Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

David Cameron has finally admitted that "integration is not working"

385 replies

WhetherOrNot · 20/07/2015 19:16

AIBU to think that he should have cottoned on about 10 years ago, not now when it is so glaringly obvious as to be an embarrassment for everyone?

OP posts:
OurDearLeader · 22/07/2015 18:36

Oh really? Why was there never a Communist state in Iran then? Did the communists accidentally put the wrong name on the letterheads and decide to call themselves an Islamic Republic instead?

Silk, yes, but that doesn't address the initial point. Which was that a poster put up a picture of women in Tehran in the 70s as apparent 'proof' that Islam is absolutely marvelous for women. When in fact portrayed the results of a more secularised Islam and that type of lifestyle was swept away when the Islamists took control.

The rest of your post may well be accurate. But it doesn't change the fact that when Islamists took over Iran they began a regime which was much more oppressive towards women. Nothing you've said is any sort of argument against that.

So I presume you are very supportive of the idea of women being executed for being raped, the death sentence for being gay? Or of children being executed because Iran reckons it's fine because Islam says it's okay? It's strongly suspected they stone people in Iran. Are you keen on that too? They still have the highest execution rate per capita according to Amnesty so I'm not exactly sure what sort of brave new dawn of a better life the Islamist brought?

silkoversatin · 22/07/2015 18:22

Which Universities are you referring to Grays? Can you tell us what your evidence for that claim is?

GraysAnalogy · 22/07/2015 15:07

I think integration is failing at some universities, where there seems to be an undercurrent of radicalism. Which makes me question why. Is it because radicalists target young people? Or is it young people who are disillusioned more?

RedDaisyRed · 22/07/2015 14:55

It was more like communism which led Iran on the path to backwardness.

silkoversatin · 22/07/2015 14:45

Iran changed in 1979 because of Islam? So that was it OurDearLeader? Here was me thinking the fact that the Iranian people were for decades living under the mass murdering Shah’s political system, [which had the highest rate of death penalties in the world, no civilian courts and a history of torture which was 'beyond belief', according to Amnesty International]. Might have had something to do with it? But no, it was Islam all along! My fault for being one of them deluded, right on people I s'pose!

See, I'd always thought the military coup organised by Britain and the United States to overthrow the democratically elected government of Iran in 1953 to secure the country’s oil, might have caused a bit of resentment amongst Iranians? How daft of me? Turns out they’re all just a load of religious nutters!

WhetherOrNot · 21/07/2015 22:04

Ah well, I stand corrected. My grasp of English is obviously not up to MN standards for starting a debate. Smile

OP posts:
Wideopenspace · 21/07/2015 20:52

From Da Meedja, innit Dora

oabiti · 21/07/2015 20:50

kardamyli how have immigrants been pandered to?! Hmm

DoraGora · 21/07/2015 20:50

One of the main responses would have been, why has it been obvious?

YouTheCat · 21/07/2015 20:46

Like Wideopenspace said - something like that would have had very different responses.

Wideopenspace · 21/07/2015 20:44

I would perhaps have said :

'I come from an exclusively white British village so am not best placed to hold an opinion based on personal experience. However, David Cameron's recent speech about 'integration not working' puzzles me because if you listen to the media, it seems this has been obvious for a while. AIBU to ask your experience of integration, in your community'

YouTheCat · 21/07/2015 20:38

Oh ffs, I wasn't even being sarky.

If I'd wanted to know something, I would have put it differently.

I haven't resorted to personal attacks so why all the passive aggression?

WhetherOrNot · 21/07/2015 20:29

Personally, I'd have worded things differently.

Sorry my literary education is not up to your exacting standards Hmm

OP posts:
DoraGora · 21/07/2015 20:23

Fairness is an ideal. Nobody ever said that it was necessary. The Tories are making a popular case for the notion that it's not necessary at all. One of the things you'll always notice about unfairness, is that it's normally promoted by the people who are doing most well of of the status quo. But, ironically, that's not always true. You do also get victims promoting their misfortunes, which is a bit puzzling.

RedDaisyRed · 21/07/2015 20:16

I suspect many of the criticisms of Islam are genuinely and rightly about the problems women face under that religion and some other religions. There are of course feminists in Islam fighting to show that the Koran is about equality and that it is men who have misconstrued against the will of God that equality. The koran also says men should cover up but men have not interpreted that remotely fairly.

YouTheCat · 21/07/2015 20:11

Well, I learned something.

Personally, I'd have worded things differently.

WhetherOrNot · 21/07/2015 20:08

And I ask again, why start a thread like this when you know so little about the subject?

Perhaps in the hope that I might learn something worthwhile YouTheCat?
I can forever live in hope I suppose Smile

OP posts:
Wideopenspace · 21/07/2015 20:01

Is that not sometimes true though Ellie - or are you not a believer in the patriarchy?

EllieFAntspoo · 21/07/2015 19:56

Indeed. Invented by men pretending there is a God to keep women in check.

Run any thread for more than dozen pages and you'll have some idiot claim it's a feminist issue and that men are to blame.

maxxytoe · 21/07/2015 19:39

I live ten minutes from cheetham hill in Manchester.
Integration is DEFINITELY not working
I wouldn't go through there on my own now , it is a ghetto

merrymouse · 21/07/2015 19:38

If you look at the Christisn blogosphere, 'modest' clothing is pretty mainstream.

On the other hand I don't think every Muslim teenager in the UK is rushing to join ISIS. Even if they are, they weren't 30 years ago, yet they still had the same Koran.

You could go back in time and get rid of the Koran tomorrow - extremists would still flourish in the right conditions. They would just find a different book.

Capricorn76 · 21/07/2015 19:36

Integration like relationships takes both sides to make an effort.

We can bang on about Muslims integrating all we want but lets be honest if a group of Asian men rocked up to a small village pub how welcome would they be made to feel?

MonstrousRatbag · 21/07/2015 19:32

Why is it only the muslims that are having a problem integrating ?

What, all of them? I don't think so. Somali Muslims? Malaysian Muslims? Bengalis, Pakistanis, Indians, Arabs, Bosnians, Nigerians? Who?

And who says they are the only people 'having problems integrating'? Go to Lincolnshire and ask the Eastern Europeans there how easy it is to integrate. Or the Portuguese in Peterborough, or wherever it was, who had threats and their windows put in after the Portuguese football team beat England.

And, in relation to any group having difficulties integrating, how do we know (i) they are to blame for these difficulties; and (ii) the difficulties are caused by the fact that they are Muslims and not any other factor like non-religious cultural differences, poverty, lack of education, racism (theirs or anyone else's) or some other factor?

No one will make the situation better without careful and honest analysis that takes a long hard look at recent history as well as the present, including white hostility to newcomers as well as the faults of the newcomers themselves. Yet again I see no evidence that any politician or commentator actually has the appetite for that.

RedDaisyRed · 21/07/2015 19:21

OurDear speaks the truth. Most muslims who are trying to get to the UK are not coming here because we emulate islamic state nor to convert the UK to Islam. Most of them want more money and more chances for their chidlren because Western democracy works and is fair and Islamic states are backward and discriminatory.

We just have to be careful about the few radicals in our midst. I am not too bothered about them leaving to kill each other abroad as long as we don't allow them back in.

MrsTerryPratchett · 21/07/2015 19:16

Actually Leader there is some decent evidence that the patriarchy is to do with the start of fixed agriculture. Before that, in hunter gatherer societies, gathering provided more of the calories so it behooved the men to be quite nice to the women. After fixed agriculture, being strong and guarding the harvest became important so muscle and aggression got you more. Money made it worse, and yes, religion too.

For the millionth time, of course support for Sharia Law is an issue, Pakistan is not a shining beacon of equality and ISIS aren't kittens. But we have the power to do something about equality in the UK and that isn't just a case of standing, pointing at Muslims and saying, "look, it's all their fault". Clearing up the array of pedophiles and rapists that run politics, the media and the Church would be a great start.