Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

David Cameron has finally admitted that "integration is not working"

385 replies

WhetherOrNot · 20/07/2015 19:16

AIBU to think that he should have cottoned on about 10 years ago, not now when it is so glaringly obvious as to be an embarrassment for everyone?

OP posts:
Wideopenspace · 21/07/2015 19:14

Something that occurs to me, ourdear is how much choice your 'average' Muslim has over whether or not to be a Muslim.

I work with a family who had to leave their home country because they converted from Muslim to a very particular form of Christianity (the name escapes me). They were subject to the most extreme persecution any have been accepted into the UK as asylum seekers.

I wonder what percentage of Muslims ever consider not being as an option (there are probably a percentage of Muslims who are the 'church of england' of the Muslim faith - they just kind of join because that's what happens and never question it? I guess?) Then there must be some who question it, but have no power to leave - or the consequences would be so massive. I'm not sure if there is a parallel in Christian based faiths - maybe some of the more evangelical American sects?

I'm meandering because I'm thinking aloud...

YouTheCat · 21/07/2015 19:10

Whether, you really need to learn to express yourself more clearly. It's not just me that didn't read your OP in the way you had intended.

I haven't called you a bigot. But there were a few posters on this thread who demonstrated that they are though. How can I try to understand your point of view when I have little idea of what that actually is?

And I ask again, why start a thread like this when you know so little about the subject?

Wouldn't it be odd if I started a thread about cars when I have very little knowledge about them and then started to argue with people about the subject when they know more than I do?

OurDearLeader · 21/07/2015 19:06

Oh for Christ's sake. 'It's the patriachy'. How the hell do you think the patriachy was formed and has lasted for thousands of year? Because of organised bloody religion. And since the west has largely stopped following the extremer versions of it the rights of women have come an awfully long way.

Yes, women in Iran in the 70s had a great time. And why did it change? Oh yes, that would be because they became an Islamic Republic wouldn't it? But of course it has nothing to do with Islam.

How many women wear that Christian swimwear? Probably a few thousand in extreme sects in the US. How many Muslims have to cover up? Millions and millions. Are there any Christian countries which legislate to force women to wear those costumes? No there aren't. There are several Islamic countries where women are forced by law to cover parts of their bodies. As for women in their underwear on magazines, I'd far rather live in a country where that happened than live in a country where that happened than where a women could be sent to jail for 'indecency' for wearing a tight low cut dress in a video as happened recently in Egypt.

Or live in a country where homosexuality is illegal, homosexuals are persecuted and sometimes it's punishable by death.

The South African state doesn't collude in rape because of the religious and cultural attitudes of the country. The Pakistani state does. Do you realise that in Pakistan DNA is inaddmissable or only usable as supplementary evidence because the hard scientific fact it provides are not allowed to supersede Islamic law on rape cases? And that rape can't happen if there are no witnesses apparently?

Honestly, some people will say or do anything to justify such behaviour, and sadly these days exactly the same people who would once have been expected to challenge such awful behaviour now champion it because they are so desperate never, ever to allow anyone to think anything negative about any Muslims.

merrymouse · 21/07/2015 19:02

And without defining what integration is, does it mean much anyway?

merrymouse · 21/07/2015 19:01

I don't really understand the point of the thread - David Cameron is saying he wants more integration. As others have said, are there people who want less integration?

WhetherOrNot · 21/07/2015 18:59

I didn't think anyone on here, YouTheCat, had shown any bigotry toward anyone, especially me. But then some people don't know the proper meaning of the word.

I am not intolerant of other races or religions. And I'd like you to quote me specifically if you think I am.

But after this thread I am certainly intolerant toward those who don't read, or listen or try to understand another's point of view.

OP posts:
YouTheCat · 21/07/2015 18:46

Nice dig there. Hmm

It's true. I'm am terribly intolerant... of bigots.

MrsTerryPratchett · 21/07/2015 18:27

That's how I read it as well, Wide.

WhetherOrNot · 21/07/2015 18:24

Still, at least it served to out a few bigots.

And some very nasty people who are intolerant of others whilst preaching tolerance Smile

OP posts:
YouTheCat · 21/07/2015 18:21

If you are going to start a thread on such a controversial subject, maybe you should learn to express yourself better instead of berating the rest of the posters on here for not getting your meaning? Just a thought.

Still, at least it served to out a few bigots.

RedDaisyRed · 21/07/2015 18:17

Indeed. Invented by men pretending there is a God to keep women in check - plus ca change which is why feminism remains extremely important in both the West and East and yes fundamentalist Christian beliefs can be pretty bad too.

DoraGora · 21/07/2015 18:13

If the book they're reading from is 1500 years old, and they're trying to read it literally, then, it's not surprising that they've stepped back in time. They wouldn't be the only peoples in that region to rock up from London, with a boat load of guns and carve out a homeland that hasn't existed for a thousand years. At least the caliphate's only been gone a couple of hundred years.

Wideopenspace · 21/07/2015 18:13

I read the OP as meaning 'integration not working is an embarrassment for everyone'

Wideopenspace · 21/07/2015 18:12

The gender pay gap in the UK stands at around 19% - despite it being a 'developed' nation.

Out of 650 seats in the UK parliament, only 148 are held by women. Despite it being a 'developed' nation.

There are magazines in supermarkets with women in their underwear.

Absolutely the scale of the patriarchy in Pakistan is bigger and has serious consequences if you are female and happen to be born there - but the UK is far from getting it right.

WhetherOrNot · 21/07/2015 18:11

live near none and YOU think integration is an issue.

MrsTP - DAVID CAMERON said integration is an issue. Not me. Stop jumping on your high horse and read read read what is written Hmm

OP posts:
WhetherOrNot · 21/07/2015 18:09

Read the OP again MrsTP - DAVID CAMERON is an embarrassment to everyone. Doh !!

OP posts:
RedDaisyRed · 21/07/2015 18:07

Yes the middle east is a mess and going backwards year by year. The picture of women in Iran in the 70s shows how far it has fallen (and yes I've been out of my City (London) and been to the middle east for work including Iran).

It depends what we mean by integration is not working. You certainly get white flight - particularly where I live and that becomes self perpetuating. We have always had some ghettos - jews in the East End, China Town etc but usually with each group gradually they move into other areas as they get more money and mix in pretty seamlessly generally benefiting from Western value as time goes on.

Islam is interesting today in the UK because people are going backwards and the rebellion of some of the young is a desire to adopt attitudes suitable for deserts 2000 years ago when women were owned. What fools they are so to be conned.

merrymouse · 21/07/2015 18:06

Modest Christian swimwear for girls - it isn't as simple as Islam against the west.

David Cameron has finally admitted that "integration is not working"
MrsTerryPratchett · 21/07/2015 18:04

And Leader women are massively discriminated against in other countries too; South Africa (rape capital of the world) for example is broadly Christian. I say again, the issue is not Islam, it is the patriarchy.

MrsTerryPratchett · 21/07/2015 18:01

Read your OP. Read it and think about how it sounds to people who are immigrants, or who love, work with, live near and care about immigrants. Really think about that. Now, can you see why people are a bit peeved and don't want to gently talk to you about your bigotry. You start by saying. " it is so glaringly obvious as to be an embarrassment for everyone" and now it seems you know no Muslims, live near none and YOU think integration is an issue.

merrymouse · 21/07/2015 18:01

Women in Iran in the 1970's

David Cameron has finally admitted that "integration is not working"
OurDearLeader · 21/07/2015 18:00

Women currently hold 5.2 percent of Fortune 500 CEO roles. Those bloody Muslims, running all the Fortune 500 companies and sidelining women.

We might not be perfect, but in Pakistan only 1 in 5 women work compared to 4 in 5 men. 85% of the workforce is men. Women who do work earn 37% less than men. Women are forced into lower status jobs on lower wages with less rights. Pakistan is rated 134th out of 135 countries for women's economic participation. Less than half of the women in Pakistan can read and write. Only 1 in 5 girls from low income families have ever been to school. Women's access to justice is severely restricted. Domestic abuse is not a crime and 97% of women report having been on the receiving end of domestic violence. Many women are not allowed to associate freely and have curbs placed on their general liberty. I could go on.

To use the fact that women are underrepresented in the very top jobs of the private sector in this country to justify and deflect from that is like someone trying to say that a splinter and tree trunk are the same thing.

WhetherOrNot · 21/07/2015 17:52

Why does this always happen on thread on MN? People who can't accept that other people see things differently always start having a 'go' at individuals like me.

By having a 'go' at me you are doing Muslims a complete disservice - you miss the opportunity to teach and you just get nasty.

OP posts:
MrsTerryPratchett · 21/07/2015 17:47

Stop being scathing and try being enlightening for a change! I can try being all sound-bitey and faux sincere like the shiny-faced arsehole if you would like.

WhetherOrNot · 21/07/2015 17:47

Don't have a go at me peeps - perhaps you ought to have a go at the media at the way they portray Muslims..........then those of us who are not enlightened can at last be learned (that's learn-ed not learned!).

OP posts: