Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

David Cameron has finally admitted that "integration is not working"

385 replies

WhetherOrNot · 20/07/2015 19:16

AIBU to think that he should have cottoned on about 10 years ago, not now when it is so glaringly obvious as to be an embarrassment for everyone?

OP posts:
MoreBeta · 20/07/2015 22:56

Radical - I was thinking of the large number of UK forces soldiers that have gone to Iraq and other bits of Africa M. East to work as mercenaries. Not picking which side they fight on but one mercenary is like any other.

Radicalrooster · 20/07/2015 22:54

Wideopenspace

Race certainly was an issue. From the Independent (fashionably left-wing)

"In most of the cases that the inquiry team examined, the victims were white children under the age of 16 and the perpetrators named in the files as “Asian males”."

A pure coincidence, I suppose? They couldn't find more Muslim girls to abduct, just to keep the score even and maintain their reputation as equal opportunities abusers? Really?

PurpleTurtles · 20/07/2015 22:54

Did someone really ask how US profitted from Iraq war????

Is that how thick people have become? Do they still think we went in to save the Iraqis from Saddam!

Its not only ISIS who brainwash people you know.

Look closer to home.

WhetherOrNot · 20/07/2015 22:53

OurDearLeader

Very well said indeed. It's just that a lot of people on MN deny that this is happening.

OP posts:
PyjamasLlamas · 20/07/2015 22:48

Sorry radical what has any of that got to do with the the hundred of thousands of Muslims in Britain?

Radicalrooster · 20/07/2015 22:47

MoreBeta, there are about 3 former British soldiers fighting against ISIS. One other died in action, one former city worker fighting as a mercenary came home. Former soldiers have much easier ways of making money these days. Syria is a deeply unattractive proposition when you could earn £300 a day working on a security gig in Nigeria.

Oh, and whatever mercenaries are out there, I bet you any money that they've yet to torture anyone to death for fun, or engage in the widescale and prolonged rape of Yazidi women, for example, or just victimise women in general (Kurds seem comparatively enlightened in that respect, apart from the whole honour killing thing). But give them time. I'm sure they'll live down to your expectations eventually.

Wideopenspace · 20/07/2015 22:46

MrsTP you also are speaking sense.

There were a large number of pakistani heritage girls who were subject to abuse that was identical to that reported on in the Rotherham child abuse case. Many of these girls never reported the abuse, but a charity called Apna Haq has supported them.

The Rotherham case was about abusers and vulnerable children. The Catholic children's home cases were about abusers and vulnerable children. The Operation Yewtree cases were about abusers and vulnerable children..I could go on. The common factor amongst the vast majority is that the abusers are men. And most (with the exception of the Catholic children's homes) of the victims are girls.

An issue with sexual violence? Absolutely. An issue with power and inequality? Absolutely. Integration? I'm not so sure it is key.

EllieFAntspoo · 20/07/2015 22:42

I noticed you skipped my query about the 'profits' we made from Iraq and Afghanistan, but hey ho, maybe your tinfoil hat slipped off.

Which companies have the contracts to rebuild these nations? Which companies have the contracts to advise? Which companies have the contracts to distribute the Iraqi oil? Which companies have the contracts to secure those fields? Who is Irans largest oil purchaser? Which country stands in the way of the Iran-China pipeline?

I really don't see the point in explaining what is very simple geopolitics here. If ignorance is your chosen bliss, you are welcome to it. This issue is far more complex than 'little Muslim man is evil and brainwashed'.

Whether by a mullah or a television set, weak minds are being told what to think on both sides here.

SinisterBunnyMonth · 20/07/2015 22:39

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

OurDearLeader · 20/07/2015 22:35

I lived all over London in areas which had high populations of Indians, the Turkish, Africans and West Indians. We all got along fine and there were no problems, including the Muslims in those communities.

But when I lived in areas which had a high population of Pakistani, Bangladeshi or Somali people my experience was very, very different, I felt high levels of hostility and faced a lot of prejudice. I could detail it all but it's too depressing. Honestly if things of the level I experienced happened to someone Pakistani or Bangladeshi in a white community there would be people in jail in a heartbeat.

I've moved up north and it's similar here but communities are even more polarised. It's not uncommon to meet 3rd generation folk who grew up in Britain but have Pakistani accents because they've grown up with very little contact outside the Pakistani community.

I think part of the problem is that the attitudes which led to Rotherham are held by a sizeable minority. White people who are not Muslims are often seen as worthless, slags, immoral, promiscuous, lazy, dirty, unworthy of respect and deserving of any violence, exploitation or unkindness which flies their way. Although obviously most people don't go as far as murder, the attitude of the families involved in the Laura Wilson murder case to a child with a white partner are often pretty typical.

We can and do as a society challenge unpleasant attitudes within other communities. I really don't see why this is different. We've tried the opposite tack of ignoring any unpleasant aspects of certain communities and denying they exist and it just hasn't worked. It's created communities who feel that the state has endorsed their decision to self segregate and segregation has accelerated, particularly in the north. I really think that something new has to be tried.

MoreBeta · 20/07/2015 22:34

There are many people of many different religions and ethnic backgrounds who have integrated so fully into UK society they are unnoticed.

We only notice those minority groups that choose not to integrate. They stand out by definition. There are Jewish people and Pakistani Muslim families I know who fall into this category. I don't especially like the fact that they shun British culture and society so actively but it is a tolerant and free country and does me no harm.

However, only a very very tiny minority of unintegrated people choose to go and join extremist groups and go on to kill.

I imagine that number of people is a lot lower than the number of former British forces personnel who have gone to fight as mercenaries.

Its a question of proportion.

MrsTerryPratchett · 20/07/2015 22:31

That's the point YOU are trying to make about Rotherham so I get why you think that is the only point. I don't think Rotherham was about integration. It was about a far wider set of issues; massive, unreported child abuse; lack of reporting and belief when things are reported; girls' and women's rights being marginalized internationally; power and what it means; the patriarchy.

Yes, I think there may have been issues with racism in Rotherham, it probably delayed this dreadful abuse coming to light. However, children in care being ignored and abused is widespread and is a bigger issue.

And stop insulting people.

YouTheCat · 20/07/2015 22:31

Kardamyli, I think the point is that I wouldn't mock anyone for their beliefs.

But you go right ahead.

PyjamasLlamas · 20/07/2015 22:30

I'm keen not to get too involved in the discussion. The usual suspects have or will come out soon and I can't bear to be sucked in but I would like to comment on a few things.

  1. The idea that there are Asian/Muslim areas and that this is a problem is hilarious. Communities tend to gather in the same place. Jewish people have their own communities in London and China town is a tourist attraction!! How can you possibly feel an outsider because you have to bear the hideousness of passing by a sari shop or gasp a halal butchers. Btw. Most 'Muslim' shop areas are not Muslim. For example green street in London is full of Hindu Sikh and Muslims shops happily existing side by side as is Southall and Wembley. I'm
Pretty sure they are all happy to serve the entire community.
  1. British values. I have never understood what this means. As a PP said how much of ones own religion culture rituals ceremonies clothing does one have to give up in order to be acceptably British??? And if the Muslims have to do it will you make all the other religions do so as well? Hindus Sikhs Jewish??
  2. Integration. Lots and lots of people don't so play dates parent meet ups and what not. Kids will
Play together in school, Go to college, university, the workplace. It's pretty hard not to integrate. Yes there may be some who choose to be insular.
  1. Muslims joining ISIS. Not sure why this is the main sticking point. Yes awful and horrendous but as a PP said 500 people have
Gone and that leave hundred of THOUSANDS who haven't. So just like the hundreds of murderers rapists and criminals in prison compared to all the law abiding citizens in the rest of the country. Don't see how it's proof of not integrating.
Radicalrooster · 20/07/2015 22:25

Pratchett, are you being deliberately obtuse? The point about the Rotherham scandal is its relevance to the issue of a lack of integration between an immigrant population and surrounding indigenous population. Your attempts to compare the actions of Catholic or Anglican paedophiles with the actions of gangs of young Muslim men targeting young white girls pretty much on the basis of their race is bizarre. It's also a distraction from a difficult subject. Such a difficult subject in fact that the police refused to heed warnings of what was happening for fear of being branded as racist. Thank God it wasn't up to MN to blow the fucking whistle on that particular scandal.

Radicalrooster · 20/07/2015 22:18

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Wideopenspace · 20/07/2015 22:17

ghosty you speak sense. In ALL of the child abuse scandals that have some to light in recent years, looked after children have featured heavily. The issue is definitely one of safeguarding vulnerable children.

To use this issue as a way of highlighting 'lack of integration' is bollocks, really. In my opinion.

MrsTerryPratchett · 20/07/2015 22:16

But, to use your anti Catholic agenda as an example, the Rotherham scandal can only be compared to abuse carried out by 'catholics' or 'white males' if those latter two groups were in the habit of organising themselves into gangs specifically in order to target thousands of local young Muslim girls because they were somehow seen as lesser beings in comparison to white Christian girls.

Does systematic, widespread and organised abuse of indigenous people count? Anglican Church... www.anglican.ca/tr/ Catholic Church didn't bother www.cccb.ca/site/eng/media-room/files/2630-apology-on-residential-schools-by-the-catholic-church www.cbc.ca/news/world/pope-expresses-sorrow-for-abuse-at-residential-schools-1.778019

ghostyslovesheep · 20/07/2015 22:12

yes bed for me too

work tomorrow - with those pesky vulnerable kids - including the UASC ones

Icelandicsuperyoghurt · 20/07/2015 22:11

Frankie I agree re we could learn from each other if there was more integration. Total Catch 22.

The first step is if people could stop highlighting their differences and celebrate what makes us all similar. Never going to happen, but its something I try to do.

ghostyslovesheep · 20/07/2015 22:11

it's child abuse - organised child abuse - in Westminster that specifically targeted vulnerable and looked after children because they had access to them

was race an issue - yes -is it THE issue - not really - the protection of vulnerable young people is the issue (Muslim girls where also abused in Rotherham)

I don't have an anti Catholic agenda at all - but religion was an issue in the organised abuse of children there as well

hence the comparisons

child abuse needs addressing and preventing full stop - focussing on one group is counter productive

EllieFAntspoo · 20/07/2015 22:09

"Time for bed." Said Zebedee.

Atenco · 20/07/2015 22:05

No society has a place for people who value religion above the lives of others

Could we change that to No society has a place for people who value money above the lives of others

EllieFAntspoo · 20/07/2015 22:05

And to all of those calling me a racist, you should know that I am of mixed race, a mixture of 4 different races if I go back to my grandparents. The difference with families like mine is that they made the effort to Integrate, which is something too many immigrants today don't do.
Indeed. You have picked up racism very well. There is so much nationalism and bigotry in your posts I'd swear you were a white unemployed male.

SunHighInTheSky · 20/07/2015 22:04

I think most of them were making a little joke Ellie. (At least I was!)

Swipe left for the next trending thread