Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

David Cameron has finally admitted that "integration is not working"

385 replies

WhetherOrNot · 20/07/2015 19:16

AIBU to think that he should have cottoned on about 10 years ago, not now when it is so glaringly obvious as to be an embarrassment for everyone?

OP posts:
YouTheCat · 20/07/2015 21:19

What is ignorant and abhorrent about not deriding other people for their religion or culture? Hmm

MrsTerryPratchett · 20/07/2015 21:17

Some areas comprise of Asian food stores, sari shops, takeaways; pharmacists; halal shops Curse them with their cheap, nice shops that are local. I much prefer Starbucks, McDonalds and Toys R Us; those lovely British shops.

Wideopenspace · 20/07/2015 21:17

Tut maid standards really are slipping.

I think that the OP is a tiny slice of a much wider context. It's not actually especially helpful to try and draw conclusions from it.

pointythings · 20/07/2015 21:17

I'm with everyone who's asking the question: Which British values? Because it isn't straightforward at all.

You start with a simple one: speak the language of the country you're living in. Fair enough. Problem is, these young people joining ISIS already do.

Then you dig a little deeper and maybe get a little more controversial: stop ritual slaughter of animals and stop cutting bits off perfectly healthy children. Oh, but then you'd have to include the Jewish community in that, wouldn't you? It isn't simple.

After that, what next? Stop wearing saris/yarmulkes? Stop eating the food of your native culture? (but you can still have chicken tikka masala, that's British). Support rights for LGBT people? Oh, but now you're treading on a lot of Christian toes.

See how tricky it gets?

MaidOfStars · 20/07/2015 21:17

Ah sarcasm and ive got muslim friends all one post good ol you

Indeed.

Which 'British values' would like my Muslim friends (I have many, all of them boringly non-extremist) to take on?

Kardamyli · 20/07/2015 21:17

I feel the same way about you YouTheCat. Ignorant and abhorrent views in every one of your posts.

frankieboy23 · 20/07/2015 21:13

Ah sarcasm and ive got muslim friends all one post good ol you.

Kardamyli · 20/07/2015 21:13

Ok ghosty, my anecdata for the evening. There are a few Muslim families whose children attend the same (primary) school as my children. The Muslim children are second, if not third or fourth generation immigrants. None of these children are allowed to mix with their non Muslim friends outside of school. Every invitation to play dates, parties etc is refused. It is not a huge school so parents in each year group know each other well. It is commented upon occasionally that all invitations are refused by these families, though the children are still always invited to whole class parties.

The parents are no better, they don't attend anything at school other than parents evening and never accept invitations to out of school social events. It can't be that they don't like the school as it is fee paying so their choice. Surely if they thought all the other children and families were horrible they would send their own children elsewhere.

If this is my experience, I don't think it can be an isolated one.

MaidOfStars · 20/07/2015 21:10

There should be an effort to take on SOME British values.

Which are?

I second this question.

Last weekend, I hosted a work get together. Imagine my horror when my Muslim colleague and her family arrived, shook hands and kissed all round, cooked and ate with us, celebrated the end of a shocker of a Ramadan (YY to previous poster with the running joke re: Scandinavia), drank mocktails and generally had a great laugh. I even, wait, observed the woman telling her husband (laughingly) he was an idiot (I forget why).

They abjectly failed to stone the gay couple.

Terrible, you can't get the Muslims these days.

YouTheCat · 20/07/2015 21:09

Ellie, totally agree with you on this one.

Kardamyli, I find your views on this, and how you expressed yourself (on the previous page especially), to be absolutely abhorrent.

Kardamyli · 20/07/2015 21:03

Ellie, who in government is telling anyone to hate Muslims? DC has called for better integration, which can only lead to less, not more, hate and division amongst communities and less dislike of Muslims, or any other immigrant community.

I'm fairly neutral on the idea of dropping bombs on ISIS. The only thing that sways me against is the likelihood that some of those bombs will hit the wrong target.

The more of your posts that I read, the more I think you're a bit paranoid. Of course there's spin put on things, and burying bad news but you really think DC is asking for better integration in society as a precursor to war? Mind you, if there was a full blown war, I suspect a lot of extremist muslim nutters would leave to join the other side. Perhaps DC should pretend he's about to declare war, wait for them to leave and then say he's changed his mind?

EllieFAntspoo · 20/07/2015 21:03

Our national media loves to paint the British public as inherently bigoted and racist, and many of the responses on this thread play very well into that stereotype.

You can plant a single seed of thought into the public psyche and all of a sudden the hatred and resentment for ones fellow human beings is brought rushing to the fore.

How very predictable we all are.

MaidOfStars · 20/07/2015 21:02

Some areas comprise of Asian food stores, sari shops, takeaways; pharmacists; halal shops

Shocking.

We demand Starbucks, a bookies, a poundland and a Tesco Express IMMEDIATELY.

Demise of the British High Street, hell in a handcart, etc etc.

MarchLikeAnAnt · 20/07/2015 21:00

There should be an effort to take on SOME British values.

Which are?

EllieFAntspoo · 20/07/2015 20:56

There have been reports of young women, young men, families including babies leaving the UK to join ISIS, but you don't think there is any sort of problem with how all those people have integrated into UK society? If they had integrated, do you think they would still have upped and left to go to Syria?

I don't get what you are saying here? Are you saying that we have failed to stamp out their culture? Or that we have failed to convert them to our way of seeing the world? Or that they are clearly stupid because they do not value what we value, and we are clearly the superior culture?

Explain what you actually believe is happening? Because it seems to me that you are saying people should be allowed to have freedom to think and choose, so long as they think in line with what you wish them to think, and choose to do what you want them to do.

What exactly has a person done wrong, in your mind, by leaving this country for another that is engaged in a war?

pointythings · 20/07/2015 20:54

They May be British ghosty, but their parents, grandparents etc have taught them not to integrate, not to mix with white british people etc.

Let's have some evidence for that assertion, please. What I see is a generation of older immigrants who have become part of British society and who are horrified to see their young people turning away from tolerance and towards extremism. Sure there are always insular people - take a look at some of the more rigidly orthodox Jewish groups whose schools refuse to teach evolution and preach against women who drive. Some serious lack of integration going on there, too.

I feel very strongly that the aftermath of 9/11 is a strong causative factor in all this - suddenly it became acceptable to hate and fear Muslims. If you give people hatred and fear, should you be surprised that you get the same in return?

I live in a very white British area (am an immigrant myself but am as integrated as fuck, I even vaguely understand cricket) but I work with people across the UK from all backgrounds and cultures - and we all cooperate with mutual respect and friendship. We - and David Cameron - really need to be careful what we say, because currently we are risking alienating a lot of people who really are part of the communities we live in. Let's by all means take a serious look at what drives young people into the arms of extremism and then act on what we find, let's by all means deal with people who break anti-terrorism laws, but if we abandon tolerance we can just abandon hope alongside it.

Wheretheresawill1 · 20/07/2015 20:50

You can't even discuss these things. There should be an effort to take on SOME British values. I don't like feeling like an outsider in my own country. I make an effort with my Muslim friends and my ex. However the home life is a mysterious world that most definitely excluded me

I can see things from another viewpoint- I hated my ex who is British born hearing racism and felt that is damaging and sends these young people off to look for an identity. I didn't like that he referred to British girls as white slags but was more than happy to taste the goods

LovelyFriend · 20/07/2015 20:49

Our primary school must be about 50% Muslim. We have 37 different languages spoken by our pupils at home. Inner London. We all knock along very well - I'd say it's a great example of very lovely integration.

EllieFAntspoo · 20/07/2015 20:47

Kardamyli

The British people are being divided into sections and and set upon one another. We divide them into classes and tell them to hate one another. We divide them into races and tell them to hate one another. We divide them into religious groups and we tell them to hate one another. If we can keep them focused upon their neighbour, worried about their neighbour, and defending their own 'rights' against attacks from their neighbours, they can be controlled and told what to do.

Last weeks media issue... Who gains from telling you to hate the lazy bone idle wasters who live on benefits?

Answer - Those who wish to dismantle the welfare state and divert its funding elsewhere.

This weeks media issue... Who benefits from telling you to hate Muslims?

Answer - Those who wish to propagate war in the oil states.

Why?

Because war is the most profitable enterprise known to man. More money is made in war than in any other human endeavour. We live on a planet of finite resources, with a declining supply. We must secure those resources either through alliance or conquest. We will have our war, and the British public will rejoice, because that is what we will tell them to do.

Right now you are being told how evil lurks in your neighbourhood (proverbially speaking). How the man with the darker skin and the fondness for facial hair, wants to kill your children. We are being fed news stories about how his evil brothers are beheading, raping and butchering in the Middle East, and how if we let them talk about it amongst themselves, they might just do this to us.

This is not different to the television reports we saw with women crying and claiming the Iraqi soldiers were emptying babies out of incubators in hospitals, or the hospitals full of dying women and children after they were gassed by the Syrian Army. Both proven categorically to have been falsified by the media.

If you cannot discern the difference between politically motivated distraction, and honest fact, and you allow yourself to be manipulated into supporting the war agenda (how many of us cannot see we are building towards war?), then let us hope it is those children who's parents support it, that are called upon to fight for their cause.

Kardamyli · 20/07/2015 20:44

Who on earth on this thread thought DC was calling for anything other than better integration? That is what I've been trying to say we need. There should be an expectation on the part of all immigrants that they will have to integrate to a certain extent into the society they have chosen to join. The UK is on the whole very welcoming to other cultures, much more so than the majority of Western countries. Sure there are a few UKIP type idiots, but on the whole most people are keen to make friends from other cultures. Them problem is the vast numbers of immigrants who make zero effort.

museumum · 20/07/2015 20:44

Trevor Philips argued that multiculturalism wasn't working. Not that integration isn't working. Multiculturalism is almost the opposite of integration. We are only recently moving towards an approach of integration but still don't really have one.
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiculturalism

Icelandicsuperyoghurt · 20/07/2015 20:40

I live near a huge Pakistani and Punjabi neighbourhood. Yes there are predominantly shops catering for their needs but I go into some of the food shops, fabric stores etc and have not felt any hostility or discomfort. I am maybe naive, but most people when met with someone who is polite, smiley and interested, will be treated just fine.

If you came into the Jewish deli I go to, the guy on the tills wouldn't say good Sabbath to you on a Friday like he would to me, but he will be kind, helpful and polite to whoever comes in. It really does work both ways.

ghostyslovesheep · 20/07/2015 20:39

Oh Kardamyli I really think you should

ghostyslovesheep · 20/07/2015 20:38

which is a good thing AnUtterIdiot - and it works both ways - I have Muslim friends, I go into multicultural areas to eat and shop I accept being part of a mixed and varied society - I don't expect everyone to be like me in order to fit in

The issue I think is a refusal to accept change - thus to accept different cultures - which leads to isolation and ignorance on many sides

Kardamyli · 20/07/2015 20:38

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Swipe left for the next trending thread