Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that sanitary towels should not be scented!

245 replies

bumbleymummy · 02/07/2015 20:51

What were Always thinking? They were the only brand in the shop and they smell vile! Why? Why would anyone choose this? Confused

OP posts:
kali110 · 03/07/2015 16:05

Smillas its noristerone you can take to lesson bleeding if you don't want to take the pill.
I had to take it when i had a blood clot and it caused horrendous periods. ThAt sorted it thankfully.

kali110 · 03/07/2015 16:03

Ash me too Smile i feel much better when i wear the scented ones.
I can smell the smell when some people ( including myself) are on, no matter how frequently i change.
I just feel more confident wearing the scented ones, funny thing is, i can't smell the 'really offensive flowery smell' through my clothes!!
I'm just very thankful being on the pill, that i rarely have to deal with this.

Lemonade your posts were not nice, that is why so many people had problems with them.

ninaaa · 03/07/2015 15:48

muminhants I have found the bodyform night to be just as absorbent as Always night (but they may not be as absorbent as secure night?)

ninaaa · 03/07/2015 15:45

Stampy I would agree with Smillas, I have been to the doctor for "heavy periods" that were less than half as bad as what you have described.

muminhants1 · 03/07/2015 15:45

Having read this thread, I bought Bodyform today which don't have scent.

I buy the newish Always Night Secure, not sure if they are scented or not, but they are the only ones that are big enough to give me a chance of not wrecking my underwear/PJs on my heavy nights. So I have to go with the scent! I don't think a Mooncup would work on its own though I might look into the washable pads for my lighter days. I do find towels itchy, but thought it was the material not the scent.

When I was pregnant I had an acute sense of smell. I don't remember smelling blood but I used to go into the loos at work and smell dehydrated urine, which was worse. I'd be thinking ladies please please PLEASE drink more!

As for tampon use, I've used maybe 10 in my life, to go swimming.

DustBunnyFarmer · 03/07/2015 15:36

Eurgh. So you are telling me that a group of teenage girls were going around school for up to a week without washing?

Pretty much. All girls school though. I suspect in co-ed the soap dodgers would have bathed daily regardless. You have wonder why their mothers weren't doing more about it.

SmillasSenseOfSnow · 03/07/2015 15:25

IHateStampysVoice, have you been to the doctor about your heavy periods? The pill should really be able to help a bit with that. And I learned from MN that there's a specific pill (not contraceptive) you can get to reduce or stop the bleeding temporarily (for your holiday next month!).

IHateStampysVoice · 03/07/2015 15:07

do people usually get up to change their pads at night?

You have never suffered from heavy periods then, you are lucky.

On my heaviest day/night I have to wear a super plus tampon and a huge pad (Tescos) and have to change up to every 30-60 minutes as it just floods straight through. Costs me a fortune in tampons.

At night I can be up two or three times (tampons plus pad) and will nearly always flood the bed.

It must be lovely to have just one pad that lasts the night, Im so, so envious. I've also just realised that I'm going to be 'on' during my holiday next month, as I was last year. Nooooooooooo!

toomuchtooold · 03/07/2015 14:55

Oh god I hate them. Can't put them in your bag or anything the smell is so strong. Also, they use that scent for nothing else. It wouldn't be so bad if it smelled like Fairy fabric conditioner or something but no, they've chosen a unique "it's that time of the month" scent for it.

slippermaiden · 03/07/2015 14:54

Ninaaa I take your point. I'm a stay at home mum so it's all good Smile

Gabilan · 03/07/2015 14:13

"I actually ended up lining some old knickers with strips of face flannel for those last couple of days when it's just a few rusty streaks. "

Hmm. Now there's an idea. And ecologically sound.

"I don't bend down and sniff my sanitary towel, so don't notice."

I didn't need to when I used the scented ones (briefly, as an experiment and because I had used Always for so long that I was reluctant to stop). I found that I could smell them as soon as or before I opened the packet and was aware of the smell during the day. Admittedly my sense of smell is fairly acute but if I could smell them, there's a good chance other people could too. Now I'm not that bothered about people knowing whether or not I'm menstruating and the "shh, isn't your body embarrassing" style of advertising really pisses me off. However, I don't want people thinking I smell of car deodoriser.

MiaowTheCat · 03/07/2015 13:35

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

ninaaa · 03/07/2015 13:35

*wouldn't be comfortable

ninaaa · 03/07/2015 13:35

Washable pads and a mooncup. Don't have to buy anything each month or get caught out. No nasty smells, no risk of toxic shock. Comfy, good for the environment. What's not to like?

Maybe would be suitable for home use, but I personally would be comfortable wearing either of these out.

Washable pads- I can be out the house at work for up to 10 hours, and am likely to need to change about 4 times. I don't fancy carrying 4 soiled pads around for hours, even if they are in a waterproof, door absorbing sealed pouch.

Mooncup- would still need to empty and wash out at least once or twice (I understand they hold more than pads/ tampons?) So would need to bring a water bottle into the toilet. It just sounds messy and an extra hassle that I don't really need.

ItsAllGoingToBeFine · 03/07/2015 13:13

Washable pads and a mooncup. Don't have to buy anything each month or get caught out. No nasty smells, no risk of toxic shock. Comfy, good for the environment. What's not to like?

This^

Plus, toxic shock is really worth worrying about www.vice.com/en_uk/read/meet-the-model-who-lost-her-leg-to-toxic-shock-syndrome-611

ByeByeButterfly · 03/07/2015 13:05

Well for me:

  1. I don't bend down and sniff my sanitary towel, so don't notice.
  2. For us with heavy periods it masks the smell.
ninaaa · 03/07/2015 12:59

There was a very unhelpful myth in circulation at the time that you couldn't bathe or shower during your period.

Eurgh. So you are telling me that a group of teenage girls were going around school for up to a week without washing? I would actually think the BO smell from a week's worth of sweat and grime accumulating on the remainder of your body (especially armpits and feet) would be strong enough to hide the period smell.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe2726 · 03/07/2015 12:53

I agree with you but only because of the godawful fragranced they use, I'd rather fragrance-free and give myself a bit of a spray up there if it mattered to me that much. Grin

slippermaiden · 03/07/2015 12:48

Washable pads and a mooncup. Don't have to buy anything each month or get caught out. No nasty smells, no risk of toxic shock. Comfy, good for the environment. What's not to like?

LurcioAgain · 03/07/2015 12:30

I'm another Always refugee, can't stand the pong and they make me itch like crazy - which reminds me, must stock up on a load of Boots own brand while I'm in town.

Lemonade - sorry you've had a bashing. Your first post was maybe not as well worded as it could have been, but you came back and apologised and I can't see why people are still mulling over it. FWIW, I use them because I'm so bloody absent minded I'd probably forget a tampon and leave it till I got toxic shock! (Left a diaphragm up there for 3 days once - v. embarrassing).

I agree that towards the end of a period just about any sort of pad leaves you feeling dry. I actually ended up lining some old knickers with strips of face flannel for those last couple of days when it's just a few rusty streaks. Changed a few times a day, thrown in the wash - works fine. (Obviously not advocating this for the start of the period when I bleed like a stuck pig).

DustBunnyFarmer · 03/07/2015 12:02

I noticed the period smell more at school when most of my friends were hitting puberty. There was a very unhelpful myth in circulation at the time that you couldn't bathe or shower during your period. Grim. My classmates gradually wised up and things improved. Almost never notice it now.

FanFuckingTastic · 03/07/2015 11:47

That's weird about smelling people on their period, I can always tell a couple of days before that I am about to come on because I get a metallic smell. I worry about people being able to smell that too.

I think I do use Tena pads, but they are scented too.

ninaaa · 03/07/2015 11:45

YANBU

I used Always ultra for years, but had to stop a few years ago due to irritation and thrush. Always now do a perfume free silk collection, but they are quite expensive. I now mostly use Bodyform, but as a few posters have said, they have also started adding scent.

The good news is, they make both scented and unscented versions for normal and long, and night are unscented only. The bad news is that the packets are almost identical. On the scented versions, they have a small flower saying "deo fresh", and the description is in a light blue bubble, but very easy to confuse with unscented.

Lime8 · 03/07/2015 11:43

Totally agree! They changed them and they are disgusting. Lilets towels are wonderful, I switched to them after the perfume was added!

IcecreamHavoc · 03/07/2015 11:42

Lemonade30, your point of view is offensive because your tone is sneers in parts and sound like you think people who don't do what you do are somehow .

Swipe left for the next trending thread