Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

David Cameron has finally admitted that "integration is not working"

385 replies

WhetherOrNot · 20/07/2015 19:16

AIBU to think that he should have cottoned on about 10 years ago, not now when it is so glaringly obvious as to be an embarrassment for everyone?

OP posts:
OurDearLeader · 21/07/2015 11:14

There is some crap on this thread.

most british people haven't met any muslims

Considering that almost 1 in 20 of the population is a Muslim that's highly unlikely.

As for this being like the 'rhetoric against the Jews in the 1930s'. In the 1930s the Jews had not violently conquered an area the size of Israel, a rich Jewish nation was not bankrolling and promoting extremism across the world, they had not destabilised countries from Tunisia to Nigeria to Somalia to Nigeria. They hadn't committed atrocities of mass murder, they hadn't kidnapped hundreds of girls or slaughtered whole villages. They didn't have entire cities which they banned non-Muslims from. They didn't control many states where non-Muslims were persecuted. In fact, if the fate of anybody at the moment could be compared to the holocaust, it's Christians in Muslim countries who are at the sharp end of Muslim persecution.

www.independent.co.uk/voices/comment/christians-the-worlds-most-persecuted-people-9630774.html

It's estimated 100,000 Christians a year are murdered for their faith or 11 every hour. If you're going to compare anything in the world at the moment to the 1930s I personally would compare it to the period of appeasement of the Nazi's where we were told if we just gave them what they wanted they'd be happy and stop.

This country has been built on the backs of immigration, from the Celts and Picts through to the Romans and Germanic tribes who formed the English race and the Normans who laid the basis of modern life.

Do you have any idea what happened to the people who already lived here when these waves of immigration took place? The Romans brutally oppressed the Celts and there were a series of violent, unpleasant wars. Roman invasion also was more of a process of cultural change and did not involve any mass migration.

The Anglo-Saxons also fought and displaced a lot of the previous populace, treated them badly and appropriated their wealth.

As for the Normans, you might like to look up 'The Harrying of the North' for a nice example of ethnic cleansing and genocide which resulted in entire counties being depopulated, famines so bad cannibalism was reported.

We've had small waves of immigration since then where in the main (except perhaps some of the Jewish in very small numbers) they have assimilated into the society of Britain. We've never before had a situation where such large numbers of people moved here who have to a large extent entirely kept their own culture and so roundly rejected that of the nation they live in.

The comparable situations I can think of off the top of my head are the Protestant settlement of Ulster and the creation of Israel as a Jewish state. And look how well they worked out eh, no trouble to see there, move along!

I'm also loving the fact that there are several 'right on' people on this thread who are declaring how tolerant we should all be while mocking, sneering and denigrating poor white people. But then they're fair game aren't they?

Puzzledandpissedoff · 21/07/2015 11:06

You cannot legislate away stupidity. It has specific skin colour

Really? And what skin colour would that be?

WhetherOrNot · 21/07/2015 10:54

Thankfully MN is not actually reflective of the vast majority of sensible people in this country who recognise that we do in fact have a real problem.

This ^^ absolutely.

OP posts:
EllieFAntspoo · 21/07/2015 10:46

... and the British people sit and debate about the rights of their fellow citizens, and why they need to be brought to heal, all the while having their own food removed, their own health care eroded, their employment curtailed, and the future prospects of their own children destroyed. Ironic isn't it? Karma maybe?

RedDaisyRed · 21/07/2015 10:36

MM tells it as it is.
The answers aren't easy but lots of contact between different people in the cities and children at school with children of different cultures helps. White flight does not help. However places like London have always had China Towns, jewish areas, and whatever group has come here next who then in the past anyway have largely moved away and integrated although it can take a few generations. Requirements to learn English (although you'd have to apply that to the Welsh I suppose), perhaps cutting all religion out of schools including the Cof E expelled from the schools of Cameron's children might help too.

(I am in I think just about the most religiously mixed area of the UK where luckily everyone largely lives in peace which is a huge testament to the spirit of tolerance of just about all groups in the UK).

silkoversatin · 21/07/2015 10:34

I don't know where to begin really to describe how despicably awful and just plain wrong this self seeking, populist, wank bag Cameron is. But I've got to try, firstly ~ the overwhelming majority of Muslims don’t want in any way an Isis-style state. They do not want religious leaders to hold direct legislative or political power at all. Meticulous research has revealed this.

The actual amount of British Muslims are believed to have gone to fight for Isis, (of course, how ever many it is, is too many) but it's actually less than 0.02 per cent of the UK’s 2.7 million Muslims.

Cameron makes no reference to the fact that we and the U.S have created the background out of which the ISIS lunatics have flourished. That they are the homegrown product of the turmoil that has engulfed: Iraq since the U.S. invasion in 2003 and Syria in 2011. (Oh and then there's the utter decimation of Libya) as well. But no, that's got nothing to do with it!

In his blather, Cameron denies the connection between 'radicalisation' and Muslim's 'historic grievances'. His reason for that are simple: not content with demonising domestic Muslim communities, he's actively trying to clear the way for his further ad hoc bombing of Syria. And so the vicious circle can continue.

Cameron's answer? A further clampdown on Muslim's (who incidentally - according to a recent YouGov poll are more patriotic Britons than Scots) civil liberties of course!!! This will obviously get 'them' to identify more fully with our British values of tolerance, democracy and free speech. Well done Dave....That'll sort it all out.

Anyone who knows anything, knows that the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia is the major ideological source of jihadist ideology, did he mention them? Don't be silly, we coddle this ghastly regime because of oil. Other muslim states that are allied to the west, that are just as appalling are Turkey, UAE amongst others.

Two years ago, public opinion and opposition to war forced Cameron (who's now proved himself as big-a-liar as Tony Blair) to say he 'got' that public and parliament were against the war and promised that the government would 'act accordingly'. We now know he was lying. He could hardly not 'get' the way parliament had voted, but he has since authorised British bombing of Syria anyhow.

MistressMia · 21/07/2015 10:14

And wrt to British values, how about
acceptance of homosexuality ?
“East London has seen the highest increase in homophobic attacks anywhere in Britain. Everybody knows why, and nobody wants to say it. It is because East London has the highest Muslim population in Britain, and we have allowed a fanatically intolerant attitude towards gay people to incubate there, in the name of ‘tolerance’.
www.pinknews.co.uk/2011/02/25/gay-journalist-johann-hari-calls-for-open-debate-on-muslim-homophobia/

Suport for free speech
-so that cartoonists, novelists and critics don't have to live in fear of being murdered and we don't have to self-censor ourselves

Support for freedom of religion

  • so that muslims who wish to leave their faith can do so openly and not have to lead a double life, be ostracised or live in fear of violent retribution
www.spectator.co.uk/features/9453112/how-liberal-britain-is-betraying-ex-muslims/

Support for sexual equality and emancipation

  • so that all muslim girls and women have the same opportunities as non-muslim girls and have the freedom to complete their education rather than be dragged off for a forced marriage, or be killed if they bring 'dishonour' or abducted and have their genitals cut off, or be forced to cover when they don't want to and not partake in everyday activities deemed un-islamic and not befitting a muslim woman.

Acceptance of British Law in all aspects

  • and not parallel legal systems such as Sharia Law that leaves women at a disadvantage struggling to obtain divorce, that forces them to become co-wives, leaves them in fear of losing their children or financially bereft of financial support in the case of divorce instigated by her.
www.onelawforall.org.uk/sharia-courts/

Intolerance of domestic violence

  • rather than condoning it through religious scripture.

I could go an and on, but frankly I don't have the time or the inclination to keep repeating myself and debating with conspiracy theorists, those with their head in the sands and false moral equivalencers. Thankfully MN is not actually reflective of the vast majority of sensible people in this country who recognise that we do in fact have a real problem.

MistressMia · 21/07/2015 10:14

I agree that the timing of DC's speech was designed to deflect attention away from the Welfare Reform Bill, however that being the case, the posts denigrating him appear to be denying that there is any problem at all with growing Islamic extremism/conservatism in this country and abroad when there quite clearly is and not just with a few few hardline nutters.

If 2000 or so have actually gone to join ISIL, we can extrapolate that there will be at least as many if not many multiples more who have similar sentiments but who for one reason or another can't go themselves. Over 40 actual terrorist plots have been foiled in this country since 7/7 and significant numbers have been convicted and jailed www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/theresa-may-british-security-services-foiled-40-terror-plots-since-77-attacks-9879712.html

We have mainstream mosques in this country e.g. East London Mosque who openly sympathise with and promote terrorists and whose ultimate aim is to replace British law with Sharia.

standforpeace.org.uk/islamic-forum-of-europe/

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/belief/2010/mar/04/islamic-forum-europe-dispatches-gilligan

It is the hard and soft islamists who are responsible for this growing gulf between a significant number of muslims and the rest of the populace and who are responsible for the segregation and closed communities that some posters have described. Its these people DC is targeting - Not your lovely muslim neighbour and work colleague. To deflect the attention away from this onto some straw man argument is complete stupidity as its these Islamists who will be responsible for the atrocity that kills your loved one in future acts of Islamic terrorism.

horseygeorgie · 21/07/2015 10:12

Not sure if stupidity has a skin colour tbh - I've met stupid people of every colour and the opposite too.

horseygeorgie · 21/07/2015 10:11

Well that's true, we all love a good moan don't we! Grin

frankieboy23 · 21/07/2015 10:10

Ellie expand ur comment please

Branleuse · 21/07/2015 10:06

i assumed you meant integration in the classroom, like with children with SEN, but really you meant actual racist stuff. wow

EllieFAntspoo · 21/07/2015 09:59

Wherever solution DC comes up with is never going to be popular but if his way of doing it bothers you then perhaps you should think about a career in politics and go and sort it out yourself!

It's that British culture thing again, horsey. The masses like nothing better than a good whinge. If they haven't got something to whine about, then the country just isn't running right.

EllieFAntspoo · 21/07/2015 09:56

You cannot legislate away stupidity.
It has specific skin colour.

horseygeorgie · 21/07/2015 09:45

I live in a rural part of the country. Very few people in the immediate area are from outside the UK. I am English and proud of it to my very core and I don't think there is anything wrong with people wanting to make sure we don't lose our identity.

BUT

people talk of immigration in terms of it being a modern issue. This country has been built on the backs of immigration, from the Celts and Picts through to the Romans and Germanic tribes who formed the English race and the Normans who laid the basis of modern life. It is not something to be scared of!

The extremist views are however, terrifying because they seem unstoppable and are gathering force. No matter what anyone says, I find it scary because we can't predict where it is going to end up. Something NEEDS to be done to find out why these people are turning to it. Wherever solution DC comes up with is never going to be popular but if his way of doing it bothers you then perhaps you should think about a career in politics and go and sort it out yourself! At least they are doing something.

DoraGora · 21/07/2015 09:30

Underlying causes? People aren't watching video nasties because of lack of access to tax credits.

Back in the day, a pope, I think his name was Urban, told English people to leave the fields, pack some bread and cheese and walk half way across the globe to liberate the Holy Land. And guess what, they did! DC has to confront the fact that, when it comes to religious messages, people will believe any old crap, and utopia is the biggest puller of them all.

If DC wants to fix this, I'd suggest a huge operating theatre and a production line lobotomy operation to rival the Ford Motor Company. It's the only solution.

DoraGora · 21/07/2015 09:22

British culture, you know, cricket.

EllieFAntspoo · 21/07/2015 09:09

DC needs to focus on addressing the underlying reasons for discontent.

That would be pointless. The country cannot afford the welfare system in its current form. Poverty is a very powerful political tool. People tend to be willing to give up their human rights in exchange for food. We will feed the poor, and they will support the removal of freedom and liberty from society.

I don't see many affluent, employed people, living in lovely houses in leafy suburbs, round our way complaining about a lack of integration.

But you'll see them voicing their opinion on MN. In reality it is a non-issue for them. An academic exercise if social politics, an indulgence of an ideology, the same way they flirt with socialism until they begin to feel the tightening noose of the welfare state threatening their idyll, and then they rush back to the safety of conservatism, and push the masses back into poverty where they belong.

These exact same dynamics have played out over and over again for a hundred years. It surprises me just how ignorant people are of what is happening in the world around them. Imagine a world where everyone believed what they were told by the man in charge. A lot of your fellow citizens are already there.

Wideopenspace · 21/07/2015 08:56

Schools in Britain ergo British Schools....melting pots of different cultures and communities, reflecting similarities, differences but all members of the community required to rub along together.

I'll take that.

MaidOfStars · 21/07/2015 08:52

Wideopen I think it's an interesting definition, one that defines the concept of 'Britishness' as a geopolitical entity.

Similarly, decrying the demise of British high streets. They are high streets in Britain ergo 'British high streets'. I like it that high streets around Britain reflect different cultures within different communities. That, for me, is 'British' (if I had to define it, which I don't).

Wideopenspace · 21/07/2015 08:45

For your perusal en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_values

Wikipedia says British Values is the state or quality of being British Hmm

#helpful

LittleLionMansMummy · 21/07/2015 08:39

Sorry MaidOfStars but I must take issue with your fish n chips statement. Isn't the British meal of choice these days curry? Wink

Positivelyfatalistic · 21/07/2015 08:34

Yes please what are #britishvalues and where can I get them? as much as Cameron lauds the christian values of the UK his political and economic ideology makes me think he'd much rather muslims replaced the Quran with Ayn Rand's Atlas Shrugged rather than the King James Bible. We are, all of us, unfortunates to be living in interesting times.

Millionprammiles · 21/07/2015 08:33

In an era of high unemployment, low opportunity for the young, unaffordable housing, increased child poverty, hopeless inequality etc, it is less likely everyone will be living together in one big multicultural happy family.

DC needs to focus on addressing the underlying reasons for discontent. I don't see many affluent, employed people, living in lovely houses in leafy suburbs, round our way complaining about a lack of integration.

EllieFAntspoo · 21/07/2015 08:30

Not to pick on the particular poster....but I still don't actually know what this means. Can anyone offer something more tangible than vague statements about British culture and values?

They don't own Stafforshire bull terriers, sit drinking in their gardens, wear our flag to football matches and rejoice when we kill people. They don't buy our magazines telling us how fat CelebX has become and how CelebY has left FootballerY to fuck FootballerZ. They just aren't 'British'.

Swipe left for the next trending thread