill enjoyed a kick around in the park with his mates on a regular basis. Now he's gone to University, he's formed a team with some other students and they play regularly in a 5 (?) / 6 (?) a-side local league in that town. That's the fab thing about mens football - you can play somewhere whatever your ability.

Lullington · 08/09/2015 21:30

Any coach that doesn't appreciate commitment at 11 or believes that raw talent sits above work and dedication isn't a good coach.

I really feel for your ds. Find another team .

TinklyLittleLaugh · 08/09/2015 21:25

Sorry I men "rotates the positions"

TinklyLittleLaugh · 08/09/2015 21:24

Absolutely Joni. We are very fortunate with DS's under 10s coach who gives all the kids equal time on the pitch and rotates the players, (I think he must have a big spreadsheet. Two sets of parents have flounced already this season because their little darlings were not up front every week. They weren't even the best ones in that position.

Lweji · 08/09/2015 21:22

In my experience the parents and coaches care more about winning or losing than the children.

Yes, but it depends.

My son's team lost most games they played last year. A couple of children were really upset at the end of some games, but most were happy just to play.
Thankfully the little group of parents was happier to chat to each other than to care about the games.

jonicomelately · 08/09/2015 21:17

In my experience the parents and coaches care more about winning or losing than the children. In reality it doesn't even matter because all the really good players can't play in these leagues anyway because they are in academies. That's the stupidity of the parents and coaches who burst blood vessels watching their boys playing while thinking they're the next Messi.

TinklyLittleLaugh · 08/09/2015 21:14

It's a shame; my eldest was never super talented and quite scrawny and didn't make the Sunday morning first 11 team by the time he got to 16 or so. Fortunately his team played a couple of indoor five a sides games on a Friday night and he loved that. Thinking about it he played five a side with a bunch of mates in the sixth form too and still ocaisionally at Uni. There is some less competitive football to be found.

BertrandRussell · 08/09/2015 21:12

It's sooo difficult. Yes of course everyone should get a game, but also it is incredibly demoralising to be badly beaten if you don't field your best team. Dp is a football coach and he spends a lot of time Juggling things trying to make sure that the weaker players get a game when the opposition isn't as strong. He deliberately doesn't play some of the kids against particular teams because, while not playing is rubbish, playing and being run rings round is even worse. Sometimes coaches are just crap, but sometimes they are really trying to do the best for the kids.........

Kandboys · 08/09/2015 21:10

My husband is co-coach for our DS1s footy team and we have players of varying abilities but all of them play every match. He just uses subs throughout the games. We are not a very successful team but at least every lad gets a game and they all have fun. We've come across some right knobs in youth football, am sure they think they are the next Alex Ferguson. And the way they talk to some of these kids, it's disgusting.

notquiteruralbliss · 08/09/2015 21:04

Sounds awful. My DCs sports team gets them to fill in a questionnaire at the start of the season asking what they want to get out of their sport. Having fun? Playing county? Being competitive? The approach is tailored to some degree) to the replies but nobody who wants to play doesn't at least get a chance to do do.

jonicomelately · 08/09/2015 20:59

'Their' and 'committed'

jonicomelately · 08/09/2015 20:57

I honestly don't recognise this 'everything changes at 11' attitude budgie speaks of. Both my DS have played in a highly competitive league but as far as I know, no children have ever been edged out of there team, as she describes, especially boys who have been commuted since day one. I hope all the trophies these coaches win are worth the broken hearts these children will have suffered. No wonder children don't want to play sport any more. Parents and coaches who care about winning need to get a grip.