Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

David Cameron has finally admitted that "integration is not working"

385 replies

WhetherOrNot · 20/07/2015 19:16

AIBU to think that he should have cottoned on about 10 years ago, not now when it is so glaringly obvious as to be an embarrassment for everyone?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ponyexpress22 · 09/08/2021 22:08

Old thread..... irrelevant then

ponyexpress22 · 09/08/2021 22:08

Agree ghosty - the failure of some white Christians to integrate with others is concerning.
Childish remark, but predictable. Anything to have a swipe at Christianity. The only religion that it's ok to insult.

phishy · 09/08/2021 19:21

‘The failures of integration’ does not mean integration as a whole is not working.

Maybe get outside of your bubble and befriend Muslim people to understand this OP.

I suspect your aim is to be goady and I have reported you for deliberately trying to stoke hatred and mistrust.

Zelvinka · 09/08/2021 19:21

ZOMBIE thread alert!!

Tiddleandplonk · 09/08/2021 19:17

I think that in the main integration woek ,or did work.
From personal experience , some groups do not seem to be mixing amd communities are being affected when large groups take over an area. There arw also some groups that do not seem to want to mix and integrate.
A recent trip to a west yorkshire city showed little mixing at all in the student cohort even . Local eateries were distinctive white or asian. In london it seems more open and intrgrated ,but other cities there are many examples of children of erhinic minorities not allowing their dc to mix. Tho many do of course.. but it is distinct and visible it really is.
Immigration of differing groups.appears to have added to tensions between groups in some cities I know well.
I like another poster feel imigration is fine,but to take on the norms and culture of the country should be expected. Just like when i go to other countries i adhere to their culture.
I think it is very very important for the way that some men in some cultures treat and view women ,are addressed. I say this as a victim of sexual assualt where my culture a western woman .. of not being modest, not covering my hair meant that i was basically fair game and that the males lust.was not his problem . He cited his culture as peemission to .attack . I totally kmow that many men of that mans culture would not do that of course,but.it brought it home to me that to hold this cultural view of females should have no part in modern britain .

1Micem0use · 09/08/2021 18:42

I think every adult should have to spend a year living and working in a foreign country with a different culture. That would solve this kind of xenophobia and out group hostility.

Eggfriedpower · 09/08/2021 18:29

As much as I hate to agree with DC, the protests at the schools in Birmingham support this.

1990b · 09/08/2021 18:17

@Wheretheresawill1

Integration not working in this very Muslim city. There are complete areas now taken over my immigrants. Generations of families bought over here crammed in houses. Lots of non English speaking. Some areas comprise of Asian food stores, sari shops, takeaways; pharmacists; halal shops. I drove through one area and there were only Asian people in Asian attire. It needs to be seen to be believed and I felt like an outsider. There desperately needs to be more integration- it's shocking
Wearing your own attire or " Asian attire" 🙄 doesn't have anything to do with integration, nor does having, pharmacies( which can be used by anyone, not only asians) shops, or halal butchers stop integration from happening.

Why should there not be a halal butchers don't Muslims have a right to eat meat? Where would we go for our meat if not halal butchers.

How simple a view you have of " asians" you have reduced a subcontinent into one.

sashagabadon · 09/08/2021 18:05

And David Cameron stopped being relevant 5 years ago!

RocketPanda · 09/08/2021 18:04

This thread is 6 years old.

Saisong · 09/08/2021 18:03

This thread is 6 years old!

IntothePitt · 09/08/2021 18:01

@retrorobot

When did homophobia become a crime? There are parts of the U.K. (Scotland and Northern Ireland) where gay men having sex was still illegal into the 1980s - that's within the lifetime of anyone 35 or over. Pretty much every mainstream Christian denomination in the U.K. still regards gay sex as a sin.

Big deal if Islam regards gay sex as a sin. Islam also regards eating pork, ham and bacon as a sin.

People can believe what they want and screw the gay community if its feelings are hurt as a result. Their feelings don't allow them to dictate what others can think. Just like hurt feelings of Muslims isn't a reason for opposing terrorism.

Let people think and say what they like so long as they are not advocating violence or aggression.

Of course gay people are going to be hurt by homophobia. And did you really just compare being gay to terrorism?
RedDaisyRed · 25/07/2015 15:37

You 're saying it is prejudiced to say gay men make good parents? I think anyone who uses a surrogate and thinks hard about having children tends to be a better parent than those of us who just have a baby by accident or without much thought. Also gay men tend to earn more so that usually means children do better too. So I stand by my comment. Obviously there will be odd one who isn't a good parent.

I also support the right of priests and imnans to say homosexuality will lead to your going to hell and for people to deny the holocaust and that women are inferior to men and to make cartoons whether or me or of Jesus and Mo. We need to make people robust and tolerant and if a drawing upsets them then poor diddums get some therapy or grow a thicker skin. However of course if people go further and start throwing bombs or chucking rocks at women attending abortion clinics then the law should step in as it does.

Atenco · 25/07/2015 14:57

I hope gay men can be encouraged to use surrogates to have children. They make good parents

You know this is also a prejudiced thing to say, RedDaisy. Once you start adscribing virtues or vices to such a huge swathe of people, that is called prejudice.

gays or women who cover up are morally wrong ?????

woodhill · 24/07/2015 23:10

I think the attitude to Homosexuality in Islam us a bit of a red herring and I think we should be more worried about the lack of tolerance towards other religions or anyone who doesn't follow Islam in tge way they interpret it. I mean from Isis's perspective.

I

OurDearLeader · 24/07/2015 22:40

RedDaisy, I don't know if you've noticed but being gay is neither an ideology nor a personality type and you get gay people who come in all sorts of different sizes and some of them will makes brilliant parents and some will make crap parents. Just like heterosexuals.

But I agree you have the right to offend me by saying they all inherently have the ability to be good parents just because they're gay. Smile

RedDaisyRed · 24/07/2015 17:12

I hope gay men can be encouraged to use surrogates to have children. They make good parents.

A fundamental to me is that we should have within reason to have the right to offend - whether that be to deny the holocaust, draw cartoons of Jesus and Mo or say gays or women who cover up are morally wrong.

MrsTerryPratchett · 24/07/2015 14:23

Already in Canada the gay community has required that the state fund surrogacy for gay men, i.e. state pays egg donor and gestational carrier/womb renter, so that gay men can have a child. This is the next thing that the gay community will demand here - in the name of equality. I'm in Canada. It's illegal here to pay surrogates.

GraysAnalogy · 24/07/2015 13:37

Again with the 'people like' me! You have no idea what I'm like, you seem to have garnered an awful lot from a single post.

I tell you what I've gotten from your posts though, you're awfully threatened by the 'gay community' aren't you?

What is wrong with surrogacy for gay men?
What's wrong with them donating bloody?

You're 'scared' of the outreach? You mean you're scared of them having the same rights as anyone else. That's ridiculous.

And like OurLeader has said, you're diverting. You're also using this thread as an outlet for your insecurity and fear of gay people.

DoraGora · 24/07/2015 13:25

Well, yes, any display of anything which is illegal is illegal, very true. But, to say that things which fall into the category of having been proscribed by the law are illegal isn't saying nothing.

Judges make that point all the time. You could try, next time you're in the dock, telling a judge that he or she isn't making an important point. Let me know how you get on.

OurDearLeader · 24/07/2015 13:24

Yes, it should have been addressed to Retro sorry.

Retro, that's not true. Which your post itself actually proves. It's more than legal for you to voice your opposition to these policy changes (if they actually happen) or for you to say you believe homosexuality is sin.

If you were to put up signs to that effect or actively seek out homosexuals to abuse by telling them they were damned and going straight to hell you might have a problem. But homophobia itself is not banned, just expressing it in a way which will cause harm to other people.

Incidentally gay men aren't banned from giving blood. People who've had anal sex within a certain time frame are because it has a higher risk for HIV transmission. This includes women who've had anal sex and also, yes, a lot of gay men, but there is no ban here or anywhere else in Europe on gay men per se.

But all of this is irrelevant bollocks which seems to me to be intended to derail the thread and has very little to do with the fact that in many Islamic countries being gay carries the death penalty or other harsh sentences.

Or do you support that too?

retrorobot · 24/07/2015 12:34

DoraGora: "Any display of it which falls outside the law is already banned."

This sentence doesn't say anything. You're just saying that displays of homosexuality that are illegal are illegal.

People like GraysAnalogy would like to have mind control / speech control so that saying that homosexual acts are a sin, that homosexuality is a lifestyle choice, etc. would be illegal. We're already seeing this approach with the attempt by the gay lobby to ban aversion therapy even when voluntarily entered into by adults.

Already in Canada the gay community has required that the state fund surrogacy for gay men, i.e. state pays egg donor and gestational carrier/womb renter, so that gay men can have a child. This is the next thing that the gay community will demand here - in the name of equality.

Because of political pressure in the UK we may now receive blood from gay men - contrary to practice in Netherlands, Germany and France. Wait until the next virus like HIV comes around and spreads through the gay community. The virus will be new and so can't be tested for and, as happened with HIV, it will spread to people, including children, through blood transfusion before people realise it.

The level of overreach by the gay community is massive. I fear for what is going to happen when the backlash comes.

DoraGora · 24/07/2015 11:45

belief isn't criminal, in the UK, it's what you do with the belief that can be criminal.

DC is trying to alienate people who he imagines to be quietly believing things that he doesn't like. But, I think he's pretty much on his own there.

GraysAnalogy · 24/07/2015 11:43

Our is that supposed to be to me? Because that seems to make more sense in reply to Retro?

DoraGora · 24/07/2015 11:42

Any display of it which falls outside the law is already banned. What more do you need?

I don't really understand what you want retro. These things are already legally defined. Do you want to change the law in order to make it less protective of minorities?