Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

David Cameron has finally admitted that "integration is not working"

385 replies

WhetherOrNot · 20/07/2015 19:16

AIBU to think that he should have cottoned on about 10 years ago, not now when it is so glaringly obvious as to be an embarrassment for everyone?

OP posts:
CherryPicking · 20/07/2015 20:37

He's quite right, of course. it's been over 100 years since the formation of the Labour party, and since then we've all (enfranchised descendents of the victorian underclass) been trying to pretend that it's possible for the interests of the masses to be compatible with the interests of a small, self-centred, non-integrated clique of very rich, very powerful people, and that democracy will sort things out. Clearly it won't - certainly not the First Past the Post system at any rate. Tories are simply not capable of integrating into a democratic system which is supposed to work in the best interests of society as a whole. They subscribe to a dangerous ideology of extreme free-market capitalism, condoning shady deals like TTIP (google it. seriously) whilst right-thinking citizens look on powerlessly.

AnUtterIdiot · 20/07/2015 20:35

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

ghostyslovesheep · 20/07/2015 20:35

you don't seem very accepting Hmm

you seem to want everyone to be like you - that's not integrating

ghostyslovesheep · 20/07/2015 20:34

these 'immigrants' are probably BRITISH kardamyli born here, raised here and part of our society - maybe you should integrate with them?

Kardamyli · 20/07/2015 20:34

I think in the context of this discussion integration does only work one way. The UK is a very to,errant and accepting society, which is of course why people want to come here. Once here people need to make the effort to integrate.

ghostyslovesheep · 20/07/2015 20:32

There's nothing like hostility to make minority groups feel beleaguered and to not leave the safety and comfort zone of their own people

^^ this

Kardamyli · 20/07/2015 20:32

who is to blame for the mess in Syria and neighbouring countries is beside the point. As others have said, there are large swathes of the UK where immigrants have no desire to integrate. I don't know what needs to be done to change that, but something definitely does need to be done.

ghostyslovesheep · 20/07/2015 20:31

Some areas comprise of Asian food stores, sari shops, takeaways; pharmacists; halal shops. I drove through one area and there were only Asian people in Asian attire. It needs to be seen to be believed and I felt like an outsider. There desperately needs to be more integration- it's shocking

so integration only works ONE WAY?

Asia is a big place btw - and these people I am guessing where paying rent on the shops, tax on the clothes etc etc - so brining something of value to society

why does 'integration' mean changing everything about yourself - that's assimilation - it's not the same thing

Icelandicsuperyoghurt · 20/07/2015 20:28

I forgot to say that I'm Jewish. I know quite a lot of 2nd and 3rd generation people in the community who only mix with other Jewish people and whos kids/grandkids are educated in Jewish schools, have only Jewish friends and attend Jewish organisations. There are insular sections of most ethic minority groups I should think. It's usually born out of fear, prejudice, feeling misunderstood and disliked. At the moment, the majority of Muslims are having to deal with the hostility caused by actions of extremists from within their community. Jews are dealing with hostility arising out of anger over the Israeli government's actions in palestine. There's nothing like hostility to make minority groups feel beleaguered and to not leave the safety and comfort zone of their own people.

ghostyslovesheep · 20/07/2015 20:28

black people can be racist - lots of people can be racist

people can have opinions - they can publish those opinions

it doesn't mean everyone has to agree - nor does it make those opinions fact - being black also doesn't mean he's right or that it's the only valid view

I do think alot of the problems with integration come from the established community and not from the newcomers

Meechimoo · 20/07/2015 20:28

It's a very complex issue and whatever Cameron or any Prime Minister did, they'd be thoroughly lambasted for it. It's a no win situation.

pointythings · 20/07/2015 20:26

I think it's a bit simplistic to try to encapsulate a situation in which very many very complex factors are involved as 'integration is not working'. It's a cheap political soundbite, and all it will do is whip up yet more hatred towards Muslims, which will feed those wanting to radicalise young minds.

Meechimoo · 20/07/2015 20:25

Sure they did youthecat, or at least implied it.Hmm

YouTheCat · 20/07/2015 20:24

No one had mentioned 'racism' until you did, Meechimoo.

Wheretheresawill1 · 20/07/2015 20:22

And before I get accused of racism for having an opinion I had a Muslim boyfriend. You can imagine how that ended

Meechimoo · 20/07/2015 20:22

Trevor Phillips said that integration wasn't working. (and he's the black son of immigrants)
Impossible to discuss without lazy cries of "Oi, racist" though..

Wheretheresawill1 · 20/07/2015 20:21

Integration not working in this very Muslim city. There are complete areas now taken over my immigrants. Generations of families bought over here crammed in houses. Lots of non English speaking. Some areas comprise of Asian food stores, sari shops, takeaways; pharmacists; halal shops. I drove through one area and there were only Asian people in Asian attire. It needs to be seen to be believed and I felt like an outsider. There desperately needs to be more integration- it's shocking

charlestonchaplin · 20/07/2015 20:19

Many of these Islamic extremists have been born and bred in the UK, as has their extremism. I saw people becoming radicalised at my British university, deviating very strongly from their parents' values. I never saw these more militant attitudes in the country I grew up in which had a large Muslim population.

Things may have changed now, though. The world is changing, but I think many people fail to acknowledge the part western governments have played in creating the situation we have now. Muslim unhappiness about the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan have provided extremist preachers with material to use to whip up idealist young Muslims. Saddam Hussein kept a tight rein on that country. We called him a dictator and liberated the people. And unleashed chaos, which ISIS is taking advantage of.

We rejoiced in the Arab Spring. ISIS is taking advantage of the weaker governments now in place. And now we are tired of war so we leave ISIS to get on with it, forgetting that the world is now a small place and those conflicts won't remain restricted to faraway lands for ever. And since the UK doesn't have the balls to stop people returning to the country after fighting for ISIS we are in a precarious position. Guantanamo Bay is probably a horrible place, but it seems a very appealing proposition right now.

YouTheCat · 20/07/2015 20:15

I don't live anywhere near the capital, though I do live in a city.

Georgina1975 · 20/07/2015 20:13

Integration is possibly more of an issue outside of the metropolis? There are certainly racial and ethnic groupings in terms of housing where I live and this translates into education (primary and secondary). Segregation along there lines become embedded in the 1970s and is difficult to address.

It is not a "muslim" thing though. The latest tension in my community is between Eastern Europeans and (relatively new) Roma incomers.

I am actually most concerned (as stated upthread) about class/social segregation.

ghostyslovesheep · 20/07/2015 20:13

probably a similar number to the 2nd 3rd and 4th generation of Irish Catholic immigrants who supported the IRA in the 70's and 80's I would imagine

yet I seemed to integrate quiet well despite the anti Irish shit that got thrown my way as a kid

ghostyslovesheep · 20/07/2015 20:10

oh and dismissing other peoples views as 'typical comments from the usual posters' is a bit rude - may be engage with the discussion?

CorBlimeyTrousers · 20/07/2015 20:10

I think those (including me) who offer our anecdotal stories are simply giving examples that 'failure of integration' is not inevitable and in many cases works very well.

How do the numbers of those who have gone to join IS etc compare to the overall number of Muslims in the country? I would expect it's a tiny minority but admittedly I don't have the figures to hand. Don't you think the answer might be to build better relationships between different communities?

Do you hold all Christians responsible for the behaviour of the very small number who harass women outside abortion clinics (and in the US sometimes kill doctors who perform abortions)?

Icelandicsuperyoghurt · 20/07/2015 20:10

In specific areas throughout the country its definitely not working. In others its much better, so its probably not something that can be generalised on. The entire issue is so complex, with so many contributing factors.

Swipe left for the next trending thread