Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

David Cameron has finally admitted that "integration is not working"

385 replies

WhetherOrNot · 20/07/2015 19:16

AIBU to think that he should have cottoned on about 10 years ago, not now when it is so glaringly obvious as to be an embarrassment for everyone?

OP posts:
OurDearLeader · 24/07/2015 11:41

Grays, we're not talking about regarding homosexuality as a sin though are we? I agree people have every right to believe that if they want as long as it doesn't mean that they treat other people in a discriminatory fashion.

But this isn't really about having a personal belief that homosexuality is a sin and choosing not to indulge in it yourself is it? It's about people who want those they believe to be homosexual to be hung, pushed off buildings, stoned or beheaded.

GraysAnalogy · 24/07/2015 11:39

'people like you' Excuse me?

I'm sorry but I'm not going to engage with someone who has been volatile from the get go. If you want a debate I suggest you change your attitude.

retrorobot · 24/07/2015 11:37

"But people should be able to live without persecution if they are doing no harm. Like gay people."

It all depends on what your definitions of "persecution" and "doing no harm" are.

I don't think you know anything about human rights at all. It's just the sort of throwaway comment that people like you use to try to intimidate others.

Now would you care to tell us what "displays of homophobia" you would ban?

DoraGora · 24/07/2015 11:28

I think grays said displaying, not saying. If I display my disapproval of Edward II by sticking a red hot poker up his bum, I can see how Brussels could take a dim view of that behaviour. However, if I say that kings who overly indulge royal favourites, especially ones of the same sex, should think more about medieval dungeons and their consequences, and less about personal pleasure, I think human rights legislators are going to find the issue more tricky.

GraysAnalogy · 24/07/2015 11:24

No I'm actually quite laid back and don't give a toss what people think about me. But people should be able to live without persecution if they are doing no harm. Like gay people.

I never said anything of the sort in regards to your second sentence, I didn't realise telling you about human rights was 'blathering on'.

You seem volatile, are you from the US? I've only ever seen such a strong response from US Republicans.

retrorobot · 24/07/2015 11:18

GraysAnalogy: Do you live in a permanent state of being offended? The gay community need to stop demanding mind control of everyone else - it's deeply illiberal and contrary to the fundamental right to free speech.

If you want people to be banned from saying that homosexual acts are a sin because it hurts gay people's feelings then come out and say that, rather than blathering on about protected characteristics and human rights.

Should religious groups also be banned from saying that they consider pre-marital sex a sin?

GraysAnalogy · 24/07/2015 11:06

Sexual orientation is a protected characteristic, so depending on how homophobia is displayed it can be a breach of Human Rights.

retro all of your post is just so offensive it's unreal. Putting a human being on the same level as eating pork? Comparing the feelings of the gay community to those of terrorists?

retrorobot · 24/07/2015 00:23

When did homophobia become a crime? There are parts of the U.K. (Scotland and Northern Ireland) where gay men having sex was still illegal into the 1980s - that's within the lifetime of anyone 35 or over. Pretty much every mainstream Christian denomination in the U.K. still regards gay sex as a sin.

Big deal if Islam regards gay sex as a sin. Islam also regards eating pork, ham and bacon as a sin.

People can believe what they want and screw the gay community if its feelings are hurt as a result. Their feelings don't allow them to dictate what others can think. Just like hurt feelings of Muslims isn't a reason for opposing terrorism.

Let people think and say what they like so long as they are not advocating violence or aggression.

MistressMia · 23/07/2015 23:23

MistressMia only ever appears on mumsnet to stir up hatred for Muslims

Taken quite a while for this accusation to emerge. On other threads you're usually straight in there within a few posts.

I live in hope that perhaps some of you at last may be beginning to question the orthodoxy of your beliefs and if you do, I'm sure you too will be able to maintain the distinction between disliking an idea and disliking the person who holds that idea sacred.

IPityThePontipines · 23/07/2015 22:37

You do know that there are Muslim women posting on Mumsnet. We're here already Smile

Radicalrooster · 23/07/2015 22:20

Indeed. A liberal society where people aren't in actuality allowed to plot and scheme because the police and intelligence services take a dim view of that sort of thing and you end up getting arrested and then jailed if proved guilty. What's your point?

DoraGora · 23/07/2015 21:56

I think the clue is in the title liberal society, dear.

Radicalrooster · 23/07/2015 21:49

If this country was ever going to turn into a police state, it would have happened by now you muppet.

DoraGora · 23/07/2015 21:34

It's not the going to join Daesh that's the problem. It's the coming back. In a liberal society people are free to scheme and plot and some will, whether they're bank robbers, IRA, Daesh supporters, you name it. There is one way to cut down the number of all kinds of plotters exponentially; set up a huge network of spies and secret police and have a series of show trials where suspects are killed horribly.

PM me for details.

RedDaisyRed · 23/07/2015 21:06

It sounds like 2000 British Muslims have gone abroad to fight for or breed / provide sexual services for ISIS. Within the UK there is a problem of too closed off communities but we have always been fairly tolerant of those from the hassidic jews in London and Manchester etc to the Brethren and many others. I think we are a pretty tolerant society. In the UK we have been more bombed by the Irish IRA in the last 50 years on home turf than Muslims. However we should not be complacent. We had 7/7 and there are more muslims in the UK who would be keener to be suicide bombers on British soil than most other groups I can think of at the moment so we do well to keep an eye on children. In fact it is parental responsibility we need here more than anything. Is your teenage boy happy adjusted and enthusiastic about a career or are you immersing him too much in religion and exposing him or allowing him to be exposed to radicals at the mosque or on line? Let the parent take responsibility perhaps not in the North Korean sense where they punish 3 generations if one family member errs but at least let the parents not blame and police, school or state. Let us look into ourselves first before blaming others.

merrymouse · 23/07/2015 20:30

I never really understand the the arguments of some people on here. 'Well I met Mahmood's Mum at school and she seemed really nice so I think we should ignore the oppression of women, gays being murdered, minorities being persecuted and killed, villages being massacred, girls being kidnapped, people being beheaded, and people being killed for leaving a religion or believing in it a bit wrong. Because she's really lovely and she gave me some sweets so there must be absolutely no problems with Islam'.

Yes, because British Muslims aren't people you grow up with or work and socialise with, they are strange veiled women with sweets!

merrymouse · 23/07/2015 19:59

But hey, you just keep on thinking that the history of Islam is just one long fluffy love in with tambourines and ignore the fact that they've often proved themselves to be extremely violent, bigoted and oppressive themselves.

I don't, but then the history of Christianity, or even just plain old Europe, isn't fluffy either.

There are plenty of non-newsworthy Muslims.

LazyLohan · 23/07/2015 19:04

MerryMouse if you read back over my posts you'll see that I have actually said that I lived alongside Muslims in some areas, particularly Turkish and Kurdish people, but also Iranian and some African Muslims and those communities got along well with the people they lived alongside.

But that doesn't change the fact that there is a hell of a lot of evil being committed all over the world in the name of Islam and a lot of people in this country subscribe to the same view as those committing these evil acts.

I never really understand the the arguments of some people on here. 'Well I met Mahmood's Mum at school and she seemed really nice so I think we should ignore the oppression of women, gays being murdered, minorities being persecuted and killed, villages being massacred, girls being kidnapped, people being beheaded, and people being killed for leaving a religion or believing in it a bit wrong. Because she's really lovely and she gave me some sweets so there must be absolutely no problems with Islam'.

The most depressing thing about it is that an awful lot of people who would normally be expected to speak about this sort of thing (repression of minority religions, gays, women), University educated liberals; they've been utterly conned into supporting this sort of things because they've bought into the totally illogical thesis that the only people who can be nasty to other people or be bigoted, violent and oppressive are white people because we've been violent and oppressive in the past.

Overlooking inconvenient historical truths like the fact that Muslims have been involved in some pretty horrific massacres and wars, have had their own oppressive empires and actually started the African slave trade.

But hey, you just keep on thinking that the history of Islam is just one long fluffy love in with tambourines and ignore the fact that they've often proved themselves to be extremely violent, bigoted and oppressive themselves.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 23/07/2015 18:54

Interesting that some tend to revert to personal attacks on those who make posts they dislike - also that they're often keen to parrot "anecdotes aren't data/evidence" but then readily share their own, presumably in the hope that their anecdote is somehow of more value

One of the reasons I find MistressMia's posts valuable is that she'll be frank where something is a purely personal experience, but when presenting things as facts she posts the relevant evidence. Of course evidence can occasionally be wrong, but when so much of it points in a particular direction it surely becomes harder to contest it - and insults do nothing to improve the credibility of the callers, no matter how much they wish it would

OurDearLeader · 23/07/2015 18:14

OurDearLeader In Nigeria, Boko Haram has a lot of Christian members in its pay and one can't help wondering where the pay comes from. In Syria the West choose to side with a group, sending arms and other resources to the group that ended up called itself ISIS, and that any Muslim could tell you acts against the mandates of the Qur'an.

If you look up that claim about Christians it comes from one report. The author of that report himself says '"But I have no doubt that the leadership of [Boko Haram] and its formal ideologies are Muslim, not Christian'.

Even if Boko Haram do use paid militia they are still Islamists and there aim is still to persecute Christians and even if they pay non-Muslims to do their dirty work they are still the people commissioning that result and they are Islamists. So it's a bit irrelevant really. Unless you're going to start claiming that Boko Haram are actually an undercover Christian sect trying to undermine Islam. Which wouldn't even surprise me on this forum TBH.

I'm not sure why you think 'Any Muslim' would tell me that it was against the Koran. For a start anybody with the slightest knowledge about Islam knows that what you call the 'mandates' of the Koran are disputed and different scholars, Muslims and Imams will tell you that the meanings are completely different things. And considering that support for extremism hovers at around 1/3 in this country according to reliable pollsters (and is probably higher because some will be reluctant to admit it), the idea that 'any Muslim' would say their acts were against the Koran is, frankly, bollocks.

RedDaisyRed · 23/07/2015 18:02

I live amongst Muslims. I don't base my views on what I see on the news and I also read widely in all media. most muslims in the UK are here because they make more money here and our legal system is better than Sharia and they are less likely to be bombed than in down town Iraq. However plenty of them are sexist to the core and homophobic. Many will say they love God more than their spouse or children and plenty would be prepared to die for their faith. None of us hate misguided sexist homophobics. We just want to communicate with them to such an extent that they cast off the yoke of religious oppression and let the scales fall from their eyes and see the true right path of Western liberalism which of course will happen as that is the global trend. There is much to hope for.

MM quotes good sources and is much respected. I have never seen anything she has posted which is hatred. It is just fact.

Inkanta · 23/07/2015 18:02

'MistressMia only ever appears on mumsnet to stir up hatred for Muslims.'

I don't see that myself. She is of the opinion there is a problem with integration and delivers a good argument.

Atenco · 23/07/2015 17:53

I don't believe in closing discussion down, Inkanta, but like merrymouse what MistressMia says and quotes bear no relation to my experience of Muslims, young and old. MistressMia* only ever appears on mumsnet to stir up hatred for Muslims.

Inkanta · 23/07/2015 17:27

Atenco

I think your argument is weak - when your focus is to criticise MistressMia for quoting media reports and stating it's all untrue. I have never understood this need to close discussion down rather than discuss, or simply say nothing.

merrymouse · 23/07/2015 17:22

36% of British muslim 16-24 year olds believe if a Muslim converts to another religion they should be punished by death, news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/6309983.

Yet this bears no relation whatsoever to my experience over 5 decades of going to school with Muslims, working with Muslims and sending my children to school with Muslims in a multi cultural metropolitan area.

There is obviously a problem with radicalisation of young Muslims, but views on this thread come across as hatred for all Muslims, not based on personal experience but on news stories.